


Ask the community...
Has anyone tried just keeping 2 sets of books? Like one for taxes with max write-offs and another one showing your actual profit for lenders? Not talking about anything illegal just different ways of presenting the same info.
That's actually a common practice. Not "2 sets of books" in the shady way, but having your tax returns optimized for tax purposes and then separate financial statements that show your true business performance. Most accounting software can generate different reports for different purposes from the same data.
This is such a great question and honestly one that trips up a lot of LLC owners! I went through this same struggle when I was trying to get financing for equipment last year. The key thing I learned is that you DON'T have to choose between tax savings and loan approval - you just need to present your financials correctly. Most business lenders are actually pretty sophisticated about this stuff. They know that smart business owners take legitimate deductions. What really helped me was preparing a simple one-page summary alongside my tax returns that showed: - My net income from Schedule C (the taxed amount) - Add-backs for depreciation, home office, mileage, etc. - My "adjusted income" for lending purposes I also kept clean P&L statements in QuickBooks that showed my actual business cash flow before tax strategies. When I brought both documents to my lender, they immediately understood what they were looking at and had no issues with the loan approval. The bottom line is: take your legitimate tax deductions AND get your loans. You just need to tell the story properly to lenders who understand business finances.
This is really helpful! I'm in a similar situation and have been stressing about this exact issue. Quick question - when you say "adjusted income for lending purposes," did you use any specific terminology or format that lenders expect? I want to make sure I'm presenting this the right way and not just making up my own categories that might confuse them. Also, how detailed did you get with the add-backs? Like did you break down every single deduction or just group the major ones?
I made the switch from a big bank to a credit union about two years ago and it was one of the best financial decisions I've made. While I didn't go with AA FCU specifically (I joined a local teacher's credit union), the experience has been night and day compared to dealing with Wells Fargo. The biggest difference for me has been the personal service - when I call, I talk to actual humans who seem to care about helping rather than just trying to upsell me on products I don't need. My loan rates have been significantly better too. Got my auto loan at 3.2% when the bank was quoting me over 5%. One thing to consider is that credit unions often have reciprocal agreements with each other, so even if AA FCU doesn't have a branch exactly where you need it, you might still be able to do banking at other credit union locations. Definitely worth looking into their shared branching network. Good luck with whatever you decide! Getting away from those monthly fees alone will probably save you hundreds per year.
That's really encouraging to hear! The personal service aspect is exactly what I'm hoping to find. My current bank feels like they just see me as an account number. Can you tell me more about the shared branching network? I travel occasionally for work and it would be great to know I can still do banking in other cities if needed. Also, 3.2% on an auto loan sounds amazing compared to what I've been seeing lately. Did you have to have a long relationship with your credit union to get that rate, or was that available as a new member?
I've been with American Airlines FCU for about 2 years now and can definitely echo what others have said about the customer service being excellent. What really sold me was their relationship with the Co-op shared branching network that someone mentioned - you can actually do most banking transactions at over 5,000 credit union locations nationwide, not just ATMs. This has been super helpful when I'm traveling for work. Regarding membership eligibility, I'd definitely call them directly to verify since the contractor relationship can be tricky. When I applied, they were pretty thorough about verifying employment but the process was straightforward once they confirmed I qualified. One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is their financial counseling services - they offer free consultations if you're looking to improve your overall financial picture, which has been really helpful for budgeting and planning major purchases. It's a nice perk that most traditional banks don't offer without trying to sell you investment products. The mobile deposit limits are reasonable (I think it's $2,500 per day for new members, higher once you're established), and I've never had issues with deposits being held longer than necessary like I experienced with my previous bank.
Thanks for mentioning the financial counseling services - that's something I hadn't considered but sounds really valuable! As someone who's been pretty frustrated with big bank fees and service, the idea of getting actual financial guidance instead of constant sales pitches is really appealing. Quick question about the mobile deposit limits - do those limits increase pretty quickly once you establish a relationship with them, or is it a gradual process? I do freelance work on the side sometimes and occasionally get larger checks that I need to deposit, so the daily limits could be important for me. Also really interested to hear more about how the shared branching network works in practice. When you go to another credit union location, can you do everything you'd normally do at an AA FCU branch, or are there limitations on certain transactions?
Has anyone used FreeTaxUSA for a part-year state return? I'm in a similar situation (moved from Illinois to Georgia) and TurboTax wants to charge me extra for the state return. Wondering if the cheaper option can handle this type of filing.
I used FreeTaxUSA for my move from Michigan to Tennessee last year and it handled the part-year residency return just fine. Their interface for state returns isn't as polished as TurboTax, but it walks you through all the necessary questions about residency dates and income allocation. Saved me like $70 compared to TurboTax and got the same refund amount.
I went through this exact same situation two years ago when I moved from California to Florida in August. Here's what I learned that might help you: For California, you'll definitely need to file Form 540NR (part-year resident). The good news is you only owe California tax on income earned while you were a CA resident AND any California-source income after you moved (which sounds like none in your case). The tricky part is determining your exact residency change date. California considers you a resident until you permanently leave with no intent to return. Document everything - your lease start date in Texas, when you got your Texas driver's license, voter registration, etc. Use the earliest defensible date as your residency change. For the $38k you earned in California and the ~3 weeks of remote work for your CA employer after moving, that remote work income should NOT be taxable to California since you were physically in Texas when you earned it. California can be aggressive, but they generally can't tax income for work performed outside the state by non-residents. Keep detailed records of your move timeline - California loves to audit people who move to no-tax states. I got audited and having documentation of my permanent move saved me from owing additional taxes. The audit was resolved in my favor, but it was stressful. One last tip: if you're still confused after reading the forms, consider getting help from a tax pro who specializes in multi-state returns. It's worth the cost to avoid mistakes with California.
Something nobody's mentioned yet - if you're teaching regular classes, you might actually have BOTH self-employment income (the nanny work) AND employee income (the teaching) depending on how the community center classifies you. Check if they're giving you a W-2 or 1099. This matters because you calculate self-employment tax only on the self-employment portion. If you're getting a W-2 for teaching, they're already withholding Social Security and Medicare taxes for that portion of your income.
This is such a good point! I was in a similar situation last year teaching at two different places - one gave me a W-2 and one gave me a 1099-NEC. Confused the heck out of me when filing. The 1099 income went on Schedule C where I could deduct expenses, but the W-2 income had different rules entirely.
Great question about LLC vs sole proprietor! As someone who's been running a small tutoring business for 3 years, I can share what I've learned. From a tax perspective, a single-member LLC doesn't give you any additional deductions compared to sole proprietorship - you'll still file Schedule C either way. The real benefit of an LLC is liability protection, which might be worth considering since you're working with children and driving them around. If there's ever an accident or incident, an LLC can help protect your personal assets. For your vehicle expenses with that much business use, definitely keep detailed mileage logs. I use a simple notebook in my car and jot down the odometer reading, destination, and purpose for every business trip. The standard mileage rate is usually easier than tracking actual expenses, but run both calculations to see which gives you a bigger deduction. One thing I wish someone had told me earlier - make sure you're setting aside 25-30% of your self-employment income for taxes, including self-employment tax. It hits harder than expected if you're not prepared!
This is really solid advice! I'm just starting out with my own childcare services and the liability protection aspect of an LLC is something I hadn't fully considered. When you mention setting aside 25-30% for taxes, do you do that with every payment you receive, or do you calculate it quarterly? I'm trying to figure out the best system to avoid getting hit with a huge tax bill at the end of the year.
Sergio Neal
Does anyone know if we're supposed to include copies of our I-20 or passport with Form 8843? My DSO gave me conflicting info on this.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
β’You don't need to include copies of your I-20 or passport with Form 8843. Just the completed form is sufficient. The form itself asks for information from those documents (like visa type and date of entry), but you don't need to send the actual documents.
0 coins
Rudy Cenizo
As someone who went through this exact same confusion a few years ago, I completely understand your stress! Let me add a few practical tips that might help: First, don't panic about the previous years - the IRS is generally understanding about Form 8843 filing delays when there's no tax owed. I filed mine for 3 previous years all at once and never heard anything back from them. For your current situation, since you mentioned you don't have any US income, you'll only need Form 8843 (not Form 1040NR). Make sure to check the "student" box in Part II and fill out the dates you were present in the US during the tax year. One thing that caught me off guard - if you traveled outside the US during the year (even briefly), you need to list those departure and return dates. Keep your passport handy when filling out the form. Also, since you mentioned visa status concerns - filing Form 8843 actually helps protect your status by formally documenting that you're claiming the student exemption from the substantial presence test. It's better to file late than never! The Austin, TX address mentioned earlier is correct for mailing. I'd definitely recommend certified mail with tracking so you have proof it was sent and received.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
β’This is such helpful advice, thank you! I'm actually in a similar boat - been here 2 years on F-1 and just learned about Form 8843. One question about the travel dates - do I need to list every single trip, even weekend trips to nearby countries? I've been to Canada a few times to visit friends, and I'm worried about listing dozens of short trips. Also, what if I can't remember the exact dates from my first year? My passport stamps aren't always super clear.
0 coins