
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Title: 1098-T filing question for dependent with scholarship income - when is filing required? 1 I'm struggling to wrap my head around my son's tax situation with his 1098-T form. From what I understand, the scholarships and grants listed in box 5 are taxable on his return if they exceed what's in box 1 (qualified education expenses). His excess scholarship amount is about $3,200 which is below the standard deduction. Does he actually need to file a tax return at all in this case? Can he just skip filing since he won't owe anything, or is he still required to file even though he's under the standard deduction? I've read so many IRS publications about the 1098-T and I still can't make sense of the filing requirements! Anyone dealt with this before?
My son just received his college scholarship for the upcoming academic year, and I'm trying to figure out our tax situation. His scholarship amount is about $6,800 more than his qualified educational expenses (tuition, fees, books). I've got the 1098-T form that shows everything, and since he's still our dependent, I'm planning to include this on our family tax return. But here's my question - does he also need to file his own separate tax return even though this scholarship overage is his only income for the year? He hasn't had a job or earned anything else in 2024 that would normally require filing. I know the excess scholarship money is technically taxable, but I'm confused about WHO needs to report it when he's our dependent. Is this something I handle on our return, or does he need to file separately even with no other income? Thanks for any help you can offer!
Has anyone dealt with reporting this excess scholarship income when the student has no way to pay the taxes? My daughter's in this exact situation - scholarship exceeds tuition by $7200, but that money went directly to her housing which is already spent. She has no income or savings to pay the tax bill. Does she need to make estimated tax payments during the year?
This is such a common confusion for families! One thing that might help clarify the situation is understanding that even though your son is your dependent, the IRS views scholarship income as belonging to the student who received it, not the parents. This is different from other types of investment income that might be reported on the parent's return under certain circumstances. For the $6,800 excess, your son will need to file Form 1040 and report this amount on Line 1a as wages (with "SCH" written next to it to indicate scholarship income). Make sure to keep good records of what the scholarship was used for - the IRS may want documentation showing which expenses were qualified vs. non-qualified. Also, don't forget to check if your son might owe estimated taxes for next year if this scholarship pattern continues. Since there's no withholding on scholarship money like there is with regular wages, he might need to make quarterly payments to avoid underpayment penalties.
I've been looking everywhere online but can't find a clear answer - I'm probably not using the right terminology. My partner and I are thinking about buying a duplex where we'd live in one half and rent out the other half. We have a combined income that puts us in the 35% federal tax bracket. Since we'd be occupying one of the two units, I'm wondering if there's a maximum amount of mortgage interest and property tax we can deduct against the rental income? I know we'll be meeting with a tax professional when we get closer to actually making the purchase, but for planning purposes, I'd love to get some clarity on this now. Just trying to understand the tax implications before we get too far along. Thanks for any help!
Has anyone considered the impact of living in a duplex on your ability to exclude gain when selling? From what I understand, you can only exclude gain on the portion you lived in under the primary residence exclusion ($250k single/$500k married).
Great question! I went through this exact situation when I purchased my duplex three years ago. The key thing to understand is that you'll be treating this as a mixed-use property - part personal residence, part rental business. For mortgage interest deductions, you'll allocate based on the percentage of the property used for each purpose (usually square footage). So if each unit is equal, 50% of your mortgage interest goes on Schedule A (subject to the $750k loan limit) and 50% goes on Schedule E as a rental expense (no limit). Don't forget about depreciation on the rental portion - that's a major tax benefit! You can depreciate 50% of the property's basis (excluding land) over 27.5 years. Also, make sure to track all expenses separately: utilities, maintenance, insurance, etc. The rental portion expenses are fully deductible against rental income. One tip: keep detailed records of your square footage calculations and any improvements made to each unit. The IRS may want to see your allocation method if audited. A simple floor plan with measurements works great for documentation. Since you're in the 35% bracket, the rental deductions will provide significant tax savings. Just remember that when you eventually sell, you'll have depreciation recapture on the rental portion and can only use the primary residence exclusion on your half.
This is super helpful, thank you! I'm curious about the depreciation aspect you mentioned - when you say "depreciation recapture," does that mean I'll have to pay back all the depreciation I claimed over the years when I sell? And is there any way to avoid or minimize that tax hit? Also, for tracking expenses, do you recommend any specific apps or software that make it easier to categorize and allocate expenses between personal and rental use? I want to make sure I'm documenting everything properly from day one.
Yes, depreciation recapture means you'll pay taxes on the depreciation you claimed when you sell - it's taxed at a maximum rate of 25% (vs regular capital gains rates). There's no way to completely avoid it, but you can do a 1031 exchange to defer it by rolling the proceeds into another investment property. For expense tracking, I highly recommend Stessa - it's free and designed specifically for rental properties. It connects to your bank accounts, automatically categorizes expenses, and has built-in allocation features for mixed-use properties like duplexes. You can set it to automatically split recurring expenses 50/50 or whatever percentage you determine. Another good option is Rentals.com if you want something simpler, or QuickBooks Self-Employed if you prefer more robust accounting features. The key is picking one system and being consistent from day one - trying to recreate records later is a nightmare!
I'm so frustrated and confused right now. I was trying to file my taxes through TurboTax like I do every year, but when I got to the end of entering all my information, I got this weird message saying "IRS Hasn't Finalized One or More of Your Forms" before I could move onto Step 2 of 3 in the filing process. Has anyone else experienced this? What does this even mean? I have all my W-2s and 1099s, and I double-checked that I entered everything correctly. I thought maybe there was some issue with the IRS systems, but I can't find any announcements about delays or problems. This is really stressing me out because I was planning to file early this year to get my refund faster. Last year I waited too long and didn't get my refund until May! My tax situation isn't even that complicated - just regular employment income, some interest from my savings account, and a small side gig that earned me about $3200. Should I just wait a few days and try again? Or contact TurboTax? Or the IRS directly? Any help would be appreciated!
idk if this helps but my accountant told me that for 2025 filing season there are specific delays with 1099-NEC processing due to some last minute tax law changes. something about gig work classification that congress changed in december. if you have self employment income like you mentioned that could be your issue for sure.
This is correct. The IRS announced a processing delay for 1099-NEC forms specifically for the 2025 filing season due to changes in the contractor classification rules that were passed late last year. They're updating the form to include the new verification codes for gig workers. Last I heard they should be finalized by February 15th.
Just to add another perspective - if you're comfortable with it, you can also check the IRS.gov website directly under their "Forms and Instructions" section. They sometimes post notices about delayed forms that might not be immediately visible in tax software. For what it's worth, the 1099-NEC delay that others mentioned is very real. I'm a tax preparer and we got official notice from the IRS about this specific issue affecting gig workers. The February 15th date mentioned by Oliver is accurate based on the latest IRS communications we've received. In the meantime, you could prepare the rest of your return and just leave the self-employment section incomplete until the forms are ready. That way you won't have to re-enter all your other information when the time comes.
I just got offered a 6-month contract position through a staffing agency at $60/hr, and they're giving me the choice between W2 employee or 1099 contractor status. The agency would handle my payments while I'd be working at the client company doing a standard office job. This would bring in about $62k for the remainder of the year and will likely be my only income source for this tax year. I'm leaning toward the W2 option, but want to make sure I'm not missing anything. Here's my rough calculation: W2: - $62,000 gross - ($27,700) Standard Deduction - $34,300 Taxable Income - Federal Tax around $3,800 - FICA/SS 7.65% of $62k = $4,743 - Total take home approximately $53,457 1099: - $62,000 gross - ($27,700) Standard Deduction - ($4,382) Self Employment Deduction - ($5,984) QBI (20% of $62,000 minus standard and SE deduction) - $23,934 Taxable Income - Federal Tax around $2,600 - FICA/SS 15.3% = $9,486 - Total take home approximately $49,914 Is there anything I'm overlooking that could make the 1099 option more attractive? Any legitimate Schedule C expenses I could claim to reduce that Self Employment tax? I'm thinking maybe car expenses, but since this is a regular 9-to-5 at the same location every day with minimal work from home, I believe that would just be considered commuting which isn't deductible. Even if I'm technically self-employed, I don't work at multiple locations or have a dedicated home office.
Great analysis! One additional consideration that might tip the scales further toward W2 - worker classification compliance. The IRS has been increasingly strict about proper classification, and if you're working at a single location, using their equipment, following their schedule, and doing work that's integral to their business, you likely meet the criteria for W2 employee status anyway. If the client company gets audited and the IRS determines you should have been classified as an employee, both you and the company could face penalties and back taxes. The company would owe the employer portion of FICA taxes they should have paid, plus penalties and interest. You'd potentially owe additional taxes if deductions were disallowed. Given that this is a standard office job at one location through a staffing agency, the W2 classification is not only financially better but also legally safer. The agency is likely offering the choice to shift some tax burden to you, but the risk/reward doesn't favor the 1099 option in your situation.
You're absolutely right to lean toward the W2 option! Your calculations look solid, and most folks in similar situations find W2 more beneficial financially. One thing I'd add - if you do end up with any 1099 work in the future, keep detailed records of everything. The IRS loves documentation, especially for home office deductions and business expenses. I learned this the hard way when I couldn't substantiate some deductions during an audit a few years back. For your current situation though, the W2 route gives you that employer FICA contribution (essentially free money), potential access to benefits, and removes the headache of quarterly estimated payments. Plus, if the contract doesn't get renewed, you'd likely be eligible for unemployment benefits as a W2 employee. The peace of mind alone is worth it - no worrying about whether you're setting aside enough for taxes or if your deductions will hold up under scrutiny. Sometimes the simpler path is the better path!
Great question about withholding! Since you're earning at an annual rate of $62k but only working 6 months, the payroll system will likely withhold as if you're making that rate all year, which could result in over-withholding in your favor. However, to be safe, I'd recommend running the numbers through the IRS withholding calculator (irs.gov/W4App) once you start the position. You can input your expected total income for the year and it will tell you if you need to adjust your W-4. Given that this will be your only income and you'll earn roughly $31k over 6 months, you'll likely be in a lower tax bracket than the withholding tables assume. You might actually get a nice refund! But definitely double-check with the calculator after your first paycheck or two to make sure you're on track. The beauty of W2 is that even if withholding is slightly off, it's usually not by much, and you avoid the quarterly payment headaches entirely. Much better than trying to estimate and pay quarterly taxes as a 1099!
Great question about withholding! Since you'll only be working 6 months but at an annualized rate of $62k, the payroll system will likely withhold taxes as if you're making $62k for the full year. But your actual income will only be around $31k (half year), which puts you in a much lower tax bracket. This means you'll probably have way too much withheld and get a large refund. The standard withholding should be more than sufficient - you might even want to claim additional allowances on your W-4 to reduce overwithholding and get more money in your paychecks. You can use the IRS withholding calculator at irs.gov to get a more precise estimate based on your 6-month work period. Just input your expected total income for the year ($31k) rather than the annualized rate. This will help you optimize your W-4 so you're not giving the government an interest-free loan all year!
Lucas Notre-Dame
11 Another thing to consider with 1098-T: if your child is claimed as your dependent, make sure you're coordinating who claims education credits. If you claim your child as a dependent, they can't claim their own education credits (like American Opportunity Credit) - YOU would claim those on your return, not theirs.
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
Author10 Wait so if my daughter has a 1098-T but I claim her as a dependent, does she still file her own return for the scholarship income, but I'm the one who claims the education credits on my return? This is confusing!
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
Author11 That's exactly right. If your daughter has taxable scholarship income, she would file her own return to report that income. However, since you claim her as a dependent, YOU would be the one to claim any education tax credits related to her education expenses on YOUR tax return, not hers. This is one of the most confusing aspects of education-related tax situations. The parent claims the education credits (if eligible), while the student reports any taxable scholarship income. Just make sure you're not both trying to claim the same expenses!
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
22 Don't forget about state filing requirements! Even if your child doesn't need to file a federal return, some states have lower thresholds for filing requirements. I learned this the hard way when my son got a letter from our state tax department asking where his return was, even though he was under the federal threshold.
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
Author2 Good point! What states have notably lower thresholds? I'm in California and wondering if my kid needs to file state even if not federal.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
California generally follows federal filing requirements, so if your kid doesn't need to file federal, they likely don't need to file state either. However, states like New York, Pennsylvania, and Massachusetts have lower thresholds - some as low as $8,000-$12,000 in gross income. I'd check your specific state's tax website or call their helpline to be sure. The last thing you want is a surprise notice months later!
0 coins