< Back to IRS

Can my 18-year-old son file his own tax return if I claimed him as dependent?

I'm trying to figure out the proper procedure for my son's taxes this year. Here's what I've done so far: 1. I already filed my 2023 taxes and claimed my 18-year-old son as a dependent on my return 2. He worked part-time at the mall and received a W-2 3. I'm not sure if he can file his own return now 4. If he can file, would he mark himself as "can be claimed as dependent"? I've been doing taxes for 40+ years but this is our first time with this particular situation. I want to make sure we're doing everything by the book. Appreciate any guidance from folks who've been through this!

Alberto Souchard

Yes, your son absolutely can (and probably should) file his own tax return! šŸ˜Š The key is that he needs to check the box that says "Someone can claim you as a dependent" on his 1040. This doesn't mean he can't file - it just alerts the IRS that someone else is claiming him. If he had federal taxes withheld from his paychecks, he'll likely get those back as a refund. Even with minimal income, filing is usually worthwhile for young folks.

0 coins

-

Katherine Shultz

Does he need to file? His income was only about $4,200.

0 coins

-

11d

Marcus Marsh

Thanks for this explanation! I was wondering the same thing about my daughter who just started working. Glad to know she can still file her own return even though I claimed her.

0 coins

-

9d

Hailey O'Leary

My son was in this exact situation last April. He was 18, I claimed him as dependent, but he had a summer job that withheld taxes. He filed his own return on April 12th, checked the "can be claimed" box, and got a refund of $320 about 2 weeks later. Totally normal process!

0 coins

-

9d

Cedric Chung

If he files and marks that he can be claimed as a dependent, will that affect my refund at all? I received exactly $3,780 as part of my refund for claiming him.

0 coins

-

9d

Nia Watson

I went through this last year with my daughter! I was so confused at first. What worked for us was having her file as "can be claimed as dependent" and she still got her refund for the taxes withheld from her paychecks. I remember being worried it would mess up my return somehow, but it didn't. Just make sure he doesn't try to claim any credits that are only for independent filers - that's where we almost made a mistake.

0 coins

-

Talia Klein

OMG this EXACT situation drove me CRAZY last year! šŸ˜¤ Called the IRS like 27 times and couldn't get through to anyone! So frustrating! Finally used Claimyr (https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c) and got connected to an agent in like 15 minutes. They confirmed my son could file his own return even though I claimed him as dependent. He just had to check the box saying he could be claimed by someone else. Saved me hours of stress trying to figure it out on my own.

0 coins

-

Maxwell St. Laurent

I'm not sure a service is necessary for this particular question. This is pretty standard tax information that's available on the IRS website or from any tax preparer. While Claimyr might be helpful for complex issues, this seems like a straightforward dependent filing situation.

0 coins

-

10d

PaulineW

I used Claimyr last month when I had questions about my stimulus payment that never arrived. My experience: ā€¢ Called IRS directly first - waited 2+ hours, then disconnected ā€¢ Tried again next day - couldn't even get in queue ā€¢ Used Claimyr - connected in 18 minutes ā€¢ Agent resolved my issue in 10 minutes Worth it for me!

0 coins

-

9d

Annabel Kimball

I think what they're saying is that while this specific question might be simple, sometimes getting through to the IRS for any question can be nearly impossible during tax season. I've experienced those endless hold times myself.

0 coins

-

9d

Chris Elmeda

I've been in your exact shoes. My son turned 18 last year, had a part-time job at a restaurant, and I claimed him as a dependent. He filed his own return, checked the box that he could be claimed as a dependent, and everything went smoothly. He still got a refund for the federal taxes that were withheld from his paychecks. The only hiccup we had was that he initially tried to claim some education credits that he wasn't eligible for since I claimed him. Once we fixed that, no problems at all.

0 coins

-

Jean Claude

Thank you for sharing your experience! It's reassuring to hear from someone who's actually been through this exact situation.

0 coins

-

9d

Charity Cohan

Same experience with my daughter last year. She actually tried using one of those free filing websites and it kept trying to give her education credits she wasn't eligible for. We had to start over with a different service that handled dependent filers better.

0 coins

-

9d

Josef Tearle

Unlike what others are saying about filing separately, we actually had our son give us his W-2 and we included his income on our return using Form 8814 (Parents' Election to Report Child's Interest and Dividends). This worked better for our situation because his income was under $12,500. This approach compared to him filing separately saved us time and paperwork, though it might not be the right choice for everyone depending on the exact income amounts and your state tax situation.

0 coins

-

Shelby Bauman

Tax professional here. There's an important distinction to make regarding your son's filing requirements. If your 18-year-old son is a dependent with earned income (W-2 wages), he has a filing requirement if his earned income exceeds $12,950 for tax year 2023. However, even if he's not required to file, he should still consider filing if any federal income tax was withheld from his paychecks, as he'll likely receive that money back as a refund. When he files, he must indicate on Form 1040 that he can be claimed as a dependent on someone else's return. This doesn't prevent him from filing - it just impacts which deductions and credits he's eligible to claim.

0 coins

-

Quinn Herbert

So to clarify - even if my son made less than the $12,950 threshold, he should still file to get his withholding back, correct? He just needs to check the box saying I claimed him?

0 coins

-

9d

Salim Nasir

Does this apply to state taxes too? Or just federal?

0 coins

-

9d

Hazel Garcia

Correct on both counts. If any federal tax was withheld (check box 2 on his W-2), he should file to get that refunded, regardless of how little he made. And yes, he must check the box indicating he can be claimed as a dependent. As for state taxes, the rules vary by state, but generally, the same principle applies - if state tax was withheld, filing a state return would allow him to get that money back.

0 coins

-

9d

Laila Fury

Thank you for this detailed explanation! Makes the whole process much clearer.

0 coins

-

9d

Geoff Richards

Another approach to consider: 1. Have your son gather all his tax documents (W-2, etc.) 2. Help him create an account on one of the free filing services 3. Walk through the process together, making sure he checks "Someone can claim me as a dependent" 4. Review the return before submitting to ensure no improper credits are claimed 5. Have him file electronically for fastest processing This is what I did with my daughter last year. It was actually a good learning experience for her to understand how taxes work, while I was there to guide her through it.

0 coins

-

Simon White

Would you recommend a specific free filing service that handles dependent situations well? I tried one with my son and it kept trying to give him credits he wasn't eligible for.

0 coins

-

9d

Hugo Kass

I've had good experiences with the IRS Free File options, particularly FreeTaxUSA and TaxAct for dependent filers. The key is to answer the dependency questions correctly at the beginning of the process. Most services will then automatically restrict credits and deductions that don't apply to dependents. Just be sure to review the final return carefully before filing.

0 coins

-

9d