


Ask the community...
Before you pursue legal action against Optima, make sure you've reviewed your contract with them carefully. Many of these companies include clauses that force arbitration rather than allowing lawsuits. Also check if there's a timeframe specified for delivering results. My sister went through something similar with another tax relief company and ended up filing complaints with: 1) The BBB (which got her a partial refund) 2) Her state's attorney general consumer protection division 3) The FTC's fraud division The attorney general's office was actually the most helpful and assigned an investigator to her case. She eventually got about 70% of her money back, but it took persistence.
Thanks for the advice. I've been reading through my contract and you're right - there's an arbitration clause buried in the fine print. Did your sister have to hire a lawyer to get her money back, or was she able to handle the complaint process herself?
She handled most of it herself with just a little guidance from a lawyer friend. The key was documenting everything thoroughly - she created a timeline of all promises made, services not delivered, and every interaction with the company. For the attorney general complaint, she included copies of all contracts, recordings of phone calls (where legal), and a detailed account of the harm caused. The most effective part was when the attorney general's office started their investigation. Companies often respond quickly when an official agency gets involved. She didn't have to proceed to formal arbitration because the company offered a settlement once they realized she was serious about pursuing all available channels. Stay persistent and document everything.
Has anyone thought about reporting these tax relief companies to the IRS itself? I remember reading that the IRS has a program called OPR (Office of Professional Responsibility) that oversees tax professionals. Maybe they could do something about companies that are falsely claiming they can resolve tax debts?
The IRS does take action against fraudulent tax resolution companies, but they're more focused on practitioners who are directly misrepresenting IRS rules or filing false documents. For consumer protection issues like this, the FTC and state agencies usually have more immediate jurisdiction. That said, reporting to multiple agencies increases the chances of action.
One practical tip that helped me with self-employment taxes was setting up a separate business checking account right away. I transfer 30% of every payment I receive into a dedicated tax savings account. This made quarterly estimated payments way less stressful because I always had the money set aside. I use the free Schedule C worksheet from the IRS website to track income and expenses throughout the year, which makes filling out the actual forms much easier when it's time. Also, don't overlook business deductions! Things like your home internet, cell phone (if used for business), home office space, professional subscriptions, and even health insurance premiums can potentially be deductible.
How do you decide what percentage of things like internet and cell phone to deduct when you use them for both personal and business purposes? I've heard conflicting advice about this.
The general rule is to deduct the percentage that you use for business purposes. For example, if you use your cell phone about 60% of the time for business calls/emails/etc., then you can deduct 60% of your cell phone bill. It's important to have some reasonable basis for determining these percentages. Some people keep logs for a sample period (like tracking business vs. personal internet usage for a few weeks) to establish their percentage. Others base it on time spent working vs. personal time. Whatever method you choose, just be consistent and make sure you can explain your reasoning if asked.
Does anyone know if using tax software like TurboSelf-Employed or H&R Block Self-Employed makes this process easier? I'm trying to decide if it's worth the cost or if I should just try to figure it out manually.
I've used TurboSelf-Employed for the past two years and it's definitely worth it for me. It walks you through all the self-employment forms step by step and automatically calculates your quarterly estimated payments. It also helps identify deductions I would have missed on my own. The expense categorization feature saves me tons of time - it learns which categories to assign to recurring expenses. And it keeps a running estimate of what I'll owe so there are no surprises at tax time.
Just to add another perspective - I've been a union electrician for 12 years. Our pension and supplemental retirement contributions made by the contractor are never deductible because, as others mentioned, they're already pre-tax. But don't forget to check if you make any VOLUNTARY contributions from your own pocket beyond what your employer puts in! Some unions allow members to make additional voluntary contributions to their plans, and those might have different tax treatment depending on whether they're pre-tax or after-tax contributions. Worth checking your union benefit booklet or asking your benefits administrator.
Is there a limit to how much can go into these accounts total? Like between what my employer puts in and what I might add?
Yes, there are annual limits to the total contributions that can go into retirement accounts. For 2024, the total contributions to a defined contribution plan (like a 401(k) or 403(b)) is capped at $69,000 or 100% of your compensation, whichever is less. This includes both employer and employee contributions combined. For traditional pension plans (defined benefit plans), the limits work differently and are based on actuarial calculations of what's needed to provide your promised benefit at retirement. Your benefits administrator at the union hall should be able to tell you exactly how much room you have for additional voluntary contributions based on your specific plan rules and the IRS limits.
Slightly different but related question - has anyone had experience with rolling over a union pension to an IRA after leaving the trade? I'm considering a career change but don't want to lose the retirement benefits I've built up.
I did this last year when I moved from a union job to management. Process wasn't too bad - contact your plan administrator and request a direct rollover to avoid tax withholding. Make sure you have an IRA already set up before you start the process. One thing to watch - some union pensions won't allow rollover until you're fully vested or have been inactive in the union for a specific period.
One option nobody's mentioned yet - if you're eligible for a Health Savings Account (HSA), those contributions DO reduce your self-employment tax base! It's one of the few pre-tax deductions that lower both income tax AND self-employment tax. To qualify, you need a high-deductible health plan (HDHP). For 2024, you can contribute up to $4,150 for individual coverage or $8,300 for family coverage. That could reduce your SE tax by up to $634 for individual or $1,269 for family (at the 15.3% SE tax rate). Worth looking into since it's literally the only retirement-adjacent account that actually reduces SE tax!
Are you absolutely sure about this? I've been contributing to an HSA for years and my accountant never mentioned it reduces SE tax. Seems like this would be common advice if true.
Yes, I'm sure. HSA contributions are one of the few "above-the-line" deductions that reduce self-employment income before SE tax is calculated. It's often overlooked because tax software handles it automatically, and many accountants just focus on the income tax benefits. If you look at Schedule 1, HSA contributions are deducted before arriving at your Adjusted Gross Income. Then on Schedule SE, your net earnings from self-employment are calculated using this adjusted figure, which means HSA contributions directly reduce your SE tax base.
My two cents - I think you're focusing on the wrong thing. S-Corp is the only real way to dramatically cut SE tax. I switched from sole proprietor to S-Corp once I hit about $75k profit and saved over $4k in SE taxes the first year. Basic math: You pay yourself a "reasonable salary" which is subject to FICA (basically SE tax), but any profit above that comes to you as distributions with NO SE tax. The trick is determining what's "reasonable" - too low and IRS might come calling. Yes, there's more paperwork and you'll pay some money for payroll processing, but at $2400 SE tax, you could likely cut that in half with an S-Corp. Talk to a CPA about this specifically - it's the #1 tax planning move for successful self-employed folks.
How much did it cost you to set up and maintain the S-Corp? I hear there are annual fees and payroll costs that eat into the tax savings. Is there a rule of thumb for when it's worth it?
Setup was about $500 with my state filing fees, then I pay around $1,200/year for payroll processing and my accountant charges an extra $350 for the S-Corp tax return versus Schedule C. So my annual ongoing cost is roughly $1,550. But I'm saving about $4,200 in SE tax, so I'm still ahead by $2,650 each year. The general rule of thumb I've heard is it makes sense when you're consistently making over $60-70K in net profit. The math works out great at higher income levels but gets questionable below $50K profit because of those fixed costs. And there's definitely more paperwork and deadlines to keep track of - quarterly payroll filings, etc. But my accountant handles most of it.
Paolo Bianchi
9 Former tax preparer here. I'd suggest looking at what specific help you need before deciding. TaxAct's Xpert Assist is decent for guidance, but if your issues are mainly around the self-employment income and multi-state filing, you might be better off consulting with a CPA for an hour. A good middle ground might be to try preparing your return yourself first, note the specific areas where you're uncertain, and then decide if you need help. For example, if you're unsure about home office deductions for your side gig or how to allocate income between states, those are specific questions you can have addressed without paying for full service prep.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
ā¢15 How do you find a CPA who'll just do a consultation rather than taking over your whole tax filing? When I've looked into it, they all seem to want to charge me $300+ to do the entire return.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
ā¢9 Many CPAs do offer consultation services, especially in the post-tax season months (May-December). You just need to be clear when you call that you're looking for tax planning or consultation, not preparation services. A good approach is to call and say something like: "I prepare my own taxes but would like a one-hour consultation to review specific areas where I might be missing deductions." Most will charge their hourly rate (typically $150-250) but the targeted advice can often save you more than that. Ask specifically for a consultation appointment rather than tax preparation services.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
2 What kind of side gig do you have? I found that the complexity of my taxes really depended on what type of self-employment I was doing. When I was just doing simple freelance writing, TaxAct's regular version was fine without any upgrades. But when I started an Etsy shop with inventory and supplies to track, I definitely needed more help.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
ā¢19 Not OP but I'm curious too - does TaxAct handle inventory tracking well? I'm starting a small online shop and trying to figure out if I need more sophisticated software.
0 coins