


Ask the community...
Something to consider - even though you technically only need to fill out Part 3, I usually fill in zeros for the lines in Parts 1 and 2 that don't apply to me rather than leaving them completely blank. My accountant friend told me that completely blank sections can sometimes trigger additional scrutiny, while zeros clearly show you didn't skip anything by accident. Probably doesn't matter much either way, but thought I'd share what I've been doing for years without any issues.
If you put zeros in Parts 1 and 2, do you need to do any calculations or just literally put 0 in each box? And have you ever been audited or questioned about your Roth withdrawals?
You just put a zero in each box, no calculations needed for parts that don't apply to your situation. It's just to show you didn't accidentally skip that section. I've never been audited specifically about my Roth IRA withdrawals. I did get a general review letter once about three years ago, but it was about something completely different (they questioned some business deductions). My Roth withdrawal reporting with the zeros-not-blanks approach has never been flagged in the 12 years I've been doing it this way.
Quick question for everyone - I'm using TurboTax to file and it's automatically filling in some fields in Parts 1 and 2 even though I only have Roth contribution withdrawals. Should I override it to leave those parts blank or just let the software do its thing?
In my experience, let the software do its thing. TurboTax is programmed to complete forms correctly based on your inputs. If it's filling parts 1 and 2, it's probably putting zeros or calculating something based on your overall tax situation that might be relevant. Tax software is designed to handle these nuances.
Just something to consider - if you're married and file jointly, your spouse's income could generate tax liability that your LLC could offset. My wife had almost no income during her grad school year, but my income allowed us to take full advantage of her education credits.
I'm not married, so unfortunately that's not an option for me. But that's good advice for others in a similar situation who might be married!
That's unfortunate. Another option to consider for future years is timing your education expenses. If you expect more income next year, you might be able to bunch more expenses into that tax year instead. For instance, paying spring semester tuition in January vs December can shift which tax year it counts for.
Has anyone had success claiming the LLC when taking online courses that aren't part of a degree program? I'm taking some professional development courses that my employer isn't paying for.
Yes! I claimed LLC for coding bootcamp courses last year. The key requirement is that the educational institution needs to be eligible and provide you with a 1098-T. The courses don't need to be part of a degree program for LLC (that's only a requirement for the American Opportunity Credit).
Just to add more context to this discussion - I've been filing non-resident returns for years, and here's what you need to know: 1. The 25% withholding on property sales is under section 116 of the Income Tax Act 2. The T2062 allows for a reduction of that withholding based on the actual gain vs. gross proceeds 3. When filing the T1-NR, the actual gain goes on Schedule 3 4. The non-resident tax rate is a flat 25% on taxable Canadian property gains 5. Any withholding tax (minus amounts already refunded through the T2062 process) goes on line 43700 Make sure you also include form NR73 if there's any question about residency status, as the CRA is very strict about this.
Thank you so much! This breakdown is super helpful. Quick follow-up though - for the actual amount of withholding, should I be using what was initially withheld ($78k) or the net amount after they already got that partial refund through the T2062 process?
You should use the net amount after the partial refund. So if $78k was initially withheld but $22k was already refunded based on the T2062 adjustment, you'd report $56k on line 43700 as the withholding tax amount. The CRA system should already have a record of both the initial withholding and the T2062 adjustment, but I always recommend including a brief note with the return explaining these amounts to avoid any confusion during processing.
Is it necessary to file a provincial return as well for a non-resident property sale? My client sold property in BC and I'm not sure if I need to complete a separate provincial form or if it's all handled in the T1-NR.
For non-residents, you don't need to file a separate provincial tax return. The federal T1-NR handles both federal and provincial taxation. Non-residents pay a flat 25% federal tax on taxable Canadian property, with no separate provincial component. Just make sure you're correctly identifying the property's location on the return since this affects CRA's internal processing, but you won't need to complete any provincial-specific forms for a non-resident property sale.
Former tax preparer here. You should know that the advice about home office deductions automatically triggering audits is extremely outdated. In my 12 years of practice, I've had plenty of clients claim legitimate home office deductions with zero issues. Your space absolutely qualifies based on your description - it's a defined area used exclusively for business. The 10% of your apartment seems reasonable and accurate. What matters most is: 1. You used it regularly for business 2. You used it exclusively for business (no watching Netflix there!) 3. It was your principal place of business for that activity Document everything now while your memory is fresh - draw a floor plan, write down descriptions, note what business activities you conducted there. This documentation will help if questions ever arise.
Thanks so much for this reassurance! I'm still a bit nervous about taking the deduction without photos. For the documentation you mentioned - would a detailed written description with measurements and a hand-drawn floor plan be sufficient? Or should I try to find other proof like emails sent from that workspace?
A detailed written description with measurements and a hand-drawn floor plan is absolutely sufficient documentation. Date it and keep it with your tax records. Including details about the built-in desk, the three walls forming the alcove, and how you used the space for specific business activities strengthens your case. Adding some supporting evidence like business emails, client invoices you created there, or phone records showing client calls would be helpful supplementary documentation, but not strictly necessary. The IRS understands that people move and may not have photographs of previous spaces. Your contemporaneous written records are considered valid documentation, especially when they're detailed and consistent with your business activities.
Is TurboTax good for handling home office deductions for self-employed people? I'm in a similar situation but trying to do it myself.
TurboTax Self-Employed version handles home office deductions pretty well. It walks you through all the questions and helps calculate both the regular and simplified methods. I've used it for the past 3 years with no problems. Just make sure you get the Self-Employed version, not the regular one.
Olivia Garcia
Don't forget to check if your state has any tax breaks for students! Some states have special credits or deductions for college students that the federal government doesn't offer. I almost missed out on a $1,000 state education credit last year because I didn't know about it. Might help offset some of what you owe. Also, if your parents are still claiming you as a dependent, make sure you're coordinating with them about who's claiming education benefits!
0 coins
RaΓΊl Mora
β’Thanks for mentioning this! I actually have no idea if my state has any special credits for students. How would I find this out? And yes, my parents are claiming me as a dependent still - what kind of coordination do we need to do? I'm so confused about all of this.
0 coins
Olivia Garcia
β’You can find state-specific education credits or deductions by checking your state's tax department website - most have a section specifically about education-related benefits. Just search "[your state] education tax credits" and you should find information. As for coordinating with your parents, since they claim you as a dependent, they're eligible for certain education tax benefits like the American Opportunity Credit or Lifetime Learning Credit. You can't claim these same credits on your return. However, you're still responsible for reporting your taxable scholarship income on your own return. Make sure your parents know about your scholarship situation so they can properly claim any education credits they're entitled to. It's a good idea to compare the tax benefit if they claim the education credits versus if you claim them (if you weren't a dependent) to optimize your family's overall tax situation.
0 coins
Noah Lee
One thing nobody has mentioned - check with your school's financial aid office ASAP! Sometimes they can restructure your aid package for next year to reduce this tax hit. My school was able to convert some of my scholarship to a work-study position, which changed how it was taxed. Also, keep ALL receipts for anything that might be education-related - lab fees, required equipment, etc. I learned this the hard way!
0 coins
Ava Hernandez
β’I work in a university financial aid office and this is good advice. We can sometimes adjust how aid is distributed or help students understand how to minimize tax impacts. Just don't wait until the last minute! Come see us early in the year, not at tax time when options are limited.
0 coins