Does the software handle the reasonable compensation requirements and QBI calculations properly? I tried doing my own S Corp return once and ended up with a notice from the IRS about my salary being too low relative to distributions. Cost me way more than what I saved on preparation.

The software does have warnings about reasonable compensation if your salary seems too low compared to distributions, but it doesn't give specific guidance on what's "reasonable" - that's still on you to research and determine. For QBI, it does the calculations automatically once you enter all the required information. The wizard asks you questions about your business type and aggregation elections to determine eligibility. It's actually handled really well. You're right that getting those aspects wrong can be costly - I spent extra time researching those specific areas before filing. There are also some good YouTube tutorials specifically on S Corp tax prep using the major software packages that helped me avoid common mistakes.

That makes a lot of sense about the experience levels. I think I'm actually going to look into a local firm based on your suggestion. I'm realizing now I've been evaluating purely on price rather than value. I don't mind paying the same amount if I'm getting actual business advice along with the tax prep. Do you think it's too late to switch for this tax season, or should I wait until next year?

Does WMR work differently for amended returns? I filed an amendment about 5 weeks ago and it's still not showing up anywhere.

Amended returns are completely different! For those, you need to use the "Where's My Amended Return" tool instead of the regular WMR. It's a separate system entirely. Amended returns also take much longer to process - the IRS says to allow up to 16 weeks (although in recent years it's been taking even longer for many people). The tracking for amendments is also much less detailed than regular returns. You'll typically just see "received," "adjusted," or "completed" without the specific deposit information that the regular WMR provides.

OMG this happened to me too!! So frustrating. Does anyone know how many times is "too many" before it locks you out?

I hadn't even thought about state taxes or the LLC angle. Do you know if forming an LLC changes how depreciation works? And would I need to file a separate business tax return if I create an LLC?

A single-member LLC is typically treated as a "disregarded entity" for tax purposes, so you'd still report everything on your personal return using Schedule E. The depreciation works the same way regardless of whether you have an LLC or not. You generally don't need to file a separate business return for a single-member LLC used for rental property. However, if you elect to have your LLC taxed as an S-corp (which some people do to potentially save on self-employment taxes), then you would file a separate return. But for most small landlords with one property, keeping it simple with a disregarded LLC is usually the way to go.

I used TurboTax Premier last year for my rental and it worked fine. It walks you through all the Schedule E stuff and helps calculate depreciation. Just make sure you keep really good records of your expenses throughout the year. The one time I got confused, I used their live help feature and the tax expert cleared things up quickly.

That's a great point! I didn't even think about my scholarship reducing my eligible expenses. I received about $3,500 in scholarships last year. So if my tuition was $5,000, I would only be able to claim $1,500 for the Lifetime Learning Credit?

That's exactly right! You would only be able to claim $1,500 as your qualified education expenses in that scenario. And remember, the Lifetime Learning Credit is calculated as 20% of your qualified expenses, so your potential credit would be $300 ($1,500 × 20%). Then, that potential credit amount gets compared to your remaining tax liability on the Credit Limit Worksheet. If your remaining tax liability is less than $300 (or zero), that's why you'd end up with zero or a reduced credit amount on line 19 of Form 8863.

I used both TurboTax and H&R Block and got the same zero result with the Lifetime Learning Credit. I think different software might do the calculations slightly differently, but the end result should be the same if you're entering the same information. Might be worth double-checking that you input everything identically in both programs.

Thanks for this info! So even if Zelle doesn't report it, I should still be reporting this income? Would I just add it as "miscellaneous income" or would I need to file as self-employed with a Schedule C?

You should definitely report the income regardless of whether Zelle issues a 1099-K. Since you're receiving regular payments for work performed, this would be considered self-employment income, not miscellaneous income. You'll need to file Schedule C to report your business income and expenses, and Schedule SE to calculate your self-employment tax. This is actually better for you in many ways because with Schedule C, you can deduct legitimate business expenses that reduce your taxable income. If you have a home office, use your phone for work, or have any other expenses related to this work, those can potentially be deductible.

Same experience here. I got a 1099-K from PayPal but nothing from Venmo despite making similar amounts on both. I reported everything anyway because I don't want headaches with the IRS, but the inconsistency is frustrating. I think different platforms are interpreting the requirements differently.