


Ask the community...
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet - if you do get the retroactive S-Corp election approved, make sure your CPA prepares a reasonable compensation study to justify whatever salary you're setting for yourself. The IRS really scrutinizes S-Corps because they know owners try to minimize salary (which is subject to employment taxes) in favor of distributions. Have you actually calculated how much you might save by switching to S-Corp status for 2022? It's mainly the Medicare and Social Security tax savings on the distribution portion, but you need to weigh that against the additional complexity and compliance costs.
What exactly is a "reasonable compensation study"? Is this something any CPA can do or do you need a specialist?
A reasonable compensation study is essentially documentation that supports the salary you've set for yourself as an S-Corp owner. It doesn't have to be a formal study done by a third party (though those exist), but should include evidence showing your salary is appropriate based on factors like: - Industry salary surveys for similar positions - Your qualifications, experience and time committed to the business - Geographic location salary data - The size and complexity of your business - Compensation for non-owner employees performing similar work - What competitors pay for similar roles Most CPAs who work regularly with small businesses and S-Corps can help put this together. The key is having it prepared before the IRS asks for it. If you're retroactively becoming an S-Corp and the IRS reviews your election, having this documentation ready shows you're making a good faith effort to comply with the "reasonable compensation" requirement.
I went through a very similar situation about two years ago and successfully did the retroactive S-Corp election. A few things I learned that might help: First, yes, Rev. Proc. 2013-30 is absolutely legitimate, but timing is crucial. You have 3 years and 75 days from the original due date you wanted the election to be effective. So for 2022, you'd need to act soon. Second, the "reasonable cause" statement is critical. I used the fact that my previous tax preparer never mentioned S-Corp elections as an option despite my business income level. The IRS accepted this reasoning. Document everything - emails, conversations, even the lack of discussion about entity elections. Third, calculate the potential savings first before diving in. In my case, I saved about $18k in self-employment taxes, but I also had to establish a reasonable salary (I used about 60% of net income based on industry data) and file amended returns for multiple years. The process took about 6-8 months total to get fully resolved, but it was absolutely worth it. Make sure your new CPA has experience with late S-Corp elections - not all tax professionals are familiar with the process. Good luck!
This is really helpful, thank you! I'm curious about the 60% salary figure you mentioned - how did you arrive at that percentage? I've been researching and seeing conflicting advice about what constitutes "reasonable compensation." Some sources say 40-60% of net income, others suggest looking at what you'd pay someone else to do your job. Did the IRS question your salary determination at all during the process, or did having the industry data backing it up make it smooth sailing? Also, when you say it took 6-8 months to get fully resolved, was most of that time just waiting for IRS processing, or were there back-and-forth communications required?
Has anyone considered Section 179 deduction for some of the more expensive components? I found that for some of the higher-end networking equipment I keep on hand (like $500+ items), my accountant suggested using Section 179 instead of supplies or CoG since they have a longer useful life.
Section 179 is definitely worth considering for more expensive items, but you need to be careful about the "placed in service" requirement. Items must actually be used in your business during the tax year to qualify for Section 179, not just sitting on a shelf as backup inventory.
This has been such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with a similar situation with my small tech consulting business. Based on all the discussion here, it seems like the key is whether your business is primarily service-based (which it sounds like yours is) and whether the parts are incidental to your services rather than merchandise for sale. From what I've gathered, since you're an MSP providing services and the components are a small percentage of revenue (5%) and often not separately billed, treating them as supplies expense on line 22 of Schedule C seems appropriate. The fact that you're under the gross receipts threshold mentioned earlier also helps with simplified accounting methods. One thing I'd add is to make sure you document your reasoning - keep records showing the percentage of revenue from parts vs services, and note when parts are included in service fees vs separately billed. This will help if you're ever questioned about your classification choice.
Thanks for the great summary! You've really captured the key points from this discussion. I'm new to this community but dealing with the exact same issue with my small IT business. One question - when you mention documenting the reasoning, do you think it's worth creating a formal policy document for my business files, or is it enough to just keep good records in my accounting software showing the revenue percentages and billing practices?
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I've been on an installment plan for about 4 months now and was getting anxious about not receiving any kind of statement or confirmation beyond the initial setup paperwork. Reading about the CP89 notices coming in January/February puts my mind at ease - at least I know what to expect and when. I'm definitely going to try the automated phone line at 1-800-829-1040 that several people mentioned. The idea of getting a balance update in just a few minutes without dealing with hold times sounds amazing. I'm also taking everyone's advice about keeping detailed records. Starting this month, I'm going to save my bank statements and take monthly screenshots of my online account (once I finally get it set up properly). After hearing about payment discrepancies, it's clear that having your own documentation is crucial when dealing with the IRS. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - this is exactly the kind of real-world advice you can't find in the official IRS publications!
So glad this thread has been helpful for you too! I'm also relatively new to installment plans (about 6 months in) and was feeling pretty lost about tracking my progress. The anxiety about not knowing exactly where you stand with your payments is real - especially when you're dealing with the IRS. I tried the automated phone line yesterday after reading about it here and it worked perfectly. Got my current balance in under 3 minutes, no hold time at all. Definitely saving that number for monthly check-ins while I work on getting the online account sorted out. The record-keeping advice from everyone is spot on. I started a simple spreadsheet this week to track my monthly payments alongside screenshots from my bank account. Figure it's better to be overly documented than caught off guard later if there are any issues. Good luck with your payment plan!
This is such a timely thread for me! I just started my installment plan about 2 months ago and have been wondering the exact same thing about statements. It's really reassuring to know that the CP89 notices come out annually in January/February - I was starting to worry that I'd never get any official documentation of my payments. I'm definitely going to try that automated phone line at 1-800-829-1040 that everyone's mentioned. Being able to get a balance update in just a few minutes without waiting on hold sounds like a game-changer. I made the mistake of trying to call the regular IRS line once and gave up after 90 minutes on hold. The advice about keeping bank statements and taking screenshots is gold. I've been pretty casual about record-keeping so far, but after reading about payment discrepancies, I'm going to start being much more diligent. Better to have too much documentation than not enough when it comes to the IRS! Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - this kind of practical advice from people who've actually been through it is invaluable.
You're absolutely right about being proactive with record-keeping! I learned this lesson the hard way when I first started my plan. One thing I'd add is to also keep a copy of your original installment agreement paperwork in the same place as your monthly records. I had to reference mine recently when there was confusion about my payment due date, and having it easily accessible saved me a lot of stress. The automated phone line really is a lifesaver - I use it monthly now just to double-check that my payments are being processed correctly. It's become part of my routine to call around the same time I check my bank statement each month. Takes less time than brewing a cup of coffee and gives you instant peace of mind!
Just to add to the confusion on 1098-T forms: the school isn't always correct either! Last year my daughter's college sent a corrected 1098-T in April (after I'd already filed) because they had reported some amounts incorrectly. It's worth double-checking with your school's financial aid office if something seems off about the form. For box 4 specifically, you can ask them to provide details about exactly what was adjusted and why. This might help you determine how to report it correctly, especially if you're using tax software like TaxAct.
I went through something very similar last year! The key thing to understand is that Box 4 adjustments don't necessarily mean you owe more taxes - it depends on what education credits you claimed previously. In TaxAct, when you get to the Education section, make sure you enter the Box 4 amount exactly as shown on your 1098-T. The software will ask you about prior year education credits and calculate any recapture automatically. Since your adjustment was due to a residency status change (reducing your tuition from out-of-state to in-state rates), this is actually pretty straightforward. One thing that helped me was printing out my prior year return before entering the new 1098-T information, so I could see exactly which education credit I had claimed and for how much. This made it easier to verify that TaxAct was handling the adjustment correctly. Don't stress too much about it - these adjustments are more common than you'd think, especially with state residency changes!
This is really helpful advice! I'm curious - when you printed out your prior year return, did you find any discrepancies between what you claimed and what the school was adjusting? I'm worried that my situation might be more complicated because I also had some scholarship money that changed when my residency status was corrected. Did TaxAct handle multiple adjustments at once for you, or did you have to enter them separately?
Chris Elmeda
Hey Ruby! Welcome to the trading world - I was in almost the exact same situation last year when I started. You're absolutely right that you'll only pay taxes on your net profit of $550 ($800 gains minus $250 losses). One thing I wish someone had told me early on is to keep really detailed records throughout the year, not just rely on your brokerage statements at tax time. I started using a simple spreadsheet to track each trade with the date, symbol, buy price, sell price, and whether it was a gain or loss. Makes tax season so much easier! Also, since you mentioned learning your lesson on penny stocks - been there! Those volatile moves can really teach you about risk management the hard way. The silver lining is that those losses do help offset your gains tax-wise, so at least there's that small consolation. Your brokerage should send you a 1099-B form early next year that will list all your transactions. Most tax software can import this directly, which saves you from manually entering every single trade. Good luck with the rest of your trading year!
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
ā¢Great advice about keeping detailed records! I'm just starting out with trading too and wondering - do you recommend any specific apps or tools for tracking trades beyond just a basic spreadsheet? I've been manually entering everything but I'm already getting overwhelmed with just a month of data.
0 coins
Mason Stone
Ruby, you've gotten some great explanations here! Just to add one more perspective - I'm a CPA and see this exact scenario all the time with new traders. You're absolutely correct that your $250 in losses will offset your $800 in gains, so you'll only owe taxes on the $550 net profit. One thing to keep in mind is that since all your trades were held for less than a year, they're all short-term capital gains/losses, which means they'll be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate (not the lower long-term capital gains rates). So depending on your tax bracket, you could be looking at anywhere from 10% to 37% tax on that $550. Also, don't forget about the wash sale rule - if you sold any stocks at a loss and then bought the same or "substantially identical" securities within 30 days before or after the sale, those losses might be disallowed. Your brokerage should flag these on your 1099-B, but it's good to be aware of. Keep those trading records organized and consider using tax software that can handle investment transactions - it'll make your life much easier come tax time!
0 coins
Zara Perez
ā¢This is really helpful, especially the point about short-term vs long-term rates! I had no idea that holding period affected the tax rate so much. Quick question - is there a minimum threshold for reporting trading gains? Like if someone only made $50 in profit for the year, do they still need to report it and pay taxes on it, or is there some kind of de minimis exception for small amounts?
0 coins