


Ask the community...
Has anyone used TurboTax for this situation? I have similar negative/positive numbers on my Schedule D and I'm wondering if the software handles this automatically or if I need to manually override something.
I went through this exact same confusion last year! You're absolutely right to use -1,912 on Line 3 and keep the minus sign. I know it feels weird entering a negative number, but the worksheet is specifically designed to handle capital losses this way. What helped me understand it better was realizing that the Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet is trying to figure out how much of your income qualifies for the lower capital gains tax rates. When you have a net capital loss (like your -1,912), it essentially means you don't have capital gains to apply the preferential rates to, so the worksheet adjusts accordingly. The key thing to remember is that "smaller" in tax terms means the value that results in less taxable income at preferential rates, not necessarily the numerically smaller number. Your -1,912 is the correct entry, and the subsequent lines will handle the math properly to ensure you're not overpaying on your qualified dividends. Don't second-guess yourself - you've got it right!
I'm so sorry for your aunt's loss. This is such a challenging situation to navigate while grieving. One important resource that hasn't been mentioned yet is the IRS Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS). Since your aunt has mobility issues and is dealing with a complex situation involving a deceased spouse, she may qualify for their assistance. TAS is a free service within the IRS that helps taxpayers resolve problems and navigate difficult situations. You can reach TAS at 1-877-777-4778, and they often can help expedite transcript requests or provide guidance on exactly what forms are needed in her specific situation. They're particularly helpful for taxpayers facing hardships, which certainly applies here. Also, if your uncle had any business income (Schedule C), rental properties (Schedule E), or investment accounts, those may require additional forms or have specific reporting requirements that could affect the final return. The transcripts will reveal these, but it's worth mentioning so you're prepared. One more practical tip: when your aunt signs the final joint return, she should use blue ink if possible. The IRS can better distinguish original signatures from photocopies, which can help avoid processing delays. Take care of yourselves during this difficult time. The tax situation will get resolved - focus on supporting your aunt through her grief as well.
Thank you for mentioning the Taxpayer Advocate Service - that's such a valuable resource that many people don't know about! The blue ink tip is also really helpful and something I never would have thought of. I'm curious about the business income you mentioned. If my aunt discovers from the transcripts that her uncle had some 1099-MISC income or small business activity she wasn't aware of, does she need to gather additional documentation beyond what shows up on the wage transcript? For example, if he had business expenses that were deducted in previous years, would she need to find those records too, or can she just report the income without the corresponding expense deductions if she can't locate the documentation? This community has been so incredibly helpful - I feel much more confident about helping my aunt navigate this process now.
Great question about business income! If the transcripts reveal 1099-MISC income or other business activity, your aunt should try to locate corresponding expense records if possible, but don't stress if she can't find everything. For the final return, she can report the income as shown on the transcripts. If she finds some business expense documentation but not all of it, she can deduct what she can reasonably document and support. However, if she has no expense records at all, it's generally safer to just report the gross income rather than guess at deductions. The IRS understands that surviving spouses may not have access to all records, especially when the deceased handled all tax matters. If there are significant business deductions from prior years that seem important but she can't locate the documentation, this might be another situation where the Taxpayer Advocate Service could provide guidance on how to handle it properly. One more thing - if your uncle had a home office or used his car for business, those are common deductions that might be harder to reconstruct without his records. Don't feel pressured to claim deductions you can't support, but do look through his files for any business-related receipts or mileage logs. You're doing such a wonderful thing helping your aunt through this. The fact that you're being so thorough will really help ensure everything is handled correctly.
I'm so sorry for your aunt's loss. Having been through this myself when my mother passed, I understand how overwhelming the tax situation can feel on top of everything else. One thing that really helped me was creating a simple checklist to work through systematically. Here's what I'd suggest for your aunt: **Immediate steps:** 1. Locate any 2023 tax documents she can find (W-2s, 1099s, previous year's return for reference) 2. File Form 4506-T requesting both Wage & Income Transcript and Account Transcript for 2023 3. Include a copy of the death certificate with the form to avoid delays **What to expect from the transcripts:** - Wage & Income Transcript will show all reported income (W-2s, 1099s, etc.) - Account Transcript will reveal any estimated payments, prior year balances, or payment plans **For the final return:** - File as "Married Filing Jointly" - Write "DECEASED" and date of death next to your uncle's name - In his signature area, write "Deceased [date]" - She signs normally in her area, adding "surviving spouse" The IRS processes transcript requests pretty quickly by mail (usually 5-10 business days), so she should have the information she needs soon. Once you see what income sources are listed, the picture becomes much clearer. Don't hesitate to call the Taxpayer Advocate Service at 1-877-777-4778 if you need additional guidance - they're specifically there to help in situations like this. You're being such a caring nephew/niece to help her through this difficult time.
Thank you so much for this incredibly organized and helpful checklist! As someone new to this community, I'm amazed by how supportive and knowledgeable everyone has been in helping with such a difficult situation. Your systematic approach really helps break down what feels like an overwhelming process into manageable steps. I especially appreciate the specific details about what to write on the tax return - knowing exactly how to handle the signature areas and where to write "DECEASED" takes away a lot of the guesswork. One follow-up question about the timeline: since tax season is approaching, should my aunt prioritize getting the transcript requests submitted right away, or is there typically enough time between receiving the transcripts and the filing deadline to prepare everything properly? I want to make sure we're not rushing her through this process, but also don't want to miss any important deadlines. This community has been such a blessing during this difficult time. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and provide such clear guidance.
I'm dealing with this exact same situation! Also went through my own "brilliant" day trading phase earlier this year and completely ignored keeping proper records. When I downloaded my Robinhood CSV file last week, I honestly felt like crying looking at hundreds of transactions with no organization whatsoever. This entire thread has been incredibly helpful and reassuring - it's amazing to see how many people have been through this same experience. Based on everyone's advice, I'm definitely convinced that trying to handle wash sales manually would be a complete disaster. I'm planning to go with TaxAct Deluxe after seeing multiple confirmations that it handles all the complex calculations correctly and matches 1099s perfectly. The $25 price point is so much more reasonable than TurboTax Premier, especially since we're already going to get hit with short-term capital gains taxes on most of these trades. The tax-loss harvesting advice before December 31st is something I really need to act on quickly. I'm also holding several positions that are still underwater from my trading spree, so strategically selling some of those losses could help offset my gains and reduce the overall tax impact. Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences and making this feel manageable instead of completely hopeless! It's honestly such a relief to know I'm not the only one who learned this record-keeping lesson the hard way. Definitely going to be much more organized with tracking everything going forward!
I'm in almost the exact same situation! Also did way too much trading earlier this year without keeping proper records, and when I saw my CSV file I felt completely overwhelmed. It's honestly so reassuring to see how many people have gone through this same experience - makes me feel way less alone in this mess! Based on everything I've read here, TaxAct Deluxe seems like the clear winner for handling wash sales automatically without breaking the bank. The fact that so many people confirmed it matched their 1099s perfectly gives me confidence it's accurate. The December 31st deadline for tax-loss harvesting is something I definitely need to prioritize too. I'm also holding some positions that are still down from my trading phase, so selling those losses before year-end could really help offset the gains and reduce the tax hit. Thanks for adding to this thread - it's been such a lifesaver for all of us who learned this record-keeping lesson the hard way! At least we're all getting organized now instead of waiting until April to panic.
I'm in the exact same situation and this thread has been such a lifesaver! I also went through a heavy trading period earlier this year without keeping proper records, and when I first opened my Robinhood CSV file I felt completely overwhelmed. After reading everyone's experiences, I'm definitely convinced that trying to do wash sale calculations manually would be a nightmare. I had no idea those rules were so complex until people started explaining them here - I definitely traded some of the same stocks multiple times within short periods. Based on all the recommendations, I'm planning to go with TaxAct Deluxe. The $25 price point is so much more reasonable than TurboTax Premier, and seeing multiple confirmations that it handles wash sales correctly and matches 1099s perfectly gives me confidence it's the right choice. The tax-loss harvesting deadline is something I really need to focus on before December 31st. I'm also holding several positions that are underwater from my trading spree, so being able to use those losses to offset my gains could significantly help with the tax situation. Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences and making this feel manageable instead of completely hopeless! It's honestly so comforting to know I'm not the only one who learned this record-keeping lesson the hard way. Definitely going to be much more organized with tracking trades going forward!
This whole thread has been incredibly enlightening! I had a similar situation with my cousin from Germany who won about $15,000 across several Vegas casinos last year. We were completely confused about what to do since gambling winnings aren't taxed in Germany at all. After reading through all these responses, it's clear we need to be more proactive. The casino did withhold 30% from his biggest win, but he never filed anything and just assumed that was the end of it. Now I'm realizing he might actually be entitled to a refund under the US-Germany tax treaty, and we should probably get him an ITIN to file properly. One question I have - does anyone know if there are any amnesty programs or voluntary disclosure options for tourists who missed filing in previous years? It sounds like the enforcement is getting stricter with international information sharing, so I'd rather get ahead of this before it becomes a bigger problem.
Great question about amnesty programs! While the IRS doesn't have a specific amnesty program just for tourists with unreported gambling winnings, they do have general voluntary disclosure procedures that can help minimize penalties for late filing. The key is being proactive before they contact you. For your cousin's situation with Germany, you're absolutely right that he likely qualifies for a reduced withholding rate under the tax treaty - probably around 15% instead of 30%. Even if it's been over a year, he can still file to claim that refund. The IRS allows amended returns for up to 3 years in most cases. I'd recommend having him apply for an ITIN first, then file Form 1040NR for the year he had the winnings. If he includes a statement explaining that this was an oversight due to unfamiliarity with US tax obligations, the IRS often waives failure-to-file penalties for first-time foreign filers, especially when they're actually owed a refund. The sooner he files, the better his position will be if any questions arise later.
Your cousin's situation with Germany is actually pretty straightforward to fix! I went through something similar with my brother-in-law from Austria. The US-Germany tax treaty does reduce the withholding rate significantly, and the IRS is generally understanding about tourists who weren't aware of filing requirements. One tip - when he applies for the ITIN, make sure to include a cover letter explaining that he's a non-resident filing to claim treaty benefits and correct previous withholding. This helps the IRS process everything faster. Also, keep copies of everything since international mail can sometimes get delayed. The good news is that even though it's been over a year, the IRS pays interest on refunds, so your cousin will actually get a bit extra back for the delay. Definitely worth pursuing, especially since $15,000 at 30% withholding means he's potentially looking at getting back over $2,000 if the treaty rate applies.
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I'm a tax professional who works with international clients, and I want to emphasize a few key points that have come up here. First, the advice about being proactive is spot-on. The IRS has significantly expanded its international data sharing capabilities through programs like FATCA and various tax treaties. What might have gone unnoticed years ago is increasingly likely to be flagged now. For anyone in this situation, here's my recommended approach: 1) Apply for an ITIN immediately if you don't have one, 2) Gather all casino documentation (W-2G forms, receipts, etc.), 3) File Form 1040NR even if it's late - the IRS is generally more lenient with first-time foreign filers who are trying to comply, and 4) If your country has a tax treaty with the US, make sure to claim those benefits. The potential upside is significant - I've helped clients recover thousands in over-withheld taxes. The key is acting before the IRS contacts you, which puts you in a much stronger position for penalty abatement and demonstrates good faith compliance.
StarStrider
Since u dont have to worry about penalties anymore, consider looking into short-term health plans to cover the gap between jobs. Way cheaper than COBRA. Just be aware they don't cover pre-existing conditions and aren't comprehensive like ACA plans. But for a few months of basic coverage against emergencies, it's better than nothing!
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
ā¢Short-term plans are trash tho. My brother got one and then needed surgery - they found some minor issue in his medical history and denied EVERYTHING. Said it was "pre-existing". Just save your $ and pray nothing happens lol
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Great question! You're absolutely right - there's no federal penalty for not having health insurance starting from the 2019 tax year. However, I'd strongly recommend looking into your options during the gap period anyway. Since you mentioned you're between jobs, you might qualify for a Special Enrollment Period on healthcare.gov if you recently lost employer coverage. This could make marketplace plans more affordable than you think, especially if your income qualifies you for premium tax credits. Also consider that even a basic catastrophic plan could save you from financial disaster if something unexpected happens. Medical debt is still one of the leading causes of bankruptcy, even for people who thought they were being smart by saving the premium money. When you do start your new job, make sure to sign up for their health insurance right away during your eligibility period - don't wait for the next open enrollment!
0 coins
Malik Thomas
ā¢This is really solid advice! I didn't realize you could qualify for a Special Enrollment Period just from losing job-based coverage. That's actually really helpful to know. I've been putting off looking into marketplace plans because I assumed they'd be crazy expensive, but if there are premium tax credits available based on income, that could change things. Do you happen to know how quickly you have to apply after losing coverage to qualify for the special enrollment?
0 coins