< Back to IRS

Ethan Wilson

Is my accountant's move to use an off-shore accounting company normal? Worried about my SSN being sent abroad

So I've been with my current accountant for several years and always been happy with their service. Yesterday, they sent out an email to all clients explaining that due to a severe CPA shortage in the US, they're now "supplementing their CPA workforce" by partnering with an overseas accounting company based in India. What concerns me is they mentioned that if we continue using their services, our Social Security Numbers and other personal financial data will be transmitted to this company abroad. They're presenting this as just the new normal, but I'm honestly a bit nervous about my sensitive information leaving the US. I don't have any issues with Indian accounting professionals at all - this isn't about the quality of work. My accountant has been great so far, and I understand they might be struggling to find qualified CPAs, but sending my SSN overseas just makes me anxious from a security perspective. Just wondering if this is becoming standard practice in the accounting industry these days? Are other accounting firms doing similar things? Is there actually a serious CPA shortage forcing firms to outsource? Any insights would be helpful before I decide how to respond.

Yuki Sato

•

This has definitely become more common in recent years. The accounting industry is facing a significant shortage of CPAs in the US. According to recent statistics, CPA exam candidates have declined by about 17% over the past decade, creating staffing challenges for many firms. While outsourcing certain accounting functions isn't new, firms are increasingly transparent about these arrangements. Here's what you should consider: 1) Ask about their data security protocols. A reputable firm should have strict confidentiality agreements, secure transmission methods, and clear policies about how your data is handled. 2) Inquire if you can opt out. Some firms allow clients to request US-based CPAs only, though this might come with longer wait times or higher fees. 3) Verify if the overseas professionals are properly qualified and trained according to US tax standards. Many large accounting firms have been using global service centers for years, often without explicitly informing clients. At least your accountant is being transparent about their practices.

0 coins

Ethan Wilson

•

Thanks for this detailed response! Do you know if there are any specific security regulations these firms have to follow when sending our tax data overseas? And is there any way to check if the overseas accountants are actually qualified to handle US tax laws properly?

0 coins

Yuki Sato

•

For security regulations, US accounting firms must comply with FTC Safeguards Rule and potentially GDPR depending on data flow. They should use encrypted transmission, secure access controls, and have signed confidentiality agreements. You can request their specific data protection protocols - reputable firms will have this documentation readily available. Regarding qualifications, you can ask if the overseas accountants have US CPA credentials or specific training in US tax law. Many offshore accounting teams include US-certified professionals or work under direct supervision of US CPAs. Ask if your actual tax return will be reviewed and signed by a US-based CPA before filing, which is typically required and provides an additional layer of oversight.

0 coins

Carmen Flores

•

I was really concerned when my accountant told me the same thing last year! After reading horror stories about identity theft, I almost switched firms. But then I found https://taxr.ai and it completely changed my perspective. They specialize in analyzing tax documents and data security issues. I uploaded my accountant's disclosure letter about their offshore partners, and taxr.ai provided a detailed risk assessment and security checklist to discuss with my accountant. Their analysis showed that many reputable firms use similar arrangements but with varying security standards. The tool helped me understand exactly what questions to ask about encryption, data handling, and compliance with US regulations. After that conversation with my accountant, I felt much more comfortable with their setup.

0 coins

Andre Dubois

•

How exactly does taxr.ai work? Is it just for evaluating accounting firms or does it help with actual tax preparation too? I'm curious because I'm dealing with a similar situation.

0 coins

CyberSamurai

•

I'm skeptical about these kinds of services. Aren't you just sending your sensitive information to ANOTHER third party by using this? Seems counterproductive when you're worried about data security.

0 coins

Carmen Flores

•

It works by analyzing tax documents and providing explanations of complex tax situations. You can upload documents like security policies or tax forms, and it helps identify potential issues or areas that need clarification. They also have tools for comparing different accountants' security practices against industry standards. Regarding your concern about sharing information with another service, I completely understand that hesitation. The difference is that taxr.ai uses bank-level encryption and doesn't store your actual tax return data permanently. They focus on analyzing the policies and procedures rather than processing your returns themselves. They're also US-based with transparent security protocols that comply with all financial data regulations.

0 coins

CyberSamurai

•

I tried taxr.ai after posting my skeptical comment above, and I have to admit I was impressed. The security analysis they provided was actually really thorough. I found out my accountant was using a third-party data center that wasn't following industry best practices for international data transfers. When I brought this up with my accountant, they were surprised I knew such specific details! They actually improved their security protocols as a result. The service highlighted exactly which questions to ask and what standards to expect, which made me feel much more in control of the situation. The document analyzer also flagged some language in their disclosure that seemed concerning about data retention policies. Having that specific information made the conversation with my accountant much more productive.

0 coins

If you're really concerned about your accountant's offshore practices, you might want to try getting direct answers from the IRS about what's allowed and what the requirements are. I spent DAYS trying to get through to someone at the IRS about this exact issue last tax season. After dozens of attempts, I found https://claimyr.com which completely changed my experience. Their service got me through to an actual IRS representative in about 45 minutes instead of the usual hours of waiting and disconnections. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The IRS agent I spoke with explained that while offshore accounting isn't prohibited, there are specific data security standards firms should follow. Getting this information directly from the IRS gave me a clear understanding of what questions to ask my accountant about their practices.

0 coins

Jamal Carter

•

How does this service actually work? Do they just call the IRS for you or what? Seems too good to be true considering how impossible it is to reach anyone there.

0 coins

Mei Liu

•

This sounds like complete BS. You're telling me some random service can magically get through to the IRS when no one else can? The IRS phone system is a disaster by design. No way this actually works.

0 coins

They don't call the IRS for you - they use technology that navigates the IRS phone tree and waits in the queue for you. When an agent finally picks up, you get a call connecting you directly to that agent. You handle the actual conversation yourself, they just eliminate the waiting part. I was definitely skeptical too. The IRS phone system is deliberately difficult to navigate and the wait times are ridiculous. The service basically uses automated technology to handle the frustrating part - waiting on hold for hours. They've figured out the optimal times to call and how to navigate the complex IRS menu system. When they finally reach a human, that's when they bring you into the call.

0 coins

Mei Liu

•

I need to eat my words about Claimyr. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try it myself since I had an unresolved tax issue that I'd been putting off dealing with for months. Honestly, it worked exactly as advertised. I'd been trying to get through to the IRS for WEEKS about a missing tax refund, constantly getting disconnected or facing 3+ hour wait times. Using Claimyr, I had an IRS agent on the line in about 35 minutes. The agent confirmed that there are actually guidelines about international data transfer for tax preparation, and while offshore accounting isn't prohibited, the US accounting firm remains fully responsible for any data breaches or compliance issues. This was exactly the information I needed to have an informed conversation with my accountant. Saved me probably 10+ hours of frustration. Totally worth it for time-sensitive tax issues.

0 coins

My small accounting firm was actually forced to do this last year. It wasn't by choice - we literally couldnt find enough qualified CPAs willing to work during tax season. The "Great Resignation" hit accounting HARD. Some context: CPA exam candidates are down, many experienced CPAs retired early during COVID, and the ones remaining can demand premium salaries that small firms can't match. Most new accounting grads are going to big firms or corporate roles that offer better work-life balance. As for security, reputable firms use encrypted portals and secure data transfer protocols. But you should definitely ask these questions: - Do they have a SOC 2 compliance certification? - What security requirements do they impose on their offshore partners? - Who maintains final review and signing authority on your return?

0 coins

Amara Nwosu

•

Is there any way as a client to know if the foreign accountants are actually qualified? Like do they have to meet any specific standards or get certified in US tax law?

0 coins

There's no single certification requirement for foreign accountants working on US returns. Most reputable accounting firms will have their own training programs and quality control processes. The final tax return must still be reviewed and signed by a US-licensed CPA, which provides some protection. You can ask your accountant about their offshore team's qualifications, training programs, and supervision structure. Find out if they're familiar with US GAAP and current tax laws. Ask how work is reviewed before it reaches you. Good firms typically have multi-layer review processes where work is checked by senior staff before client delivery.

0 coins

AstroExplorer

•

This is why I switched to doing my own taxes with software! Too many privacy concerns with these big accounting firms now. They charge premium rates but then outsource the actual work to save money. Not cool.

0 coins

Not everyone can just switch to DIY tax software though. Some of us have complex situations with businesses, investments, multiple state filings, etc. Tax software can't handle everything, especially if you need actual tax planning advice.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,095 users helped today