


Ask the community...
Quick question related to this - my dad (Canadian) is thinking of investing in my small manufacturing business. I was planning to use an S-Corp but now I'm confused if that's even allowed with a foreign investor? Do I need to switch to C-Corp?
You can't have a non-US citizen/resident as an S-Corp shareholder - it's one of the strict eligibility requirements. If your Canadian father wants to invest, you'd need to switch to a C-Corporation or find another structure. The tax implications are significant, though, as C-Corps face potential double taxation (corporate tax + dividend tax) while S-Corps have pass-through taxation. It's definitely worth consulting with a tax professional to find the optimal structure.
This is a complex international tax situation that definitely requires careful planning! A few additional considerations that might be helpful: The French uncle should also be aware of French tax obligations on his US investments. France taxes worldwide income, so he'll likely need to report the US dividends and investment gains in France as well, though he may be able to claim foreign tax credits for US taxes paid. For the mixed-use LLC (business investment + personal stock investments), consider the administrative burden this creates. Having separate entities might actually save costs long-term since it simplifies record-keeping, especially if the uncle ever wants to bring in additional investors or exit one investment but not the other. Also worth exploring: if the acquisition is substantial enough, there might be advantages to structuring this as a partnership rather than having the LLC own corporate stock directly. This could provide more flexibility for profit distributions and potentially better tax treatment for both parties. Given the complexity with treaty benefits, withholding requirements, and the various reporting forms mentioned by others, I'd strongly recommend getting a consultation with someone who specializes in US-France tax matters before finalizing the structure. The upfront cost will likely save significant headaches and potential penalties down the road.
This is really helpful insight about the French tax obligations - I hadn't even considered that the uncle would need to report this income in France too! Do you happen to know if there are any specific French reporting requirements for foreign investments that we should be aware of? Also, your point about separate entities makes a lot of sense from an administrative standpoint. Would there be any downsides to having two separate LLCs versus one mixed-use LLC from a US tax perspective?
Don't overlook your state tax obligations too! When I had federal tax issues, I stupidly ignored the state taxes thinking I'd deal with them later. Big mistake - some states are actually MORE aggressive than the IRS with collections. Make sure you're addressing both federal and state tax debts at the same time. In my case, the payment plan with the state was actually harder to get than the IRS one.
That's a really good point. Which states are the worst to deal with for tax collections? I'm in California and I've heard they can be pretty ruthless.
I've been through this exact situation - owed $27k to the IRS after some freelance work got misclassified. The anxiety is absolutely brutal, but you have more options than you think. First thing: breathe. The IRS actually wants to work with you because they know they can't collect from someone who's broke or homeless. They'd rather get paid something over time than nothing at all. Here's what worked for me: I immediately called the IRS (yes, the hold times are terrible but it's worth it) and requested an installment agreement. With your income level, you'll likely qualify easily. They'll want financial statements showing your monthly income and expenses, so gather those up. The key is being proactive. If you wait for them to come after you, your options become more limited and expensive. But if you reach out first, they're usually pretty reasonable. Also, file your tax return ASAP even if you can't pay. The penalty for not filing is 5% per month vs 0.5% per month for not paying. That adds up fast. One more tip: ask about first-time penalty abatement if this is your first major tax issue. It can save you thousands in penalties. You have to specifically request it though - they won't offer it automatically. You've got this. It's scary but totally manageable with the right approach.
This is really helpful advice! I'm curious about the first-time penalty abatement - do you know if there are specific requirements to qualify for it? Like how many years back can you go, or do you need to be current on all your filings? I've heard it mentioned a few times in this thread but I'm not sure if I'd qualify since my tax issues span multiple years.
One more important thing: if you deducted any medical expenses in previous years that were later reimbursed by this settlement, you may need to report that reimbursement as income in the year you receive the settlement (called the "tax benefit rule").
Based on your breakdown, you're on the right track! The $6,500 for lost wages is definitely taxable income that you'll need to report. The medical expenses ($14,500) and pain/suffering ($8,000) portions are not taxable since they're compensating for physical injuries. For the $3,000 car repair portion, as long as it doesn't exceed what you originally paid for the car (minus any depreciation), it's typically not taxable income either - it's just making you whole for your property loss. One thing to watch out for: if you itemized deductions in previous years and deducted any of those medical expenses that are now being reimbursed by the settlement, you might need to include that reimbursed amount as income under the tax benefit rule. Also don't forget to check your state tax requirements - while federal rules are fairly clear on settlements, some states have different approaches to taxing settlement proceeds. Keep all your settlement documentation organized. The IRS likes to see clear records showing how the settlement amount was allocated between the different categories when there are questions.
This is really helpful, thank you! I'm new to dealing with settlements and taxes, so I appreciate the clear breakdown. Just to confirm - since my car was worth about $12,000 when I bought it 3 years ago, and the $3,000 repair settlement is way less than that, I shouldn't have to pay taxes on that portion either? Also, I didn't itemize deductions in previous years (always took the standard deduction), so I think I'm safe from the tax benefit rule issue you mentioned. It sounds like I really only need to worry about reporting the $6,500 lost wages portion as regular income. Is that right?
dont forget about state taxes too!! some states have different rules for reporting 1099-K income. like here in Massachusetts our threshold is still $600 even tho the federal is $20k. so you might get a state 1099-K even if you dont get a federal one. check your state tax dept website!!
This is a really good point. I live in Vermont and they also kept the $600 threshold for state reporting. It creates a weird situation where you might get a state 1099-K but not a federal one. Always good to double-check your specific state requirements.
This is such a helpful thread! I'm in a similar situation with my small craft business on multiple platforms. One thing I learned from my tax preparer is that it's really important to track ALL your business expenses throughout the year, not just when tax season comes around. Even if you're only making $740 like the original poster, you can still deduct things like materials, shipping costs, platform fees, even a portion of your internet bill if you use it for business. I use a simple spreadsheet to track everything monthly - it only takes a few minutes but it's saved me hundreds in taxes. Also, if you're using platforms like Etsy, PayPal, or Square, most of them have annual tax summary reports you can download that show all your transactions for the year. This makes it much easier when you're filling out Schedule C, especially if you don't receive a 1099-K form.
This is really great advice about tracking expenses! I'm just starting out with online selling and had no idea about deducting things like internet costs. Do you happen to know if there's a minimum amount you need to make before you can start claiming business deductions? And for the internet bill portion - how do you figure out what percentage to deduct? I work from home part-time so I use internet for both personal and business stuff.
Max Reyes
Just a heads up - I'm not a tax pro but I went thru something similar. If ur settlement included any interest (like if the discrimination happened years ago and they added interest to the settlement), that part is DEFINITELY taxable and should be reported as interest income. My settlement had like $5k in interest and I missed it initially. Had to amend my return.
0 coins
Mikayla Davison
ā¢This is a really good point. The company should break this out on your 1099 if interest was included, but sometimes they mess it up. Check your settlement agreement carefully because interest is reported differently than the main settlement amount.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
One thing to keep in mind with discrimination settlements is that the IRS has been increasingly scrutinizing these cases, especially larger amounts like yours. They're looking for proper documentation that supports the tax treatment you claim. Make sure you keep detailed records of everything - your settlement agreement, any correspondence with your attorney about the tax implications, and documentation of what portions relate to different types of damages. If the IRS ever questions your filing, you'll want to be able to show exactly how you determined what was taxable vs. non-taxable. Also, since you mentioned this was age discrimination, be aware that the EEOC has specific reporting requirements for employers on discrimination settlements. This means the IRS likely already knows about your settlement, so make sure you report it correctly rather than trying to minimize it inappropriately. Given the complexity and the amount involved, it might be worth investing in a consultation with a tax professional who specializes in settlement income. The cost of getting it right up front is usually much less than dealing with IRS problems later.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
ā¢This is excellent advice about documentation and IRS scrutiny. I'm actually dealing with my first settlement situation and hadn't thought about the fact that the IRS might already know about it through EEOC reporting. Quick question - when you mention getting a consultation with a tax professional who specializes in settlement income, how do you find someone like that? Is this a specific designation or certification I should look for? My regular CPA seems pretty uncertain about the discrimination settlement rules, so I'm thinking I need someone with more specialized knowledge. Also, do you know if there's a statute of limitations on how long the IRS can question settlement tax treatment? Just wondering how long I need to keep all this documentation.
0 coins