
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Just verified my identity through ID.me and wondering what to expect. Anyone know how long it usually takes for transcripts and Where's My Refund to show updated info after verification? Getting antsy about my refund and would love to hear others timelines.
I'm looking at an investment opportunity in a real estate LLC that generates tax losses through property purchases and donations (basically tax equity deals). The structure seems pretty advantageous - if I invest $100K, I could potentially save around $130K in taxes by offsetting my income with these pass-through losses. I understand there's a 30% of AGI limitation for real estate donation deductions, but I'm confused about how this works when I have both regular income and capital gains in the same year. In 2024, I'm expecting significant capital gains alongside my normal W2 income. Let me use a simplified example to explain my question (ignoring marginal rate complexities): - If I only have W2 income: $750K W2 income with a 30% tax rate = $225K tax - With a $250K LLC loss, my taxable income drops to $500K, and my tax goes down to $150K But what happens when I add capital gains? - $750K W2 income at 30% = $225K tax - $400K capital gains at 20% = $80K tax - Total AGI: $1.15M with $305K tax With my AGI at $1.15M, my 30% loss capacity would be around $345K. But my question is: what does this LLC pass-through loss offset first? Does it reduce my W2 income or my capital gains? Or do I not even get the increased capacity based on my total AGI? The tax savings obviously needs to account for the initial investment, but I'm trying to understand the mechanics of how these losses are applied first. Any insights?
Just a heads up - there are additional complications with these real estate donation structures that aren't immediately obvious. I invested in one last year and found out afterward that there are strict "at-risk" and "basis" limitations that might restrict how much of these losses you can actually use. In my case, I could only deduct losses up to my actual economic investment (my "basis"), which was less than the paper losses the LLC generated. Also, the IRS has been scrutinizing these deals more closely lately, especially if the appraisals for the donated properties seem inflated. Make sure the LLC has strong supporting documentation for their valuations.
That's a great point about the basis limitations - I hadn't considered that. Does your basis include just your cash investment, or also your share of any LLC debt? And did you encounter any issues with step transaction doctrine challenges from the IRS?
Your basis includes both your cash investment and your share of qualified LLC debt, which can increase your deduction potential. However, for "at risk" purposes, only recourse debt (where you have personal liability) counts, not non-recourse debt. This is an important distinction that my tax advisor initially missed. I didn't face step transaction doctrine challenges, but the LLC sponsor had specifically structured the timing of the transactions to avoid this issue. The real estate purchases and subsequent donations were separated by legitimate business activities and appropriate time periods. The IRS is definitely looking for "predetermined" transaction sequences where the outcome is essentially guaranteed. If your LLC investment has a track record of previous deals and can show that not all properties end up being donated, that helps establish legitimate business purpose beyond just tax benefits.
Question for anyone who understands Form 8582 - If I've invested in this LLC that generates passive losses through real estate, do I need to fill out the entire Passive Activity Loss Limitations form even if I'm under the 30% AGI limitation for the charitable contribution portion? I'm worried about triggering unnecessary IRS scrutiny with my return.
Thanks for clarifying! So I need to handle both limitations separately - first determine how much of the passive loss I can take via Form 8582, and then apply the 30% AGI limitation to the charitable portion. That makes sense, though it's more complex than my accountant initially explained. Is there a specific order of operations for how these forms should be completed on my tax return? I'm assuming I need to complete Form 8582 first to determine my allowable passive losses before I can properly complete Schedule A for the charitable contributions?
Exactly right - you need to complete Form 8582 first to establish your allowable passive activity losses, then use those results when completing Schedule A for the charitable deduction portion. The order matters because the passive loss limitations can restrict how much of the total loss flows through to your personal return. Here's the sequence: Form 8582 determines your current year allowable passive losses (with any excess carried forward). Then on Schedule A, you apply the 30% AGI limitation to whatever charitable contribution amounts made it through the passive loss filter. One thing to watch out for - if part of your LLC losses get suspended due to passive activity rules, those suspended losses don't disappear. They carry forward and can be used in future years when you have passive income or when you dispose of the investment. This is actually a common outcome with these real estate tax equity deals, so don't be surprised if you can't use the full loss amount in year one.
So here's the situation - my husband and I are trying to figure out our tax situation for this upcoming filing. We just had our first child last year and I left my job to be a full-time mom. Since I haven't earned any income at all this year, my husband is wondering if he should be claiming me as a dependent on his taxes. He's also suggesting we might be better off filing separately rather than jointly like we've always done in the past. I always thought married couples should file jointly for the best tax benefits, especially now with a child, but I honestly don't know much about tax rules. Can a spouse actually be claimed as a dependent? And does filing separately make any sense in our situation with me being a stay at home parent now?
Congrats on the baby! Just a practical tip - don't forget you also qualify for the Child and Dependent Care Credit if you pay for childcare while you're looking for work, even if you're not currently employed. A lot of stay at home parents miss this. The credit can be up to $2,400 for one child.
Kennedy, you're absolutely right to question your husband's suggestion! As others have confirmed, spouses cannot be claimed as dependents regardless of income. The IRS explicitly excludes spouses from dependent status. Given your situation - new baby, single income household - filing jointly is almost certainly your best option. You'll get the higher standard deduction ($29,200 vs $14,600 each if filing separately), full Child Tax Credit eligibility, and access to other family-related credits that are reduced or eliminated when filing separately. The only scenarios where married filing separately might make sense are very specific situations like income-based student loan repayment plans or certain medical expense deductions. For most families with one income and children, joint filing saves thousands of dollars. Since you mentioned being uncertain about tax rules, you might want to run the numbers both ways or use a tax analysis tool to confirm the difference. But I'd be very surprised if filing separately benefited your situation at all.
Has anyone filed with Liberty Tax this year? I'm so frustrated and confused right now! π« I filed and got the refund advance, which was helpful, but I'm having issues tracking my actual refund. I usually file with Turbo Tax or Jackson Hewitt and can easily check my status through Republic Bank's portal. I tried checking because my state refund was already sent, and I know the fees will come out first, but I can't get logged in at all! I've tried entering the full amount of my federal AND state refund combined. Then I tried with just my federal amount. Both times it's saying "invalid" and I'm getting really worried about where my money is. Anyone else experiencing this?
This happens every year with these refund transfer products. I've seen this pattern repeat itself across multiple tax preparation companies. Back in 2022, I had a similar issue with Jackson Hewitt, and before that with H&R Block. These bank products add an extra layer of complexity that often causes confusion. Your refund is likely fine - it's just the tracking system that's problematic. Here's what I've learned works best: 1. Contact Liberty Tax directly - Republic Bank customer service often can't help with Liberty-specific issues 2. Check your IRS transcript directly if possible 3. Wait 24-48 hours after seeing your state refund before panicking about federal 4. Remember that the advance is separate from your actual refund processing
I had this EXACT problem with Liberty last year. Turns out they had my email address wrong by one character, so I never got any of the status update emails. When I finally got through to someone, they told me my refund had been processed weeks earlier and the remaining balance (after fees and my advance) had been direct deposited. Check your bank statements going back a few weeks!
I'm dealing with the exact same Republic Bank login nightmare right now! Filed with Liberty Tax for the first time this year and regretting it. Their portal is absolutely terrible compared to what I'm used to with other services. I've tried every combination of amounts - full refund, refund minus fees, just federal, just state - nothing works. What's really frustrating is that I can see my state refund already hit my account, so I know the IRS processed everything, but I have no idea what's happening with the federal portion. Has anyone had success reaching an actual human at Liberty Tax who could explain their specific Republic Bank login requirements? I'm about ready to just wait it out and hope the money shows up, but not knowing is driving me crazy!
I'm having trouble accessing my IRS online account and I'm not sure what to do. I tried contacting them, but they couldn't help me directly with account access. They referred me back to ID.me, but ID.me doesn't offer phone support. I've been trying email support, but it's not really helping me get back into my account. Has anyone else dealt with this? Any suggestions on how to regain access?
I went through this exact same situation about 6 months ago and it was absolutely maddening! What finally worked for me was actually calling the IRS Practitioner Priority Service line (855-562-5227) early in the morning around 7 AM. Even though it's technically for tax professionals, they were able to help me reset my account access. The key was being super persistent and explaining that I couldn't file my taxes because of the account lockout. They transferred me to someone who could manually verify my identity over the phone using information from my previous tax returns. It took about 45 minutes total, but I was back in my account the same day. Worth trying before you go through the whole ID.me verification process again!
Wow, that's amazing that you got through! I've been trying the regular IRS number for weeks with no luck. Quick question - when you called the Practitioner Priority line, did they ask you to prove you were a tax professional or did they just help you directly? I'm worried they might turn me away since I'm not actually a practitioner. Also, do you remember what specific information from your tax returns they used to verify your identity? Want to make sure I have everything ready before I try calling. Thanks so much for this tip!
I'm going through the exact same nightmare right now! Been locked out for 2 weeks and it's so frustrating. The ID.me system is such a pain - I've submitted my documents three times and keep getting generic email responses that don't actually solve anything. Has anyone had luck with the IRS Taxpayer Advocate Service that someone mentioned earlier? I'm getting desperate at this point and wondering if I should just try calling them directly instead of dealing with ID.me. This whole system feels broken! π€
Nia Davis
I veryfied last Tuesday and my transcripts updated this morning! Got my DDD for next week lessgooo
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Authoromg giving me hope!! π
0 coins
Miguel HernΓ‘ndez
Congrats to everyone getting their updates! For those still waiting, don't lose hope. The ID.me verification is just one step - sometimes there are other review processes happening behind the scenes that can add time. I verified 3 weeks ago and just got my transcript update yesterday. Hang in there! πͺ
0 coins