Can I convert a SEP IRA to a Roth IRA — will the IRS treat it like a regular rollover?
My tax situation got a lot more complicated this year and I'm trying to figure out if moving money from my SEP IRA into a Roth IRA is something the IRS actually allows. I've been self-employed for about six years, contribute to a SEP IRA every year, and recently had a conversation with a financial advisor who mentioned this conversion was possible — but then said I'd owe income tax on whatever I move over. That part I understood. What I can't figure out is whether the IRS treats this the same as a traditional IRA to Roth IRA conversion, or if there are different rules because it's a SEP. I filed my 2025 return on extension back in October and I'm still waiting on that refund, so the last thing I want is to do something wrong with my retirement accounts on top of that. Has anyone done this or talked to the IRS about it? My return is still showing as processing and I don't want to call about two separate things at once if I can avoid it.
73 comments

Owen Jenkins
An amended return I filed back in the spring for tax year 2024 sat with no movement in the tool for weeks, so I finally decided to phone the IRS directly. Hold times in the fall stretch well past 15 minutes most days, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with 800-829-1040 for you so you end up talking to a live agent. Video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent pulled up my record and confirmed the 1040-X had been received and was in processing — they gave me the exact date it was logged. That was all I needed to stop checking every other day. On your SEP question, the IRS itself doesn't publish guidance on that through the online account or Where's My Refund — that's really a question for a tax professional or the form instructions, since how a SEP conversion is taxed goes beyond what the IRS's general phone line will walk you through.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Your amended return situation is basically what I'm dreading. Mine for 2024 has been sitting at 'received' in the tool for about nine weeks now — does the agent actually give you a processing timeline or just confirm receipt?
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
My agent confirmed the receipt date and said to allow the standard processing window — they didn't go beyond what the IRS's own published timeframes say. No estimate beyond that, which is frustrating but at least I knew the form hadn't gotten lost.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Your point about the SEP question being outside what the phone line covers is right. The IRS's general line handles account and return questions, not tax planning. For the conversion mechanics a tax professional or a CPA is the right call.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
SEP IRAs and traditional IRAs actually sit in the same bucket for IRS purposes when it comes to conversions — you can roll a SEP IRA into a Roth IRA, but every dollar you move gets counted as ordinary income in the year you do it. That's the part that catches people off guard. Your financial advisor is right that the tax hit is real. The IRS doesn't treat the SEP differently from a regular pre-tax traditional IRA for this purpose, as far as the rollover rules go. But the actual tax consequences of your specific numbers are something you'd want to map out with a professional before moving anything, especially if you're already waiting on a refund from a return filed on extension.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorThe 'counted as ordinary income' piece is what I keep coming back to. My 2025 return is already on the complicated side with the self-employment income, so adding a large conversion on top of that in the same year might not be smart timing. Worth figuring out before year-end though.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Your note about timing is exactly the thing. If the OP is already in a higher bracket from self-employment income this year, a large conversion could push things further. That's the year-end math a CPA can run before December 31.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Partial conversions are also an option — you don't have to move the whole balance in one year. You could convert a portion and spread the tax impact across multiple years. Still a question for a professional, but it's worth knowing the IRS doesn't require you to do it all at once.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Waited seven months for my 2025 refund from an October extension filing and it still shows 'being processed.' I know that's not the same as your SEP question but the double-stress of a pending refund AND trying to plan a conversion in the same tax year is real. I ended up just deciding to hold off on any big retirement account moves until my refund actually posts and I can see what my final 2025 tax picture looks like.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorHonestly that's probably the smarter approach — my refund is still in processing too and trying to plan the conversion math without knowing what 2025 fully looks like feels premature.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
Your refund from an October extension — have you checked the IRS Online Account to see if there's any notice or adjustment showing? Sometimes the account shows something that Where's My Refund doesn't.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
My accountant explained the SEP-to-Roth path to me last year when I was considering it. The IRS sees it as a two-step thing in some cases — SEP to traditional IRA first if the funds aren't already in a traditional IRA, then traditional to Roth. But if your SEP IRA is already set up as a SEP-IRA at a brokerage, many custodians can do a direct conversion to Roth without the intermediate step. Either way the tax treatment is the same: you owe income tax on the converted amount. The IRS form instructions and your plan custodian are both good starting points before you decide anything.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorMine is at a brokerage so the direct conversion path might be available — I hadn't thought about asking the custodian directly. Good point about checking with them alongside a tax professional.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
Your two-step description — does that apply even if the SEP contributions were always pre-tax? I assumed any SEP balance is pre-tax by definition, so the whole thing gets taxed on conversion regardless of how many steps it takes.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
Pre-tax on the way in, yes — SEP contributions are always pre-tax, so the whole converted amount is taxable income when it hits the Roth. The step question is more about how your custodian processes the transfer than about the tax treatment, which stays the same either way.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Went through this exact conversion process in early 2025 with a portion of my SEP. My CPA ran the numbers and we picked an amount that kept me from jumping into the next bracket. The IRS didn't flag anything unusual — my return processed normally and the Roth conversion just showed up as income on the 1040. Form 1099-R from the custodian is what the IRS uses to verify the conversion amount, so make sure that form matches what you report.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorForm 1099-R — that's the one I'd receive from the brokerage after the conversion, right? And that's what I'd report on the 2026 return since any conversion I do now would happen this year?
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Correct — if you convert in 2026, the custodian sends a 1099-R for the 2026 tax year, and you report it on the return due in April 2027. Your CPA can walk you through where it lands on the 1040.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Your point about not jumping a bracket is the key planning piece. A partial conversion timed before December 31 is a real strategy, but you need current-year income estimates to do it right. Worth getting in front of a professional before year-end.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
A letter showed up on my IRS Online Account in September — it was asking for additional information related to my 2024 return. I'd missed the notice in my physical mail and only caught it because I logged in to check my transcript. Used Claimyr to get to a live agent at 800-829-1040 and found out the notice had been issued in August, what it was specifically asking for, and the response deadline. I sent in what they needed the following week. Flagging this for anyone with a pending return: logging into the IRS Online Account regularly is worth it — digital copies of notices show up there sometimes before the paper copy arrives.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorMy IRS Online Account hasn't shown any notices for my 2025 return yet, which is reassuring — but I should probably be checking it more often than I am.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Your September notice situation — did the agent say anything about how long it typically takes for the IRS to process a response after you send it in? My account shows a pending item from earlier this year and I'm not sure if I should follow up.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
My agent said to give it the time frame shown on the notice itself and that I'd hear back by mail if anything else was needed. No specific estimate beyond what the notice said.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
Roth conversions from a SEP are also irreversible now — the IRS eliminated the recharacterization option for conversions a few years back, so once you move money from the SEP into the Roth, there's no undoing it if the market drops or your tax bill is higher than expected. That's not a reason not to do it, but it's a reason to be very certain about the amount before you pull the trigger.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorWait — recharacterization was eliminated? I had no idea. I thought you could undo a conversion within a certain period. That changes the planning picture significantly.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
Recharacterization of conversions was removed starting with tax year 2018. You can still recharacterize a contribution — like if you put money into a Roth IRA directly and then find out you're over the income limit — but not a conversion. Your tax professional can confirm this for your situation.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Your recharacterization point is the most important thing in this thread for someone on the fence about timing. The 'I can always undo it' safety net doesn't exist for conversions anymore.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
My refund from an extension filing this fall has been sitting at 'return received, being processed' for about ten weeks. I know the IRS says mailed returns can take six weeks or more, but mine was e-filed — does the processing time stretch this long for October extension e-files, or is there something I should check?
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
E-filed returns on extension generally still aim for the same roughly three-week refund window from acceptance, but returns filed in October can sometimes take longer depending on volume. Checking the IRS Online Account is worth it — it can show if anything is pending or if a notice was generated that hasn't arrived by mail yet.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
My IRS Online Account shows the return but no notices and no refund date. I guess I keep waiting — ten weeks feels long for an e-file but maybe not unusual for an extension return.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Your situation sounds close to mine. Extension e-files don't always move as fast as early-season ones. Eleven weeks and counting here, still at 'being processed.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
I got confused about this for a while — I kept reading about Roth conversion income limits and thinking my SEP conversion would be blocked if I earned too much. Turns out the income limit applies to direct Roth IRA contributions, not to conversions. There's no income cap on doing a Roth conversion, SEP or traditional IRA. My CPA cleared that up for me last spring and I wish I'd known it sooner.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorThat's a relief actually — I make too much to contribute to a Roth directly, so I'd assumed the same limit applied to conversions. Knowing there's no income ceiling on conversions makes this more viable.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Your point about the income limit only applying to direct contributions is accurate and worth highlighting. The confusion between contribution limits and conversion limits trips up a lot of people planning a Roth conversion for the first time.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
My CPA also mentioned the pro-rata rule, which is something to ask about if you have any after-tax basis in any traditional IRA — it affects how the taxable portion is calculated on conversion. Not a simple calculation if you have multiple IRAs.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
After my October extension e-file, Where's My Refund went silent for almost two months — no status update, no refund date, nothing. Tried calling 800-829-1040 several times and kept hitting long waits that ended without reaching anyone. Eventually I went through Claimyr, and a live IRS agent pulled up my account and told me the refund amount that was showing on my record and the date it had been issued. It had already gone out — just hadn't hit my bank account yet, which the agent confirmed was showing as sent. Checked my bank the next morning and it was there. For anyone with a stalled Where's My Refund and a refund from an extension return, the account sometimes updates later than the actual deposit.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorTwo months with no Where's My Refund update and it had already been sent — that's both frustrating and reassuring. Mine is coming up on ten weeks now so maybe I should check the online account more carefully.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Your experience with the deposit arriving before the tool updated — did the IRS Online Account show it any earlier than Where's My Refund did, or were they both behind?
0 coins
Rami Samuels
My IRS Online Account also lagged behind the actual deposit. The agent's information was more current than either tool at the time I called.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
Your bank showing it the next morning after the agent confirmed it was sent — that timeline matches what a lot of people report. The tools just don't refresh as fast as the actual payment system apparently.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Pro-rata rule is worth understanding before you convert anything from a SEP. If you have multiple IRAs — including any traditional IRAs with after-tax contributions — the IRS calculates the taxable portion of your conversion across all of them together, not just the SEP. So even if you're trying to convert only the pre-tax SEP money, any after-tax basis you have sitting in another IRA gets factored in. It's one of those things that seems simple until you do the math.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorMy only IRA is the SEP — no traditional IRA with after-tax contributions. Does the pro-rata rule still apply in that case, or does it simplify if everything in the IRA is pre-tax?
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
If your only IRA is the SEP and all contributions were pre-tax, the math simplifies significantly — the entire converted amount is taxable income, full stop, no proration needed. The pro-rata issue mainly comes up when you have a mix of pre-tax and after-tax IRA money across multiple accounts.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Your simplified scenario — all pre-tax, single account — is actually the cleaner conversion case. The form your custodian sends after the conversion will show the full distribution as taxable, and your return reflects that.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Filing on extension and then trying to do year-end retirement planning at the same time is genuinely chaotic. My 2025 return is still sitting in processing after nine weeks and I've basically put all retirement account decisions on hold until I know what my tax picture actually looks like. A partial SEP-to-Roth conversion is on my list for 2027 when I'll have a cleaner year behind me.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorWaiting until next year sounds reasonable — though I keep thinking about the long-term benefit of getting money into a Roth sooner. Hard to weigh that against the uncertainty of doing it in a year when my return is still unresolved.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
The long-term math on a Roth is real, but so is the short-term tax hit. If your 2025 self-employment income was high, adding a conversion this year might not be the right move. Getting the 2025 return fully settled first lets you make 2026 decisions with better information.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
My CPA ran me through this last December and one thing she flagged was estimated tax payments. If you do a large Roth conversion in 2026 and you're self-employed, you're already making quarterly estimated payments — but a big conversion could mean your Q4 payment needs to be larger to avoid an underpayment penalty. The deadline for the Q4 2026 estimated payment is in January 2027. Worth factoring in if you're considering converting before year-end.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorEstimated payments — I hadn't connected those two things. If I convert in December, would that all go on the Q4 payment due in January, or do I need to adjust something sooner?
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Your Q4 payment due in January 2027 would cover income earned through December 31, 2026, including any conversion done in December. But the size of that payment depends on your full-year income picture, so your CPA or a tax professional should run the numbers before you convert. Underpayment penalties are real if the quarterly payments end up too low.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Your estimated payment point is a good one that doesn't come up enough in these conversations. Self-employed people doing large Roth conversions in Q4 sometimes get surprised by an underpayment situation come filing time.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Tried to look up Roth conversion rules in my IRS Online Account and realized pretty quickly that the online account is for account and return information — not tax planning guidance. The IRS's site has publications and form instructions that cover the rollover and conversion rules in detail, but honestly for a decision this size, paying a CPA for a one-time planning session is worth it. The online account is great for checking your balance, pulling transcripts, seeing notices — not for answering 'should I convert and how much.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorUsing the IRS Online Account for transcripts and notices makes sense — I've got it set up with ID.me and check my transcripts occasionally. I just wasn't sure if there was guidance on the SEP conversion question somewhere I was missing on the IRS's site.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
The IRS's publications page has Publication 590-A and 590-B covering IRA contributions and distributions, including rollovers and conversions. Those are the official sources for the rules. But the planning piece — how much to convert given your income — is where a professional earns their fee.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
My amended 1040-X for 2024 has been in processing since late spring and I keep second-guessing whether I should call or just wait. The amended return tool says 'received' but hasn't moved to 'adjusted' or 'completed' in nine weeks. Is that normal or should I be concerned?
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Nine weeks is still within the range the IRS says to allow — they tell people to expect 8 to 12 weeks, sometimes up to 16. The tool not moving from 'received' doesn't mean something is wrong, it just means it hasn't been fully processed yet. The status should update when it gets further along.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Twelve or sixteen weeks is a long time to just sit on it. My 1040-X involved a pretty significant change to my reported income so I keep worrying something will come up that requires a response.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
Your concern about a response request is worth monitoring — the IRS may send a letter if they need something, and those show up in the IRS Online Account sometimes before the paper copy arrives. Checking the account every couple of weeks is probably your best early-warning system.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
The five-year rule on Roth IRAs is something nobody explained to me when I did my first Roth conversion. Each conversion starts its own five-year clock for penalty-free withdrawals of that converted amount — separate from the five-year rule on earnings. So if you're close to retirement and you think you might need access to the converted funds within five years, that affects the planning. Worth asking your tax professional about if timeline is a factor.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorMy retirement is probably 15 years out so the five-year clock doesn't scare me much, but I hadn't heard of each conversion having its own clock — I thought there was one five-year period for the whole Roth account.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
Your account's five-year clock for earnings starts with the year you first fund any Roth IRA. The conversion-specific five-year rule is a separate layer that applies to each converted amount individually for the penalty on that principal. Your tax professional can explain how the two rules interact for your specific situation.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Your layered five-year rule point is one of the more confusing parts of Roth planning. The IRS has different clocks running for different purposes, and the rules interact in ways that aren't obvious from reading a summary.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
My SEP contributions this year were pretty significant and I've been going back and forth on whether to convert any of it before December 31. The income tax hit feels large right now, but the idea of decades of tax-free growth in a Roth is hard to ignore. What finally got me to slow down was my CPA pointing out that the break-even on a Roth conversion depends entirely on what your tax rate is now versus what it's likely to be in retirement — and that's a personal calculation, not a universal answer.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorYour CPA's break-even framing is probably the most useful way I've heard this explained. If I expect my retirement income to be lower than my current self-employment income, the conversion math might not favor doing it now. Something to actually model out.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
Exactly — and if you have state income tax on top of federal, the break-even shifts again. Your CPA can run the numbers for your specific state situation alongside the federal piece.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Went through the SEP-to-Roth conversion decision last year and ended up not doing it. My reasoning was simple: I'm having a good income year, the tax hit would have been substantial, and I didn't want to pay the highest rate on the converted amount now when I genuinely don't know what rates will look like in 15 years. I kept the SEP as is and my CPA suggested I revisit in a year where my income is lower. That might not apply to everyone but it was the right call for my situation.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorLower-income year as the right window for a conversion makes sense — I hadn't thought about timing it around a business slow period rather than just doing it now because the account balance has grown.
0 coins
Nina Chan
My CPA also mentioned that some people do conversions specifically in years between retiring and taking Social Security, when income temporarily dips. If you're self-employed and have flexibility over when and how much income you recognize, there may be future years that make more sense than 2026.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Your point about timing the conversion around income is the core of Roth conversion strategy. A lower-income year — a business transition, a gap year, early retirement — is exactly when the math tends to favor pulling the trigger.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Worth knowing that the IRS doesn't have a specific form just for reporting a Roth conversion — it flows through your 1040 via Form 8606, which tracks your IRA basis and reports the taxable conversion amount. The 1099-R from your custodian kicks off the reporting, but Form 8606 is where the IRS sees the actual conversion math. Your tax software or CPA handles this, but if you're a DIY filer it's worth knowing 8606 exists before you file.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
AuthorForm 8606 — hadn't come across that one yet. My current tax software handles it automatically when I enter the 1099-R info?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Most major tax software walks you through the 8606 when you enter a 1099-R showing a rollover or conversion — it'll ask questions about your IRA basis and populate the form. If you've never had after-tax IRA contributions the form is pretty straightforward.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Your point about 8606 being automatically triggered by the 1099-R is accurate for most software. The key is making sure the basis information is correct — if you've made any after-tax traditional IRA contributions over the years, that history needs to be in there.
0 coins