


Ask the community...
Your roommate should talk to their employer about a couple options: 1. Request reimbursement for supplies through an accountable plan. This would let them get reimbursed tax-free. 2. Ask about changing their employment structure. Many tattoo artists work as booth renters (self-employed) rather than employees specifically because of the equipment issue. The shop is honestly getting a great deal if they're paying employment taxes on them but making them buy all their own equipment. Most tattoo artists I know either work as independent contractors or the shop provides the basics.
Thanks for the suggestions! Do you know if the booth rental option would require my roommate to do anything special with taxes throughout the year? They're worried about owing a huge amount at tax time if they go independent.
If they switch to booth rental (self-employed), they would need to make quarterly estimated tax payments. They'd pay both income tax and self-employment tax (which covers Social Security and Medicare). The benefit is they could deduct ALL their business expenses - not just supplies, but also a portion of their phone bill, mileage driving to buy supplies, art classes to improve their skills, even a home office if they do any work at home. These deductions often offset much of the self-employment tax increase.
I'm a tattoo artist and this is exactly why I left being an employee! The booth rental/independent contractor route is WAY better tax-wise if you're buying all your own stuff anyway. One thing nobody mentioned - if your roommate gets reclassified, they should look into setting up an LLC or S-Corp eventually. Once you're making decent money (like $40k+), the tax savings can be huge. My accountant saved me about $6k last year through my S-Corp setup.
Is it complicated to set up an LLC? I'm in a similar situation (hairstylist buying all my own stuff) and thinking about going independent, but all the business formation stuff seems intimidating.
Important point nobody mentioned yet: dual-status taxpayers can't take the standard deduction and can't file jointly with a spouse. You're also restricted from claiming certain credits. If you're from Canada specifically, the US-Canada tax treaty might give you special provisions, so make sure whoever prepares your taxes understands tax treaties. This is why many people get conflicting advice - accountants who don't regularly handle nonresident or dual-status returns often miss these details. Also, each day you're physically in the US counts (including partial days!), so keep good records of border crossings. The IRS can check this against immigration records.
Do you know if there's a minimum income threshold for filing 1040NR? I was only in the US for 2 months and made about $8,300.
For nonresidents on 1040NR, you generally must file if you engaged in business in the US during the year or had any US source income where the tax wasn't fully paid through withholding. For your situation with $8,300 in US income, yes, you would need to file regardless of the amount. Unlike residents who have filing thresholds based on standard deduction amounts, nonresidents typically must file even for small amounts of US source income. The only exception would be if you earned wages under the personal services exemption threshold in a tax treaty (which varies by country), but even then you'd usually file to claim the exemption.
Just went through this exact situation as a Canadian! The key is figuring out if you're a "resident alien" or "nonresident alien" for tax purposes. If you qualify as a resident under the SPT (but remember J-1 days don't count for first 2 years), file Form 1040. If you're a nonresident the whole year, file Form 1040NR. If you're a resident for part of the year and nonresident for the other part (dual-status), it gets complicated. You'd file either: - Form 1040NR and write "Dual-Status Return" across the top, attaching a Form 1040 labeled as "Dual-Status Statement" for the resident portion of the year, OR - Form 1040 with "Dual-Status Return" written across the top, attaching a 1040NR as a statement for the nonresident portion Which one you use as the "main" form depends on your status on the last day of the tax year.
Omg this makes so much more sense now! I've been so confused about which form to use as the "main" one for dual-status. So if I was nonresident until August and then became a resident for the rest of the year, I'd use 1040 as my main form with 1040NR attached as a statement?
Yes, exactly! Since you'd be a resident on December 31 (the last day of the tax year), your "main" form would be the 1040 with "Dual-Status Return" written at the top, and you'd attach a 1040NR as a statement for the part of the year you were a nonresident (January through July). The IRS looks at your status on the last day of the tax year to determine which form serves as the "main" one. It's one of those details that even some tax preparers get wrong if they don't regularly work with international clients.
Just to add one more consideration - check if your university offers free tax assistance for students. Many schools have volunteer tax assistance programs that specialize in situations like yours. My university had a dedicated tax advisor just for international and fellowship students who helped me figure everything out without having to pay for a professional. Also, don't forget that you might be eligible for education tax credits like the Lifetime Learning Credit even while on fellowship. That can help offset some of the tax burden from your taxable fellowship income.
That's great advice - I didn't even think to check if my university offers tax help! Do you know if there are any specific deductions that fellowship recipients should look into? I've heard mixed things about whether we can deduct research expenses.
Unfortunately, deductions for research expenses are very limited for students since the 2018 tax law changes. Previously, unreimbursed employee expenses could sometimes be deducted, but that's largely gone now. However, if your research is directly related to your degree requirements, some expenses might reduce the taxable portion of your fellowship. The key is whether they count as "required educational expenses" - if your program specifically requires certain research materials or activities that aren't covered by your fellowship, those might reduce your taxable amount. But general living expenses while doing research won't qualify.
Um, isn't there a tax exemption for scholarships and fellowships? My roommate is on a full-ride scholarship and she told me she doesn't pay taxes on any of it. Super confused why some people have to pay taxes on this stuff and others don't...
Your roommate is probably only talking about the portion that covers qualified educational expenses (tuition, required fees, books). That part IS tax-free. But any scholarship or fellowship money that goes toward living expenses (room, board, travel, etc.) is taxable income according to the IRS. A lot of students don't realize this and end up with tax problems later.
Just to add a bit more clarification because I think people get confused about the tax brackets too. When you reduce your taxable income with a Traditional IRA contribution, you're saving at your MARGINAL tax rate - the highest rate you pay. Example: If you're married filing jointly with taxable income of $190k (like OP), you're in the 24% bracket for 2023. Contributing $6,000 to a Traditional IRA would save you approximately $1,440 in federal taxes (24% of $6,000). It's still a great deal since you're getting an immediate tax benefit PLUS tax-deferred growth over time. Just don't expect it to reduce your tax bill by the full contribution amount.
So if I'm in a lower tax bracket now but expect to be in a higher one when I retire, should I do Roth instead? I'm trying to figure out which type of IRA makes more sense for my situation.
That's a great question and you've hit on one of the key considerations. If you expect to be in a higher tax bracket in retirement, a Roth IRA might make more sense because you pay taxes now at your lower rate, and then withdrawals are tax-free in retirement. Conversely, if you expect to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement, a Traditional IRA might be better since you get the tax deduction now at your higher rate, then pay taxes at your lower retirement rate when you withdraw. It's also worth considering that tax laws change over time, so having some money in both types of accounts (called "tax diversification") can be a prudent strategy.
One thing nobody's mentioned - don't forget about state taxes! Your traditional IRA contribution usually reduces your state taxable income too, not just federal. So if your state tax rate is like 5%, that's additional savings on top of the federal tax reduction. I contribute the max to my traditional IRA every year for this reason - between federal and state tax savings, it's a no-brainer. Just remember that you'll eventually pay taxes when you withdraw in retirement, but hopefully at a lower rate.
Not all states treat IRA deductions the same way as the federal government though. Some states don't allow all deductions that the feds do.
Connor O'Brien
3 Another thing to consider - your son should definitely start making quarterly estimated tax payments for his self-employment income. The deadline for Q1 2025 payments is April 15th. This spreads out the tax burden throughout the year AND helps avoid underpayment penalties that the IRS can charge! For a rough estimate, he should set aside about 30% of his self-employment profit for taxes (15.3% for self-employment tax plus income tax). The IRS Form 1040-ES has worksheets to calculate this more precisely.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
ā¢17 How do you actually make these quarterly payments? I just started doing some freelance work and want to avoid a big surprise next year.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
ā¢3 You can make quarterly estimated tax payments directly on the IRS website through their Direct Pay system at irs.gov/payments. Just select "estimated tax" as the payment type. You can also mail in payments with Form 1040-ES vouchers if you prefer paper. For figuring out how much to pay, the safest approach is to pay at least 100% of your previous year's tax liability divided into four equal payments (or 110% if your income is over $150,000). This gives you "safe harbor" protection from underpayment penalties even if your income increases.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
4 Your son might also qualify for the Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction, which could reduce his taxable income by up to 20% of his net business profit. This only applies to income tax though, not self-employment tax. Make sure your tax software is calculating this - it can make a significant difference!
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
ā¢9 Does the QBI deduction apply to all self-employment or only certain types of businesses? I do graphic design freelance work.
0 coins