Is it normal for tax preparers to charge so much? I've been filing my S-Corp taxes with TurboTax for $170. Am I missing something by not using a professional?

It depends entirely on your business complexity and comfort level with tax regulations. TurboTax works well for straightforward businesses with minimal special situations. Where professionals provide value is with tax planning, specialized deductions, complex allocations, and having someone to represent you if questions arise. If you're confident in your understanding of business tax rules and your return is relatively straightforward, software might be sufficient. But many business owners find professionals help identify deductions and planning opportunities that more than offset their fees. Also, having representation during notices or audits can be invaluable for complex business structures.

Do you think its worth getting a lawyer involved? My cousin is an attorney and said I could have him send a letter for free.

In my experience, involving a lawyer should be your absolute last resort, not your first step. A strongly worded attorney letter might get immediate attention, but it also immediately creates an adversarial relationship that can make an amicable resolution harder. I'd recommend following the escalation chain first - preparer → office manager → corporate customer service. Most tax preparation chains have established protocols for handling errors and want to preserve their reputation. Save the legal approach for if they flatly refuse to address the issue after you've exhausted normal channels. Even a free lawyer letter from your cousin changes the dynamic significantly.

Is Modelo 210 something I can file online or do I need to physically go to a Spanish tax office? I'm planning to buy but won't be in Spain more than a few weeks each year.

You can definitely file the Modelo 210 online through the Spanish Tax Agency's website. You'll need to get an NIE (Foreigner Identification Number) first, which is required for property purchase anyway. Many non-residents also use a "fiscal representative" in Spain - basically an accountant or lawyer who handles the filing for you. This is often the easiest option if you're only there a few weeks a year. Most of the online filing system is available in English now, which is a big improvement from when I first bought my place five years ago. But the translations can be a bit confusing sometimes, which is why many people just hire a local tax advisor for a few hundred euros per year.

I went through this when my uncle passed and left his Malaga apartment to my cousin. Inheritance tax in Spain varies HUGELY by autonomous region - some regions like Madrid and Andalusia have big exemptions, especially for close family members. But as non-residents, you don't automatically get all the same benefits as residents. The good news is that in 2018, the rules changed to allow non-EU residents to benefit from regional tax rules instead of just the national ones, which are usually less favorable. So definitely check the specific inheritance tax rules for Mallorca (in the Balearic Islands region).

Thank you so much for this info! I had no idea the rules had changed in 2018 - that's a huge relief. I'll definitely look into the specific rules for the Balearic Islands. Did your cousin end up paying a lot in inheritance tax, or were they able to take advantage of the regional exemptions even as a non-resident?

This makes sense. I'm wondering if my preparer is confusing different rules. Do you have any recommendations for tax software that handles Form 1116 and foreign tax credit carryforwards properly?

In my experience, TaxAct Premium handles Form 1116 and foreign tax credit carryforwards correctly. It walks you through the proper allocation of carryforwards and applies them appropriately to your current year US tax liability. I've also heard good things about TaxSlayer Premium for international tax situations, though I haven't personally used it. The key is to make sure you're using a premium or top-tier version of whatever software you choose, as the basic versions often don't include the proper support for Form 1116.

This is excellent advice. I messed this up years ago with my Hong Kong income and it caused a huge headache. Had to amend returns because my preparer put everything in passive category when most should have been general.

I've considered that, but the inheritance left me really overweighted in just two sectors (finance and healthcare). The financial advisor at Vanguard recommended I diversify since these stocks now make up almost 30% of my total portfolio. I'm just trying to be smart about when and how I make the transition to minimize the tax hit.

I understand wanting to diversify, but consider doing it gradually over a couple of tax years instead of all at once. You could sell enough this year to stay in a lower tax bracket, then do the rest next year. Also worth checking if any of these companies offer dividend reinvestment plans (DRIPs). If they do, you could potentially shift some portion to those programs and slowly diversify without selling and triggering capital gains.

That's actually incorrect. The wash sale rule only applies when you sell at a LOSS and then rebuy within 30 days. OP is dealing with GAINS, so the wash sale rule isn't relevant here at all. Plus, what would be the point of selling at a gain, paying taxes, and immediately rebuying? That would just create a tax bill with no benefit.

Thanks for this detailed advice! Did you also need to submit a revised Form 940 for 2022, or was providing the proof of state payments enough? I'm wondering if I need to get our accountant involved to redo any filings.

We didn't need to submit a revised Form 940. The documentation of state payments was sufficient since we had already filed the original Form 940 correctly - the issue was just that the states hadn't reported our payments to the IRS. I'd recommend having your accountant review the documentation package before submission though. In our case, our accountant noticed that we needed to include Schedule A of Form 940 to properly document the credit reduction states where we had employees. This was crucial for getting the assessment reversed.

Look at Box 16 on the notice - it should list the "Credit Reduction States" that are causing the issue. For 2022, there were specifically 5 states that had FUTA credit reductions: California (0.9% reduction), Connecticut (1.5%), Illinois (1.2%), New Jersey (1.8%), and New York (1.2%). If your notice doesn't specify, you'll want to gather documentation for any of these 5 states where you had employees in 2022.