I went through this exact same nightmare last year! My tax preparer claimed she filed my extension but the IRS had no record of it. Here's what worked for me: 1. **Get everything in writing from your preparer** - Ask for a detailed timeline of when she claims to have filed, what confirmation she received, and any reference numbers. That screenshot might be helpful even if you doubt it. 2. **Request your IRS transcript immediately** - File Form 4506-T or get it online through IRS.gov. This will show exactly what the IRS has on file for you and can definitively prove whether an extension was filed or not. 3. **For Form 843, focus on reasonable cause** - In Part II, emphasize that you hired a licensed professional specifically to handle this filing requirement and reasonably relied on their expertise. Include copies of your contract/agreement showing you paid them to file the extension. 4. **Document your good faith effort** - Include evidence that you provided all necessary information to your preparer well before the deadline and that filing the extension was explicitly part of their service. The IRS is generally sympathetic when taxpayers can show they made good faith efforts to comply by hiring professionals. Just make sure your Form 843 tells a clear story of reasonable reliance on professional advice. Also, definitely pursue getting reimbursed by your preparer - most carry professional liability insurance for exactly these situations!

I'm so sorry you're dealing with this - tax preparer mistakes are incredibly frustrating! I went through something similar a few years ago and learned some hard lessons. One thing I'd add to the excellent advice already given: when you're preparing your Form 843, make sure to include a timeline of events in your reasonable cause explanation. Show exactly when you hired the preparer, when you provided all necessary documents, when the extension was supposed to be filed, and when you first discovered the problem. The IRS likes to see that you acted promptly once you became aware of the issue. Since you just found out about this last week, make sure to emphasize that you're filing the abatement request immediately upon discovering the problem. Also, if your preparer is enrolled with the IRS (has a PTIN number), you can look up their credentials on the IRS directory. This can be useful documentation to include showing that you reasonably relied on a properly credentialed professional. One last tip - if your Form 843 gets denied initially, don't give up! You can request a supervisory review or file an appeal. Sometimes it just takes getting in front of the right person who understands the situation better. Good luck with this mess - I hope you get it resolved quickly!

I just wanted to add another perspective since I've helped several international students through this exact situation. The most important thing to remember is that your tax filing status (resident vs nonresident alien) is determined by IRS rules, not by what forms your university issues you. Since you've been in the US since 2018 and meet the substantial presence test, you're absolutely correct to file as a resident alien using Form 1040. The 1042S is essentially just a reporting document showing income and withholding - think of it like a W-2 that was issued incorrectly. One tip that might help: when you enter the fellowship income in FreeTaxUSA, you can add a brief description like "Fellowship income reported on 1042S" so it's clear where the number came from. This can help if there are any questions later. Also, don't forget that you might be eligible for education credits (American Opportunity Credit or Lifetime Learning Credit) based on your qualified tuition payments, which could further increase your refund. Many students in your situation miss out on these credits because they get overwhelmed dealing with the 1042S issue. The bottom line is that you should get back most of that incorrectly withheld money - universities typically withhold at 30% for nonresidents when you should probably be paying closer to 12-22% as a resident, depending on your total income.

I went through this exact situation two years ago when my university incorrectly classified me as a nonresident and issued a 1042S for my research stipend. Here's what worked for me: First, you're absolutely right to file Form 1040 as a resident alien - your tax status is determined by IRS rules (substantial presence test), not what forms your university issues. In FreeTaxUSA, I reported the fellowship income from Box 2 of the 1042S as "Other Income" on Schedule 1, Line 8i. I wrote "Fellowship income per 1042S" in the description field. For the withholding from Box 7, I entered it under "Other Federal Income Tax Withheld" in the payments section. The key thing that helped me was being very clear in the software that I was filing as a resident - I made sure to answer "No" to all questions about being a nonresident alien, even though I had a 1042S form. I was able to e-file successfully and got my refund in about 3 weeks. The IRS didn't question the mixed forms at all. I ended up getting back about $1,800 of the $2,200 they had incorrectly withheld at the 30% nonresident rate. Also, don't forget to check if you're eligible for education credits based on your tuition payments - that was an additional $2,000 credit I almost missed! Keep your documentation from the university acknowledging their error, but honestly, the IRS sees this mistake from universities pretty regularly and handles it smoothly.

Just wait for your regular refund date and skip all this advance nonsense. The IRS is actually pretty fast these days if you file electronically and use direct deposit.

I actually went through this exact situation last month. Yes, you definitely need to open a Credit Karma Money account - there's no way around it anymore since Intuit owns both companies. The good news is the account is completely free with no fees or minimum balance. The advance amount depends on your refund size but it's usually a decent chunk. Just be aware that once you get the advance, you're locked into keeping that account open until your full refund processes, otherwise they can hit you with penalties. Overall it worked fine for me but definitely feels like they're forcing you into their ecosystem.

Keep that Credit Karma account closure documentation just in case you need it later. Sometimes these things come back to haunt you

Had this exact same situation happen to me two years ago with TurboTax and Chime. The IRS check definitely comes straight to you - they don't coordinate with the tax prep companies for refund advance repayments. Just make sure you keep enough to pay back the advance when TurboTax comes calling for it (usually within a few weeks). The advance and your actual refund are totally separate transactions in the IRS system.

I went through this exact situation last month and can confirm what others have said - Credit Karma is absolutely mandatory for TurboTax's refund advance. There's no workaround. However, I want to add a few things that might help: The good news: Credit Karma Money accounts are actually free with no monthly fees or minimum balance requirements. The transfer to your regular bank is also free and typically takes 1-2 business days. The not-so-good news: You'll need to provide additional verification documents beyond your tax info, and the approval isn't guaranteed even if you have a large expected refund. One tip: If you do go this route, make sure to turn off all marketing communications in your Credit Karma settings immediately after approval. Otherwise you'll get bombarded with credit card offers and loan promotions. Alternative suggestion: If you're mainly concerned about cash flow timing, consider filing your return as early as possible (the IRS started accepting returns in late January). With direct deposit, most people get their refund within 21 days, which might not be much longer than dealing with the advance process anyway.

I've been researching this exact question for weeks! Based on my experience and what I've learned from TurboTax customer service, here's the reality: Credit Karma is 100% required - no exceptions, no alternatives. They have an exclusive partnership that routes ALL advance deposits through Credit Karma Money accounts. However, here are some practical considerations that might help with your decision: **The process is actually streamlined:** Opening the Credit Karma account takes about 5 minutes during the TurboTax advance application. They pre-populate most of your info, so it's not as cumbersome as opening a regular bank account. **Transfer options:** Once the advance hits your Credit Karma account, you can immediately transfer it to your existing bank via ACH (free, takes 1-2 days) or use their instant transfer feature for a small fee if you need it same-day. **Timeline reality check:** The advance approval and deposit usually happens within 24 hours, but then you still need transfer time to your main bank. Compare this to filing early and getting your full refund via direct deposit in 2-3 weeks - the time difference might not be as significant as you think. **Bottom line:** If cash flow timing is critical and you're comfortable with the Credit Karma requirement, it works. But if you're just trying to get money a week or two earlier, you might want to just file early and wait for the IRS direct deposit instead.