Foreign-owned Wyoming LLC - Late filing of form 5472 and potential penalties for reportable transactions

The IRS takes Form 5472 filing requirements very seriously for foreign-owned disregarded entities. The $25,000 penalty for each missed form is not something I'd recommend gambling with. From my experience, the better approach is definitely Option 2 - file both your 2022 and 2023 forms. The payment to your registered agent is indeed a reportable transaction. When you file the late 2022 form, attach a reasonable cause statement explaining why it was late (perhaps you weren't aware of the requirement as a first-time filer). The IRS does have a first-time abatement policy that may help, but it's not guaranteed for information returns like the 5472. Your statement should focus on how you discovered the error and took immediate corrective action once you realized the mistake. Remember that ignoring past filing requirements doesn't make them go away, and the statute of limitations doesn't start running until you actually file.

I went through something similar with my foreign-owned LLC. Super stressful! After spending hours trying to decipher the IRS rules myself, I used https://taxr.ai to analyze my situation. It saved me so much anxiety. Their document analysis caught that I had missed reporting several transactions that counted as "reportable" under the 5472 rules that my previous accountant completely missed. They flagged the registered agent fee specifically as a trigger for filing (which I had no idea about). The system even helped draft a reasonable cause letter explaining why I missed the deadline. When I uploaded my documents, it identified multiple compliance issues I wasn't even aware of.

I was totally in your shoes last year! I had a UK-owned Wyoming LLC and had no clue about the 5472 requirement until my accountant mentioned it casually. I panicked because I was already late for two years. After checking out https://taxr.ai based on recommendations here, I uploaded my LLC formation docs and past transactions. The system immediately flagged that I had multiple reportable transactions including my registered agent payment. What impressed me was how it helped me prepare both the late returns AND drafted a reasonable cause letter explaining my situation. I submitted everything and braced for the worst, but the IRS accepted my explanation without penalties! The detailed analysis of what qualified as "reportable" saved me from missing additional items too. Definitely don't just ignore 2022 - that penalty is no joke if they decide to enforce it.

I spent THREE MONTHS trying to get through to someone at the IRS about my foreign-owned LLC and Form 5472 questions. Was put on hold for hours, disconnected, transferred to wrong departments... absolutely maddening. Finally tried https://claimyr.com and used their IRS call back service (demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c). They got me connected to an actual IRS agent within 2 hours who specialized in international business reporting. The agent confirmed I should absolutely file for both years and explained exactly how to prepare my reasonable cause statement. They even noted in my file that I had proactively reached out for guidance before they received my late filing, which apparently helps show good faith effort.

I take back what I said. After my comment, I was desperate enough to try the Claimyr service from COMMENT 4. Honestly shocked that it actually worked - I got a call back in about 90 minutes connecting me to an IRS international tax specialist. The agent reviewed my situation and strongly advised filing both years with a detailed reasonable cause statement. She said that while first-time abatement isn't guaranteed for informational returns like Form 5472, they do consider factors like: - Being a first-time filer - Proactively filing before being contacted by the IRS - Having a clear explanation for why you weren't aware of the requirement - Showing you've taken steps to ensure compliance going forward This was WAY more helpful than the generic advice I was getting elsewhere. Going to file both years this week and include all the documentation she recommended.

Don't listen to anyone telling you to just ignore the 2022 filing. I did that with a similar situation (foreign-owned Florida LLC) and got absolutely hammered with a $25k penalty last year that the IRS refused to abate. The IRS has been massively increasing enforcement on foreign-owned disregarded entities over the past 2 years. They know a lot of people are unaware of the Form 5472 requirement, and they're using it as a revenue source. File both years ASAP with a detailed reasonable cause statement. Include documentation showing when you discovered the requirement and how quickly you acted to comply once you learned about it.

One thing nobody has mentioned - if you decide to file for 2022, make sure you use the correct form version. The Form 5472 has changed, and using an outdated version can cause processing delays or even rejection. Also, when e-filing your 2022 Form 5472 late, you'll need to attach it to a pro forma Form 1120 with zeros (even though as a disregarded entity you don't actually file a 1120). This trips up a lot of people.

I'm dealing with almost the exact same situation! Foreign-owned Wyoming LLC, missed the 2022 Form 5472 filing because I had no idea about the registered agent fee being reportable. After reading through all these responses, I'm definitely going with Option 2 - filing both years. The consensus seems pretty clear that ignoring 2022 is way too risky given the $25,000 penalty. What's really helpful from this thread is understanding that I need to document WHEN I discovered the requirement and show I acted quickly once I learned about it. I'm going to start gathering all my emails and research from when I first found out about Form 5472 to include with my reasonable cause statement. Quick question for those who've been through this - how detailed should the reasonable cause letter be? Should I include the specific date I learned about the requirement, or just a general timeline? And do I need to attach any supporting documentation beyond the letter itself? Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences. This thread has been way more helpful than the generic advice I was getting from other sources!

I've been through this exact scenario with my foreign-owned LLC and can confirm that filing both years is absolutely the right call. The $25,000 penalty per missed form is not something the IRS takes lightly, and enforcement has definitely ramped up in recent years. A few practical tips from my experience: 1. When preparing your reasonable cause statement, focus on the fact that you weren't aware of the requirement rather than trying to argue the registered agent fee shouldn't be reportable (it definitely is). 2. Include specific dates - when you formed the LLC, when you first learned about Form 5472, when you started taking corrective action. Documentation is key. 3. Consider having a tax professional review your forms before filing, especially for the 2022 late filing. The penalty is steep enough that it's worth the extra cost to get it right. 4. File the 2022 form as soon as possible. The longer you wait, the harder it becomes to argue reasonable cause. The good news is that many people have successfully avoided penalties with proper documentation and a well-crafted reasonable cause statement. Don't let anyone convince you to just ignore the missed year - that's playing with fire given the penalty amount.