


Ask the community...
I think a lot of people are missing that there's a difference between the penalty for late FILING and late PAYMENT. Since you're a nonprofit that doesn't owe taxes, you're only dealing with the late filing penalty, which might give you more flexibility. Also worth checking if you qualify for first-time penalty abatement (FTA) which the IRS offers for organizations with a clean compliance history. You don't even need reasonable cause for that - just a clean record for the past 3 years.
Actually, @Jake Sinclair raises an important question about FTA for nonprofits. From my understanding, first-time penalty abatement is primarily available for income tax penalties, employment tax penalties, and certain excise tax penalties - but NOT for information return penalties like the Form 990 late filing penalty. The IRS treats information return penalties (which is what Form 990 falls under) differently from tax penalties. For Form 990 late filing, you really need to establish reasonable cause rather than relying on FTA provisions. That said, your situation does have some strong elements for reasonable cause: volunteer status, small organization with limited resources, and a significant life event (new baby). I'd focus your letter on those factors rather than trying to pursue FTA, which likely won't apply to your Form 990 situation.
just wanna add that your parents should probably claim you as a dependent if they provide more than half your support (housing, food, tuition help, etc). the american opportunity credit is worth up to $2500 and your parents can only claim it if they claim you as a dependent. since you only worked one month, you probably dont have enough income for the credit to be worth much to you personally. you'll probably still get a small refund from your summer job withholding regardless of whether youre a dependent or not. make sure to file regardless!
Thanks for the explanation! Just to clarify - if my parents claim me as dependent, can I still file my own return to get back the money that was withheld from my summer job? Or does everything have to go through their tax return?
Yes, you should absolutely still file your own tax return even if your parents claim you as a dependent! The two things are separate. You file to get back your withholding from your summer job. Your parents would file their return claiming you as a dependent and including the education expenses from your 1098-T forms to get the education credits. Both things can happen at the same time - you get your refund from your withholding, and they get the benefit of the education credits.
One thing nobody's mentioned that tripped me up last year - if u make under like $12,500 (the standard deduction amount) filing as single, you might not even need to file federally! But u should STILL file to get any withheld money back from those summer paychecks. For the 1098-Ts, whoever claims you as dependent gets to use those for the education credits. in my case, my parents let me file independent last year because they make too much to qualify for the education credits anyway (there's an income limit). but if ur parents can use the credits, usually best for them to claim you and you can still file to get ur withholding back on ur own return.
But if his parents claim him, doesn't he have to check the "someone can claim you as dependent" box on his return? Does that affect his refund at all?
Yes, if your parents claim you as a dependent, you do have to check that box on your return. It mainly affects your standard deduction amount - as a dependent, your standard deduction is limited to the greater of $1,150 or your earned income plus $400 (up to the regular standard deduction amount). But since you only worked one month at minimum wage, your income was probably pretty low anyway, so this shouldn't really hurt your refund much. The main thing is you'll still get back whatever federal taxes were withheld from your paychecks, which is probably the bulk of any refund you'd get regardless of dependency status.
One option nobody mentioned yet - you could use a Print-on-Demand platform that handles tax for you. I use Printful through their Etsy integration, and Etsy collects and remits all the sales tax automatically. I just deal with my income taxes in France, and it's much simpler. The downside is you'll make less profit per item since these platforms take a cut, but the time and stress saved on tax compliance might be worth it when you're starting out.
As someone who went through this exact process last year, I'd highly recommend starting with the basics first. Before diving into tools or services, make sure you understand the fundamental difference between income tax (federal) and sales tax (state-level). For income tax, you'll likely need an ITIN (Individual Taxpayer Identification Number) from the IRS since you're not a US citizen. This lets you file the proper forms like 1040-NR for nonresident aliens. The process takes a few months, so start early. For sales tax, track your sales by state from day one. Most states have economic nexus thresholds around $100K in sales OR 200+ transactions per year. Keep detailed records because once you hit these thresholds, you'll need to register for sales tax permits in those states. Also consider getting a US bank account through services like Wise or Mercury - it makes payments from US customers much smoother and can help with your business legitimacy when dealing with suppliers.
This is really helpful advice! I'm just starting to research this whole process and the ITIN requirement is something I hadn't heard about yet. A few months processing time sounds like a lot - do you know if there's any way to speed that up, or should I just plan to wait before I can properly file US taxes? Also, when you mention getting a US bank account through Wise or Mercury, did you need the ITIN first, or can you set those up with just your European documentation?
Has anyone used the IRS's own QBI worksheet rather than online calculators? I found it in the Form 1040 instructions and it seems more detailed than most online tools. It definitely accounts for the thresholds and limitations we're discussing.
I tried the IRS worksheet last year and it was helpful but super time-consuming. It's about 12 pages of calculations! The forms correctly handle the wage limitations and phase-out thresholds, but you need to be really careful about entering everything perfectly. I made a small error that cascaded through the calculations and had to start over twice.
The IRS worksheet is definitely the most accurate approach, but you're right about it being complex. As a CPA who helps clients with QBI calculations regularly, I always recommend starting with the official worksheet to get the correct baseline calculation before using any online tools. One tip that helps avoid calculation errors: work through each section methodically and double-check that your "qualified business income" number excludes reasonable compensation from your S-corp. I see clients mess this up frequently - they include their W-2 wages in the QBI amount when it should only be the remaining business profits. For Dylan's original question about the $340K joint income with $250K from the S-corp - make sure you're clear on whether that $250K is before or after your reasonable compensation. If it's after, then you're on the right track. If it includes your salary, you'll need to subtract that first to get your actual QBI amount.
This is really helpful clarification! I think this might be where I went wrong with my calculations. When I said $250K from my S-corp, that was actually the total business income before paying myself. I pay myself $80K in reasonable compensation, so my actual QBI would be $170K, not $250K. That changes the calculation significantly - 20% of $170K is only $34K potential deduction. With the $80K in W-2 wages, the limitation would be 50% of $80K = $40K, so I'd still get the full $34K deduction even above the income threshold. Thanks for catching that - no wonder the online calculator seemed off!
Hassan Khoury
The most important thing I learned from my tax debt situation is DONT IGNORE IT!! I buried my head in the sand for 2 years and my original $15k debt ballooned to over $28k with penalties and interest. For real tho, call the IRS yourself first. The people on the phone are actually pretty helpful if you're honest and polite. At minimum, get on a basic payment plan to stop the penalties from getting worse while you figure out your options.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
β’This is so true. I worked out a simple payment plan with the IRS and the agent was super helpful. Wasn't scary at all once I finally made the call.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
I'm dealing with a similar situation - about $19,000 in back taxes from a consulting business that went under in 2022. The constant mail from the IRS was giving me panic attacks, but I finally called them directly last week using the number Isabella mentioned (1-800-829-1040). The IRS agent was actually really understanding and explained that I could set up an installment agreement for around $320/month based on my current income. She also mentioned that once I get current on payments, I might qualify for penalty abatement which could reduce the total amount. What really helped was having all my financial documents ready before calling - bank statements, pay stubs, and a list of monthly expenses. The whole process took about 45 minutes and I walked away with a manageable payment plan instead of the crushing anxiety I'd been carrying for months. Emma, definitely try calling them directly first before paying thousands to a tax relief company. The worst they can say is no, but in most cases they'd rather work with you than go through the collection process.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
β’This is really encouraging to hear! I've been putting off calling the IRS because I was terrified they'd be aggressive or unsympathetic, but it sounds like they're actually willing to work with people who are honest about their situation. Did you have to provide a lot of documentation upfront, or was most of it done over the phone? I'm trying to get organized before I make the call but I'm worried I'm missing something important. Also, how quickly did the installment agreement go into effect after you set it up? @Emma Swift - Omar s'experience sounds very similar to yours, so this might be exactly what you need to hear before taking that first step.
0 coins