How to Transfer Vanguard Roth IRA to Self Directed IRA after withdrawal?
I recently withdrew about $75,000 from my Vanguard Roth IRA to fund a hard money loan at 15% interest. I also used another $50,000 to buy a rental property that was actually appraised for quite a bit more than what I paid (serious equity built in from day one). Now I'm wondering about the tax implications and if I can somehow fix this situation. It's only been about 3 weeks since I pulled the money out. Questions: 1. Is it possible to move that $75,000 into a self-directed IRA and somehow undo or avoid the taxes since it hasn't been that long? 2. Can I somehow claim that rental property purchase was actually through a self-directed IRA even though I bought it personally? Basically, I'm trying to figure out if there's any way to backtrack and avoid the taxes on these withdrawals. Any advice on how to handle this situation? I didn't realize the tax implications when I made these moves.
18 comments
Join the conversation
Jade Lopez
You've got yourself in a bit of a tricky situation here. Let me try to help clear things up. For your first question - unfortunately, once you've taken a distribution from your Roth IRA, you generally only have 60 days to roll it over to another retirement account if you want to avoid taxes and penalties. This is called the 60-day rollover rule. Since it's only been a few weeks, you're still within that window! However, there's a big catch here - if you've already used the money for a hard money loan, it's no longer eligible for rollover because you've already "used" the funds. For your second question - no, you cannot retroactively claim the rental property was purchased through a self-directed IRA. For a property to be owned by an IRA, the IRA itself must make the purchase directly. The fact that you purchased it personally means it's not an IRA asset. The best course of action now might be to consult with a tax professional who specializes in retirement accounts to see if there are any strategies specific to your situation.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
•If I'm understanding correctly, the 60-day rollover only works if the money is still sitting in my account untouched? What if I could get the same amount of money from somewhere else and put that into the self-directed IRA? Would that work?
0 coins
Jade Lopez
•The 60-day rollover requires that you deposit the same assets you took out. Unfortunately, if you've already spent or invested the distributed funds, you can't substitute other money to qualify for the rollover. The IRS views this as you having used the distribution, which makes it a taxable event. Even if you could get the exact same amount from another source, the IRS would consider that new money, not the original distribution. The original withdrawal would still be considered a distribution subject to any applicable taxes and penalties.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
I had a similar issue and ended up using taxr.ai to help me figure out the proper way to handle my Roth IRA distributions. Their analysis tool helped me understand exactly what options I had when I moved money between retirement accounts and made some investment decisions I wasn't sure about. I uploaded my distribution statements and they explained what I could and couldn't do within the IRA rules. Check them out at https://taxr.ai if you're trying to understand the complex rules around retirement accounts. Their system basically translated all the IRS jargon into plain English so I could figure out where I stood.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
•Did they give you different advice than what the first commenter said? I'm curious if there are actually ways around the 60-day rule or if that's pretty much set in stone.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
•I'm skeptical of these online tax tools. How exactly do they know IRA rules better than a real tax professional? Do they just quote IRS publications or do they actually have strategies that work?
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
•They basically confirmed the 60-day rule is pretty strict but helped me understand some nuances that applied to my situation. In my case, I had taken a distribution but hadn't actually spent all of it, so I was able to roll some back in. Their value is that they don't just quote publications but actually analyze your specific situation. They have tax professionals who review complex cases and provide specific guidance based on your documents. It's not just an algorithm - they help interpret how the rules apply to your particular circumstances.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
I was really skeptical about online tax tools at first, but I decided to try taxr.ai after seeing it mentioned here. I'm actually impressed with how they handled my Roth IRA situation. I uploaded my distribution statements and explained my situation (different from yours but also involved a property purchase), and they pointed out a strategy I hadn't considered involving partial rollovers that saved me quite a bit in taxes. Their analysis was detailed and included specific IRS citations that my regular accountant hadn't mentioned. Not a magic solution, but definitely more helpful than I expected!
0 coins
Maya Diaz
After dealing with IRA distribution issues myself, I spent HOURS trying to get someone from the IRS on the phone for clarification. It was absolutely maddening! I eventually found Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) which got me connected to an actual IRS representative in about 20 minutes. You can see how it works in their demo video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The IRS agent I spoke with walked me through the exact documentation I needed to provide for my situation and confirmed that the 60-day rule applies regardless of what you did with the money. Saved me from making an even bigger mistake with my retirement funds. Might be worth calling the IRS directly to get official guidance on your specific situation.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
•How does that even work? The IRS phone lines are always jammed. Do they have some special backdoor number or something?
0 coins
Rami Samuels
•Sounds like a scam to me. No way to get through to the IRS that easily when it takes most people hours or days of trying. Plus, why would you need a service when you can just call yourself?
0 coins
Maya Diaz
•They use a system that continuously redials and navigates the IRS phone tree until it gets through. It's basically doing what you'd do manually, but automated. There's no special backdoor - just technology handling the frustrating part. You absolutely can call yourself, but it might take you dozens of attempts and hours on hold. I tried for three days before giving up and trying this. The service just saves you the time and frustration, especially if you're trying to resolve something time-sensitive like the 60-day rollover window the OP is dealing with.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
I have to eat my words about Claimyr. After calling the IRS myself for two days straight with no luck (kept getting disconnected after waiting on hold), I broke down and tried it. Got connected to an IRS agent in about 15 minutes. The agent confirmed everything about the 60-day rule that others mentioned here but also told me about Form 5329 which can help request a waiver of the 60-day requirement in certain hardship situations. Not sure if it would apply to OP's case, but definitely worth knowing about. Still not cheap to use a service just to make a phone call, but considering I wasted hours trying on my own, it was worth it for me.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Something nobody has mentioned - if you already made unqualified distributions from your Roth IRA for the hard money loan and property purchase, you might want to look into converting your remaining Vanguard Roth to a self-directed IRA for FUTURE investments, not to fix the past ones. Self-directed IRAs let you invest in things like real estate, private loans, etc. directly through the IRA. Might help you avoid this situation in the future. Companies like Equity Trust, IRA Financial, and Rocket Dollar specialize in these accounts. Just a thought!
0 coins
Douglas Foster
•Do self-directed IRAs have different rules about distributions? Like could OP have done these exact investments but avoided the tax hit if they were already in a self-directed account?
0 coins
Haley Bennett
•Self-directed IRAs follow the same basic distribution rules as any IRA. The difference is what you can invest in while the money remains inside the IRA. If OP had already set up a self-directed IRA before making these investments, they could have made the hard money loan and purchased the rental property directly through the IRA without taking a distribution. The IRA itself would own the property and loan, keeping everything tax-advantaged. All income and gains would flow back into the IRA tax-free (for a Roth). That's the major advantage - making alternative investments while keeping the tax benefits intact.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Has anyone dealt with trying to put real estate back into an IRA after purchasing it personally? I heard there's some kind of prohibited transaction rule about selling your own property to your IRA. Is that true?
0 coins
Jade Lopez
•Yes, that's absolutely true and a critical point. The IRS has strict rules against "self-dealing" transactions. You cannot sell property you already own personally to your IRA - that's considered a prohibited transaction and can result in the entire IRA being disqualified. The same applies to transactions between your IRA and any "disqualified persons" which includes yourself, your spouse, parents, children, and certain business partners. So unfortunately, once you've purchased property personally, there's no way to transfer it into an IRA without triggering these prohibited transaction rules.
0 coins