


Ask the community...
I'm an expatriate tax consultant, and this exact example confuses many of my clients. Here's the clearest way I can explain it: The physical presence test requires 330 full days of presence in a foreign country during a period of 12 consecutive months. In the example, counting forward 330 days from June 1, 2022 (excluding US days) gets you to May 12, 2023. Now you need to identify which 12-month period contains those 330 days. The period must end on May 11, 2023 (not May 12) because: - If the period ended on May 12, 2023, it would start on May 13, 2022 - But your qualifying foreign presence began on June 1, 2022 - So a period from May 13, 2022 to May 12, 2023 would include days before you established foreign presence That's why they use May 11 as the end date - to create a 12-month period (May 12, 2022 to May 11, 2023) that properly contains all your qualifying days.
But if I started my foreign assignment on April 15, 2022 (earlier than the example's June 1), wouldn't the period from May 13, 2022 to May 12, 2023 work just fine? All those days would still be within my foreign presence period, right?
If you started your foreign assignment on April 15, 2022, then yes, a period from May 13, 2022 to May 12, 2023 would technically work for you. But the IRS example is specifically dealing with someone who began their foreign presence on June 1, 2022. The key is finding the optimal 12-month period that maximizes your qualifying days. If you started on April 15, you might actually have a different optimal 12-month period than the one in the example. You'd need to count forward 330 days from your start date (accounting for any US visits) and then establish your specific 12-month period.
Anyone know if 2025 is bringing any changes to the FEIE physical presence test? I've heard rumors about the IRS tightening the rules for digital nomads who bounce between countries. Will this counting method stay the same?
As far as I know, the basic mechanics of the physical presence test aren't changing for 2025. The 330-day requirement and 12-month period calculation should remain the same. What might be getting more scrutiny is whether digital nomads truly have a "tax home" in a foreign country, which is a separate requirement for the FEIE.
From my experience as a tax preparer, here's a practical answer: for fed taxes, an $84 change to your W2 would result in roughly $20 extra tax depending on your bracket. State would be even less. Technically yes, you're supposed to amend. Realistically? The chance of the IRS coming after you for this is extremely low. They have bigger fish to fry. But if you're the rule-following type or plan to apply for a mortgage or something where super clean tax records matter, then go ahead and file the 1040-X. Just my two cents - not telling you to break rules, just being practical about the situation!
Do you know how much it typically costs to file an amended return if you use a tax preparer? I'm in a similar boat but with a $120 discrepancy and wondering if it's worth paying someone to fix it.
Most tax preparers charge between $75-150 to file an amended return, even for something simple like this. This is why many people choose not to amend for very small amounts - the preparation fee often exceeds the tax difference. If you're comfortable doing it yourself, you can file a 1040-X for free. It's not extremely complicated for a simple W2 correction. You'd just need to fill out the form showing the original amounts, the corrected amounts, and the difference, then provide a brief explanation like "Received W2c from employer with wage adjustment.
I'm confused about something - when you get a W2c, doesn't the employer also send that information to the IRS? So wouldn't they already know about the correction and expect your numbers to match up?
Yes, your employer sends the corrected W2c to the Social Security Administration, which then shares the info with the IRS. So the IRS will eventually have both sets of numbers. This is actually why small discrepancies like this sometimes get flagged in their automated system - their records won't match what you filed.
Something nobody's mentioned yet - even if you can't beat the standard deduction now, keep track of your potential itemized deductions anyway. My first 3 years as a homeowner I couldn't itemize, but in year 4 I had some major medical expenses plus I replaced my roof and HVAC. That one "expensive year" pushed me well over the standard deduction threshold. If I hadn't been tracking things all along, I would have missed out.
Does the IRS ever question large jumps in deductions from one year to the next? I'm worried if I suddenly itemize after years of standard deduction it might trigger an audit.
A significant change in deduction strategy alone isn't typically what triggers IRS scrutiny. What matters is that you have proper documentation for everything you're claiming. The IRS understands that life events happen - medical issues, home repairs, major purchases - that can cause a one-year spike in deductions. Just make sure you keep receipts for any large purchases, medical bills, property tax statements, mortgage interest statements, and donation receipts. If you have the documentation to back up your claims, you shouldn't worry about itemizing when it benefits you.
Here's a tip that worked for me: If you know you're making a major purchase (car, boat, home renovation), try to time multiple big purchases in the same tax year when possible. I "bunched" my new car purchase and home renovations in the same year, which pushed me over the standard deduction. Then I took the standard deduction the following year. Alternating years can maximize your tax savings.
I've been a tax accountant specializing in oil and gas for 15+ years. Here's what you need to know: 1. Your new CPA is correct. IDC and depletion should be subtracted from box 14a when calculating SE income. 2. The note on your K1 about "QBI not reduced" is standard language that specifically exists to tell you these amounts need to be backed out for SE tax purposes. 3. Your former CPA was incorrect, and yes, you should definitely amend 2020 and 2021 returns. With differences of $45k and $85k, you're looking at potential SE tax savings of approximately $6,800 and $12,800 respectively. Don't be surprised that your former CPA is resistant - admitting this error would open her up to liability for the mistake. I'd suggest having your current CPA or another preparer handle the amendments.
Thank you for this clear explanation! Since my current CPA isn't being very responsive, do you think this is something I could potentially handle myself with tax software? Or is it too complex for DIY?
I wouldn't recommend DIY for this particular situation. The amendments will need to properly document the IDC and depletion adjustments, and most consumer tax software doesn't handle these specialized oil and gas calculations well. If your current CPA continues to be unresponsive, I'd suggest finding a new preparer who has specific experience with oil and gas partnerships. Look for someone who regularly works with clients who have working interests rather than just royalty interests. This distinction is critical, as they have very different tax treatments, and it's where many CPAs get confused. The investment in a knowledgeable preparer will likely pay for itself many times over given the tax amounts at stake.
A key point I haven't seen mentioned yet - the statute of limitations for amending returns is typically 3 years from the original filing date, but can be extended to 6 years in certain situations. Make sure you get those amendments in for 2020 ASAP before the window closes!
Ava Rodriguez
Has anyone dealt with damaged tax documents due to the hurricane? My 2021 paperwork got wet in the flooding and some of it is barely readable now. Not sure how to proceed with filing when I can't clearly see all the numbers.
0 coins
Miguel Ortiz
ā¢You can request copies of your wage and income transcripts from the IRS for free. Go to IRS.gov and search for "Get Transcript Online" or call their transcript request line at 800-908-9946. This will give you all the info reported to the IRS like your W-2s and 1099s for 2021. For bank statements and other documents, contact those institutions directly for replacements.
0 coins
Zainab Khalil
Anyone know if we're eligible for any special tax benefits or deductions related to Hurricane Helene damages when filing these older returns? My 2021 taxes don't relate to the hurricane obviously but I'm filing them now while dealing with all the hurricane aftermath.
0 coins
Mei Chen
ā¢Unfortunately, you can't claim Hurricane Helene disaster losses on your 2021 return since the disaster occurred in 2024. Casualty losses must be claimed for the tax year in which they occurred. You'll need to claim Helene-related losses on your 2024 tax return (which you'll file in 2025) or potentially on an amended 2023 return if you choose to claim the loss in the immediately preceding year, which is sometimes allowed for federally declared disasters. But for your 2021 return that you're filing now, you can only claim the extension - not any hurricane-related losses.
0 coins
Zainab Khalil
ā¢Thanks for clarifying that! Makes sense that I can't claim 2024 losses on a 2021 return. I'll focus on just getting the 2021 return filed with the extension for now and deal with the hurricane losses on my 2024 taxes next year.
0 coins