


Ask the community...
Have any of you had luck with the Taxpayer Advocate Service? My cousin was in a similar situation but much more severe. They really helped him, and it's totally free!
I've been through something very similar with my elderly father who also had significant tax debt and language barriers. Here are a few additional thoughts based on what worked for us: Definitely go with Form 2848 as others have suggested - the full power of attorney is essential when dealing with complex cases like this. When you fill it out, I'd recommend being very broad with the tax years (maybe 2010-2024) and tax matters you're requesting authority for. This gives you maximum flexibility to address any issues that come up. One thing that really helped us was getting a complete Account Transcript from the IRS once the 2848 was processed. This shows every transaction, payment, penalty, and interest charge on the account going back years. It helped us identify some penalties that shouldn't have been applied and gave us the full picture of what we were dealing with. Also, don't overlook the possibility of an Offer in Compromise if your mom truly can't pay the full amount and is unlikely to be able to in the future. Given her age, fixed income, and the size of the debt, she might qualify to settle for much less than the full amount owed. The key is getting that 2848 filed first so you can start gathering information and exploring all the options available to her.
This is excellent advice, especially about requesting the Account Transcript once the 2848 is processed. I'm curious - when you mention an Offer in Compromise, what kind of settlement amounts did you see in similar situations? My grandmother is in her 80s with only Social Security income, and I'm wondering if this might be a viable path for us too. Also, how long did the whole process take from filing the 2848 to getting everything resolved?
Something else to consider - location matters too! Some states offer state-level earned income tax credits to ITIN filers even when they're ineligible for the federal EITC. California, Colorado, Maryland, and a few others have inclusive state credits that can boost refunds for undocumented taxpayers with dependents.
This is a really comprehensive discussion! One thing I'd add is that documentation requirements can also create differences in practice. While both citizens and ITIN holders can claim dependents, citizens typically have easier access to required documents like Social Security cards for their children. For mixed-status families where some children are citizens and others aren't, the tax benefits can vary significantly per child within the same household. Citizen children with SSNs qualify for more credits than children without SSNs, even when claimed by the same parent. This creates complexity that many families don't realize until they're preparing their taxes. Also worth noting that some undocumented immigrants overpay taxes through withholding but don't file returns to claim refunds due to fear or lack of knowledge about their rights. The IRS estimates billions in unclaimed refunds each year, with a significant portion likely from immigrant communities.
I'm in this exact situation - our income jumped from around $180k to $240k and suddenly we owe instead of getting a refund! Has anyone tried adjusting withholdings to account for this? I'm thinking of changing my W-4 to withhold an additional $200 per paycheck to avoid owing next year.
I went through this last year. Had to update my W-4 to withhold an extra $350/month. You can use the IRS withholding calculator on their website to get a pretty accurate estimate for your situation. Just make sure you have your most recent paystubs and last year's tax return handy when you use it.
I went through almost the exact same situation two years ago - income jumped from $165k to $225k and suddenly owed $800 when we'd always gotten refunds before. The shock is real! What helped me understand it was realizing that our 401k contributions were still doing their job (reducing taxable income), but we were losing other benefits I didn't even know we had. The student loan interest deduction completely disappeared at our new income level, and we lost some education credits for my spouse's graduate courses. The other big factor was that more of our income was now taxed at higher marginal rates. When you're at $175k vs $228k, a much larger chunk of that income falls into the 24% bracket instead of the 22% bracket. That alone can create a significant difference in your tax liability. I'd definitely recommend running the numbers on adjusting your withholdings for 2025. We ended up increasing our 401k contributions slightly and adjusted our W-4 withholdings to account for the higher tax burden at our new income level.
Thanks for sharing your experience! It's reassuring to hear from someone who went through the exact same thing. The jump from always getting refunds to suddenly owing money is such a shock to the system. I'm curious about your strategy of increasing 401k contributions - did you max out at the annual limit or just bump it up enough to offset some of the tax impact? We're already contributing about 15% but wondering if we should push it higher to help with the tax situation. Also, when you adjusted your W-4 withholdings, did you use the IRS calculator or just estimate based on what you owed? The marginal tax rate explanation makes so much sense now. I kept thinking something was broken with our 401k deductions, but it's really just that we're paying higher rates on more of our income. Definitely going to look into both strategies you mentioned for 2025!
I wonder if it's worth trying a different tax software? I started with TurboTax and it said I had to mail my Oregon return, but when I tried FreeTaxUSA with the exact same information, it let me e-file with no problems. Could be worth the time to input your info elsewhere if you really want to avoid mailing.
Another thing to check is whether you're filing early in the tax season. I had this exact problem with Michigan a couple years ago - filed in late January and was forced to mail my return even though my situation was straightforward. When I called the state tax department, they explained that they sometimes disable e-filing for certain forms or situations at the very beginning of tax season while they're still testing their systems. The rep suggested I wait until mid-February and try again. Sure enough, when I re-submitted the same return information a few weeks later, it went through electronically with no issues. Might be worth holding off for a couple weeks if you filed very early, especially since you mentioned this hasn't been a problem in previous years.
Emma Wilson
For someone in your situation with $475K from a business sale, I'd strongly recommend "The Tax and Legal Playbook" by Mark Kohler. He's both a CPA and attorney, so he covers both the tax optimization and asset protection angles really well. The book specifically addresses how to structure things after a liquidity event like yours. Another excellent resource is "Loopholes of Real Estate" by Garrett Sutton - even if you're not planning to invest in real estate, it explains how different entity structures work for asset protection in ways that apply to any type of wealth. One thing I learned the hard way: don't rush into setting up complex structures just because you can. Start with understanding what you're actually trying to protect against and what your ongoing tax situation will look like. Sometimes a simple LLC is perfect, other times you might need a more sophisticated setup with trusts or multiple entities. Also, make sure whatever accountant you work with has experience with business sales and the resulting tax implications. The person who did your personal returns might not be the best fit for post-sale planning.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
β’This is exactly the kind of practical advice I was hoping for! I hadn't considered that my regular accountant might not be the best fit for this level of planning. The Kohler book sounds perfect since it addresses both the tax and legal sides - that's exactly what I'm trying to wrap my head around. Quick question: when you mention not rushing into complex structures, how do you know when you actually need something more sophisticated than a basic LLC? Is it based on the amount of assets, the type of risks you're facing, or something else? I'm definitely guilty of getting excited about all the possibilities without really thinking through what problems I'm actually trying to solve. Thanks for the reality check!
0 coins
Kristin Frank
β’Great question! The complexity you need really depends on three main factors: 1) Your risk exposure (are you in a lawsuit-prone profession or industry?), 2) The types of assets you have (real estate, securities, business interests each have different considerations), and 3) Your state's laws (some states like Nevada and Delaware offer better asset protection than others). For someone with $475K mostly in cash/securities, a single-member LLC might be perfect if you're just looking for basic liability protection and some tax flexibility. But if you're planning to buy rental properties, start another business, or you're in a high-risk profession, you might need multiple LLCs or even domestic asset protection trusts. The Kohler book actually has a great flowchart that helps you assess your specific situation. I'd start there before meeting with professionals - it'll help you ask the right questions and avoid getting sold structures you don't actually need. And you're absolutely right to think through the problems first! I see too many people set up elaborate structures and then realize they're paying thousands in annual maintenance fees for protection they didn't really need.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
Coming from a similar situation (sold my tech consulting business last year), I can't recommend "The Entrepreneur's Guide to Business Law" by Bagley and Dauchy highly enough. It's more comprehensive than most single-topic books and covers everything from entity selection to exit strategies. For the asset protection side specifically, "Asset Protection for Everyone" by Robert Mintz is written in plain English and doesn't assume you have a law degree. He explains when simple structures work versus when you need more sophisticated planning. One practical tip: before diving deep into books, spend a weekend mapping out your current financial situation, future income expectations, and what specific risks you're trying to protect against. This will help you focus on the most relevant sections of whatever books you choose. Also, since you mentioned feeling lost with your accountant - consider interviewing 2-3 different CPAs who specialize in business owners and wealth management. The right professional relationship will be worth more than any book, and they can recommend additional reading tailored to your specific situation.
0 coins