


Ask the community...
Hey! I'm dealing with a similar situation right now and this thread has been super helpful. I just started selling on a few different platforms and was totally overwhelmed by the tax implications. One thing I'm still confused about though - if I'm using multiple platforms (like feetfinder, OnlyFans, etc.), do I need to fill out separate T2125 forms for each one, or can I combine all the income from different platforms into one business activity? Also, for anyone who's been doing this for a while - what's the best way to track payments that come in at different times? Sometimes platforms hold payments for a week or two, so I'm not sure if I should record income when I earn it or when it actually hits my account. Don't want to mess up my record keeping from the start! Thanks for all the great advice in this thread - definitely feel more confident about handling this properly now.
Great questions! You can definitely combine all your platform income into one T2125 form - the CRA sees it all as the same self-employment business (content creation/digital services). Just make sure to keep detailed records showing which platform each payment came from in case they ever ask. For tracking payments, you should record income when you actually receive it (when it hits your account), not when you earn it. This is called "cash basis" accounting and it's what most small businesses use. So if you earn $100 on Monday but the platform doesn't pay you until the following week, record it on the day you actually get paid. This makes it much simpler to match your records with your bank statements too! I'd recommend setting up a simple spreadsheet with columns for: Date Received, Platform, Amount, and maybe a notes column. That way you have everything organized for tax time.
This is such a common question and I'm glad you're being proactive about it! I went through the exact same confusion when I started earning from similar platforms. The key thing to remember is that in Canada, ALL income must be reported regardless of the source or amount - there's no minimum threshold. Even if you only make $50, technically it should be on your tax return. The good news is that as self-employment income, you can deduct legitimate business expenses against it. Since you're in Ontario, you'll report this on your T1 return using Form T2125. Some expenses you can likely deduct include: - Portion of your internet/phone bills used for business - Any equipment purchases (camera, lighting, props, etc.) - Marketing costs if you promote yourself My advice: start tracking everything from day one. Keep a simple spreadsheet with your monthly earnings and any related expenses. Set aside about 25-30% of what you earn for taxes. And don't stress too much - once you get the hang of it, it's really not that complicated! The CRA would much rather see you reporting everything properly from the start than trying to figure it out later.
This is really solid advice! I'm just starting out with this whole side income thing and honestly was pretty intimidated by all the tax stuff. The 25-30% rule is something I hadn't heard before but makes total sense - better to have too much set aside than scramble at tax time. Quick question though - when you say "portion of internet/phone bills," how do you actually calculate that? Like if I use my phone/internet for personal stuff too (which obviously I do), how do I figure out what percentage is reasonable to claim as a business expense? Don't want to get in trouble for claiming too much but also don't want to miss out on legitimate deductions. Also super helpful to know there's no minimum threshold - I was definitely one of those people thinking small amounts might not matter. Better safe than sorry!
Don't forget about state tax issues! Depending on your state, you might have franchise tax or entity-level taxes that are affected by the change from partnership to single-member LLC. In California for example, the $800 minimum franchise tax applies differently to partnerships vs. disregarded entities. Also, if you have any registered intellectual property like trademarks or patents in the LLC's name, you'll want to document that these remain with the entity through the transition. Some states also require notification to any LLC registered agents when ownership changes by more than a certain percentage.
Thanks for mentioning state taxes - we're in Michigan. I'll check if there are any specific requirements here. We don't have registered IP yet, but we do have our domain names and some digital assets that should be documented as remaining with the LLC. Good point!
Michigan has pretty straightforward requirements for LLC ownership changes. You'll need to file an amendment to your Articles of Organization with the state if your operating agreement requires it, but many standard LLCs don't actually require this filing just for membership changes. For taxes, Michigan follows federal treatment pretty closely - your LLC will be disregarded for state tax purposes once you become the sole member, so you'll report business income on your individual Michigan return instead of filing a separate entity return. No special franchise tax issues like California. One thing specific to Michigan - if you have any state tax credits or incentives tied to the LLC (like Renaissance Zone benefits or certain business development programs), make sure those don't get affected by the ownership change. The Michigan Department of Treasury sometimes requires notification for significant ownership changes in entities receiving state benefits. Also document your digital assets and domain ownership clearly in your buyout agreement. Even though they're not "registered IP" yet, having a clear record of what stays with the LLC will save headaches later if you do end up filing for patents or trademarks on your software.
This is really helpful Michigan-specific info! I hadn't thought about the state tax credits aspect - we don't have any currently but it's good to know for future reference. Quick question - when you mention filing an amendment to Articles of Organization "if your operating agreement requires it" - how do I know if mine does? Is this something that's typically spelled out clearly in standard operating agreements, or do I need to dig through the legal language? I'm trying to avoid missing any required filings but also don't want to file unnecessary paperwork if it's not required. Also, for the domain ownership documentation - would including a simple list of domains and digital assets in the buyout agreement be sufficient, or should I transfer them formally through the registrars to show clear LLC ownership?
One additional consideration for your dual-status situation - make sure you're aware of any potential treaty benefits between the US and Canada that might affect your tax calculation. The US-Canada Tax Treaty has specific provisions for residents who change status during the year, and there might be tie-breaker rules that could impact how you're treated for certain types of income. Also, since you mentioned you were working remotely for your Canadian employer while being a US tax resident, you'll want to verify that your employer properly handled any Canadian tax withholdings during that period. Sometimes employers don't adjust withholdings when employees become non-residents for Canadian tax purposes, which could affect your foreign tax credit calculations. Have you considered whether you need to file any additional Canadian forms (like a departure tax return) since you became a non-resident of Canada? The timing of your tax residency changes in both countries can create some complex interactions that might affect your overall tax liability.
This is a really important point about the US-Canada Tax Treaty! I'm dealing with a similar situation and hadn't considered the tie-breaker rules. Do you know if there are specific provisions that would help someone in Jacob's situation where he became a US resident mid-year but continued working for a Canadian employer? I'm wondering if the treaty might provide some relief for the potential double taxation during that transition period. Also, regarding the departure tax return - I believe Canada requires a deemed disposition return when you cease to be a resident, but there might be exceptions for certain types of property or if the total value is below certain thresholds. This could definitely impact the foreign tax credit calculations if there are additional Canadian taxes owed from the departure.
Jacob, your approach looks solid, but I wanted to add a few practical tips from my own dual-status experience moving from the UK to the US: 1. **Documentation is key** - Keep detailed records of your residency determination. Since you mentioned becoming a US resident under the Green Card test, make sure you have clear documentation of when your status changed, as this will be crucial if the IRS has questions. 2. **State tax considerations** - Don't forget about state tax implications! Depending on which state you're in, you may need to file a part-year resident return there too, and some states have different rules for recognizing foreign tax credits. 3. **Estimated tax payments** - Since you had no US income in 2023 but will likely have US income in 2024, consider whether you need to make estimated tax payments for 2024. The transition year can sometimes create unexpected tax liabilities in the following year. 4. **FBAR and Form 8938** - Make sure you're also considering your reporting requirements for foreign bank accounts and assets. Even though you're focused on the income tax return, the FBAR and Form 8938 thresholds and requirements can be different for dual-status taxpayers. The foreign tax credit timing issue you mentioned is very common - I had the exact same situation with additional taxes paid the following year. Amelia's advice about claiming them on your 2024 return is spot on. Good luck with your filing! The first dual-status return is always the most challenging, but you'll have a much better understanding for future years.
According to the Treasury Department's official FAQs (https://fiscal.treasury.gov/top/faqs-for-the-public.html), unemployment benefits themselves don't create offset situations. The system works by matching your SSN against a database of debtors. If you've confirmed no matches via the phone system, you should be good. The database is updated weekly, so checking once a week until your refund arrives should give you peace of mind.
I completely understand your concern, especially dealing with financial uncertainty after a divorce. The good news is that unemployment compensation itself won't create any offset issues - it's simply taxable income that you report on your return. The Treasury Offset Program only targets specific federal debts like defaulted student loans, unpaid child support, or back taxes from previous years. Since you've already checked the offset phone line and it shows clear, you should be fine. One thing to keep in mind though - if you didn't have federal taxes withheld from your unemployment benefits, you might end up owing rather than receiving a refund, but that's a separate issue from offsets. The fact that you're being proactive about checking shows you're on top of things!
Cynthia Love
Make sure you also consider other tax benefits when planning this! My ex and I alternated claiming our daughter during college, but we didn't realize it would affect things like: 1. Filing status (head of household vs. single) 2. Earned Income Credit 3. Child Tax Credit (until age 17) 4. Higher education credits (American Opportunity Credit is worth up to $2,500) The parent NOT claiming the child in a given year should adjust their W-4 withholding at work to account for the change in tax situation that year. Also, I think one of you might be misunderstanding the savings bond education exclusion. You can only exclude the interest if the bonds are in YOUR name (not the child's) and you use them for qualified education expenses. But you also need to meet income limits, which phased out at like $98k-$128k for single filers last time I checked.
0 coins
Darren Brooks
ā¢Good points! Another thing to consider is that if one parent remarries, their household income might put them above the threshold for some education benefits, making it more beneficial for the single parent to claim the student. Also, don't forget that the American Opportunity Credit can only be claimed for 4 years, while the Lifetime Learning Credit can be used for graduate school too. So you might want to map out your strategy for all the potential years of education.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
This is such great advice from everyone! I'm going through a similar situation with my ex, and reading through all these responses has been incredibly helpful. One thing I'd add is to make sure you coordinate the timing of when you complete Form 8332 each year. We learned the hard way that if the custodial parent doesn't get the form to the non-custodial parent early enough in the tax year, it can create complications when filing. Also, I'd strongly recommend sitting down together (or communicating through email if that works better) to map out a 4-year plan before your son starts college. Figure out which parent will claim him each year, and factor in things like: - Who will be using 529 funds or savings bonds in which years - Any expected changes in income that might affect education credit eligibility - Whether either parent might remarry (affecting household income thresholds) We created a simple spreadsheet showing the projected tax benefits for each scenario over all four years, and it made the decision much clearer. Having it all planned out in advance has eliminated any confusion or arguments during tax season. One last tip - keep copies of all Form 8332s and any written agreements you make. The IRS can ask for documentation if they ever question who has the right to claim the dependent in a given year.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
ā¢This is excellent advice about planning ahead! I'm new to this situation (just getting divorced and my daughter will be starting college in two years), so I really appreciate seeing how other families have handled this. The spreadsheet idea is brilliant - I'm definitely going to suggest that to my ex when we have our discussion about this. One question though: when you say "any expected changes in income," should we also consider things like potential job changes or retirement? My ex is planning to retire in about 3 years, which would significantly drop her income and might change which education credits would be most beneficial for each of us. Also, does anyone know if there are any restrictions on how many years in advance you can complete Form 8332? Like, could we potentially do all four forms now to avoid any future disagreements, or does it need to be done year by year?
0 coins