


Ask the community...
Don't forget podcasts as a supplement to books! "Planet Money" by NPR has several excellent episodes on taxation that might help spark your interest before diving into heavier books. Their episodes "Tax Hero" and "Paying for the Crime" are particularly good introductions to tax concepts. There's also the "Taxology" podcast which is surprisingly entertaining despite focusing exclusively on tax history and policy. I've found listening to these while commuting helps build background knowledge that makes the books easier to understand.
Any specific Planet Money episodes you'd recommend starting with? They have hundreds of episodes, and searching for tax-related ones is bringing up too many results.
Start with episode #945 "The Liberty City" about tax havens and how they work - it plays out like a fascinating economic mystery story. Then try #420 "The Tax Man Cometh" which explores the history of income tax in America. Both use narrative storytelling techniques that make tax concepts really accessible. For Taxology, I'd recommend starting with their episode on "The Boston Tea Party Revisited" which gives amazing context to how tax resistance shaped American identity from the beginning. Their "History of the IRS" episode is also excellent and helps explain why our tax administration works the way it does today.
As someone who also struggled with the dry nature of tax topics, I found that starting with "The Power to Destroy: How the Antitax Movement Hijacked America" by Michael Graetz really opened my eyes to how taxation connects to broader American political culture. It reads more like political history than a tax book, but gave me the conceptual framework that made everything else click. Another approach that worked for me was reading "The Hidden Wealth of Nations" by Gabriel Zucman alongside some of the books mentioned here. It's about tax avoidance and offshore banking, but understanding how the wealthy navigate (or circumvent) the tax system actually helped me better appreciate why certain rules exist for regular taxpayers like us. One thing I'd suggest is not trying to tackle too many dense books at once. I made that mistake initially and got overwhelmed. Pick one that sounds most interesting based on the recommendations here, read it thoroughly, then move to the next. The context from each book builds on the others in ways that aren't obvious at first.
This is exactly the kind of approach I was hoping to find! Starting with political history rather than diving straight into tax mechanics makes so much more sense for someone with a humanities background. "The Power to Destroy" sounds like it would give me that broader context I'm craving. I really appreciate the advice about not overwhelming myself with too many books at once - I definitely have a tendency to create huge reading lists and then abandon them when they feel unmanageable. Taking it one book at a time and letting each build on the last seems much more sustainable. The Gabriel Zucman recommendation is intriguing too. Understanding how the system gets gamed might actually make the legitimate rules feel less arbitrary and more purposeful. Thanks for these thoughtful suggestions!
Quick question about all this - I'm just a dog walker who files Schedule C. My tax software is showing an option for "paying myself" - should I just ignore that completely and stick to owner draws?
This situation is unfortunately more common than it should be. I've seen several cases where tax preparers set up sole proprietors with payroll systems, often because they're using generic business software that assumes corporate structures. The $275 fee is definitely a red flag - proper business tax preparation requires understanding entity structures, and competent preparers charge appropriately for that expertise. Your instincts are absolutely correct here. Beyond the immediate tax issues others have mentioned, there's also a compliance nightmare brewing. If your client is running payroll, they're likely supposed to be filing quarterly 941 forms, making federal tax deposits, potentially dealing with state payroll requirements, etc. All of this creates unnecessary administrative burden and potential penalties for a structure that shouldn't exist. I'd strongly recommend your client consult with a qualified tax professional (CPA or EA) to clean this up. They'll need to decide whether to amend previous returns or just correct going forward, depending on the amounts involved and audit risk tolerance. The sooner this gets fixed, the better - especially before any IRS correspondence arrives. Your recommendation about either taking proper draws or electing S-Corp status is spot-on. The client needs to pick a lane and do it correctly.
Went through literally the EXACT same thing last year! We thought we filed through H&R Block but never submitted. Found out when applying for a car loan. We ended up going to a local CPA who charged us $275 to e-file our prior year return. Had it done in 2 days and got confirmation really quick. Mortgage companies usually just need proof you filed, not that everything is fully processed. Ask your mortgage broker exactly what they need to see - sometimes just the filing confirmation is enough to keep the loan moving.
I'm a tax preparer and see this situation fairly often. Dylan, you're absolutely right to be concerned about timing, but there are a few things that can work in your favor here. First, since you already completed everything in TurboTax, you have all your documentation organized. A tax professional can take that information and e-file your 2021 return immediately - we're not restricted by the same e-file dates that consumer software has for prior year returns. For a straightforward return like yours (sounds like W-2 income), you should expect to pay $200-350 for the service. Yes, it's more expensive than doing it yourself, but given your mortgage timeline, it's probably worth it. Here's what I'd recommend: Find a local CPA or enrolled agent (not a chain like H&R Block) who can e-file immediately. Ask them to provide you with a copy of the filed return and the e-file confirmation. Your mortgage lender will likely accept this as proof of filing while they wait for IRS processing. The penalties aren't as scary as they seem - you're looking at roughly 5% of your tax owed per month for failure to file (capped at 25%), plus 0.5% per month for failure to pay, plus interest. On $1,800, that's probably around $400-500 in total penalties and interest for being 3+ years late. Get this handled this week if possible. Your mortgage situation is salvageable, but time is definitely of the essence here.
wmr still says processing but transcript updated thank god
Congrats on finally getting your 846! That's such a relief after waiting since May 2024. The timeline definitely makes sense - your amended return was completed on 1/16 and now you have a DDD of 2/14, which is pretty typical processing time. You should definitely see that $4,872 hit your account on or around 2/14. The fact that it went from processing to 846 so quickly after completion is a really good sign. Hang in there, you're almost at the finish line! š
Genevieve Cavalier
When you file the amended return with Form 8936, be prepared to wait much longer than usual for your refund. I amended for the EV credit back in February and still waiting. The IRS website still shows "received" as the status. š¤
0 coins
Ethan Scott
ā¢I amended for the same reason in March and got my refund about 16 weeks later. The "Where's My Amended Return" tool never updated beyond "received" but the money showed up in my account. Check your bank account - it might have come through already!
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
I'm in a very similar situation! Just realized I forgot to claim the EV credit for my Model Y purchased in August 2023. Reading through all these responses has been super helpful - sounds like I definitely need to file Form 1040-X with Form 8936. Quick question for everyone who's been through this process: How long did it actually take from mailing your amended return to getting the refund? I'm seeing conflicting timeframes here - some saying 16 weeks, others still waiting since February. Also, did anyone try e-filing the amendment or is mail the only option for this situation? Thanks for all the detailed info, especially about checking VIN eligibility and the various tools mentioned. This community is awesome!
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
ā¢Welcome to the amended return club! Based on my experience and what I've seen others report here, processing times seem to vary quite a bit. I filed my 1040-X with Form 8936 in January and got my refund after about 20 weeks - definitely longer than the typical 16 weeks they quote, but it did come through eventually. For e-filing, unfortunately most tax software (including TurboTax) doesn't support e-filing amended returns with Form 8936 yet. I ended up having to print and mail everything. Make sure to send it certified mail so you have proof of delivery - that really helps if you need to call and check on status later. One tip: keep copies of absolutely everything and take photos of your mailed package. The IRS "Where's My Amended Return" tool is pretty unreliable, so having your own documentation helps a lot if you need to follow up. Good luck with your amendment!
0 coins