Back to IRS

Isabella Ferreira

Do you issue a 1099 to a Canadian citizen who did work for your business?

Hired a freelancer earlier this year to do some design work for my small business — she's based in Canada, Canadian citizen, no U.S. address. Paid her a few thousand dollars total across a few invoices. Now I'm trying to figure out the year-end paperwork and I genuinely don't know if the 1099 rules even apply when the person isn't a U.S. citizen or resident. Do you issue a 1099 to a Canadian citizen, or is this handled differently? My accountant is on vacation until January and I don't want to let this sit. Anyone dealt with this for a foreign contractor?

Two tax years of back balances showed up in my IRS Online Account at once, and I had no idea which one was being calculated correctly. I tried 800-829-1040 for three days straight and kept hitting the same recorded message telling me to try again later. Claimyr (claimyr.com) waits on hold with the IRS for you so you end up talking to a live agent — Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent pulled up both tax years and told me exactly what the balance owed was for each one, so I finally knew which figure to work from. Anyway, your Canadian freelancer question is real and comes up a lot for small businesses — the short answer is that Form 1099 is a U.S. domestic reporting form, and whether it applies to a foreign person doing work outside the U.S. is a question for your accountant or a tax professional, since it turns on facts specific to your situation. The IRS's site has a section on payments to foreign persons that's worth reading while you wait.

0 coins

Appreciate the tip on the IRS site — I'll dig into the foreign persons section while I wait for my accountant. And glad you finally got someone on the line about those balances.

0 coins

I had the same problem reaching anyone for a payment plan question last spring. Ended up having to go in person to the TAC just to get a human being.

0 coins

The TAC appointment line, 844-545-5640, is actually pretty easy to get through. Might be faster than the main line depending on what you need.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact situation last year with a developer I hired from Ontario. What helped me understand it was realizing that 1099 forms and W-9 forms are set up for U.S. persons — when you bring in a foreign contractor, the IRS has a whole separate process, and the form involved is a W-8, not a W-9. The W-8BEN is what an individual foreign contractor fills out for you. That form is what tells you they're not a U.S. person. I'd strongly suggest getting that form from your designer before year-end regardless of anything else, because it documents who she is for your own records. What she does with it on her end in Canada is between her and the CRA.

0 coins

W-8BEN is the piece I was missing — I'd only ever dealt with W-9s before. Going to send her a note today asking if she can fill one out.

0 coins

W-8BEN was news to me too when I first hired someone outside the country. My payroll person had to explain the whole thing. The IRS's site actually has a pretty readable page on it.

0 coins

Exactly — the IRS's instructions for Form W-8BEN are on irs.gov and they're clearer than you'd expect. It's not a form you file with the IRS yourself, you just keep it in your records.

0 coins

I may be wrong about this but I thought any payment over $600 required a 1099 no matter what? Like the threshold is the same for everyone? I've been telling people that for years and now I'm second-guessing myself reading this thread.

0 coins

The $600 figure you're thinking of applies to payments to U.S. persons — it's the threshold for Form 1099-NEC for domestic contractors. Foreign persons are a different category entirely and the reporting rules work differently. A tax professional would be the right person to confirm how it applies to any specific payment.

0 coins

So I've been oversimplifying that for a while. Good to know there's a distinction before I give someone bad advice about a foreign contractor.

0 coins

I made the same assumption for a long time. It's one of those things that seems obvious until you read a little further and realize it's more layered.

0 coins

Something people skip: even before you figure out the reporting form question, you should know whether the work she did was performed inside or outside the U.S. That detail matters for how the IRS categorizes the income. If she was sitting in Canada the whole time doing the design work, that's foreign-source income. If she ever came to the U.S. to do any of the work, different story. I'm not saying I know the answer for your situation — I'd check with a tax pro — but it's the first question they're going to ask you.

0 coins

She was entirely remote, never set foot in the U.S. — all the work was done from her studio in Canada. Good to know that's a relevant factor.

0 coins

That remote vs. U.S. presence question tripped me up with an overseas vendor a couple years back. My accountant asked about it in the first five minutes.

0 coins

Had a withholding situation come up on my own return this year that sent me to the IRS by phone. The wages and withholding the IRS had on record from one employer didn't match what my W-2 showed, so I needed someone to read me the figures off my account. I used Claimyr and ended up on the phone with an agent who read me exactly what had been reported for the year — the wages and the withholding amount on record — which let me figure out where the discrepancy was coming from. On your question: the W-8BEN the person above mentioned is the right starting point. Keep it on file and talk to your accountant about whether withholding applies to your specific payments.

0 coins

Withholding is another thing I hadn't even thought about in this context — going to add it to my list of questions for my accountant.

0 coins

Withholding on foreign contractors is genuinely complicated and depends on the type of income and treaty status. I always just hand that piece straight to my CPA.

0 coins

Same — my accountant handles anything treaty-related. I just needed the raw figures off my account to know what the IRS had on record.

0 coins

Does the Canada-U.S. tax treaty change any of this? I know there's a treaty but I have no idea if it affects what a U.S. business has to do for reporting or withholding on payments to a Canadian. Curious if anyone's actually dealt with that layer.

0 coins

The treaty can affect withholding rates depending on the type of income, but working through how it applies to a specific payment is exactly the kind of thing a tax professional needs to walk through with you. It's not a simple lookup — it depends on what kind of income it is and other facts.

0 coins

That makes sense — it's not a general rule, it's specific to the facts. I'll flag it as a question for my own CPA when I get to this for my own business.

0 coins

My installment agreement had an amount in my IRS Online Account that didn't match what I thought we'd agreed to, and I needed someone to tell me the actual monthly amount and the due date on record. I used Claimyr and spoke with an agent who read me the payment plan's monthly amount and due date exactly as they were showing on my account. That cleared up the confusion immediately. On the original question here — I had a similar situation with a UK contractor a couple years ago and my accountant was clear that W-8BEN was the right form and that a 1099 wasn't the form to use for a foreign person who performed the work abroad.

0 coins

Good to hear the same answer from someone who actually went through it. I'll make sure I have her W-8BEN before I close the books on this year.

0 coins

I dealt with a payment plan discrepancy too — it's surprisingly common for the amount in the account to look off. Good to know there's a way to get a live person to confirm the figures.

0 coins

My understanding — and I could be off — is that you might still need to do something called Form 1042 and Form 1042-S for payments to foreign persons in certain situations, even when you're not issuing a 1099. I'm not certain which circumstances trigger that, but I ran across it when I was researching a similar question for my own LLC. Worth asking your accountant specifically whether those forms apply.

0 coins

You're pointing in the right direction — Form 1042 and 1042-S are part of the foreign person payment reporting picture. Whether they apply depends on factors like the type of income and whether withholding was required. Definitely a question for a tax professional rather than a forum.

0 coins

Glad I'm not totally off base. I didn't want to say it too confidently since I wasn't sure of all the conditions.

0 coins

Adding Form 1042 and 1042-S to my list. I had no idea there were this many forms involved in what felt like a simple contractor payment.

0 coins

Honestly this is why I've started requiring every contractor I bring on to give me the right form before I pay them a single invoice. If they're U.S.-based, W-9 before the first payment. If they're foreign, I ask what the right form is and have them fill it out. It's annoying to chase down at year-end. Live and learn.

0 coins

That's exactly the habit I'm going to build starting next year. The paperwork chase at the end of the year is not worth it.

0 coins

Collecting the form before the first payment is good practice. I had a contractor go dark on me after the project ended and tracking them down for a W-9 was a nightmare.

0 coins

My amended return for 2024 had been sitting with no movement in Where's My Refund for about four months, so I needed someone to actually look at the return's status on the account. I used Claimyr and got to a live IRS agent, who confirmed that the amended return had been received and told me it was still being processed — no additional action needed on my end. On your situation: everything in this thread about the W-8BEN is accurate from what I've seen. The 1099-NEC is strictly for U.S. persons reporting domestic payments; it's not the form for a foreign contractor.

0 coins

That confirmation on the amended return must have been a relief — four months of watching no movement would have me nervous. And thanks for the reinforcement on the W-8BEN.

0 coins

Four months on an amended return is actually within the normal window — the IRS says to allow up to 16 weeks in some cases. Good that the agent confirmed nothing was stuck.

0 coins

Knowing it was received and in process was enough for me — I just needed to rule out that it had gotten lost in the mail.

0 coins

I was confused for a while because I thought an ITIN and an EIN were the same type of number and either one would work on a W-8BEN. They're not the same at all. An ITIN is for an individual who can't get a Social Security number — it's a personal tax ID. An EIN is for a business entity. If your Canadian contractor is an individual doing freelance work, she'd use her own ITIN or her foreign tax identification number on the W-8BEN, not a business EIN. Worth knowing before you hand her the form.

0 coins

I definitely would have mixed those up — assumed an EIN was just a general tax ID number for anyone. Good catch.

0 coins

I made that exact mistake once and my accountant had to explain the difference. ITIN is an individual number for people who can't get an SSN, EIN is a business number. Totally different purposes.

0 coins

The W-7 is the application for an ITIN if she doesn't already have one and needs one for U.S. tax purposes — but whether she actually needs an ITIN in your situation is a question for your accountant.

0 coins

Does she need to have a U.S. ITIN to fill out the W-8BEN? Or can she use her Canadian tax number? I'm asking because I have a similar situation coming up with a contractor in Mexico and I want to get this right.

0 coins

The W-8BEN has a line for a foreign tax identification number, so she can use her Canadian tax ID there. Whether a U.S. ITIN is required depends on specific circumstances — your accountant or a tax professional would be the right person to confirm for your Mexico situation too.

0 coins

Helpful to know there's a foreign tax ID line on the form. I'll pull the W-8BEN instructions from the IRS's site and read them before I talk to my CPA.

0 coins

I ran into the question of what to do when a contractor refuses to fill out any form at all. My accountant told me that backup withholding rules kick in for U.S. persons who won't give you a W-9, but the situation is different for a confirmed foreign person who gives you a W-8BEN. The W-8BEN itself is the documentation. If you can't get any documentation at all, that's when things get complicated and a tax professional really needs to advise you.

0 coins

She's been responsive so far, so I don't think documentation will be an issue — but good to know what the stakes are if someone refuses.

0 coins

Had a contractor go unresponsive right as I needed their form. Ended up having to get my accountant involved just to figure out the right path forward.

0 coins

I want to flag one thing nobody's said yet: even if you determine that you don't issue a 1099 to a Canadian citizen in your situation, you still need to keep records of the payments. Invoices, bank transfers, whatever you have. The W-8BEN goes in that same file. If the IRS ever asks about the deduction for the contractor payments, your documentation is what supports it.

0 coins

Records are already in good shape — I kept every invoice and wire transfer confirmation. The W-8BEN is the piece that was missing.

0 coins

Documentation is half the battle with any contractor payment, domestic or foreign. Good habit regardless of which form applies.

0 coins

My brother-in-law's business got a notice a couple years ago asking about contractor payments and the IRS wanted to see that the business had collected the right forms. They didn't have W-8BENs on file for two foreign contractors and it was a real headache to sort out after the fact. Get the form before anything else.

0 coins

Chasing documentation after a notice is so much worse than collecting it upfront. That's exactly the kind of thing that makes you change your whole intake process.

0 coins

Exactly — now their policy is no payment goes out without the right form in hand. It was an expensive lesson.

0 coins

I looked into this a while back for a freelancer I was going to hire from outside the U.S. and the IRS's irs.gov site has a section specifically for businesses making payments to foreign persons. I found it by searching 'IRS payments to foreign persons' — it's clearer than most of the tax guides I've read online. The W-8 series forms are all explained there.

0 coins

Going straight to irs.gov tonight — I'd been reading third-party guides and they were giving me conflicting answers.

0 coins

The IRS's own pages really are more readable than a lot of the tax blogs out there. At least you know the information is current.

0 coins

I hired a graphic designer from Vancouver a few years ago — the whole thing seemed simple until I got to the tax part. My accountant ended up handling it and told me afterward that the W-8BEN and understanding the source of the income were the two things that mattered most for getting the paperwork right. The 1099-NEC never entered the picture.

0 coins

That's reassuring to hear from someone who's been through it end to end. W-8BEN and income source — those are my two anchors until I can reach my accountant.

0 coins

The income source piece is what most people don't think to ask. Where was she physically when she did the work? That's the question.

0 coins

I want to circle back to what someone said earlier about the W-8BEN not being filed with the IRS — that's right, you keep it in your own records. But it's not a set-it-and-forget-it thing either. The form has an expiration, and if you keep working with the same foreign contractor year after year, you'll need to get a fresh one periodically. Something to keep in mind if this becomes an ongoing relationship.

0 coins

I had no idea it had an expiration — glad that came up. This might become an ongoing relationship so I'll make a note to track it.

0 coins

The W-8BEN expiration piece is real. The instructions on irs.gov explain when a new one is needed. Worth reading them once so you know the triggers.

0 coins

Exactly — the instructions are worth reading even if your accountant handles the actual decision. At least you'll know the right questions to ask.

0 coins

I assumed for a long time that any form of payment — whether by check, wire, PayPal, whatever — had the same reporting requirements. Turns out the payment method doesn't change whether you need a W-8BEN; what matters is who the person is and where they performed the work. I had to unlearn that assumption when I hired my first foreign contractor.

0 coins

I was going to ask if the fact that I paid by wire transfer changed anything — good to know it doesn't affect the form requirements.

0 coins

Payment method is a completely separate question from reporting requirements. Easy assumption to make, but they're unrelated.

0 coins

Has anyone dealt with a situation where the foreign contractor is actually operating as a business entity rather than as an individual? My Canadian designer invoices through her own company, not under her personal name. I'm not sure if the W-8BEN is still the right form or if there's a different one for a foreign entity.

0 coins

If the contractor is a foreign business entity rather than an individual, the form would be a W-8BEN-E rather than a W-8BEN. The W-8BEN-E is for entities. Your accountant would need to confirm which one applies based on how her business is set up.

0 coins

W-8BEN-E for entities — that's the distinction I was missing. Going to look that up on the IRS's site tonight and then confirm with my CPA.

0 coins

I actually don't know if she invoices as an individual or through a registered business — going to ask her that too when I send the form request.

0 coins

The TAS — Taxpayer Advocate Service — is worth knowing about if you ever end up in a situation where the IRS hasn't responded to something and you're stuck. It's free and independent. Not relevant to your current question but it came up in my own experience when a business return got tied up for a long time. You can reach them at 1-877-777-4778 or through taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov.

0 coins

Good to have that in my back pocket. I'll bookmark the TAS page — hopefully I won't need it but it's good to know it exists.

0 coins

TAS has been a lifesaver for people I know who had returns stuck for more than 30 days past the normal timeframe. Worth knowing the threshold before you contact them.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure