


Ask the community...
I work in the financial aid office at a university, and I see this confusion all the time. Just to clarify something important: the reason you still had to pay $1,300 out of pocket despite the scholarship exceeding tuition is likely because some of that scholarship money was applied to room and board, meal plans, or other non-qualified expenses. Many large scholarships/grants cover more than just tuition - they often include housing, meals, etc. For tax purposes, only the portion covering qualified education expenses is tax-free.
Thanks for this insight! Quick question - do student loans factor into this calculation at all? My daughter has both scholarships and loans.
Student loans don't impact the taxability of scholarships. Loans are simply money you have to pay back, so they're not considered income. The calculation only looks at: 1) How much in qualified education expenses did you have? and 2) How much in scholarships/grants (money you don't have to repay) did you receive? If #2 is larger than #1, the difference is taxable income. Loans are completely separate from this calculation. However, you may be eligible for the student loan interest deduction for interest paid on those loans, which is a different tax benefit entirely.
Intentionally leaving off forms the IRS already has copies of is literally the definition of tax fraud. As someone who got audited over education credits, let me tell you - it's NOT worth it. I "forgot" to include a 1098-T from a community college class (was only $600) and ended up paying the back taxes PLUS a 20% accuracy penalty PLUS interest. And that was considered an "honest mistake" - if they determine it was intentional, the penalties are way worse.
How did they even catch such a small amount? Was it just random bad luck that you got audited or do they actually check everyone's forms that carefully?
Former VITA volunteer here. What happened to you shouldn't have happened. VITA volunteers are supposed to be certified and supervised. You mentioned they created their own 1098-T, which is a big no-no. Here's what I'd recommend: 1) Contact the site coordinator for that VITA location. Every site has a manager who oversees the program, and they need to know about this serious error. 2) Ask for a complete copy of what was filed. You're entitled to this. 3) Use the superseding return advice others mentioned, or if it's too late, file Form 1040-X to amend. 4) Consider filing a complaint if the site coordinator doesn't take this seriously: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/free-tax-return-preparation-for-qualifying-taxpayers
I'm definitely going to contact the site coordinator. Should I specifically mention which volunteers made the mistakes, or just explain the situation generally? And is there any chance this could get me in trouble since I signed it even though the information was wrong?
It's helpful to mention specifically which volunteers made the mistakes so the coordinator can address the training issues, but don't worry about getting yourself in trouble. The IRS understands that taxpayers rely on preparers' expertise, especially in VITA programs. You're taking the proper steps to correct the return, which shows good faith on your part. Remember that VITA volunteers are trained specifically not to create forms or enter information they don't have documentation for. The site coordinator needs to know this happened so they can make sure those volunteers receive additional training or supervision. This protects future taxpayers from experiencing the same issues.
Quick question - does anyone know if using the free tax software like TurboTax Free or H&R Block Free would be better than going back to VITA for fixing this? I'm also a student and had issues with VITA last year (though not as bad as OP's situation).
I've used both VITA and TurboTax Free. Honestly, for basic student returns, the free software is pretty foolproof. It asks straightforward questions about your education expenses and walks you through everything. Plus, you can save your work and think about it or do research before submitting.
I gave up on TurboTax for RSUs and switched to H&R Block's software last year. Their interface for stock compensation is MUCH clearer. They specifically ask if the RSU income was already included on your W-2 (which it almost always is) and then only have you report the sales transaction with the correct cost basis. TurboTax kept double-counting my RSU income for three years before I realized what was happening. Literally paid thousands in extra taxes before figuring it out and filing amendments. Such a nightmare.
Does H&R Block handle the capital gains calculation correctly? My situation is complicated because some of my RSUs vested early in the year and then I sold them months later when the price had changed quite a bit. I need to make sure I'm reporting both the initial income and the capital gains/losses correctly.
Yes, H&R Block handles the capital gains calculation correctly. It separates the initial income recognition (which appears on your W-2) from any subsequent capital gains or losses that occur between vesting and selling. When you enter your stock sales, you'll provide both the sale price and the cost basis (which is the fair market value on the vesting date). The software then correctly calculates only the difference as capital gains/losses. It's much more straightforward than TurboTax, especially for situations where there's a significant time gap between vesting and selling with price changes.
Important tip: make sure you have your Form 3922 from your employer handy when dealing with RSUs in any tax software. This form should clearly show the FMV of your shares on vesting date, which is your cost basis. Sometimes TurboTax gets confused if you manually enter numbers that don't precisely match what's on your W-2 and other forms.
Form 3922 is for ESPP (Employee Stock Purchase Plans), not RSUs. For RSUs, employers typically provide a summary statement but not a specific IRS form. Most just include it on your W-2 and provide supplemental information.
Just want to add one thing that nobody's mentioned: if you have $4,000 in 1099 income and can legitimately deduct expenses to bring it down to $0, you won't owe ANY self-employment tax on it. That's because SE tax only applies to your net profit after expenses. But make sure your deductions are legitimate business expenses - the IRS looks closely at Schedule C deductions, especially when they completely eliminate taxable income.
Thanks for this clarification! So if I understand correctly: I should definitely file Schedule C with my business expenses to reduce my self-employment tax, but that's completely separate from deciding between itemized vs. standard deduction? And since my total income is only around $32,500, the standard deduction ($13,850) is probably better unless I have some major itemized deductions?
Yes, that's exactly right! File Schedule C to report your 1099 income and expenses (which reduces or eliminates self-employment tax on that income). And yes, at your income level, you'll almost certainly want to take the standard deduction unless you have extraordinary itemized deductions like major medical expenses, huge charitable contributions, or large mortgage interest payments. For most people in your situation, itemized deductions don't exceed the $13,850 standard deduction.
Anyone have experience with using the home office deduction? I have a dedicated space in my apartment where I do all my freelance work. Is it worth claiming?
Jacob Lee
Quick question about FL filing requirements - are you sure you need to file Florida corporate returns? I thought if your corporation was under a certain income threshold, you might be exempt? Not trying to give advice, just wondering because I'm in a similar position with a small C corp.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
ā¢Florida requires C corporations that are doing business in Florida to file Form F-1120 (Florida Corporate Income Tax Return) regardless of whether they have any tax liability. Even if your corporation falls below the income threshold where you'd owe tax, you typically still need to file the return. There is an exception for corporations not doing business in Florida and corporations that have no income reportable to Florida. So it depends on where your C corporation is operating and generating income. Florida does have filing exemptions for certain entities like S corporations and certain non-profits, but standard C corporations generally need to file.
0 coins
Emily Thompson
One thing to consider - if you owe taxes for those unfiled years, you might want to look into the IRS Fresh Start program. I was in a similar situation with unfiled returns and substantial tax debt, and qualified for an installment agreement with some penalties reduced. Don't let fear of penalties prevent you from filing. The penalties for not filing are much worse than the penalties for filing late. And remember that the failure-to-file penalty stops accruing once you file, even if you can't pay right away. Also, be sure to e-file your current year (2023) return on time while you're catching up on past years. You don't want to fall further behind.
0 coins