


Ask the community...
This has been such an informative discussion! As someone who's dealt with similar IRA contribution complications, I wanted to add one more consideration that might be relevant to your situation. Since you're a consultant with potentially lumpy income, you might want to look into setting up quarterly check-ins with yourself (or a tax professional) to reassess your contribution strategy throughout the year. With income that can swing dramatically like yours, having a system to adjust your retirement contributions quarterly could help you avoid this kind of mid-year scramble in the future. For this year specifically, I'd echo what others have said about recharacterization being your best bet - it avoids the earnings penalties and keeps your money working for you. But going forward, you might consider a more conservative approach where you wait until later in the year to make Roth contributions once you have a better sense of your annual income, or default to the backdoor Roth strategy from the start if your income is likely to be variable. Also, don't forget that you have until your tax filing deadline (including extensions) to sort this out, so you're not under immediate time pressure. Take the time to run the numbers properly and choose the strategy that works best for your overall financial picture!
This is such excellent advice about the quarterly check-ins! As someone new to navigating these retirement contribution complexities, I really appreciate the suggestion to be more proactive rather than reactive. The idea of waiting until later in the year to make Roth contributions when income is uncertain makes a lot of sense - I've been thinking about it backwards, trying to contribute early and then scrambling to fix it later. Your point about having until the tax filing deadline is also reassuring - I was feeling like I needed to make a decision immediately, but having that buffer time to really analyze all the options (recharacterization vs. withdrawal vs. backdoor Roth setup) is helpful. The quarterly review system sounds like it would be perfect for my consulting situation where client contracts can change so dramatically. I'm definitely going to implement something like that going forward. Thanks for sharing your experience and the practical advice!
As a fellow freelancer who went through almost this exact scenario last year, I completely understand your stress! The good news is that this situation is more common than you think, especially with the gig economy creating so much income volatility. Here's what I learned after consulting with both my CPA and my brokerage: You have several solid options, and none of them involve losing your money or getting penalized unfairly. The recharacterization route that others mentioned worked great for me - I was able to convert my Roth contributions to Traditional IRA contributions, then later did a backdoor Roth conversion once I sorted out my other IRA balances. One thing I'd strongly recommend is calling your brokerage sooner rather than later, even if you don't make a final decision right away. They can walk you through exactly how each option would work with your specific account and contribution amounts. Most of them deal with this situation regularly and have streamlined processes. Also, don't forget to factor in business deductions when calculating your final MAGI - as a consultant, you likely have more deductible expenses than you realize, which could potentially keep you closer to the Roth limits than your gross income suggests. Equipment, software, home office, professional development, etc. can all add up significantly. You've got time to figure this out properly, and based on all the great advice in this thread, you have excellent options to choose from!
Thank you so much for sharing your real-world experience with this exact situation! It's incredibly reassuring to hear from someone who actually went through the recharacterization process successfully. I've been losing sleep over this thinking I might lose money or face penalties, but hearing that you navigated it smoothly gives me confidence. Your suggestion about calling the brokerage early is smart - I keep putting it off because I thought I needed to have all the answers first, but you're right that they probably deal with this all the time and can help me understand my specific options better. The business deduction reminder is also really valuable. I've been focused on the gross income jump but haven't done a thorough analysis of what my actual MAGI will be after all legitimate business expenses. Between equipment upgrades I need anyway and other deductible expenses, I might not be as far over the limits as I initially calculated. Thanks for the encouragement and practical advice - this thread has been a lifesaver for understanding what seemed like an impossible situation!
Something else to consider - if you're buying chargers and phone accessories for employees, make sure you have an accountable plan in place if you're reimbursing them for these purchases. Otherwise, those reimbursements could be considered taxable income to the employees.
Wait really? I've been buying phone chargers and giving them to my employees whenever they need them. Do I need to be reporting that somehow on their taxes? They're just cheap $10-15 chargers usually.
@Andre Dupont For small items like $10-15 chargers provided to employees, these are typically considered de minimis fringe benefits and don t'need to be reported as taxable income to the employees. The IRS has a de minimis threshold for minimal-value items that would be administratively burdensome to account for. However, if you re'buying more expensive items or providing them frequently to the same employees, you should definitely have an accountable plan in place. An accountable plan requires employees to substantiate the business purpose and return any excess reimbursement. Without this, even small amounts can technically be considered taxable compensation. For occasional cheap chargers, you re'probably fine, but it s'worth discussing with your accountant to make sure you re'compliant, especially if this becomes a regular practice.
This is exactly the kind of question I had when I started my small business! I was putting everything phone-related under utilities and it was such a mess. One thing that helped me was creating a simple spreadsheet to track all these small tech purchases throughout the year. I have columns for date, item, cost, business percentage, and category. For chargers and accessories, I use "Office Supplies" as mentioned by others here. Also, if you're like me and use your phone for both business and personal, don't forget to calculate that business use percentage. I track my business calls/usage monthly to justify my deduction percentage. For accessories that are used 100% for business (like that extra charger you keep at the office), you can deduct the full amount. Keep all those receipts organized - even the small $10 ones add up over the year and every legitimate deduction helps!
This spreadsheet idea is brilliant! I'm definitely going to set something like this up. Quick question though - when you're calculating business use percentage for your phone, do you go by time spent on business calls, or do you factor in things like business emails, work apps, and other business-related phone usage too? I feel like just counting call time might underestimate the actual business use, especially since I'm constantly checking work emails and using business apps on my phone throughout the day.
Slightly different perspective - have you checked if you might qualify for the reduced 50% exclusion rather than the 100% exclusion? The rules vary based on when the stock was acquired as C corp shares. For C corp shares acquired after August 10, 1993 but before February 18, 2009, you can exclude 50% of the gain. For shares acquired after February 18, 2009 and before September 28, 2010, you can exclude 75%. And for shares acquired after September 28, 2010, you can exclude 100%. But this all depends on when the shares were acquired as C corp shares, which in your case sounds like October 2018, so you'd be in the 100% category if you met the holding period.
This is a good point, but the exclusion percentages only matter if OP meets the 5-year holding requirement first, which seems to be the main issue here. Being 2 months short of 5 years means they likely can't access any of the exclusion percentages.
I'm really sorry to hear about your situation - being just two months short of the 5-year requirement is incredibly frustrating, especially when you've been with the company since its founding. While the other commenters are correct about the general rule that C-Corp holding periods don't "tack" from previous entity types, there might be one avenue worth exploring given your specific timeline. Since your S-Corp to C-Corp conversion happened in October 2018, you should definitely investigate whether this qualified as a tax-free reorganization under Section 368 of the Internal Revenue Code. If the conversion was properly structured as a Section 368 reorganization (which many S-Corp to C-Corp conversions are), there's potentially an argument for holding period tacking under certain circumstances. This is an extremely technical area of tax law where the specific documentation and structure of your conversion matters enormously. Given the potential tax savings at stake, I'd strongly recommend consulting with a tax attorney who specializes specifically in Section 1202 and corporate reorganizations - not just a general CPA. You'll need someone who can review your conversion documents, operating agreements, and any legal opinions from 2018 to determine if there's any path forward. The fact that you were kept in the dark about sale details is also concerning from a fiduciary duty standpoint, but that's a separate issue. For now, focus on gathering all your corporate documents from the 2018 conversion and get specialized legal advice before your filing deadline.
This is exactly the kind of detailed advice I was hoping for. You're right that being kept out of the sale discussions was problematic on multiple levels, but I need to focus on the tax implications first since the filing deadline is approaching. I'm going to dig through all the 2018 conversion paperwork this weekend. My co-founder who handled the legal work has been difficult to work with, but I think I can get the documents from our corporate attorney directly. Do you happen to know what specific language or provisions I should be looking for in the documents that would indicate it was structured as a Section 368 reorganization? Also, given how specialized this area is, do you have any recommendations for finding attorneys who specifically handle Section 1202 cases? Most of the tax attorneys I've found seem to focus on more general corporate tax issues.
Great thread! I'm currently studying for my EA exams too and wanted to add a few more budget-friendly options I've discovered: 1. **IRS Circular 230** - This is completely free from the IRS website and covers the ethics portion (Part 3). It's dense reading but comprehensive. 2. **YouTube channels** - There are several tax professionals who post EA exam prep videos for free. "Tax School for Pros" has particularly good content for Parts 1 and 2. 3. **Local community college courses** - Some offer EA exam prep as continuing education classes for around $200-300. You get instructor support and often access to their practice question banks. 4. **Study groups** - Check if there's a local NAEA (National Association of Enrolled Agents) chapter near you. They sometimes organize study groups where members share materials and costs. Also, don't forget that EA exam fees are tax deductible as an educational expense related to your career, so keep all your receipts! Good luck with your studies - the summer break timing is perfect for tackling all three parts.
These are fantastic additional resources! I hadn't thought about community college courses - that's a great middle ground between fully self-study and expensive commercial courses. The YouTube suggestion is especially helpful since I learn better with visual explanations. Quick question about the NAEA study groups - do they typically welcome prospective EAs who aren't members yet, or should I join first before looking for study groups? Also, thanks for the tax deduction reminder - every little bit helps when you're on a student budget!
Adding to the great suggestions here - I recently passed all three EA parts using a combination of free and low-cost resources that totaled under $200. Here's what worked for me: **Free Resources:** - IRS Publication 17 (Your Federal Income Tax) - covers most of Part 1 - IRS Publication 334 (Tax Guide for Small Business) - essential for Part 2 - All the IRS Circular 230 materials mentioned above **Low-Cost Purchases:** - Used Gleim books from 2 years ago on eBay ($85 total for all three parts) - TaxMama's practice question bank ($149 - totally worth it for the explanations) **Study Strategy:** I spent about 6 weeks total, doing 2-3 hours daily during my summer break. The key was using the IRS materials for content learning and the practice questions to identify weak spots. One thing I wish someone had told me: the exams are very application-based, so focus more on understanding concepts rather than memorizing exact tax code sections. The practice questions from TaxMama really helped with this approach. Also, consider taking Part 3 (ethics) first - it's the shortest and gives you confidence going into the other two parts. Good luck with your summer study plan!
This is exactly the kind of breakdown I was hoping to find! Your total cost of under $200 is so much more manageable than the $500+ courses. I'm particularly interested in your suggestion about taking Part 3 first - I hadn't considered that strategy but it makes sense to build confidence with the shorter exam. Quick question about the used Gleim books from 2 years ago - were there any significant tax law changes that made some sections outdated, or do the fundamentals stay pretty consistent? I'm a bit worried about studying from older materials and missing important updates. Also, thanks for the tip about focusing on application rather than memorization. Coming from an academic background, I tend to want to memorize everything, so this mindset shift could save me a lot of unnecessary stress!
Diego Vargas
Don't forget that if your daughter files her own return, she needs to check the box that says "Someone can claim you as a dependent" on her 1040! I made this mistake with my kid last year and it caused issues with both of our returns being processed.
0 coins
NeonNinja
β’Also be aware that she'll need to file BOTH federal and state returns in most cases! That caught me by surprise when my teenager had to file.
0 coins
Alicia Stern
Great question! I dealt with this exact situation with my 16-year-old last year. Here's what I learned: Your daughter definitely needs to file her own tax return since she has self-employment income over $400. The $1,150 on her 1099-NEC means she'll owe self-employment taxes (about 15.3% on the net earnings). Good news though - you can absolutely still claim her as a dependent on your joint return as long as she meets the qualifying child requirements (under 19, lives with you more than half the year, etc.). A few important things to remember: - She needs to check the "Someone else can claim you as a dependent" box on her return - Consider any business expenses she had for the graphic design work (software, supplies, etc.) - these can reduce her taxable income - She'll file Form 1040 with Schedule C for the business income - Both federal AND state returns will likely be required The process isn't too complicated once you know the rules. FreeTaxUSA should handle her return just fine too. Just make sure both returns are consistent about the dependency claim to avoid any processing delays.
0 coins
RaΓΊl Mora
β’This is really helpful! I'm in a similar situation with my 17-year-old who just started doing some freelance photography work. Quick question - when you mention business expenses like software and supplies, does that include things like camera equipment if it was purchased specifically for the freelance work? Also, how detailed does the record-keeping need to be for a teenager's first year filing?
0 coins