


Ask the community...
Great summary of the key steps! For timeframes, in my experience the correction process itself took about 6-8 weeks from filing to receiving the official corrected assessment. The refund check came about 3-4 weeks after that, so roughly 2.5-3 months total. Most counties don't charge fees for filing correction requests when you have clear documentation like builder plans - they consider it fixing an error rather than a formal appeal. However, if you escalate to a formal assessment appeal board, there might be a small filing fee (usually $25-50). One additional tip: when you contact the assessor's office, ask specifically about their "correction" process versus their "appeal" process. Corrections are usually faster and simpler for clear documentation errors like wrong square footage, while appeals are more formal and take longer. You definitely want the correction track for your situation! Also keep copies of everything you submit - having a paper trail helps if you need to follow up or if there are any delays in processing.
This is really comprehensive advice, thanks! I'm wondering about the documentation requirements - when you mention keeping copies of everything, should I be making copies before I submit or will the county office make copies for me? Also, did you need to get your builder documents notarized or certified in any way, or were regular photocopies sufficient for the correction process? I'm trying to gather everything together before I contact my county office, and I want to make sure I have all the right paperwork in the right format. The last thing I want is to get there and be told I need additional documentation that delays the whole process.
I've been through this exact situation! Make your own copies of everything before submitting - don't rely on the county office to do this for you. Bring originals to show them, but submit copies and keep your originals. For builder documents, regular photocopies are usually sufficient for correction requests since they're considered factual documentation errors rather than disputed valuations. However, I'd recommend calling your specific county assessor's office ahead of time to confirm their requirements - some counties are pickier than others. Also bring a copy of your current property tax statement showing the incorrect square footage, and if you have your original purchase contract or closing documents that reference square footage, include those too. The more consistent documentation you have from different sources, the stronger your case. One thing that really helped me was creating a simple one-page summary sheet listing: 1) Current assessed square footage, 2) Actual square footage with source document, 3) Years this error has existed, and 4) Requested action (correction + refund). Having everything clearly laid out made the meeting much smoother.
This one-page summary idea is brilliant! I wish I had thought of that when I was preparing my documentation. Having everything laid out so clearly probably saved you a lot of back-and-forth with the assessor's office. Quick question - when you listed "years this error has existed," did you have to provide proof for each year or was it sufficient to just state the timeframe? I'm trying to figure out if I need to dig up tax statements from previous years or if the current assessment and builder docs are enough to establish the pattern of overpayment. Also, did your county have any limit on how far back they would provide refunds? I keep seeing different numbers mentioned in this thread (3-5 years) and I'm wondering if there's a standard or if it really varies by location.
I made this exact change last year and it worked out great! You're absolutely right that the money already withheld stays with you - when you file your return, the IRS just looks at total withholding vs total tax owed for the entire year. One tip that really helped me: I set up a separate "tax savings" account and had my bank automatically transfer 22% of each paycheck (my estimated effective rate) the day after payday. This way I never saw the money and wasn't tempted to spend it. By the end of the year, I had more than enough saved up and actually earned a little interest on it. The psychological benefit was huge too - instead of feeling like the government was taking my money all year, I felt like I was actively managing my finances. Just make sure you understand your state's rules if they differ from federal, and keep an eye on any bonuses or overtime that might push you into a higher bracket than expected.
That's really encouraging to hear from someone who actually did this! The 22% automatic transfer idea is brilliant - I was wondering what percentage to use and that gives me a good baseline to start with. I love that you earned interest on the money too instead of giving the government an interest-free loan all year. The psychological aspect you mentioned is exactly what I'm hoping for. I feel like I'm just on autopilot right now with withholding, and taking more control over when and how much I pay seems like it would make me more engaged with my overall financial picture. Did you find that 22% ended up being pretty accurate for your situation, or did you have to adjust it throughout the year? I'm trying to figure out if I should start conservative and adjust down, or if it's better to nail the percentage right from the beginning.
The 22% worked really well for me, but I did have to make one small adjustment in October when I realized I was being a bit too conservative. I ended up reducing it to 20% for the last quarter since I was building up more than I needed. My advice would be to start slightly higher rather than lower - maybe 23-24% - especially for your first year doing this. It's much better to have a little extra saved up than to scramble at tax time. You can always adjust down if you're accumulating too much, and any excess just becomes a nice bonus for yourself instead of a refund from the IRS. The key thing I learned is to check in every few months. I used a simple tax calculator online around July and again in October to make sure I was still on track. Once you get a feel for it, it becomes pretty routine. And honestly, having that money earning interest in my savings account felt so much better than waiting for a refund check!
I actually went through this exact situation two years ago and can confirm that yes, you'll absolutely still get credit for all the taxes that have already been withheld this year. The IRS doesn't care about the timing of when taxes were withheld - they just look at your total annual income versus total withholding when you file. One thing that really helped me was calculating my "breakeven point." I looked at what I'd already had withheld, estimated my total tax liability for the year, and figured out exactly how much I needed to set aside from each remaining paycheck. This prevented both overpaying and underpaying. Also, don't forget to submit a new W-4 to your employer to make the change official. Some people think they can just tell payroll verbally, but you need the paperwork on file. And if you're married or have dependents, double-check that going exempt won't mess up any credits you're planning to claim - sometimes having zero withholding can affect things like the Child Tax Credit advance payments if you're receiving those. The financial discipline aspect you mentioned is key. I found it helpful to treat my "tax savings" like any other bill - set up automatic transfers so the money never feels like it's available to spend.
This is really helpful advice, especially the point about calculating a "breakeven point"! I hadn't thought about looking at it that way but it makes perfect sense to figure out exactly what I need from each remaining paycheck rather than just guessing. The reminder about submitting the actual W-4 form is important too - I definitely would have assumed I could just tell HR verbally. Good thing you mentioned that! I don't have dependents but I am married, so I'll definitely need to double-check how this affects our overall tax situation. We usually file jointly but my spouse has different withholding preferences, so I want to make sure my change doesn't create any unintended consequences for our combined return. The automatic transfer approach seems to be the consensus recommendation from everyone who's actually done this successfully. I'm convinced that's the way to go to avoid the temptation to spend that extra money from each paycheck.
does anyone know if there's a statue of limitations on these CP2000 things? i got one for my 2021 taxes but it just arrived last month. feels kinda ridiculous they can come after u years later when i dont even have those documents anymore
The IRS generally has 3 years from when you filed to audit/assess additional tax, but it extends to 6 years if you omitted more than 25% of your income. For international students, it can sometimes be longer if there are substantial reporting issues. So yes, they can definitely come after you for 2021 taxes now. Pro tip: Keep ALL tax docs for at least 7 years, no matter what.
@Aisha Ali, I went through almost the exact same situation when I was doing my master's here! The housing scholarship tax issue catches so many international students off guard because it really isn't intuitive coming from other countries where scholarships are completely tax-free. A few things that helped me when I got my CP2000: 1. Don't panic about the 30-day deadline - if you need more time, you can call and request an extension, especially as an international student still learning the system. 2. The IRS calculation might not account for any applicable tax treaty benefits. Depending on your home country, you might qualify for reduced tax rates or exemptions under the tax treaty. 3. When you respond, include a brief letter explaining that you're an international student new to US tax laws and made an honest mistake. This can help with penalty abatement. 4. Check if your university's international student services office has any tax clinics or partnerships with local tax preparers - many do, especially around tax season and for situations like this. The good news is that this is super common and the IRS deals with it all the time. As long as you respond promptly and pay what you legitimately owe, it shouldn't be a big deal. You've got this!
This is such helpful advice! I'm also an international student (just started my program this year) and I'm already worried about making tax mistakes. The point about tax treaties is really important - I had no idea that could affect how much you owe. @Emma Davis, when you mention calling for an extension, do you call the general IRS number or is there a specific number for CP2000 notices? And did you end up owing the full amount or were you able to get it reduced through the tax treaty provisions? Sorry to piggyback on @Aisha Ali's thread, but this is exactly the kind of situation I want to avoid!
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now with a failed tech startup LLC. Based on what I've learned from my research and conversations with tax professionals, here are a few key points that might help: First, the timing matters a lot. You generally have 3 years from when you filed your original return to claim a refund via amended returns, but there's an exception for worthless securities that extends this to 7 years from the original due date. This could be crucial for your situation since it's been several years. Second, you'll want to establish the exact year the investment became worthless. This isn't necessarily when the company officially closed, but when it became clear there was no reasonable prospect of recovery. Based on your description, this sounds like it happened when the managing partners abandoned the company. Third, gather any evidence you can find that shows you made reasonable efforts to get information or recover your investment. Emails to the managing partners, attempts to contact the registered agent, anything that shows you tried to determine the status of your investment before claiming it as worthless. The fact that another investor successfully claimed these losses is encouraging - it shows there's precedent for your situation. I'd strongly recommend finding an accountant or tax attorney who has experience with partnership abandonments rather than trying to handle this with someone who isn't familiar with these specific rules. Also document everything thoroughly because the IRS may have questions about why you're claiming losses without K-1s, especially if it triggers any audit flags.
This is really comprehensive advice, thank you! The 7-year rule for worthless securities is something I hadn't heard before - that could be a game changer for my situation since it's been about 5 years. Do you know if that 7-year exception applies specifically to LLC interests, or is it just for traditional securities like stocks and bonds? I want to make sure I understand this correctly before getting my hopes up about being able to go back further than 3 years. Also, you mentioned establishing the exact year it became worthless - in my case, the managing partners bailed around 2020 but the company technically wasn't dissolved until 2021. Would I claim the loss for 2020 when it became clear there was no recovery prospect, or 2021 when it was officially over? This timing could affect which tax years I need to amend.
Great questions! The 7-year rule for worthless securities does apply to LLC interests, but there's a catch - it depends on how the IRS classifies your LLC investment. If it's treated as a security (which most passive LLC investments are), then you get the extended period. If it's classified as a business investment, you might be stuck with the regular 3-year limitation. For the timing question, you'd generally claim the loss in the year it became worthless from an economic standpoint, not when it was legally dissolved. So in your case, that would likely be 2020 when the managing partners abandoned it and it became clear there was no reasonable prospect of recovery. The IRS looks at when a "reasonable person" would have concluded the investment was worthless. This is actually really important because it determines which tax year you amend. You'd want to claim the loss on your 2020 return (via amended filing) rather than waiting until 2021. The fact that the company wasn't officially dissolved until 2021 doesn't matter as much as when the economic reality made it clear the investment was toast. I'd definitely recommend documenting the timeline carefully - emails, news about the company's troubles, when partners left, etc. This helps establish that 2020 was the right year to claim the loss.
I'm sorry to hear about your situation - it's frustrating when you trust your accountant to handle something this important and they just ignore it. You're definitely not alone in this type of mess. Based on what others have shared here, it sounds like you have several viable options for claiming these losses even without K-1s. The key seems to be treating this as an "abandonment loss" since there's clearly no one left to manage the LLC or generate proper tax documents. From what I'm reading, you'll want to: 1. Gather all your original investment documentation (bank statements, operating agreements, any old K-1s) 2. Document your attempts to get information from the defunct company 3. Calculate your tax basis (what you invested minus any prior losses claimed) 4. File amended returns for the appropriate tax years The timing aspect that others mentioned is crucial - you need to determine exactly which tax year the investment became worthless. This sounds like it happened when the managing partners abandoned the company, not necessarily when it was legally dissolved. I'd strongly recommend finding a new accountant who actually has experience with partnership abandonments. Your current one clearly isn't equipped to handle this situation. The fact that another investor successfully claimed similar losses shows this is definitely doable with the right expertise. Don't let this drag on any longer - you've already lost several years of potential tax benefits because of your accountant's negligence.
Kelsey Hawkins
Quick tip from someone who's been freelancing for 15+ years: start including a damage clause in your contracts! I specifically have language that states any reimbursements for damaged equipment are not considered income and will not be reported on tax forms. It's saved me from this exact headache multiple times. Most clients don't even notice it when signing, but it gives you something concrete to point to when their accounting department tries to 1099 you for reimbursements. Worth adding to your contracts going forward!
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
ā¢Do you have an example of the language you use? I'm updating my contract template and would love to include something like this.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
This is a great discussion with solid advice from everyone! I'm dealing with a similar situation right now where a client damaged some lighting equipment during a corporate shoot. Reading through all these responses really helped clarify my options. I'm definitely going to try contacting their accounting department first to explain that it should be treated as property damage reimbursement, not service income. If that doesn't work, the backup plan of reporting it as income but then deducting the exact repair amount on Schedule C makes sense as a safety net. The contract clause suggestion from Kelsey is brilliant - I'm definitely adding that to my standard agreement going forward. Prevention is always better than having to fix these issues after the fact! Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences and solutions. This community is incredibly helpful for navigating these tricky tax situations that come up in freelance work.
0 coins
Noah Lee
ā¢Great summary, Mason! I'm new to freelancing and this whole thread has been incredibly educational. I had no idea that reimbursements could be misclassified on tax forms like this. One thing I'm curious about - for those who've dealt with this before, how do you typically document the damage when it happens? Should I be taking photos, getting written acknowledgment from the client, or both? I want to make sure I have proper documentation from the start in case something like this ever happens to me. Also, does anyone know if this same principle applies to other types of reimbursements, like if a client covers travel expenses that I initially paid out of pocket?
0 coins