Does physical gold stored in a foreign vault by custodian require FATCA or FBAR reporting?

This is a great question about foreign asset reporting! The distinction really comes down to how your gold ownership is structured. For FBAR (FinCEN Form 114), you generally need to report foreign financial accounts where you have an interest or signature authority if the aggregate value exceeds $10,000 at any point during the year. Physical gold itself typically wouldn't trigger FBAR filing, but if your arrangement with the custodian involves a financial account, that's different. For FATCA (Form 8938), the reporting requirements focus on "specified foreign financial assets." Physical gold held directly is not inherently a financial asset, even when stored abroad. However, if your ownership is structured through a custody account that can hold cash or if you have a financial interest in the storage entity, that could trigger reporting. Based on your description, you should determine whether you have a custodial account with cash holdings or just a storage arrangement. The distinction matters significantly for your filing requirements.

After struggling with similar foreign asset reporting questions last year, I started using taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) and it's been incredibly helpful for sorting through these complex IRS rules. I uploaded my custodian statements and got a clear analysis of exactly what needed to be reported where - saved me hours of research trying to figure out if my foreign-held assets needed FBAR or FATCA reporting. Their system specifically handles these edge cases like physical gold stored overseas where the regulations aren't completely clear. They actually cited the specific IRS guidance that applied to my situation and explained it in plain English.

Just wanted to follow up - I tried taxr.ai for my situation with some gold and silver I have stored in various international vaults. It was actually really helpful! The system analyzed the custodial agreements I had with each storage facility and clearly explained which ones created reportable accounts for FBAR purposes and which ones didn't. Turns out the way my Swiss vault is structured created a financial account relationship that needed reporting, but my Singapore storage was direct ownership that didn't trigger FBAR or FATCA. The analysis saved me from over-reporting on some assets while ensuring I didn't miss the required filings for others. Definitely cleared up my confusion about these precious metals reporting requirements.

For anyone dealing with the IRS about foreign asset questions, I highly recommend Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was in a similar situation with foreign-held gold and couldn't get clear guidance from the IRS website. After waiting on hold with the IRS for nearly 3 hours over multiple attempts, I found Claimyr and they got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 20 minutes. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The IRS agent I spoke with provided official guidance on my specific situation with physical gold in an overseas vault. Definitely worth it for getting authoritative answers directly from the source rather than relying on internet forums (no offense to anyone here!).

I need to eat my words about Claimyr. I decided to try it after continuing to fail getting through to the IRS about my foreign asset reporting questions. Used the service yesterday and got connected to a specialist at the IRS in about 25 minutes (after trying for literally weeks on my own). The agent clarified that my physical gold holdings in a foreign vault DO need FBAR reporting because of how my particular storage agreement is structured - turns out I have signature authority over a financial account that holds the gold, not just direct ownership of stored metal. This completely contradicted what I'd been reading online, and I would have filed incorrectly without this information. Honestly shocked at how helpful this was.

From my experience dealing with these issues as an expat, the key distinction is whether you have a custodial financial arrangement or direct ownership with just storage. If your gold is held in a segregated allocated storage where specific bars or coins are assigned to you and you just pay storage fees, that's generally not an FBAR reportable account. However, if you have an account with the storage company that can hold cash, conduct transactions, etc., then it likely is reportable. Same general idea applies to FATCA reporting but with different thresholds. The penalties for non-filing are no joke - get professional help if you're uncertain!

I've been investing in precious metals for over a decade and have stored gold in vaults across four different countries. Here's what I've learned: The crucial factor is whether you have what the IRS considers a "financial interest in or signature authority over" an account. With most reputable gold storage providers, you typically get an account where your ownership is tracked, you can direct sales, transfers, etc. This almost always constitutes a financial account that needs FBAR reporting. I file FBARs every year for my gold storage accounts in Switzerland, Singapore, and New Zealand. Better safe than sorry - the penalties for non-filing can be severe, especially if the IRS deems it willful non-reporting.

As someone who's dealt with similar precious metals storage situations, I'd strongly recommend getting clarity directly from the IRS or a qualified tax professional before making any filing decisions. The distinction between reportable accounts and simple storage can be subtle but has major compliance implications. From what you've described, the key question is whether your Swiss custodian arrangement creates a financial account relationship or is purely storage. If you can direct sales, receive account statements, or the custodian can hold cash proceeds on your behalf, that typically creates a reportable account for FBAR purposes given your $175K value. For FATCA Form 8938, physical gold ownership generally doesn't trigger reporting unless it's held through a specified foreign financial asset structure. However, if your custodial arrangement has account features, you'd need to evaluate whether it meets the filing thresholds. Given the severe penalties for non-compliance (up to 50% of account value for willful FBAR violations), I'd definitely get professional guidance rather than risk guessing wrong. The investment in proper tax advice is minimal compared to potential penalty exposure on $175K in assets.

I went through this exact situation last year with gold stored in a Canadian vault. After much research and consulting with a tax attorney, here's what I learned: The IRS looks at the "substance over form" - meaning they care more about what you can actually do with the arrangement than how it's labeled. In your case, if you can: - Direct the custodian to sell your gold - Receive proceeds from sales - Get regular statements showing values - Have the custodian hold cash on your behalf Then you likely have a financial account that requires FBAR reporting since your value exceeds $10,000. For FATCA Form 8938, physical gold itself typically doesn't qualify as a "specified foreign financial asset" even when stored abroad. However, if your custodial arrangement has account-like features, it could potentially trigger FATCA reporting depending on your filing thresholds. I ended up filing an FBAR for my Canadian gold storage account to be safe. The penalties for non-filing are so severe (potentially 50% of the account value) that it's not worth the risk. Better to over-report than under-report with these foreign asset rules. I'd strongly suggest getting a consultation with a tax professional who specializes in international tax compliance - the $500-800 you'll spend on proper advice is nothing compared to the potential penalties on $175K in assets.

This is exactly the kind of complex international tax situation where the details of your specific arrangement really matter. Based on what you've described - physical gold worth $175K stored by a Swiss custodian - you're right to be concerned about potential reporting obligations. The key factor is whether your arrangement creates what the IRS considers a "financial account" versus simple storage. If your custodian can execute transactions on your behalf, provides account statements, or can hold cash proceeds from sales, that typically crosses the line into FBAR territory given your value exceeds $10,000. For FATCA Form 8938, direct ownership of physical gold generally doesn't trigger reporting even when stored overseas. However, if your custodial relationship has account-like features, you'd need to evaluate it against the filing thresholds. Given the potentially severe penalties for non-compliance (FBAR penalties can reach 50% of account value for willful violations), I'd strongly recommend getting a consultation with a tax professional who specializes in international compliance. The few hundred dollars for proper advice is minimal compared to your potential penalty exposure on $175K in assets. Don't try to guess on this one - the distinction between reportable and non-reportable arrangements can be subtle but has major consequences. Better to get definitive guidance now than face penalties later.