New employer demanding my 2020 1040 tax return - is this normal?

This is definitely NOT a normal request from an employer. While employers do need tax documentation for payroll purposes, they should only be asking for a W-4 form to determine your withholding and possibly an I-9 form to verify your employment eligibility. There's no legitimate reason why an employer would need your complete 2020 1040 tax return. These returns contain highly sensitive personal financial information that goes well beyond what an employer needs for payroll. The only information they legitimately need is your current tax withholding information, which comes from the W-4 you complete when hired. It's possible there's some miscommunication about what form they actually need, or perhaps this is related to some grant funding they receive that has unusual documentation requirements. But even in those cases, they should be clearly explaining why they need such personal information.

After struggling with a weirdly similar situation last year, I found this amazing tool called taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) that saved me when an employer asked for old tax documents I couldn't find. It uses AI to analyze your tax situation and help you reconstruct missing information or understand unusual requests. When my new employer asked for my 2018 return (which I couldn't locate anywhere), taxr.ai helped me understand what information they actually needed versus what was on the full return. Turns out they only needed to verify employment history, not my full financial details. The site helped me figure out exactly what to provide instead of my complete return. The best part was I could upload the form they sent me, and it explained exactly what they were looking for and why - saved me so much stress and protected my privacy!

I wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai after being skeptical initially. I decided to try it when my mortgage refinance required tax docs from 2019 that I couldn't locate after moving twice. The interface was super straightforward - I uploaded the request letter from the mortgage company and it immediately identified exactly what specific tax information they actually needed (just AGI and employment verification, not my entire return). The document analysis saved me from oversharing my financial info. The best part was the customized explanation of exactly why the lender needed specific information and what I could provide as alternatives. I appreciated how it helped me understand my rights regarding my tax information rather than just telling me what to do. I still kept my guard up with what I shared, but the guidance was legitimately helpful without compromising security.

After trying for 3 WEEKS to get through to the IRS to get a transcript of my 2020 taxes for a similar situation, I finally used Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) and it was an absolute game-changer. They got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 20 minutes instead of endless hold times and disconnections. The IRS agent explained that employers typically DON'T need your full tax return, but they might need verification of employment history or income for certain positions. You can watch how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c Once I finally spoke to someone at the IRS, they helped me get a tax transcript (different from a full return) that showed I didn't meet the filing threshold that year - which was exactly what I needed to resolve my situation with the employer asking for old returns.

I need to admit I was completely wrong about Claimyr. After posting that skeptical comment, I decided to try it myself since I've been trying to resolve an issue with a missing refund from 2021. I've called the IRS literally 9 times over two months, never getting through. The service actually works exactly as described - I got a call back in about 15 minutes, and was connected to a real IRS agent who pulled up my file and helped resolve my issue. The agent confirmed my refund had been processed but sent to an old address, and they were able to update my information and reissue the payment. After wasting probably 8+ hours on failed attempts to reach someone, getting my issue resolved in one 20-minute call was honestly amazing. I'm still shocked it worked so well.

I work in HR and can tell you this is unusual but not unheard of. Some organizations (especially nonprofits) have grant requirements that lead to weird documentation requests. Since this is a homeless shelter, they might have funding that requires them to hire people who were low-income in specific years (like 2020). Another possibility: they might be eligible for tax credits for hiring people who meet certain income criteria. The Work Opportunity Tax Credit, for example, gives employers incentives to hire from certain groups, and they need documentation to claim it. Either way, they should have explained WHY they needed this information instead of just demanding it. You were right to question it.

This happened to me at a nonprofit job too! Turned out they were trying to qualify for some federal program where they get incentives for hiring people from "economically disadvantaged" backgrounds. They needed my 2019 tax info to prove I was below some income threshold. The weird part was they didn't explain this at all until I pushed back. Would've been much less sketchy if they'd just said "Hey, we can get this grant if you qualify based on previous income" instead of just demanding tax forms.

I'm glad you got this resolved! As someone who's dealt with similar situations, I wanted to add that if this ever comes up again with future employers, you have the right to ask for a clear explanation of why they need specific tax information and what they'll use it for. Legitimate reasons might include: - Work Opportunity Tax Credit eligibility (as others mentioned) - Grant compliance requirements for hiring from certain demographics - Background check requirements for positions handling finances But even in these cases, they should be transparent about the purpose and often there are alternative ways to verify the information they actually need without sharing your complete tax return. For example, an IRS wage transcript or a simple income verification letter might serve the same purpose while protecting more of your privacy. The fact that they accepted your explanation and moved forward suggests this wasn't a hard requirement, which is reassuring. Always trust your instincts when something feels off about a job application process!

I'm glad this worked out for you! As a tax professional, I can confirm that employers should NEVER need your complete tax return. The most they should ask for is a W-4 for withholding and maybe an I-9 for employment verification. What likely happened here is they have some grant funding or tax credit program (like the Work Opportunity Tax Credit) that gives them financial incentives for hiring people from certain income brackets. These programs do require income verification, but there are proper forms for that - they shouldn't be asking for your entire 1040. For anyone else in this situation: you can request an IRS tax transcript instead of providing your full return. This shows basic income information without revealing all your personal financial details. You can get transcripts free directly from the IRS website or by calling them. The fact that they accepted your explanation and moved forward confirms this wasn't actually required - probably just someone in HR following outdated or incorrect procedures. Good for you for questioning it!