Back to California Franchise Tax Board

Alejandro Castro

Discharging FTB taxes — has anyone actually gotten California state income tax wiped in bankruptcy?

Filing Chapter 7 next month and my attorney mentioned that some of my California income tax debt might be dischargeable. I owe FTB for 2020 and 2021, both years I had a freelance income spike and completely dropped the ball on estimated payments. The returns were eventually filed late, and the balances have been sitting there growing with penalties and interest ever since. My attorney says the federal side might be dischargeable under certain timing rules but was vague about whether California follows the same approach. Has anyone here actually dealt with FTB and a bankruptcy at the same time? Did the balance survive? Did anything get released? I can't find a straight answer on ftb.ca.gov and I don't want to go into this blind.

California state income tax and bankruptcy — it's murky territory and your attorney is right that timing is everything. Roughly speaking, the same age-of-debt tests that apply on the federal side tend to apply to state income tax too, but the specifics of your 2020 and 2021 returns being filed late changes those calculations. FTB doesn't decide what's dischargeable — a bankruptcy court does — but FTB keeps collecting until a court order stops them. Keep paying on whatever schedule you're on while your case moves through, because a balance FTB is actively chasing won't pause on its own just because you filed.

0 coins

Paying while the case moves through is exactly what my attorney said too. The 2021 balance is the bigger one and I'm worried about whether the late-filed return resets some kind of clock. That's the part I can't get a clear answer on.

0 coins

Late-filed returns are the whole complication in these situations. I'd push your attorney hard on the specific dates — when you actually filed versus when the return was originally due — because that gap matters a lot for how courts look at these debts. FTB isn't going to volunteer that analysis for you.

0 coins

Yeah I have the actual file dates from when my preparer submitted them. Going to bring those to the next meeting.

0 coins

My situation was a bit different — I owed FTB for 2019 and went through Chapter 13 rather than 7, so the debt got folded into the repayment plan rather than discharged outright. The FTB filed a proof of claim in my case, and their number was higher than what MyFTB showed because of the interest that had accrued by the filing date. Ended up paying through the trustee for about three years before the case closed. Not exactly what you're asking about but wanted to give a data point that FTB does participate in bankruptcy proceedings and they do file claims.

0 coins

Chapter 13 is actually my backup if 7 doesn't work out cleanly. Knowing FTB files a proof of claim is helpful — at least they show up and the numbers are on the table.

0 coins

FTB filing a proof of claim is standard. They're a creditor like anyone else in that proceeding, and their number at the time of filing is what gets listed. The interest calculation running up to the petition date is something a lot of people don't expect.

0 coins

Did FTB's proof of claim match what your MyFTB account was showing, or was it noticeably different? Trying to understand how much the interest gap can widen.

0 coins

Mine was off by a few hundred from what MyFTB showed, all interest from the last couple of months. Nothing shocking but worth checking your own balance before the petition date so you're not caught off guard.

0 coins

Payment plan situation on my own account pushed me to actually talk to someone at FTB about where my installment agreement stood. I'd submitted the request and weeks had gone by with no acceptance letter, and I wanted to know the monthly amount on record before my bankruptcy attorney asked me for it. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handled the hold on the collections line so I didn't have to sit there, and I ended up talking to a representative who confirmed the request had been received, gave me the monthly amount in the system and the payment due day. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the Franchise Tax Board: https://youtu.be/XbqD8mexcoQ. The setup fee of $34 gets added to the balance once it's approved, and the rep confirmed that acceptance letter still comes by mail.

0 coins

Knowing the monthly amount before the attorney meeting would have saved me two emails. I'll remember that approach if I need to get the payment plan details confirmed before anything is filed.

0 coins

I didn't know you could get the monthly amount over the phone before the letter comes. Phoning collections at 800-689-4776 to confirm receipt of a payment plan request seems obvious in hindsight.

0 coins

The letter eventually came, but having the confirmed amount a week earlier helped when my attorney was putting together the schedule of debts. The rep just read off what was in the system.

0 coins

Did the rep say anything about whether a bankruptcy filing would affect the installment agreement? Curious what happens to an active plan if a case gets opened.

0 coins

The rep didn't go into that — they confirmed what was on the account and said any other questions about the plan's status during a legal proceeding would need to come from an attorney. Fair enough honestly.

0 coins

Nobody told me until way too late that the automatic stay in bankruptcy actually stops FTB's collection activity too — no garnishment, no levy, nothing while the stay is active. My wages were being hit by an earnings withholding order for 2018 taxes and filing Chapter 7 stopped it. The debt ultimately wasn't discharged because of the timing, but at least the EWOT paused. When the case closed without discharge, FTB resumed collection. Painful but at least I understood what was happening.

0 coins

That piece about the automatic stay pausing the EWOT is new to me. My attorney mentioned the stay generally but didn't get specific about FTB's collection tools. Worth asking about directly.

0 coins

Automatic stay covering state tax collection including earnings withholding orders is standard — FTB has to honor it. But you're right that it's temporary if the debt survives. Once the case closes or the stay lifts, they can resume from where they were.

0 coins

Resumed is exactly what happened. The withholding restarted, same order. I'd called FTB before the case opened to ask about it and they said only FTB can modify or release the EWOT — a bankruptcy attorney confirmed the stay was the other path.

0 coins

There's a thing that trips people up: FTB has 20 years to collect a tax debt. So even if bankruptcy doesn't discharge your 2020 and 2021 taxes, the collection clock doesn't expire anytime soon. The amount keeps accruing interest too. I'm not trying to be grim, just — going in knowing that FTB isn't going anywhere is useful when you're deciding between Chapter 7 and 13.

0 coins

Twenty years is a long runway for them. That's part of why I'm pushing to understand the discharge question now rather than just letting it ride.

0 coins

Does that 20-year window get paused by anything? Like if there's a bankruptcy proceeding in the middle of it?

0 coins

That's a legal question that really needs your attorney — the interplay between the bankruptcy stay and FTB's collection window is not something to guess on. FTB's site says 20 years, but the tolling rules during a court proceeding are court stuff, not FTB stuff.

0 coins

Makes sense, I'll ask my own attorney. I owe for 2022 and have been ignoring it longer than I should have.

0 coins

Went into my Chapter 7 not knowing if any of my FTB debt was going to get touched. Ended up with the 2019 balance discharged and 2021 not, based on the court's ruling. The difference really did come down to when each return was filed and how long had passed since the return was due. The 2019 one had enough time behind it; 2021 didn't.

0 coins

An actual discharge outcome — this is exactly the kind of thing I couldn't find. The different result by tax year is what my attorney was hinting at. How confident was your attorney that 2019 would go through?

0 coins

Cautiously confident was how they put it. They walked through the three-year rule, the two-year rule from filing, and the 240-day rule. All three had to line up, and for 2019 they did. My returns weren't filed super late, just a month or two, which helped.

0 coins

What happens to the penalties on the discharged year? Do those go with it or does FTB keep those?

0 coins

The penalties on 2019 went with the principal in my case. The attorney said penalties associated with discharged tax generally follow the tax itself. But I'd really verify that with your own attorney rather than take my word as a rule.

0 coins

This thread is making me think about my own FTB situation more carefully. I had an address issue where I wasn't sure FTB even had my current address on file, so notices about my 2022 balance may have gone somewhere else. Had to verify that separately before anything else.

0 coins

I want to flag something I see come up a lot: people assume that just because a tax debt is old, it'll automatically get wiped. The age rules are necessary but not enough on their own — the return has to have been filed by you (not assessed by FTB estimating your income), it can't be a fraudulent return, and there's a third condition around the timing of any assessment. If FTB assessed additional tax within 240 days before you filed bankruptcy, that assessment might not be dischargeable even if the original return passes the age tests. This comes up a lot with NPAs — if you got a Notice of Proposed Assessment and it was finalized recently, that can be its own wrinkle.

0 coins

The NPA point is relevant to me. FTB issued one for 2021 about two years ago, which I didn't protest because I didn't have the energy. Need to find out if that affects the 240-day calculation.

0 coins

An NPA you didn't protest would have become a final assessment at some point after the protest window closed. That date is what matters for the 240-day count, not the NPA's issue date. Find that date and give it to your attorney.

0 coins

Where would someone even find the date an NPA became final? MyFTB or would FTB need to tell you?

0 coins

MyFTB shows notices and correspondence, so the NPA would be there. The date it became final is a different question — that's something to ask FTB about directly, since the protest deadline on the notice is when it would have finalized if no protest was filed.

0 coins

I had a wage garnishment from FTB running for my 2020 taxes when I started the Chapter 7 process. The earnings withholding order paused when the stay went into effect, like others have said. My employer got notified, which was awkward, but the paycheck returned to normal for the duration of the case. When my attorney said the 2020 debt wasn't dischargeable, we pivoted to negotiating a payment plan after the case closed.

0 coins

How did FTB react when you asked for a payment plan after a closed bankruptcy case? I'd assume they'd be willing since you'd just proven the debt survived.

0 coins

They were willing. I applied through the phone line at 800-689-4776 and they set it up. The $34 setup fee was added and I got the acceptance letter within about six weeks, though they say it can take up to 90 days. I kept a small payment going while waiting.

0 coins

Keeping payments going during the 90-day window is something I didn't know about. I requested a plan and then stopped paying because I assumed it was pending. That was apparently the wrong call.

0 coins

Definitely keep paying while it processes. FTB's page on payment plans says to keep paying while the request is being reviewed — if you don't and it doesn't get approved, you'll have more interest added.

0 coins

Phoning them to confirm the request was received sounds like it's worth doing just to make sure it didn't get lost.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the One-Time Penalty Abatement is still available after a bankruptcy case closes and the tax survives? I owe FTB for 2022 and have late payment and late filing penalties stacked up. If the debt isn't going anywhere, I'd want to at least knock the penalties down.

0 coins

Your 2022 situation could actually be a fit for abatement. FTB's one-time penalty abatement applies to late filing and late payment penalties for tax years starting on or after January 1, 2022, so 2022 is in range. You'd request it on form FTB 2918, through MyFTB, or by phoning 800-689-4776. You need to have all required returns filed first, and you can only use it once in a lifetime.

0 coins

I haven't had it before, and 2022 is the only year I owe for. That sounds like it might apply. Does a bankruptcy proceeding affect whether you've met the filing requirement?

0 coins

The filing requirement is about whether the return exists in FTB's system. If you filed the 2022 return, even late, the return is there. The bankruptcy proceeding is separate from whether you filed. Consult your own attorney on the interaction, but the abatement request is based on the return and penalty record, not on the court case.

0 coins

Filed the 2022 return last spring, just late. So the return is there. I'll request the abatement through MyFTB and see what happens.

0 coins

Addresses were a problem in my FTB situation. I'd moved twice since the last return FTB had on file and I was worried none of the notices about my 2022 balance had reached me. Ended up phoning FTB and I used Claimyr to handle the wait, then spoke with a representative who confirmed the mailing address they had on file for me. It was my address from two moves ago. The rep told me I could update it in MyFTB under Profile then Update contact information, or by mailing form FTB 3533, or right on the phone, so I updated it on the spot. The rep then confirmed which notices had been mailed and to what address.

0 coins

Address issues are really common and nobody thinks about it until a notice gets missed. Glad you got that confirmed before anything escalated.

0 coins

If I hadn't confirmed the address I might have missed an NPA protest window without even knowing an NPA existed. That would have been a problem.

0 coins

Can you update the address in MyFTB even if you haven't registered yet? Or do you have to register first?

0 coins

You'd register first — the address update is in the Profile section of MyFTB. Registration uses info from a recent California return, then either instant verification through personal questions or a PIN letter that takes 5 to 7 business days to arrive at your address on file, so make sure that one is right before you try.

0 coins

If the address on file is wrong, would the PIN letter even get there? Sounds like phoning to update it first makes more sense in that case.

0 coins

I had penalties from FTB on top of the principal for 2021 that I wanted to dispute. My attorney told me I could pay them and file a claim for refund if the bankruptcy didn't cover them. The claim for refund has to be in writing, signed, explaining the reason, and generally has to be filed within 4 years of the return's original due date or 1 year from the overpayment, whichever is later. So if you're thinking about that route, the clock matters.

0 coins

Four years from the original due date for a claim for refund. For 2021 that's April 15, 2026, which already passed. That window has closed for me on that year hasn't it.

0 coins

April 15, 2026 would have been the four-year mark from a 2021 return's original due date. If you paid anything after that date though, the one-year-from-overpayment calculation might apply separately — your attorney would know which clock is relevant to your specific payments. It's not always just one deadline.

0 coins

There were payments made this year against the 2021 balance. Need to flag that to my attorney as a possible claim for refund angle on the penalties.

0 coins

Penalty disputes that don't get picked up in bankruptcy often get overlooked. The claim for refund route at least keeps the option open if something was wrongly assessed.

0 coins

I know someone who kept getting notices from FTB even after they filed bankruptcy and thought the automatic stay should have stopped all of it. Turns out some of the notices were automated and didn't reflect that the stay was in place yet. FTB recommends in those situations to contact them so the case filing date gets noted, since automated systems don't always catch it immediately. Just something to watch for.

0 coins

My attorney actually warned me about automated notices continuing for a bit at the start. Said to track everything that comes in with its date so we have a record if something needs to be addressed.

0 coins

Tracking dates on every piece of mail from FTB during a case is genuinely useful. I had to pull dates on old notices when my attorney needed to show the stay was in effect at a certain time.

0 coins

Keeping a folder with every FTB envelope, opened or not, with the postmark date noted is about the most practical thing you can do during this period.

0 coins

Are the late payment penalties the ones that keep growing during a bankruptcy proceeding or do they pause? I got confused reading about this — someone told me penalties keep accruing on a non-dischargeable debt even during the stay.

0 coins

Your question turns on what kind of penalty and what the court orders. The automatic stay stops FTB from taking collection action, but the tax debt itself — including interest and potentially penalties — can continue to accrue on what's owed. The stay stops active collection steps, not necessarily the meter on what you owe. That's a legal nuance your attorney would need to walk through for your specific debt.

0 coins

So the balance could technically still be growing even though FTB can't do anything about it during the case. That's not what I expected.

0 coins

The stay is about collection actions — garnishments, levies, liens — not about whether the debt itself keeps accruing. The two are different things, and mixing them up leads to surprises when the case closes.

0 coins

My situation isn't bankruptcy-related but this thread helped clarify something. I had a large balance on my 2022 return and was scared of a levy on my bank account. I didn't realize FTB typically sends multiple notices before taking that kind of action. FTB's own site says they contact you by mail several times before reaching out directly by phone or in person. Knowing there's a letter trail before any involuntary action helped me feel less panicked.

0 coins

The notice trail point is real. I've had three or four letters from FTB over the past year on the balances I owe, so I know I'm not at the surprise levy stage yet.

0 coins

Three or four letters on the same balance before anything more serious is exactly the pattern described. By the time you're in this thread asking questions, you're usually not at the emergency stage — there's still room to respond.

0 coins

Responding to each notice by its deadline is what keeps more serious steps from happening. Missing the protest window on an NPA is the one that really closes doors.

0 coins

Refund from my 2019 return was something I hadn't thought about during the bankruptcy. After the case closed and that year's tax was discharged, I realized I might have overpaid. I wanted to know whether FTB had ever issued a refund for that year or applied anything. Claimyr waited on hold with FTB for me and I ended up on the phone with a representative who confirmed the refund's issue date and that it had gone out as a check to my old address — not direct deposit because my bank account had changed. The check was from several years back and had long expired, so the rep pointed me toward requesting a replacement through FTB.

0 coins

A refund check that expired — that's one more thing to track during a messy period. How do you request a replacement on a check that old?

0 coins

The rep confirmed the original amount and issue date and said I'd need to contact FTB directly about a replacement. FTB's site has information on stale checks — a check under three years old goes by letter requesting a new one, and over three years uses a Replacement Warrant Claim form called 3900A. Mine was over three years, so the 3900A was the path.

0 coins

Knowing a refund went out to a stale address and the check expired is exactly the kind of thing that gets lost. The address update issue from earlier in this thread would have caught that before it happened.

0 coins

Address on file is the thing that keeps coming up. If FTB's address for you is wrong, refund checks, notices, NPA letters — all of it goes to the wrong place and you're in the dark.

0 coins

Has anyone dealt with FTB placing a lien during or after a bankruptcy? I owe for 2022 and 2023 and haven't been able to pay. I'm scared about property.

0 coins

FTB can record a Notice of State Tax Lien with a county recorder or file with the Secretary of State if letters go unanswered and the debt isn't paid. It's public record, lasts at least 10 years, and can affect credit — FTB doesn't report it to credit bureaus themselves but it can still show up. It gets released after the liened debt is paid in full, and that release process starts once the payment posts.

0 coins

Two years of unanswered balance notices and I haven't paid anything. How close am I to that actually happening?

0 coins

There's no announced schedule FTB publishes for when a lien gets recorded. If you can see your account in MyFTB, the lien status is there. Contacting them directly at 800-689-4776 to get on a payment plan before they record one is the more direct move.

0 coins

Setting up MyFTB tonight to check. I've been avoiding it but that's clearly making things worse.

0 coins

My employer was served an earnings withholding order for taxes for my 2020 FTB balance earlier this year. I had no idea it was coming — just saw my paycheck short one week. My employer gave me a copy of the EWOT within a few days. FTB's rules say the employer gives the employee a copy within 10 days of receiving it. The withholding is up to 25% of wages until the balance is paid or FTB releases the order. Hardship is a reason to contact FTB about modifying it.

0 coins

The 25% withholding on wages would wreck my monthly budget completely. Knowing hardship is a path to modify the EWOT is useful even if I don't end up with a garnishment — good to know the option exists.

0 coins

I called FTB about the hardship angle. They asked for financial information and said only FTB can change the amount or issue a new order. It's not something the employer can adjust on their own end.

0 coins

Once a balance is paid in full, you have to contact FTB to close the account and get the garnishment released — it doesn't automatically stop, even at zero. That's something a lot of people don't realize.

0 coins

The release doesn't happen automatically, yes. I confirmed that with FTB — you have to follow up directly after the balance clears to get the EWOT released.

0 coins

Payment applied to the wrong tax year was something I had to sort out during my own case. I'd made a payment intending it for 2021 but suspected it had gone to 2022 instead based on what MyFTB was showing. Phoning FTB to verify which year the payment actually landed on was the first step. I used Claimyr to wait on the customer service line, spoke with a representative who confirmed which tax year the payment had been applied to — it was 2022, not 2021. I then asked about getting it moved and the rep said to ask FTB which year it should be applied to.

0 coins

Payment to the wrong year is something I haven't thought about. I've made a few separate payments and assumed they went where I intended. Need to check MyFTB to see how each one is recorded.

0 coins

MyFTB's payment history shows what FTB has on record. If something looks off from what you intended, phoning them is the clearest way to confirm before anything else.

0 coins

How do you specify the tax year when making a payment? I usually just go through Web Pay and don't double-check the year field.

0 coins

Web Pay is meant to take separate payments for different tax years, so the year selection matters. If you're not confirming which year you're paying, it's worth verifying in MyFTB after you submit to make sure it landed where you wanted.

0 coins

Can FTB garnish a Social Security check? Someone told me they can't, but I've also read that they can go after Social Security income somehow. My mother is retired and owes FTB for 2020 and I don't want her to get surprised.

0 coins

FTB's earnings withholding order for taxes covers wages — Social Security income and the question of how it can be collected is a legal question your mother should ask a tax professional or attorney about directly. FTB does have collection tools beyond just wage garnishment, including an order to withhold from bank accounts, so the picture isn't just about the paycheck.

0 coins

So the OTW on a bank account could affect Social Security payments that are deposited there?

0 coins

A bank levy through FTB's order to withhold takes from the bank account whatever is there up to the balance due. What goes into that account is a question for an attorney — specifically whether Social Security funds retain any protection in a bank account under California law. FTB's collection page doesn't address that, so this is attorney territory.

0 coins

I'll get her to talk to someone who knows California law specifically. I didn't want to assume nothing could happen to her income.

0 coins

Something I haven't seen mentioned: Taxpayer Advocate Services inside FTB exists for situations where normal channels haven't worked. If a wage garnishment or levy is causing genuine financial hardship and regular FTB contact hasn't helped, TAS can get involved. The request form is FTB 914. They don't take cases just because you're unhappy with wait times, but actual hardship tied to a levy, garnishment or lien is their territory.

0 coins

TAS might actually be relevant if the garnishment starts and my financial situation hits a certain point. Saving that number — 800-883-5910, weekdays 8 AM to 5 PM.

0 coins

Knowing TAS exists and what it actually handles is useful. I've heard of it but assumed it was just another way to get to the same phone queue. Knowing hardship tied to a levy or garnishment is the actual threshold helps.

0 coins

TAS doesn't take identity theft cases or straightforward claims for refund either — that's in their scope description. Worth knowing what they don't handle so you're going to them for the right thing.

0 coins

Exactly — going to TAS with a call center wait time complaint means you won't get far. Going with a levy that's literally preventing you from covering rent is the kind of case they're set up for.

0 coins

Bookmarking that 914 form in case things escalate. I'd rather have it and not need it.

0 coins

Coming into this having filed today. The attorney got the automatic stay in place and confirmed it covers FTB's collection tools including the earnings withholding order that had just started on my account. For anyone else in this situation — the stay is real and FTB has to honor it. The discharge question on 2020 and 2021 is still open and will depend on the court's ruling. 2021 is the one with the late-filed return and the NPA that became final in early 2024, so the 240-day calculation is what my attorney is focused on. I'll update when there's a ruling but wanted to close the loop on what actually happened with the stay.

0 coins

Phoning FTB after the case closes to confirm the stay was honored the whole time is worth doing, especially on the EWOT. Sometimes automated systems send things out anyway and you want to know what's on record.

0 coins

The 2024 NPA finalization date is the key variable on 2021. If the case was filed more than 240 days after that date, the timing test passes on that front. Your attorney will know the exact count.

0 coins

Glad the stay kicked in. Watching the paycheck return to normal the first cycle after the stay went into effect was the first time in months I felt like things might actually be manageable.

0 coins

California Franchise Tax Board AI

Expert Assistant
Secure