


Ask the community...
Don't overthink this too much. If you're making $42k as a freelancer, just file Schedule C as a sole proprietorship. Set aside about 30% for taxes (15.3% self-employment + income tax). The only reason to consider LLC is liability protection if you're worried about being sued. S-corps are only worth the hassle when you're making closer to $100k because of the extra paperwork and costs.
This makes sense but I've heard some freelancers can reduce their tax burden significantly with the right business entity. Is sole proprietorship really the most tax efficient at $42k? Wouldn't an S-corp save on self-employment taxes?
At $42k in profit, an S-corp typically won't save you money because of the additional costs involved. With an S-corp, you must pay yourself a reasonable salary (subject to both employer and employee portions of FICA taxes), file separate corporate tax returns, and potentially pay for payroll services. The tax advantage of an S-corp comes from distributing some profits as dividends that aren't subject to self-employment tax. But when your profit is around $42k, a reasonable salary would likely be most or all of that amount anyway, leaving little to nothing for the tax-advantaged distributions. Plus, you'd have several hundred dollars in additional annual costs for corporate filing fees, separate tax returns, and possibly accounting services. The math usually doesn't work out favorably until you're earning significantly more.
Important thing nobody mentioned yet: as a freelancer, you should be making QUARTERLY estimated tax payments! I learned this the hard way and got hit with penalties my first year. Since you're not having taxes withheld like with a W-2 job, the IRS expects you to pay as you earn throughout the year.
I think people are missing an important perspective here. My teenage daughter works part-time and pays taxes. When we discussed this issue, she pointed out something interesting - she WANTS to pay into the system even without being able to vote yet. She sees it as learning financial responsibility and contributing to public services she uses like schools and roads. That said, she definitely feels there should be some mechanism for youth voices to be heard in tax policy discussions. Maybe not full voting rights at 16, but perhaps some kind of youth advisory council that provides input on how tax dollars affecting youth are spent?
That's an interesting perspective, but how would a youth advisory council actually work? Would they have any real power or just be symbolic? And who would choose which teens get to serve on it?
Those are good questions. I think for it to be meaningful, the council would need some actual authority - perhaps control over a small portion of the budget earmarked for youth programs, or veto power over certain spending decisions that directly impact young people. As for selection, I would suggest a combination of approaches - some members elected by high school students, others appointed based on applications and interviews to ensure diverse representation across socioeconomic backgrounds, geographic regions, etc. Maybe even have a rotating membership with 1-2 year terms so more young people get the opportunity to participate.
Honestly this whole argument seems misguided to me. Teens under 18 are still being represented - by their parents or guardians who DO vote. Parents are supposed to consider their children's interests when voting. Same with the standard deduction thing - that's specifically designed to protect low-income earners, including most working teens. As for felons, losing voting rights is part of the punishment for serious crimes in many states. They knew the consequences of their actions. The "no taxation without representation" slogan was about having NO representation whatsoever. These groups still have representation, just not direct voting rights.
That's a really privileged perspective. Not all parents vote in their children's best interests - many vote against policies that would help their own kids based on political ideology. And regarding felons, many states now recognize that permanent disenfranchisement after serving a sentence is counterproductive to rehabilitation and reintegration. That's why so many states have restored voting rights after sentence completion.
Make sure to check if the letter has a deadline for response!! I ignored a confusing IRS letter thinking it was a mistake, and ended up with penalties because I missed the response window. Even if you're getting help or figuring out what to do, sometimes you need to send a basic response by the deadline just to buy yourself more time.
Omg thank you for mentioning this! I just checked and there IS a deadline - it says I need to respond within 30 days of the letter date (which was last week). Do you think it's enough if I just call them before the deadline or should I actually mail something back?
I'd recommend doing both if possible. Call them to understand what's happening, but also send something in writing before the deadline. You can send a simple letter stating you received their notice dated [date], you're currently reviewing it, and you've also called for clarification. Include your name, SSN, the notice number, and keep a copy of what you send along with proof of mailing (certified mail is best). This creates a paper trail showing you responded by the deadline, which protects you even if the phone call doesn't resolve everything immediately. The written response buys you time to figure everything out without risking penalties for non-response.
Is the letter asking you to pay something? If its saying you owe money make sure it's actually from the IRS. There are sooo many scams going around! Real IRS letters have a notice number, your tax ID info, and official letterhead. Scam letters usually demand immediate payment thru gift cards or wire transfers.
Great point! Also check the return address - official IRS letters come from places like Kansas City, MO; Austin, TX; or Ogden, UT. And they'll NEVER ask you to pay by bitcoin, gift cards, or wire transfer. If you're unsure, you can always call the main IRS number (not the one on the letter if you're suspicious) to verify it's legitimate.
I'm torn between FreeTaxUSA and TaxSlayer this year. Anyone try both? I have a backdoor Roth plus some crypto transactions to report.
Used both last year to compare. FreeTaxUSA was WAY better for crypto. TaxSlayer kept giving me errors when trying to report multiple coin transactions, while FreeTaxUSA handled it smoothly. Can't speak to the backdoor Roth part tho.
Has anyone else noticed that FreeTaxUSA is actually better at finding deductions than TurboTax? I switched this year and somehow got an extra $720 on my refund with the exact same info.
Yep! I found the same thing. TurboTax somehow missed that I could deduct my HSA contributions even though I entered all the same information. It was like $800 difference in my refund!
Paolo Esposito
9 For Dual Status returns specifically, I recommend creating a cover letter that explains your situation and lists all the forms you're attaching. I did this last year and my return was processed without any issues. Also, don't forget that you need to write "Dual-Status Return" across the top of your 1040 or 1040-NR (whichever you're using as your main form).
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
ā¢10 Is the cover letter something official or do you just type up a regular letter explaining things?
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
ā¢9 The cover letter isn't an official IRS form - it's just a letter you create yourself that explains your situation. I simply typed up a one-page letter stating my name, Social Security number, the dates of my residency change, and a list of all forms included in my return package. It's not required, but IRS agents have to manually review Dual Status returns, and giving them a clear roadmap of your situation helps them process your return more efficiently. In my experience, anything you can do to make the IRS agent's job easier benefits you in the long run.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
5 A quick tip most people don't know - make copies of EVERYTHING before you mail it. The IRS occasionally loses attachments, and having proof of what you sent can save you a huge headache later. I speak from painful experience after having my Dual Status return flagged for "missing documents" that I definitely included.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
ā¢4 I'd recommend sending it with tracking too. USPS certified mail or similar so you have proof they received it.
0 coins