
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Hey everyone, I'm trying to verify my Michigan state refund online but keep running into problems. The verification site gives me an error message every time I try to access it. Is there another way to complete the verification process? Or am I possibly using the wrong website? Any advice would be really helpful - we can figure this out together!
I've been with my current employer for over 9 years now, and I keep noticing this weird pattern that's confusing me. Every single year, my W2 shows approximately $5,000 more in income than what my final December paycheck shows as Year-To-Date earnings. I could understand if there was a small difference - maybe a week's worth of pay that gets processed in January but counts for December - but $5,000 seems like a lot! This has happened consistently for several years now. I know my company covers a portion of my health insurance premiums (though I pay some too), and they match 3% on my ROTH 401k contributions. Could these benefits somehow be showing up on my W2 but not on my regular paystubs? My paystub does itemize everything, but I'm wondering if I'm missing something in how to read it correctly. Has anyone else experienced this kind of discrepancy? Is this normal or should I be concerned?
Has anyone else noticed that companies are increasingly adding these "hidden" benefits that you don't really see until tax time? My company does the same thing - they advertise a salary but then there's all this "total compensation" stuff they add on. I'd rather just have the cash tbh.
This is such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with something similar where my W2 shows about $3,200 more than my final paycheck YTD. Reading through everyone's experiences, it sounds like the most common culprits are employer-paid benefits that show up as taxable income on the W2 but aren't reflected in regular paycheck totals. @Diego - glad you found the Box 12 codes explanation helpful! That's exactly where I need to look on mine. I think my company provides life insurance and some wellness benefits that I never really thought about as "income" but apparently the IRS does. One thing I'm curious about - do these discrepancies ever indicate actual payroll errors, or is it pretty much always just these fringe benefit reporting differences? I want to make sure I'm not missing something that could affect my tax filing.
I'm helping a buddy file his overdue 2022 taxes (he got an extension) using FreeTaxUSA, and we're stuck on how to handle his backdoor Roth situation. Here's what happened: * April 19, 2022: He put $16,000 into his Traditional IRA account at Vanguard. He swears he started the transaction on the 18th, and Vanguard customer service confirmed it was processed correctly. The funds settled on the 19th. * April 20, 2022: He converted the entire Traditional IRA ($16,000) to his Roth IRA and bought some investments. * April 29, 2022: His former accountant filed his taxes, but looking at his 1040 copy, there's zero mention of the backdoor Roth conversion anywhere. Now he's ditching his accountant and using FreeTaxUSA instead (all his income is just W2 anyway). But we're completely lost on how to fix this situation. Did the accountant mess up? Is this going to be a problem? And most importantly - how do we enter this correctly in FreeTaxUSA now? Any help would be seriously appreciated!
Just wanted to add some specific FreeTaxUSA navigation tips for your backdoor Roth situation: 1. Go to the Deductions & Credits menu 2. Select "Retirement/IRA" 3. When asked about Traditional IRA contributions, select "Yes" 4. Enter the $16,000 contribution amount 5. Indicate it was a non-deductible contribution 6. Later in the section, it will ask about conversions to a Roth 7. Enter the conversion amount and date The software should then generate Form 8606 correctly. HOWEVER - for the excess contribution (anything over $6,000), you'll need to also report that. Look for the section about "Excess Contributions" and follow those prompts too. I did this exact process last year and it worked perfectly. The key is making sure to indicate the contribution was non-deductible.
Thanks for this! Would there be a separate section for reporting the excess contribution, or is it handled automatically when I enter $16,000 as the contribution amount? I'm worried about FreeTaxUSA not flagging this as an issue.
The software should alert you when you enter $16,000 since it exceeds the annual limit, but don't count on it catching everything automatically. Look specifically for a section about "Excess Contributions" after you complete the basic IRA information. If you don't see it immediately, try searching for "excess" in the software's search function. You'll need to indicate whether the excess amount was withdrawn before the tax filing deadline (with extension). If it wasn't withdrawn, the 6% penalty applies and will need to be calculated. FreeTaxUSA should handle this calculation, but make sure it appears on Form 5329 in your final review.
Your friend is in the middle of what's called a "backdoor Roth IRA" which is completely legal but needs specific reporting. The issue isn't just that the previous accountant missed it - the $16,000 amount is a red flag. The IRA contribution limit for 2022 was only $6,000 (or $7,000 for those 50+). Unless your friend was contributing for both 2021 and 2022 in that single transaction (which would be unusual timing in April), he's looking at an excess contribution situation.
When you say backdoor Roth is "completely legal," isn't there some controversy about this? I keep reading conflicting things about whether the IRS frowns on it or not. Some article mentioned a "step transaction doctrine" that could potentially make these invalid.
The backdoor Roth is indeed legal and widely used, despite some confusion about this. The IRS has never challenged backdoor Roth conversions when done properly, and it's been a standard strategy for high-income earners who exceed Roth IRA income limits for over a decade. The "step transaction doctrine" you mentioned is a theoretical concern that tax attorneys sometimes discuss, but in practice, the IRS has consistently allowed these conversions. The key is proper documentation and timing - you make a non-deductible Traditional IRA contribution, then convert it to a Roth. As long as you report everything correctly on Form 8606, you're following established tax law. The real issue here isn't the legality of the backdoor Roth - it's that $16,000 contribution amount which creates an excess contribution problem that needs to be addressed.
Hey everyone, I just got this letter 4883C from the IRS and they want me to verify my identity and tax return. Has anyone dealt with this before? What should I expect when I call them? I'm kinda nervous about the whole thing.
Is it bad that I'm kinda relieved to see I'm not the only one dealing with this? Misery loves company I guess ๐คทโโ๏ธ
Just went through this myself a few weeks ago! Don't stress too much @752ce4ac1090 - it's really not as scary as it seems. The whole process took about 45 minutes on the phone. They asked me basic stuff like my SSN, filing status, previous year's AGI, and a few personal questions like old addresses. The agent was actually pretty nice and walked me through everything step by step. Once it's done, they'll tell you if your return can be processed or if there's anything else you need to do. You got this! ๐
SBTPG has my refund. They won't release until 2/26. I've called twice. No exceptions. Just sharing for others in same boat. Nothing we can do. Have to wait. At least I have a date now.
I've been through this SBTPG nightmare three years running. Last year they held my refund for 7 days after receiving it from the IRS. The year before that, it was 5 days. This year I wised up and just paid my preparation fees upfront. My refund came direct from IRS to my bank account in 13 days total. No more SBTPG for me ever again!
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! SBTPG told me they received my refund on 2/20 and won't release it until 2/26. It's so frustrating because I can see on my IRS transcript that they already sent the money, but now I'm stuck waiting another 6 days. At least we both have concrete dates - I was reading about people who don't even know when their funds will be released. Still doesn't make the wait any easier when you're expecting that money for bills and expenses.
Haley Bennett
Be careful with how many times you attempt verification! My cousin kept trying over and over with the Michigan site, and after his 10th attempt, his account got locked for 48 hrs due to "suspicious activity." Then he had to call to get it unlocked which was another whole nightmare. MI Treasury told him they've been having probs w/ their verification system since they upgraded in Jan. Might be worth waiting a day before trying again if you've already made multiple attempts today. Just FYI so you don't end up in verification limbo like he did.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
I've been dealing with this exact same Michigan verification nightmare for the past week! After reading through everyone's experiences here, I tried the early morning approach (around 6:30 AM) and it finally worked. The site seems way more stable before regular business hours. Also want to echo what others said about using different browsers - Safari on my Mac kept timing out, but switching to Edge did the trick. One thing I noticed that hasn't been mentioned yet: make sure you're entering your SSN exactly as it appears on your return (with or without dashes - the system is picky about formatting). Hope this helps someone avoid the frustration I went through!
0 coins