


Ask the community...
Another situation where filing separately can help: if either of you have income-contingent debts or obligations like child support from a previous marriage. My friend was paying child support based on his combined household income when filing jointly, but when they switched to filing separately, his payments were recalculated based only on his income, saving about $3,600/year.
This is actually not universally true. Child support calculations vary dramatically by state, and many states look at "household income" regardless of tax filing status. In my state (TX), they specifically request tax returns but the court can consider total household resources regardless of filing status.
One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet is the impact on future financial aid eligibility if you're planning to go back to school or have kids who might attend college. When you file separately, only the income of the parent filling out the FAFSA is considered for need-based aid calculations, which can sometimes result in significantly more financial aid. Also, if either of you is considering applying for income-driven forgiveness programs in the future, your current filing status choice can affect your payment history. Some couples strategically file separately for several years to keep payments low and maximize forgiveness, then switch to joint filing later. Given your income levels and the student loan situation others mentioned, I'd strongly recommend running the numbers both ways using actual tax software rather than estimates. The break-even point between filing statuses can shift based on small changes in deductions, credits, and other factors that are easy to overlook in manual calculations.
This is really helpful information that I hadn't thought about! We're not planning kids anytime soon, but my wife has been talking about maybe going back for her master's degree in a few years. If filing separately could help with financial aid eligibility down the road, that's definitely worth factoring into our decision. The point about payment history for forgiveness programs is especially relevant since she's already on an income-driven plan. Do you know if there's a minimum number of years you need to file separately to see meaningful benefits for forgiveness, or is it more about keeping the payments as low as possible throughout the entire repayment period? And you're absolutely right about using actual tax software - I've been doing rough estimates in my head but clearly there are way more variables than I realized!
I went through this exact situation last year with a UI overpayment from 2021. The key thing to understand is that unemployment overpayments are typically handled at the state level, and most states don't participate in the Treasury Offset Program for these specific debts. If you're not seeing any offset indicators on your IRS account transcript and the state specifically told you only state taxes would be affected, that's usually accurate. The federal and state tax systems operate separately for unemployment debt collection. I'd recommend checking your IRS transcript one more time for any offset codes (like the 898 code mentioned above) to be completely sure, but based on what you've described, your federal refund should be safe while your state refund will likely be intercepted.
This is really reassuring to hear from someone who actually went through it! I'm new to dealing with any of this tax stuff and it's honestly pretty overwhelming. Did you end up having to pay back the unemployment overpayment eventually, or did they just take it from your state refund and call it even? I'm trying to figure out if there might be other consequences down the road that I should be preparing for.
@Connor Byrne In my case, they took about 60% of what I owed from my state refund, and I had to set up a payment plan for the remaining balance. They were actually pretty reasonable about it - gave me options for monthly payments over 12 months with no interest. The important thing is to respond to their notices promptly and communicate with them if you re'having financial difficulties. They d'rather work with you than send it to collections. Just make sure to keep all your documentation and get any payment agreements in writing. The whole process was less scary than I expected once I actually dealt with it directly.
I can confirm what others have said here - unemployment overpayments typically stay at the state level for collection. I work with tax resolution cases regularly and have seen this exact scenario many times. The Treasury Offset Program (TOP) requires specific agreements between states and the federal government for unemployment debt collection, and most states haven't set up these agreements because of the administrative burden and costs involved. If your state unemployment office explicitly told you only state taxes would be intercepted, and you're not seeing any offset codes on your IRS transcript, your federal refund should be safe. The systems really are separate for this type of debt. That said, I'd still recommend checking your IRS account transcript one final time about a week before your expected refund date just to be absolutely certain, but based on everything you've described, you should be good to go.
This is exactly the kind of professional insight I was hoping to find here! As someone new to dealing with tax issues, it's really helpful to hear from someone who works with these cases regularly. I'm definitely going to check my IRS transcript one more time next week like you suggested. Quick question though - when you say "offset codes," are there specific numbers I should be looking for besides the 898 code that was mentioned earlier? I want to make sure I'm not missing anything when I review my transcript.
@AstroAce Great question! Besides the 898 code, you should also look out for codes like 896 (offset referral) and 971 (notice issued). These typically appear in the cycle date sections of your transcript. Also check the "Account Balance" section - if there's going to be an offset, it usually shows as a pending transaction. The IRS is pretty good about updating these codes well before your refund processes, so if you're not seeing anything unusual by now, you're probably in the clear. Just make sure you're looking at your Account Transcript, not just the Return Transcript, as that's where offset information appears.
This is such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with a similar situation but with a twist - I have two roommates who each pay different amounts ($700 and $500) because one has the larger bedroom. Do I need to calculate separate percentages for each roommate's space, or can I just use the total amount they pay ($1,200) against the total percentage of the house they occupy together? Also, if I'm reporting this on Schedule E, do I need to treat this as two separate rental activities or can I combine it all as one rental income source? I'm using a 4-bedroom house where I occupy one bedroom and they occupy the other two, plus we all share common areas. Thanks for all the great advice in this thread - definitely going to look into some of the tools mentioned here!
Great question about handling multiple roommates with different payment amounts! You can definitely combine both roommates into one rental activity on Schedule E - there's no need to treat them as separate rentals since they're both part of the same property. For calculating the percentage, you'll want to base it on the total square footage that both roommates use combined. So if your two roommates together occupy 50% of the house (their bedrooms plus their proportional share of common areas), you'd use 50% as your deduction percentage against the total $1,200 monthly income they pay. The fact that they pay different amounts doesn't affect the calculation - what matters is the total space they occupy versus the total rental income you receive. You'll report the combined $14,400 annual income ($1,200 Γ 12) on Schedule E and deduct the same percentage of your eligible expenses against that total. This is actually a pretty common scenario, and the IRS is used to seeing single-property rentals with multiple tenants paying different amounts. Just make sure to keep good records of all payments received from both roommates and maintain documentation of your square footage calculations for your deduction percentage.
This is really helpful clarification! I was overthinking the multiple roommate situation. Just to make sure I understand correctly - if my roommates' bedrooms are 200 sq ft each and we split common areas (kitchen, living room, bathrooms) proportionally, I would calculate their total usage as: (200 + 200) + their share of common areas, then divide by total house square footage to get my deduction percentage? And then I can deduct that same percentage of mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, utilities, repairs, etc. against the full $14,400 income? Also, do I need any special documentation since there are two different people paying me, or is tracking the total monthly income sufficient for tax purposes?
I've been tracking H&R Block's refund advance approval rates this tax season across several forums. For first-time customers specifically, I've noted 73.8% approval rate with an average processing time of exactly 37.2 hours from submission to advance funding. The median refund amount for approved advances was $2,847. Does your expected refund fall above or below this threshold? I've observed that amounts significantly below this have a notably lower approval rate of approximately 52.4%.
Those numbers are spot on. It's like fishing - the bigger the fish (refund), the more likely you'll catch it (get approved). H&R Block is essentially making a short-term loan based on your expected refund collateral. The Tax Pro Review actually improves your odds because it's like having a professional fisherman check your equipment before you cast.
Based on my experience with H&R Block's system, you're in a good position having used Tax Pro Review. I went through this same process two years ago and found that the IRS acceptance typically comes within 24-48 hours as you mentioned from Publication 1345. However, what many people don't realize is that H&R Block's refund advance approval happens in parallel with IRS processing, not sequentially. They begin their internal credit assessment as soon as your return is transmitted, so you might actually get approval notification very close to when you receive IRS acceptance. The key factors I noticed were: expected refund amount (they seem to prefer $1,000+), clean credit history, and no complex tax situations that could delay IRS processing. Since you used Tax Pro Review and are a homeowner with proper documentation, you're likely in their preferred approval category. Keep an eye on both your email and their mobile app - sometimes one updates before the other.
Tony Brooks
Hey Allen! I went through the exact same thing last year - those codes are super stressful when you don't know what they mean. The 971 code just means the IRS sent you a notice explaining any changes they made to your return, and the 570 code puts a temporary hold on your while they review something. In most cases, if everything checks out, the hold gets released automatically within 1-2 weeks and you'll see an 846 code with your direct deposit date. The most common reasons for these codes are stimulus payment amounts that don't match their records or small calculation errors that they can fix on their end. Keep checking your - once you see that 846 code, you're golden! The waiting is definitely the hardest part but it sounds like you're almost there after 9 months of processing.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
β’Thanks Tony! That's really reassuring to hear from someone who went through the same thing. The waiting has been absolutely brutal, especially after 9 months already. I keep obsessively checking my hoping to see that magical 846 code appear π Did you end up getting the actual notice in the mail too, or did your just show up before the arrived? I'm trying to figure out if I should wait for the or if things might resolve automatically like you mentioned.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Those codes are definitely nerve-wracking after such a long wait! The 971 means they're sending you a notice explaining what they reviewed, and the 570 is just a temporary hold while they sort things out. After 9 months of processing, you're likely in the final stages. Most people with this combo see the hold release within 1-2 weeks with an 846 code and deposit date. The most common causes are stimulus payment discrepancies or small errors they can fix automatically. Keep checking your daily - once you see that 846 code pop up, you'll know your is on the way. Hang in there, you're so close!
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
β’Julia's absolutely right! After going through 9 months of processing hell myself, seeing those codes is actually progress believe it or not π The 570 hold usually releases pretty quick once they finish their review - mine lifted in about 10 days and boom, got my DDD. Most of the time it's just them double-checking stimulus amounts or verifying some income stuff. Stay strong and keep refreshing that transcript! You've made it this far, you're definitely in the home stretch now πͺ
0 coins