


Ask the community...
I've been dealing with similar issues with Robinhood's options wash sale reporting. One thing that helped me understand the problem better was pulling my own trade history and manually calculating what should and shouldn't be wash sales based on the IRS criteria. For options, the key factors are: same underlying stock, same strike price, AND same expiration date. If any of these differ, there's a strong argument that they're not "substantially identical." However, Robinhood's system seems to flag anything with the same underlying as a potential wash sale, which is overly broad. In your PYPL case, if you never repurchased options with identical terms within the 30-day window, those definitely shouldn't be wash sales. The $0.00 profit/loss display is almost certainly a system glitch - I've seen this happen when their automated calculations get confused by expired contracts. My advice: Document everything with specific transaction dates and contract details. When you contact support, reference the specific IRS Publication 550 language about "substantially identical securities" and ask them to review each flagged transaction individually rather than relying on their automated system. It's frustrating, but the squeaky wheel gets the grease with Robinhood. Keep escalating until you reach someone who actually understands options taxation rather than just reading from a script.
This is really helpful advice! I'm new to options trading and had no idea about the specific criteria for "substantially identical" securities. I've been getting wash sale flags on what seem like completely different contracts just because they're for the same underlying stock. Quick question - when you say "same expiration date," does that mean the exact same expiration, or would weekly options vs monthly options for the same week potentially be considered different? I've been trading both SPY weeklies and monthlies and I'm wondering if that affects the wash sale treatment. Also, has anyone had success citing IRS Publication 550 specifically when dealing with Robinhood support? I'm wondering if mentioning specific tax code sections actually helps or if their first-level support just ignores it.
Great question about the expiration dates! Yes, it needs to be the exact same expiration date for the IRS to consider options "substantially identical." So SPY weeklies expiring on Friday and SPY monthlies expiring that same Friday would be considered the same, but weeklies vs monthlies with different expiration dates would not trigger wash sales. Regarding citing IRS Publication 550 - it definitely helps, but you need to get past the first-level support. The initial chat representatives usually don't understand tax regulations and will just give you generic responses. However, once you get escalated to their tax specialist team (which you can request specifically), mentioning Publication 550 Section 4 about wash sales and providing the specific language about "substantially identical securities" carries a lot more weight. I'd recommend having the exact quote ready: "Substantially identical securities include the same stock in the same corporation." For options, this has been interpreted to require same underlying, strike, AND expiration. The more specific you can be with regulatory citations, the more likely they are to take your case seriously and actually review the transactions rather than just defending their automated system. One tip: when you escalate, specifically ask to speak with someone who handles "complex options taxation issues" rather than general customer service. That usually gets you routed to someone with actual knowledge of these rules.
I've been following this thread closely as I'm dealing with a similar situation. Just wanted to add another perspective on the "substantially identical" issue that might help others. I had a case last year where I was trading AAPL options - sold some $150 calls expiring in March at a loss, then bought $155 calls expiring in April within the wash sale period. Robinhood flagged this as a wash sale, but when I challenged it, they eventually agreed it shouldn't have been flagged since both the strike price AND expiration date were different. The key insight I learned from my tax attorney is that the IRS applies the "substantially identical" test very strictly for options. Even a $5 difference in strike price or one day difference in expiration is enough to make them NOT substantially identical. This is different from stocks where small differences might still be considered substantially identical. What really helped me was creating a simple table showing: - Original contract: Underlying, Strike, Expiration, Sale Date - Replacement contract: Underlying, Strike, Expiration, Purchase Date - Days between transactions - Why they're NOT substantially identical This visual format made it much easier for Robinhood's tax team to understand why their automated system was wrong. I'd recommend anyone dealing with this issue to document it the same way - it really cuts through the confusion and gives them something concrete to work with. For what it's worth, after getting my corrected 1099, my additional deductible losses were about $8,400. Definitely worth the effort to fight these incorrect wash sale designations.
This is exactly the kind of systematic approach I needed to see! Thank you for sharing that table format - it makes so much sense to document it visually rather than trying to explain it in paragraphs. I'm dealing with a similar situation where Robinhood flagged SPY options as wash sales even though they had different strikes and expirations. Your example with AAPL gives me confidence that these should definitely be challengeable. Quick follow-up question: when you submitted this to Robinhood, did you go through regular support channels or did you have to escalate to get someone who understood the nuance? And roughly how long did the whole process take from initial challenge to receiving the corrected 1099? Also, did your tax attorney charge a lot for helping with this? I'm trying to weigh whether it's worth getting professional help or if the documentation approach you described is enough to handle it myself.
Don't forget about reporting requirements! While the transfer itself might not be taxable beyond potential currency gains, you may need to file an FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) if your foreign accounts exceeded $10,000 total at any point during the year. I learned this the hard way after moving money between my Canadian and US accounts. The penalties for not filing an FBAR can be severe even if you don't owe any taxes. There's also Form 8938 if your foreign assets exceed certain thresholds, but that typically applies to residents, not someone on a J-1 visa. Since you were on a J-1 and never a US resident for tax purposes, your reporting requirements might be different, but it's worth checking just to be safe.
Does using TransferWise (now Wise) change any of this? I've been using them for my US-France transfers because the fees are lower than bank wire transfers.
Using Wise (formerly TransferWise) doesn't change the fundamental tax treatment or reporting requirements. The IRS cares about the value of your foreign accounts and any currency gains, not which transfer method you use. However, Wise makes it easier to document your transfers since they clearly show the exchange rates used and fees charged. This can be helpful for calculating any currency gains. Just remember that for FBAR purposes, if you have a Wise account that holds balances, that might also count as a foreign financial account that needs to be included in your FBAR reporting if your total foreign accounts exceed $10,000.
Just went through this exact situation last month when transferring funds from my US account back to Australia after finishing my F-1 OPT period. Here's what I discovered: The transfer itself is NOT taxable - you're just moving your own money between accounts. However, you do need to be aware of potential foreign exchange gains/losses. Since you earned the money at one exchange rate and are transferring at potentially a different rate, any gain could technically be taxable income. For your J-1 situation specifically, since you were never a US resident for tax purposes, your obligations are more limited than someone who was a resident. But you should still document the original exchange rates when you earned the money versus when you transfer it. One thing that caught me off guard - make sure to check if you need to file an FBAR. Even though you're not a US resident, if your UK account (or combination of foreign accounts) exceeded $10,000 at any point during the tax year, you might still have FBAR filing requirements. The rules can be tricky for non-residents with US source income. I'd recommend keeping detailed records of when you earned the money, the exchange rates at that time, and the rates when you transfer. That way you're covered if there are any questions later.
This is really helpful - I'm actually in a similar situation but with transfers to Canada. Quick question: when you mention documenting the "original exchange rates when you earned the money" - did you use the daily rates from when each paycheck was deposited, or did you use some kind of average rate for the period you were working? I'm trying to figure out the most accurate way to track this since I had regular paychecks over 8 months.
For tracking exchange rates on regular paychecks, I used the daily rates from when each paycheck was actually deposited into my US account. It's more work than using an average rate, but it's also more accurate and defensible if the IRS ever questions it. I created a simple spreadsheet with columns for deposit date, USD amount, exchange rate that day (I used the Treasury's daily rates), and the equivalent value in my home currency. When I transferred the money months later, I could calculate the exact gain/loss for each deposit. Using an average rate for the whole period might seem easier, but it could either overstate or understate your actual gains depending on how exchange rates moved. Plus, the IRS generally prefers actual transaction-date rates when they're available. The extra documentation effort was worth it for the peace of mind.
This thread has been such a goldmine of information! I just filed my return three days ago and was already starting to check my transcript daily (okay, maybe more than daily...). Reading through everyone's detailed experiences has completely changed my understanding of the process. The fact that the 846 code is actually the Treasury authorization rather than just a status notification makes so much sense - no wonder it's such a consistent predictor across everyone's stories here! I love how this community shares real data points instead of just speculation. Currently showing the 150 code, but now I know exactly what to watch for and when to check. Definitely implementing the Friday morning strategy to save my sanity. Thanks to everyone for sharing their timelines and experiences - this is exactly the kind of practical information that helps reduce the tax season stress!
Welcome to the transcript checking club! I just joined this community myself and filed around the same time as you. This thread has been absolutely invaluable - I had no idea about the technical details behind the 846 code until reading everyone's experiences here. It's so reassuring to see how consistent the pattern is across different people's situations. I was definitely heading toward the same obsessive checking habit, but learning that it's actually the Treasury authorization (not just a status update) really helps explain why the timing is so reliable. The Friday morning strategy seems like a much healthier approach than my current "check whenever I'm bored" method! Thanks for adding another data point to this incredibly helpful discussion.
Just filed my return yesterday and already found myself checking my transcript this morning - glad I discovered this thread early! The technical explanation about the 846 code being the actual Treasury authorization rather than just a status update is incredibly helpful. I had always assumed these codes were just informational, but understanding that 846 literally triggers the payment process makes the timing patterns everyone's describing make perfect sense. Currently showing the standard 150 code, but now I know exactly what progression to expect and when to realistically check for updates. The Friday morning strategy sounds much more sustainable than daily checking - thanks everyone for sharing such consistent real-world experiences instead of just guessing about how the system works!
I'm so glad I found this thread! I'm dealing with almost the exact same situation - unemployed since January and just discovered I owe $2,400 from some freelance work I did last year. The stress has been keeping me up at night. Reading through everyone's experiences has been incredibly helpful and reassuring. I had no idea there were so many options available beyond just "pay it all or face consequences." The Currently Not Collectible status sounds like it might be perfect for my situation while I'm job hunting. One thing I want to add that helped me when I was researching this - make sure to check if you qualify for any earned income tax credit or other credits you might have missed. Sometimes people in tough financial situations overlook credits they're entitled to, which could reduce what you owe. Also, I called my local VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) program and they offered to review my return for free to make sure I didn't miss any deductions from my freelance work. It's worth double-checking before you commit to owing the full amount. Thank you to everyone who shared their stories here - knowing that so many people have successfully worked through this exact situation has given me hope that I can figure this out too. This community has been a lifeline during what felt like an impossible situation!
@1fc5995409a3 Thank you for mentioning VITA programs! As someone who's also new to dealing with tax debt while unemployed, I hadn't heard of the free return review service they offer. That's such a valuable resource, especially when you're trying to make sure you haven't missed any deductions that could reduce what you owe. Your point about checking for earned income tax credit and other credits is really important too. When you're stressed about owing money, it's easy to overlook that there might be credits you qualify for that could help offset the debt. I'm in a very similar situation - lost my job a few months ago and just realized I owe money from some contract work I did last year. Reading through everyone's experiences in this thread has been such a relief. Like you said, knowing there are options like Currently Not Collectible status, payment plans, and penalty relief makes this feel manageable instead of hopeless. It's amazing how supportive this community has been. When I first saw my tax bill, I felt so alone and panicked. But seeing how many people have been in this exact situation and found ways to work it out has really helped calm my anxiety. We're definitely going to figure this out!
I'm in a remarkably similar situation and this thread has been such a blessing to find! Lost my job in October and just calculated that I owe about $2,700 from driving for Lyft and doing some freelance photography work last year. The panic when I first saw that number was absolutely crushing. What's really helped me feel less alone is seeing how many people here have navigated this exact scenario successfully. I had no idea options like Currently Not Collectible status existed, or that the IRS might actually be willing to work with unemployed people rather than just demanding immediate payment. I'm definitely going to start with that online Payment Plan tool several people mentioned, and if I need more help, I'll reach out to the Taxpayer Advocate Service. The fact that there's free guidance available without any sales pressure is such a relief. One thing I learned from my unemployment counselor that might help others - if you're receiving any kind of job training or certification assistance through your state's unemployment services, keep track of those expenses too. Some of them can be deductible as job search costs for next year's taxes. Thank you to everyone who shared their stories here, especially @51c8bbd08643 for starting this conversation. Knowing there's a community of people who understand exactly what this feels like and have found ways through it has given me the courage to actually address this instead of hiding from it. We've got this!
@65e896fcd3a5 Aaron, thank you for sharing your story and for mentioning the job training expenses tip! That's something I hadn't considered, and since I'm also going through some certification programs while job hunting, it's good to know those costs might be deductible next year. Your situation sounds so similar to mine - I'm also dealing with gig work taxes (drove for Uber and did some freelance writing) after losing my job earlier this year. Like you, I had that same crushing panic when I first calculated what I owed. But this thread has been incredible for showing us that we're definitely not alone in this. I'm really impressed by how supportive everyone has been here. When I first joined this community, I was honestly embarrassed about my situation and worried people would judge me for not understanding the tax implications of gig work better. But seeing how common this experience is - and how many people have successfully worked through it - has been such a relief. I think you're absolutely right that we've got this! Between all the options people have shared (payment plans, Currently Not Collectible status, penalty relief, free resources like VITA and the Taxpayer Advocate Service), there are real paths forward. It's just a matter of taking that first step and being proactive about it instead of letting the anxiety paralyze us. Thank you again to @51c8bbd08643 for creating this space where we could all share and learn from each other!
StarSeeker
Don't forget that QBI gets reported on Form 8995 (simplified) or 8995-A (full) depending on your income level. I messed this up my first year and just put the deduction on Schedule C which was totally wrong!
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
ā¢Also worth noting that some tax software doesn't calculate QBI correctly if you don't specifically enter your business information in the right sections. I used TurboTax last year and it missed applying my QBI deduction until I went back and made sure all my 1099 income was properly classified as business income.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
Just wanted to add another important point about QBI that I learned the hard way - the deduction is subject to an overall limitation of 20% of your taxable income MINUS net capital gains. This usually isn't an issue for most people, but it can come into play if you have significant capital losses or other deductions that bring your taxable income way down. Also, make sure you're tracking all your business expenses carefully throughout the year. Since QBI is calculated on your net business income (after expenses), every legitimate business deduction you can take will increase your QBI deduction. Things like home office expenses, business meals (50% deductible), professional development, software subscriptions, etc. can all add up to meaningful tax savings. One more tip - if you're planning to scale up your side business, consider whether forming an S-Corp might make sense once your income gets higher. The tax implications change significantly, but it can sometimes result in overall tax savings when you factor in both QBI and self-employment tax considerations.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
ā¢This is incredibly helpful! I hadn't considered the S-Corp election for the future. At what income level does it typically make sense to consider that switch? I'm still pretty new to all this but my side business is growing faster than I expected. Also, you mentioned the 20% of taxable income limitation - does that include my W-2 income in the calculation, or just the business income portion? With my combined income around $225K, I want to make sure I'm not missing anything that could limit my QBI deduction. Thanks for the detailed breakdown on tracking expenses too. I've been pretty good about receipts but I'm definitely going to review what I might have missed for legitimate business deductions.
0 coins