


Ask the community...
19 From my experience as a full-time Uber/Lyft driver, the key thing the IRS is looking for is consistency in your record-keeping method. If you create a system and stick with it all year, you're much less likely to be questioned. What I do: I take a photo of my odometer at the start of each shift and another at the end (with timestamps). I keep a super simple spreadsheet with date, starting miles, ending miles, which app I was driving for, and total business miles. That's it. Been doing this for 4 years, never had a problem with the IRS. The people saying you need origin/destination for every trip are probably mixing up the requirements for reimbursement from an employer (which is more detailed) versus self-employed mileage deduction (which is more reasonable).
11 Taking odometer photos is genius! That's like indisputable proof of your mileage. I'm definitely stealing this idea.
As a tax professional who works with a lot of gig drivers, I can confirm that your daily starting/ending odometer readings are actually a solid foundation for mileage deduction! The IRS doesn't require trip-by-trip logging for delivery drivers like some people think. Here's what you should definitely keep: 1) Date of work, 2) Starting odometer reading, 3) Ending odometer reading, 4) Total business miles, and 5) Brief description like "Pizza Hut delivery shift." The key is being consistent with whatever method you choose. One thing I'd add to your current system: keep track of your total annual mileage (both business and personal) so you can show the percentage of business use. Also, if you use your car for both jobs on the same day, try to separate those entries if possible - it makes things cleaner if you ever get audited. You're not doing anything wrong! Your method is actually pretty good compared to some drivers I've worked with who have no records at all.
This is really reassuring to hear from a tax professional! I've been stressing about this for weeks. Quick question - when you mention keeping track of total annual mileage, do I need to document every single personal trip too? Or is it enough to just note my odometer reading at the beginning and end of the year to show total miles driven?
I'm really sorry this happened to you - mortgage servicer negligence with escrow accounts is unfortunately more common than it should be, but that doesn't make it any less infuriating when you're the victim. One thing I'd add to the excellent advice already given: make sure your attorney considers the **contractual breach** angle in addition to the RESPA violations. Your mortgage agreement almost certainly contains specific language requiring them to pay property taxes from your escrow account in a timely manner. Their failure to do this isn't just a regulatory violation - it's a fundamental breach of your contract that directly caused you financial harm. Also, when calculating damages, don't forget about **opportunity costs**. The money you had to scramble to pay for redemption fees, attorney costs, and penalties - that money likely came from savings, retirement accounts, or required you to take on debt. Calculate what that money would have earned if it had remained invested, or what interest you're now paying because you had to use credit to cover their mistake. Your situation is exactly why escrow accounts exist in the first place - to protect homeowners from exactly this scenario. The fact that their system failed so catastrophically (to the point where your home was actually sold at auction!) suggests this wasn't just a simple oversight but potentially systemic negligence in how they manage escrow accounts. Stay strong, and don't let them minimize the severity of what happened here.
This is such an important point about opportunity costs that often gets overlooked! I hadn't even thought about the fact that the money I had to scramble together for all those fees came from my emergency savings that was earning interest. Plus I had to put some of the redemption costs on credit cards because I didn't have enough liquid cash available immediately - so now I'm paying 22% APR on debt that exists solely because of their negligence. The contractual breach angle is really smart too. My attorney mentioned RESPA violations but framing it as them failing to fulfill their basic contractual obligations might carry more weight with a judge or in settlement negotiations. They literally had one job with my escrow account and they completely failed at it. You're absolutely right that this seems systemic rather than just a one-off mistake. How does a mortgage company just "forget" to pay property taxes for an entire year when they have automated systems for this stuff? Makes me wonder how many other homeowners are dealing with similar issues.
I'm really sorry you're going through this - it sounds absolutely devastating to almost lose your home because of your mortgage company's negligence. One thing that might help strengthen your case is getting a professional analysis of your mortgage and escrow account history. I've heard good things about services like https://taxr.ai that can analyze all your mortgage documents and create detailed reports showing exactly where and when errors occurred. Having that kind of documentation could be invaluable for your attorney to demonstrate the pattern of mismanagement. Also, definitely file a complaint with the CFPB as others have mentioned. Mortgage servicers often take these complaints more seriously than direct customer complaints, and it creates an official record of their failure. For settlement amounts, given the severity of what happened (your home was literally sold at auction!), I wouldn't lowball yourself. Consider not just the immediate costs you paid, but the ongoing financial impact of that $750 monthly increase. That's $9,000 per year in additional costs caused entirely by their mistake. Over time, that adds up to significant damages. Document everything - every fee, every sleepless night, any medical costs from stress, time off work to deal with this mess. Their negligence put your most important asset at risk, and that deserves meaningful compensation, not just covering your out-of-pocket costs.
This is really solid advice, especially about getting professional documentation of the escrow mismanagement. Having a detailed third-party analysis could be the difference between a lowball settlement offer and fair compensation. I'd also suggest keeping a detailed diary of how this has affected your daily life - sleep loss, stress, time spent on phone calls, any work you've missed dealing with this mess. Courts often award damages for these "quality of life" impacts, especially in cases where the defendant's negligence threatened someone's home. Given that your house actually went to auction sale, this isn't just a billing error - it's a catastrophic failure of their basic fiduciary duty. Don't let them frame this as a minor accounting mistake when their negligence literally put your homeownership at risk.
I'm a volunteer board treasurer, and we specifically set up our reimbursement process to avoid this exact problem. Make sure you're using an expense reimbursement form that clearly documents these are HOA expenses, not payments for services. For next year, I'd suggest working with your board to implement a better system. Our association has a credit card that board members can use for purchases, which eliminates the need for reimbursements entirely. Alternatively, some property management companies can make purchases directly if given enough notice.
The credit card idea is smart. Our HOA did something similar after several board members had this same tax headache. Now our management company handles all the purchasing directly, and in emergency situations, they have a company card they can let board members use.
I went through this exact situation last year with my condo board reimbursements. What worked for me was creating a detailed spreadsheet that matched each expense category to the corresponding receipts, then reporting it on Schedule C with the 1099-NEC amount as income and the exact same amount as expenses. The key is being very specific in your expense descriptions - instead of just "HOA expenses," break it down like "Landscaping supplies - HOA maintenance," "Pool chemicals - HOA facility maintenance," etc. This creates a clear paper trail showing these were legitimate association expenses, not personal income. I also wrote a brief explanation letter that I attached to my return explaining the situation - that I'm an unpaid volunteer board member who was incorrectly issued a 1099-NEC for expense reimbursements. While not required, it helps clarify things if there are ever any questions. The good news is that since your income and expenses will be equal, you'll have zero net profit and zero self-employment tax. Just make sure to keep detailed records of everything in case of future questions.
This is exactly the approach I needed to hear about! The detailed spreadsheet idea makes so much sense - I was worried about just lumping everything together as "HOA expenses." Breaking it down by category will definitely create a clearer picture for anyone reviewing the return. I really like the idea of including an explanation letter too. Even though it's not required, it seems like good documentation to have on file. Did you submit it as a separate attachment or just include it with your Schedule C paperwork? One question - when you say you reported the exact same amount as expenses, did you have any issues with expense categories? Some of my purchases don't fit neatly into the standard business expense categories on Schedule C.
Based on what I've seen in this thread, it sounds like you have several good options to explore for maximizing your vehicle deduction. One thing to keep in mind is timing - if you can purchase before December 31st, 2024, you'd get the 80% bonus depreciation rate instead of the 60% rate for 2025. That could mean an extra $2,600 in first-year deductions on a $13k vehicle with 80% business use. Also consider the vehicle weight factor that Ethan brought up. If you can find a used SUV or truck over 6,000 lbs GVWR in your price range, you might qualify for full Section 179 expensing instead of bonus depreciation, which could be even better than the bonus depreciation route. For documentation, definitely start that mileage log from day one - apps like MileIQ make it pretty painless. The IRS really scrutinizes vehicle deductions, so having solid records is crucial. Have you considered whether you'd actually drive enough business miles to make the standard mileage rate (67 cents/mile for 2024) more beneficial than the actual expense method? At 80% business use, you'd need to drive about 15,500 business miles annually for standard mileage to beat the depreciation approach on a $13k vehicle.
This is really helpful analysis! I hadn't thought about the timing aspect - buying before December 31st to get the higher depreciation rate could save me a significant amount. That extra $2,600 in deductions would definitely make it worth accelerating my purchase timeline if I can swing it financially. The vehicle weight consideration is also interesting. I was originally thinking about a smaller used sedan, but if I can find a reliable SUV or pickup truck over 6,000 lbs GVWR in my budget, the Section 179 deduction could be even better than bonus depreciation. Do you know if there are any reliable resources to check GVWR specs before I go vehicle shopping? Your mileage calculation is spot-on too. I estimate I'll drive about 18,000-20,000 business miles per year based on my current client schedule, so the actual expense method with depreciation should definitely be more beneficial than standard mileage rate. Thanks for helping me think through all these angles!
For checking GVWR specs before shopping, I'd recommend using the manufacturer's official spec sheets or the NHTSA vehicle database at nhtsa.gov/vehicle-identification-number. You can also check Edmunds.com or KBB.com which usually list GVWR in their detailed specs section. Some popular used vehicles that typically exceed 6,000 lbs GVWR in your price range include: - Chevy Tahoe/Suburban (like Ethan mentioned) - Ford Expedition - GMC Yukon - Nissan Armada - Most full-size pickup trucks (F-150, Silverado, Ram 1500) Just double-check the specific year and trim level, as base models sometimes fall just under 6,000 lbs while higher trims exceed it. One more timing consideration - if you do find a qualifying vehicle and purchase before year-end, make sure to actually place it in service for business use before December 31st to claim the deduction. Simply buying it isn't enough; you need to start using it for business purposes. Given your high business mileage (18k-20k annually), you're definitely on the right track with actual expenses + depreciation. That's going to save you thousands compared to standard mileage rate.
This is incredibly thorough advice! The NHTSA database tip is gold - I had no idea that resource existed. I'm definitely leaning toward looking at those full-size SUVs or pickup trucks now, especially since my business involves hauling equipment to client sites anyway. Quick question about the "placed in service" requirement - does this mean I need to actually drive it for business purposes before Dec 31st, or is it enough to purchase it and have it available for business use? I'm wondering if buying something on December 30th would still qualify as long as I start using it for business in January. Also, has anyone had experience with financing vs paying cash when it comes to these deductions? I could potentially pay cash for a $13k vehicle, but if I can get low-interest financing, would that affect the depreciation calculations at all?
Aisha Rahman
Has anyone tried ExpensePath for accountable plans? My clients struggle with all the documentation requirements, and I heard this platform specifically addresses accountable plan compliance.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
ā¢I tested ExpensePath last year and wasn't impressed. The UI was clunky and my clients found it confusing. It also didn't integrate well with QBO at the time - not sure if that's improved. I ended up going back to a simpler solution with just a dedicated expense form in their accounting software.
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
ā¢Thanks for the feedback! That's disappointing to hear. I think I'll stick with my current approach instead of risking client confusion with another platform. Simplicity really is key for getting compliance from small business owners.
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
I've been managing accountable plans for s-corps for about 5 years now and totally understand the compliance headaches. One thing that's helped me tremendously is creating a simple one-page checklist that I give to all my s-corp clients explaining exactly what makes an expense reimbursable under their accountable plan. The checklist covers the three key requirements: business connection, adequate substantiation within 60 days, and return of excess advances. I also include common examples of what qualifies vs. what doesn't (like the meals 50% limitation, entertainment exclusions, etc.). For the actual tracking, I've found that keeping it within their existing accounting software works best for adoption. Whether it's QBO or Xero, I set up dedicated expense accounts specifically for accountable plan reimbursements and train clients on proper coding. The key is making the monthly reporting as automated as possible - I create custom reports they can just run and email to me. The biggest game-changer has been requiring photo uploads of receipts directly in their accounting software rather than separate systems. Clients are much more likely to snap a photo when they're already entering the expense than to deal with external platforms or forms.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
ā¢This is exactly the kind of practical advice I was looking for! The one-page checklist idea is brilliant - I'm definitely going to create something similar for my clients. Do you mind sharing what specific examples you include for the "business connection" requirement? That seems to be where my clients get confused the most, especially with mixed-purpose expenses like meals or travel. Also, when you mention "return of excess advances" - do you typically set up your s-corp clients with advance systems, or do you mostly handle reimbursements after the fact? I've been doing post-expense reimbursements to keep things simple, but wondering if advances might actually make the cash flow easier for some of my smaller clients.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
ā¢Great question about business connection examples! I include things like: client meetings (meals must include business discussion), travel to client sites or conferences, office supplies used for business operations, and professional development directly related to their industry. For mixed-purpose expenses, I emphasize the need to separate personal vs business portions - like if they extend a business trip for vacation, only the business days qualify. Regarding advances vs reimbursements - I actually prefer post-expense reimbursements for most of my smaller s-corp clients because it's cleaner administratively. With advances, you have to track the advance, match it against actual expenses, and handle any excess returns, which adds complexity. Most small business owners find it easier to pay out of pocket and get reimbursed monthly. However, for clients with tight cash flow, I do set up advance systems - just requires more careful tracking to maintain accountable plan compliance. The key is whatever system you choose, make sure it's documented in the formal accountable plan document and followed consistently!
0 coins