


Ask the community...
has anyone actually received their ertc refund yet??? filed 941-x last february and still nothing. getting worried the money will never come at this point :
I got mine, but it took 14 months from filing the 941-X forms. No communication from the IRS during that time, the checks just showed up one day. Keep in mind they're processing them in the order received, so February 2023 filings should be coming up in the queue soon if they're maintaining the same timeframe I experienced.
I can confirm what others have said - your accountant is definitely wrong about claiming ERTC on current year taxes. As a small business owner who went through this process last year, you absolutely must file Form 941-X amendments for each qualifying quarter. I made the mistake of trusting my original CPA's advice (similar to yours) and almost filed incorrectly. The ERTC is specifically tied to payroll taxes from those pandemic quarters, not income taxes. There's no mechanism in the tax code to shift it to current year filing. My advice: find a new accountant who understands ERTC rules properly, or at minimum get a second opinion from someone who specializes in employment tax credits. The penalties for filing incorrectly could be severe, and you don't want to deal with that headache later. The extra paperwork for proper 941-X filings is worth doing it right the first time.
This is really helpful - thank you for sharing your experience! I'm definitely getting concerned about my accountant's approach now that multiple people are confirming it's wrong. Can you recommend what to look for when finding an accountant who actually understands ERTC rules? Are there specific certifications or specializations I should ask about? I don't want to make the same mistake twice with choosing someone who doesn't know the employment tax credit requirements.
Great thread! I've been struggling with the same issues and this discussion has been incredibly helpful. One thing I wanted to add based on my experience last year - make sure you're also considering the timing of when you moved funds between exchanges. I had a situation where I transferred a large amount from Binance to KuCoin in the middle of the year, and for a brief period, the same funds were technically "in transit" but still showing on both platforms. I almost double-counted that amount when calculating my maximum balance. The key is to track the actual settled balances, not pending transfers. Also, if you're using any foreign lending platforms (like BlockFi when it was operational, or current platforms like Nexo), those definitely count as foreign financial accounts for FBAR purposes if they're not US-based. I learned this the hard way when my tax preparer caught it during review. The monthly screenshot approach mentioned earlier is genius - I wish I had thought of that instead of trying to reconstruct everything from transaction histories at year-end!
This is such a great point about funds in transit! I had a similar issue where I was moving Bitcoin from one exchange to another and the blockchain confirmation took longer than expected. Both exchanges were showing the balance temporarily, which would have definitely led to double-counting if I hadn't been careful. Your mention of lending platforms is really important too - I think a lot of people don't realize that platforms like Nexo or even some of the newer DeFi lending protocols based outside the US could trigger FBAR requirements. It's not just traditional "exchanges" but any foreign platform where you're holding crypto assets. The complexity of this stuff is exactly why I've been considering getting professional help for next tax season. Between tracking maximum balances, avoiding double-counting during transfers, and making sure I'm not missing any foreign platforms that count as "financial accounts," it feels like there are so many ways to accidentally mess up the reporting. Has anyone here worked with a tax professional who specializes in crypto? I'm wondering if it's worth the extra cost to avoid potential compliance issues.
As someone who went through this exact nightmare last year, I can't stress enough how important it is to get professional help if you're dealing with multiple foreign exchanges. I tried to handle everything myself initially and made several mistakes that could have resulted in penalties. The key things I learned: First, the $10k threshold is indeed based on aggregate maximum values across ALL foreign accounts, not simultaneous balances. Second, you need to be really careful about what constitutes a "foreign financial account" - it's not just exchanges, but also lending platforms, staking services, and even some DeFi protocols depending on where they're incorporated. One thing that saved me was discovering that some exchanges provide annual statements specifically designed for tax reporting. Binance, for example, has a tax reporting section where you can generate statements that show your maximum balance for the year. Not all exchanges offer this, but it's worth checking before you spend hours reconstructing your records. Also, don't forget that beyond FBAR, if your foreign crypto assets exceed certain thresholds ($50k for single filers), you may also need to file Form 8938 (FATCA reporting) with your regular tax return. The thresholds and requirements are different from FBAR, so you could end up needing both forms. The good news is that once you set up a proper tracking system, it becomes much more manageable in subsequent years. But for your first year dealing with foreign exchanges, seriously consider getting help from a tax professional who understands crypto - it's worth the peace of mind.
This is incredibly helpful - thank you for sharing your experience! I'm definitely in that "first year dealing with foreign exchanges" category and feeling overwhelmed by all the requirements. The point about Binance having tax reporting statements is huge - I had no idea that was available and have been trying to manually track everything through their regular transaction history. Quick question about the Form 8938 threshold you mentioned - when you say $50k for single filers, is that based on the same "maximum aggregate balance" calculation as FBAR, or is it calculated differently? I want to make sure I understand if I might need both forms. Also, do you have any recommendations for finding tax professionals who actually understand crypto? I've called a few local CPAs and most of them seemed uncomfortable with crypto questions, let alone foreign exchange reporting requirements.
Don't forget about the business use percentage! If you're using your Santa Fe for both personal and business purposes, you can only depreciate the business portion. For example, if you use it 70% for business and 30% personal, you can only take depreciation on 70% of the cost. Also, have you considered just taking standard mileage for 2022 and 2023 instead of actual expenses with depreciation? With your low income, it might be simpler and possibly more beneficial.
Your situation is more common than you think! The good news is that filing late doesn't disqualify you from bonus depreciation - what matters is when you actually placed the vehicle in service for business use. Since you bought the Santa Fe in March 2022 and presumably started using it for business then, you can still claim 100% bonus depreciation for 2022. However, you'll face late filing penalties and interest on any taxes owed. Given your low income across 2022-2023, I'd strongly recommend running the numbers on a few different scenarios: 1. **100% bonus depreciation in 2022** - This will likely create a large NOL that carries forward 2. **Section 179 election** - You can choose exactly how much to deduct (maybe just enough to zero out your 2022 income) 3. **Standard mileage method** - Might be simpler and more beneficial given your income levels With three Schedule Cs and varying income levels, the optimal strategy isn't obvious. You'll need to track business use percentage carefully and allocate between your different businesses based on actual mileage. Consider getting professional help given the complexity - whether that's a tax software that can model different scenarios or speaking with a tax professional who can run the numbers for your specific situation.
This is exactly the kind of comprehensive breakdown I was hoping for! I hadn't really thought about running different scenarios to compare the outcomes. Since I'm dealing with multiple years of low income and three different businesses, it sounds like the standard approach might not be the best fit for my situation. The idea of using Section 179 to just zero out my 2022 income instead of creating a huge NOL makes a lot of sense. Do you know if there are any good resources or tools that can help model these different scenarios? I'm trying to avoid making a decision that looks good for 2022 but creates problems down the road with my 2023 and 2024 returns. Also, when you mention tracking business use percentage - is this something I need to reconstruct for 2022 since I didn't keep detailed records back then, or can I estimate based on my current usage patterns?
Just want to add another important tip - if you're using a credit card to pay your CP14 balance, check if your card offers any cash back or rewards for tax payments. Some cards categorize these payments as "government services" which might earn you points. Also, make sure you're not close to your credit limit before making the payment. I've seen people have their payments declined because they didn't account for the processing fee on top of the balance owed. The last thing you want is a failed payment when you're trying to stop penalties from accumulating! And definitely double-check that you're using one of the IRS-approved processors (PayUSAtax, Pay1040, or ACI Payments). There are some sketchy websites out there that look official but aren't actually authorized by the IRS.
Great point about checking credit limits! I learned this the hard way when my payment got declined because I forgot about the processing fee. Had to scramble to make a bank transfer instead, which delayed everything by a few days. For anyone reading this - the processing fees are usually around 1.87% to 1.99% of your payment amount, so for a $750 balance you're looking at roughly $14-15 in fees on top of the amount owed. Factor that into your available credit before hitting submit! Also seconding the advice about only using IRS-approved processors. I almost fell for a fake site that looked identical to the real ones but had slightly different URLs. When in doubt, go directly to IRS.gov and click their links to the authorized payment processors.
I went through this exact same situation last month with a CP14 notice. Here's what worked for me: 1. Use the IRS.gov website to access the approved payment processors - don't Google them separately as there are fake lookalike sites. 2. For the payment category, select "Form 1040 payment" or "Individual tax payment" - there's no specific CP14 option. 3. Make sure to enter the correct tax year from your notice (probably 2024), not the current year you're making the payment. 4. Have your SSN, notice number, and exact balance amount ready before starting. I used Pay1040 and it worked perfectly. The fee was about $15 on a $800 payment. The key thing is making sure all your identifying information matches exactly what's on the CP14 notice so the payment gets applied correctly. One more tip - set up an online IRS account if you don't have one already. Even though their payment system was down when you tried, you can usually track when your payment gets processed and see your balance update in real time once it goes through.
This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I'm new to dealing with IRS notices and was really stressed about messing something up. Your step-by-step breakdown makes it seem much more manageable. Quick question - when you say "set up an online IRS account," is that different from the regular IRS.gov login? I tried creating an account before but got confused by all the different portals they have. Which specific one should I be looking for to track my CP14 payment? Also, did your balance update immediately after payment or did it take the full processing time to show the change? I'm worried I'll keep getting follow-up notices even after I pay if their system is slow to update.
Oliver Zimmermann
I dealt with this exact same code 6657 penalty situation last year and successfully got it removed! Here's what I learned: **Most important tip**: Request abatement under BOTH "reasonable cause" AND "First Time Penalty Abatement" if you qualify. Many people don't realize you can use both arguments in the same letter. **For your letter, include**: - Clear statement that you're requesting abatement of IRC Section 6657 penalty - Explanation that payment was properly set up through TurboTax with sufficient funds - Bank statement showing available balance on the scheduled payment date - Copy of your TurboTax payment confirmation/screenshot - Statement that the same account worked when you paid manually later **Key phrase to use**: "The payment failure was due to circumstances beyond my control and not due to willful neglect or intentional disregard of tax obligations." **Important**: Send to the correspondence address on your CP14 notice (usually in the upper right corner), NOT the payment address. Use certified mail with return receipt. The whole process took about 45 days for me, and I got the full $235 penalty refunded plus interest. Don't give up - these technical payment failures are often the IRS system's fault, not yours. You have a strong case for abatement!
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
ā¢This is incredibly helpful! I had no idea you could request abatement under both reasonable cause AND First Time Penalty Abatement in the same letter. That's a game-changer for maximizing your chances of success. Quick question about the bank statement - did you include the entire monthly statement or just highlight the specific date when the payment was supposed to process? I'm worried about sending too much personal financial information to the IRS if it's not necessary. Also, when you say "plus interest" on the refund, does that mean they actually pay you interest on the penalty amount while they were holding it? I didn't realize the IRS paid interest on penalty refunds - that's a nice bonus if true!
0 coins
Aaron Boston
ā¢For the bank statement, I just included the relevant pages showing the account balance around the payment date - you don't need to send your entire monthly statement. I highlighted the specific date when the IRS payment was supposed to process and a few days before/after to show consistent sufficient funds. You can also black out any unrelated transactions if you're concerned about privacy. And yes, they do pay interest on penalty refunds! It's called "refund interest" and it's calculated from the date you paid the penalty until the date they issue the refund. The rate is usually around 3-4% annually, so it's not huge money, but it's something. In my case, it was about $8 extra on my $235 penalty refund since the whole process took about 7 weeks. The IRS is actually required by law to pay interest on any overpayments, including penalties that get abated after you've already paid them. It's one of the few times the IRS actually works in your favor!
0 coins
Yara Elias
I went through almost the identical situation last year! The IRS direct debit system definitely has technical glitches that aren't the taxpayer's fault. Here's my step-by-step approach that worked: **For your abatement letter, include these key elements:** - Your personal info (name, SSN, address, tax year 2023) - CP14 notice number and date - Specific request for "abatement of Internal Revenue Code Section 6657 penalty" - Clear explanation that you had sufficient funds and payment was properly set up through TurboTax - Attach bank statement showing available balance on the scheduled payment date - Include TurboTax payment setup confirmation/screenshot - Emphasize that the same account worked when you paid manually afterward **Critical language to use:** Request abatement under "reasonable cause due to circumstances beyond my control" AND mention "First Time Penalty Abatement" if you've had clean compliance for the past 3 years. **Logistics:** Send to the correspondence address on your CP14 (not the payment address), use certified mail with return receipt requested. The fact that your bank account had sufficient funds and the payment worked later strongly supports that this was a system error, not your fault. I got my $190 penalty completely removed in about 6 weeks using this exact approach. Don't pay the penalty upfront unless you're worried about interest - if they approve abatement, you'll avoid the penalty entirely. Good luck! This is definitely worth fighting since it wasn't due to your error.
0 coins
StarStrider
ā¢This is such valuable advice! I'm dealing with a similar situation right now and was feeling overwhelmed by all the paperwork. One quick question - you mentioned not paying the penalty upfront unless worried about interest. How much interest are we typically talking about? My penalty is around $150, so I'm trying to decide if it's worth paying now to stop the interest clock or waiting to see if the abatement gets approved first. Also, has anyone had success getting these abatements approved faster by including additional documentation like a letter from their bank confirming the account was in good standing? I'm wondering if more documentation helps or just complicates things.
0 coins