


Ask the community...
This highlights a bigger problem - there are so many "ERC specialists" out there giving terrible advice just to collect their 15-25% contingency fees. They make the claim, take their cut, and disappear when the audits start rolling in. Businesses are left holding the bag with penalties and interest.
Exactly! My friend who runs a restaurant got convinced by one of these "specialists" to claim ERC based on dining capacity restrictions, which was legitimate. But then they pushed him to claim additional quarters when only OSHA guidance was in effect. Now he's worried about what will happen and the ERC company is nowhere to be found. They already took their 20% fee!
Does anyone have the link to the actual GLAM document? I'd like to read the details for myself.
Here's a practical tip for those caught in this hobby/business dilemma: keep DETAILED records regardless of which path you choose. I sell handmade jewelry occasionally and decided to establish it as a legitimate business even though sales are minimal. The key is showing your "profit motive" - document your efforts to make the activity profitable over time. Take photos of your workspace, keep receipts organized (I use QuickBooks Self-Employed), maintain a separate bank account, create a simple business plan, and market your creations consistently. Even if you don't show a profit immediately, these efforts demonstrate you're treating it as a business, not a hobby. This has worked for me for 3 tax cycles without issues.
Do you think having a separate business banking account is absolutely necessary? I sell crocheted items on Etsy (maybe $1200/year) but just use my personal account and track everything in a spreadsheet. Would the IRS have an issue with that?
Having a separate business account isn't absolutely required by law, but it's one of the strongest indicators that you're treating your activity as a business rather than a hobby. It shows clear separation between personal and business finances, which is important if you're ever questioned. For a small Etsy operation like yours, a detailed spreadsheet is better than nothing, but I'd strongly recommend at least opening a free business checking account. Many banks offer them with no minimum balance. This simple step adds significant credibility to your business classification and makes tracking expenses much easier come tax time.
An important point nobody's mentioned yet: If you're selling handmade items, you might also need to check your local laws about business licenses, sales tax collection, etc. Even if the fed gov considers you a "hobby," your state or local gov might still classify you as a business if you're making sales! I found this out the hard way with my stained glass hobby - my state requires me to collect sales tax even on occasional sales. Complete nightmare trying to fix this after the fact!
22 Don't make the same mistake I did with Section 179! I bought a $65k Escalade for my real estate business in 2022, took the max deduction, then only used it for business about 30% of the time. Got audited, and had to pay back most of the deduction plus penalties. The key thing nobody told me: you MUST use the vehicle more than 50% for business to qualify for Section 179 at all. And you need to keep a detailed mileage log to prove it. If you can't demonstrate that business use, the IRS will disallow the entire deduction. Also, be aware of the luxury auto depreciation limits for vehicles under 6,000 lbs - they're much lower. That's why so many accountants push business owners toward the larger SUVs.
10 How did the IRS know you were only using it 30% for business? Did they just look at your mileage log, or did they have other ways of figuring it out?
22 The IRS asked for my mileage log during the audit, and I had only kept sporadic records. They compared the total miles on the vehicle to the business miles I could document, and it came out to around 30%. They also looked at my appointment calendar and client locations to verify whether my claimed business trips were legitimate. The auditor explained that without a contemporaneous mileage log (meaning one kept at the time of travel, not created later), they default to assuming more personal use. The burden of proof is entirely on you as the taxpayer to demonstrate business usage. Without proper documentation, you'll lose the deduction every time.
9 Can someone explain how bonus depreciation works with vehicles compared to Section 179? I've heard bonus depreciation might actually be better in some cases, especially with the changes coming next year. Is it worth waiting until 2025?
2 Bonus depreciation is different from Section 179 in a few key ways. For 2024, bonus depreciation is at 60% (down from 80% in 2023), and will drop to 40% in 2025. Unlike Section 179, bonus depreciation CAN create a loss for your business, which might be beneficial depending on your situation. For vehicles above 6,000 lbs, you could potentially get a larger first-year deduction using a combination of Section 179 (up to $27,000) and bonus depreciation on the remaining basis. For vehicles under 6,000 lbs, the luxury auto limits still apply even with bonus depreciation.
One thing to consider - if you used that retirement money for qualified education expenses, you might be exempt from the 10% early withdrawal penalty. Since you mentioned graduating college, it's possible some of the funds went toward that? When I took an early distribution from my IRA for my last semester, I still had to pay income tax on it, but I avoided the 10% penalty by filing Form 5329 and indicating the qualified education exception.
That's really interesting - I didn't realize education expenses could qualify for avoiding the penalty. About $6,000 of what I withdrew actually did go toward my final tuition payment. Would I need to file an amended return to claim this exception, or can I just dispute the CP49 notice directly?
You can address it directly in your response to the CP49 notice. You'll need to complete Form 5329 for the tax year in question, entering the distribution amount on line 1, then the amount used for qualified education expenses on line 2 of the "Exceptions" section. I'd also include proof of payment to your educational institution from that year. The IRS will recalculate your liability based on this information. Since it's been a few years, gather as much documentation as possible - receipts, account statements, anything showing you used those funds for education.
Did you check to see if any taxes were already withheld from the distribution? Usually retirement plan administrators automatically withhold 20% for federal taxes when you take early distributions. If they did that, it should be credited against what you owe.
Alberto Souchard
Just want to add some practical advice from someone who's worked as a tax preparer. When you're filing back taxes: 1. Start with the most recent year (2024) and work backward, since the most recent year is most important to get current. 2. If you're owed refunds, you only have 3 years to claim them, so file 2022-2024 ASAP. 3. File all years separately - don't combine multiple years on one return. 4. Be prepared for paper filing for older years as electronic filing is only available for the current and previous two tax years. 5. It's often worth paying a professional for at least a consultation to make sure you're not missing anything. Also, the penalty for failing to file is usually worse than failing to pay, so getting those returns filed, even if you can't pay right away, is crucial!
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
ā¢Is there a statute of limitations on back taxes? Like, if they haven't contacted me about unfiled taxes from 10 years ago, am I in the clear?
0 coins
Alberto Souchard
ā¢There's no statute of limitations for unfiled tax returns - the IRS can come after you at any time for returns that were never filed. However, once you do file, the general statute of limitations is 3 years for the IRS to audit or assess additional taxes (this extends to 6 years if you underreported your income by more than 25%). For refunds, you only have 3 years from the original due date to claim them. After that time passes, you lose the refund forever, even if you were owed money. That's why it's important to file, even years later - at minimum to start the statute of limitations clock and potentially claim refunds that aren't yet time-barred.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
Has anyone used a paid tax preparer to file back taxes? I'm wondering if it's worth the cost or if I should just use tax software. I'm in a similar boat (3 unfiled years) but my situation is complicated because I had some 1099 income and worked in two different states.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
ā¢I used H&R Block for 4 years of back taxes and it was SO expensive - like $350 per year! In retrospect I should've just used software. Especially since they made a mistake on one of my returns that I had to fix anyway. Just make sure whatever you use has the right forms for your situation.
0 coins