Unemployment taxes if 10 percent withholding not selected for first weeks - California EDD situation
Okay so I've been collecting unemployment since late September and I completely forgot to set up the federal tax withholding when I first filed. I was so stressed about whether I'd even get approved that the tax question during certification just kind of slipped by me. I think I skipped it or said no without really thinking about it, and now I've been getting my full weekly amount for about six weeks without anything being withheld for federal taxes. I talked to my accountant friend and she said I might owe a chunk at tax time since unemployment is federally taxable. I had no idea - I honestly thought since I got laid off from my retail job it might be treated differently or something. So now I'm trying to figure out: can I change the withholding going forward for the remaining weeks, and what do I actually owe on those first six weeks where nothing was withheld? Is there any way to fix this mid-claim or am I just going to get hit with a big bill in April? Anyone dealt with this?
71 comments

Edwards Hugo
Form 1099G is what catches a lot of people off guard after their first time on unemployment. EDD mails it every January - it's also in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G by January 31st. Whatever you got paid across the year shows up on there and goes straight to your federal return as ordinary income. The federal tax piece is real, California state income tax doesn't apply to UI benefits, but the IRS absolutely counts them. What I'd do in your spot is change the withholding starting with the very next certification. During your biweekly certification EDD asks if you want 10 percent taken out for federal taxes - just say yes from here on out. You can't go back and add withholding to weeks that already paid out, but you stop the bleeding going forward. For those first six weeks where nothing came out, you'll want to either make an estimated tax payment now or just set money aside. How much you owe depends on your total income for the year, your filing status, all that. Your accountant friend can help you figure the actual number.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorThe UI Online path to Form 1099G - that's good to know, I was wondering how I'd even get that. So I literally just answer yes during the next certification and it starts then? No separate form to fill out?
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
UI Online certifications are where you handle it - no separate form needed. Answer yes to the withholding question and it starts on whatever weeks haven't been paid yet. It won't fix anything retroactively but it'll reduce what you owe going forward.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
My first certification period I skipped the withholding question too and didn't realize until I got my 1099G. It was a rude awakening honestly. Changing it mid-claim absolutely works, did it myself around week eight.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Six weeks without withholding hit me too on a previous claim and I needed to actually talk to an EDD agent about whether the 1099G would reflect anything I did mid-claim or just show total gross. Getting through on the phone was the problem - I tried several mornings and kept hitting the high call volume message. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the line. They've got a video showing the whole process of reaching someone at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent confirmed my 1099G would show total gross benefits paid for the year with no breakdown by withholding status - the withheld amount shows separately on the form in a different box. She also said I should keep a running total of what I'd received before switching so I could estimate my tax bill accurately.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorThe 1099G has a separate box for the withheld amount - that actually makes sense now. So even if you switch partway through, the form shows both the total paid and whatever was actually withheld, and you calculate the difference yourself?
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Exactly what I was told - two separate boxes on the form, total benefits in one, federal tax withheld in the other. If you withheld for some weeks and not others, whatever total came out is in the withholding box. You can estimate the rest on your own or with a tax person.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
Had the same question after my own claim and the 1099G format makes it pretty clear once you see it. Total gross on one line, withholding on another - easy to hand to your tax preparer.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
Something worth knowing here - unemployment is completely exempt from California income tax. So your state return isn't affected at all by any of this. The only bill you're looking at is federal. That can still be significant depending on your bracket and other income you had this year, but at least it's one problem instead of two. If you had any other income before getting laid off - wages, freelance, anything - your accountant will want to add the UI amount to that to figure your effective rate.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorThat's actually a relief to hear about state taxes - at least it's just the federal piece I need to worry about.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
Agreed on the California exemption, it's one of the few things that's genuinely easier here than a lot of other places. Federal still hits though so worth taking seriously.
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
My tax person last year added my UI to my part-time income I had before the layoff and my rate ended up being about what I expected from wages. The benefit amount isn't huge so if your bracket is lower it might not be as bad as you fear.
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
If you're worried about those first six weeks and don't want to wait until April, the IRS lets you make estimated tax payments directly - search for IRS Form 1040-ES if you want to prepay some of what you'll owe. That way you're not scrambling come filing time. A lot of people on unemployment don't know estimated payments are even an option. It doesn't eliminate the bill but it spreads it out or gets ahead of it. Your accountant friend probably knows this route well.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorLooked up Form 1040-ES just now and I see the quarterly due dates. I might have already missed one for this quarter depending on timing - does that mean a penalty or just pay when I can?
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
Missing a quarterly estimated payment can technically result in an underpayment penalty when you file, but it's usually small. Your tax person can run the numbers to see if it's worth making a payment now versus just settling up in April. For most people on UI it's not a giant penalty.
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Estimated payments are genuinely underused - most people just absorb whatever they owe in April but if the number is big enough paying quarterly makes a real difference.
0 coins
Daniel White
Quick note on the actual certification process since I went through this exact thing a few months ago - during each two-week certification EDD asks about withholding. It's not a one-time setup buried in account settings somewhere. You actively choose yes or no during each certification round. So if you said no during your first few periods you just say yes next time and that's it. The change is immediate for those weeks being certified. Just wanted to clarify because I'd seen some conflicting info on other forums suggesting you had to call EDD to change it, which isn't true.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
Checked my own certification screen after reading this and confirmed - the withholding question is right there in the flow. I've been saying yes since my first week, glad I did.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorNo call needed just answer yes next certification - that simplifies things a lot. I was dreading having to get through to someone just to flip a switch.
0 coins
Daniel White
Exactly, and EDD's phone line is better saved for actual account issues. The certification stuff really is just within the UI Online flow. That said for bigger questions about your 1099G or tax totals, the agents do actually know their stuff when you reach them.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
Something that tripped me up at first - I thought my employer had been withholding unemployment insurance from my paycheck so when the tax question came up I figured I was already covered. Turns out UI is funded through employer taxes only, nothing ever comes out of your wages for it. So unemployment benefits themselves are completely untaxed at the source - 100 percent of what you get paid lands in your pocket and your responsibility. That's why the 10 percent federal withholding option exists, it's entirely optional and voluntary because nothing is being withheld automatically.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Made that same mistake my first claim - assumed some withholding was happening automatically. Had a real surprise come tax time.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
The employer-side funding thing confused me too early on. My paystub has CASDI on it and I assumed that covered something for unemployment, but that's State Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave - completely separate from UI. When my claim started I had to remind myself that the whole weekly check was gross with nothing out, which is why I actually used Claimyr to get through to EDD when I had a question about how my pension income would interact with my benefit amount. The agent looked at my claim and told me EDD would determine the offset, not something they could calculate on the call, but at least I understood what I was dealing with going forward.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
CASDI getting confused with UI funding is super common, glad that got cleared up. And yeah the pension interaction is one where EDD really does need to decide case by case - good call actually getting someone on the line for it.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
Four months into my own claim after being let go from my warehouse job and the tax question is one that stressed me out early too. The 1099G box breakdown the person above mentioned is accurate - mine from last year showed gross benefits in box 1 and whatever I'd had withheld in box 4. I'd switched withholding on partway through and both figures were right on the form with no issue. My CPA said to just hand her the form and not to overthink it. As far as getting EDD info directly, Claimyr got me in front of an agent when I needed to ask about a couple of pending weeks on my Claim History - the agent pulled up my account and confirmed which certification period was holding things up. Took care of a question that had been sitting there for weeks.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorThe 1099G having the split already calculated on the form makes this way less scary than I thought. I was imagining having to track down every payment myself.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
EDD's records are solid on that - the form just shows up and has the numbers laid out for whoever does your taxes. No manual tracking needed.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
My CPA said the same thing last year, just hand over the 1099G and let it do the work. The form is pretty self-explanatory once you see it.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Something I want to flag for anyone reading who might be thinking the 10 percent covers everything - it's just 10 percent withheld, not necessarily the full amount you'll owe. If your marginal federal tax rate is higher than 10 percent because of other income, you could still owe some at filing even with withholding turned on. It won't be as bad as zero withholding but it's not a guarantee you're fully paid up. Worth running your expected annual income through a tax estimator if you're not sure where you land.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorGood point - I'd been treating 10 percent like a magic number that fully covers it. For those six weeks I definitely need to calculate my actual rate.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Exactly - 10 percent is better than nothing and it's the only option EDD offers, but it's just a flat rate. Your actual obligation depends on your whole picture for the year.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
Learned this the hard way my first year on UI - still owed about $200 at filing even with withholding on the whole time because my spouse's income bumped our bracket. The 10 percent is a floor not a ceiling on what might be owed.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
When I'd been on unemployment and had a withholding question I checked in through the live chat on UI Online - the Help button opens a chat with an EDD agent, Monday through Friday 9am to 2pm. I asked about how the 1099G handles mid-year withholding changes and the agent was pretty direct: the form just totals everything correctly, nothing you need to do manually. Phone line is 1-800-300-5616 if chat doesn't work for you, 8 to 5 weekdays. For tax-specific questions beyond EDD's piece, that's really a CPA or IRS question though.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorDidn't know about the live chat window - that might be easier than the phone for quick questions. What kind of questions is it actually useful for versus when you'd need to call?
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
Chat works well for account questions - what's pending, what a form shows, whether something was received. For anything complex about eligibility or adjudication, the phone is better since agents can pull more and document the call.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
The 9 to 2 chat window is real - I've used it twice and both times got someone within a few minutes. Good for quick lookups.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
Got my DE 429Z in the mail when my claim first opened and that showed my weekly benefit amount but it said nothing about taxes. I think some people read that letter and assume they're approved and all set. It's just showing what the claim can pay, not any kind of final go-ahead, and it has zero tax info. The tax situation is entirely on the certifier to manage through that withholding question. EDD really could do a better job of making the tax piece obvious upfront.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorThe DE 429Z was the first thing I looked at and you're right - nothing about tax withholding on it. I assumed EDD would handle that side automatically somehow, which was clearly wrong.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
It's a confusing setup, most income-replacement things automatically withhold. UI being all-or-nothing at 10 percent and totally voluntary is different and the documentation doesn't really flag it.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
The DE 429Z showing your weekly amount is great but the tax piece really should be in the same mailing. First timers constantly miss it.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
Something I saw someone say in another thread that is worth correcting here - there was a suggestion that you can amend past certified weeks to add withholding retroactively. You can't. Once a week is certified and paid, that payment is done. The withholding question only applies going forward to weeks not yet processed. So if someone told you there's a way to fix previous weeks, that's not accurate. The only path for those is estimated payments to the IRS or accepting the tax bill in April.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorGood to know that's a myth - I saw something similar suggested somewhere and was going to ask EDD about it. Would have wasted everyone's time.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
Exactly the kind of thing that gets passed around and sounds plausible but isn't how the system works. Worth clearing up before someone calls EDD expecting to be able to do it.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
EDD agents are good about clarifying this if you ask directly - no retroactive withholding changes, that was confirmed to me when I called after my first claim.
0 coins
Zane Gray
My layoff was in August and by the time I'd gotten through the whole application and ID.me verification process I was so mentally checked out that I think I answered almost everything on autopilot. The withholding question totally went past me. I ended up setting aside 12 percent of each payment in a separate account just to be safe after I realized what I'd done. Bit of overkill maybe but I'd rather have extra in April than be scrambling.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorSetting aside a percentage manually is probably what I should have done from the start. 12 percent seems reasonable depending on your bracket.
0 coins
Zane Gray
For my income level it ends up being more than I'll owe but the cushion feels worth it. Better to have a small refund than a big surprise bill.
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Manual savings is basically what a lot of financial people recommend anyway if you're doing any kind of gig or freelance income. Same principle applies here.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
The CalJOBS registration piece that EDD sends a notice about (DE 8405) is totally separate from the tax question but I want to mention it because some people on first claims think they're related somehow - they're not. The tax withholding is handled through each certification, the CalJOBS registration is a one-time thing required within 21 days of that notice. Got confused about those two steps on my first claim. Had an open question about whether a resume I'd already posted met EDD's standard, so I ended up getting through to an agent through Claimyr to ask - agent confirmed the existing resume was fine and the registration had been noted on my claim.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorHad been wondering about CalJOBS too - good to know those are completely separate processes. The resume question is something I haven't looked into yet.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
The CalJOBS step has its own deadline on the DE 8405 notice. If you got that notice, check the date on it and make sure you're registered. It's separate enough from certifying that it's easy to forget.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
Missed my CalJOBS deadline on my first claim and it held up my payments for a couple weeks until I got it sorted. Worth doing as soon as you get that notice.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
For the 10 percent federal withholding the original poster mentioned - just to be super clear on the math - 10 percent comes out of your weekly benefit amount, not some larger or smaller base. So if you're getting $380 a week, $38 goes to federal withholding each week. For six weeks of no withholding at that amount you'd be looking at roughly $228 in federal taxes not withheld. Whether that creates a bill or gets absorbed by other factors in your return depends on your full year picture.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorRunning those numbers in my head now - yeah the amount is manageable if I set it aside now rather than waiting. Thanks for putting actual math to it.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
The dollar amount is usually not catastrophic for most people since weekly UI amounts are capped at $450. It's more about not being blindsided than a massive liability.
0 coins
Abigail Patel
The cap at $450 weekly is good context - even at max with zero withholding your exposure for a few months is a known number, not open-ended.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
EDD really should default the withholding to yes and let people opt out instead of the reverse. The number of people who end up here asking this exact question after their first claim says a lot. I've been on UI twice and both times I had to actively remember to say yes because the question is phrased as 'do you want to have 10 percent withheld' which sounds optional and forgettable. Positive opt-in for a tax obligation that's genuinely mandatory at the federal level is backwards policy in my opinion.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Hard to argue with that logic. The IRS doesn't make federal tax optional - EDD making withholding feel like an extra you can skip causes exactly this kind of confusion for first-timers.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
Every thread like this one is basically the same question from someone who didn't realize the choice even had real consequences. The framing of the question during certification really undersells what's at stake.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
Came here with almost this exact question three months into my first claim. Would have been nice if the withholding screen had one sentence explaining the tax obligation clearly. Would have saved me a lot of worrying.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
Something worth adding since your accountant friend came up - if your total income for the year including UI is below certain thresholds, you might owe nothing or even get a refund depending on credits and deductions. Some people on unemployment for the whole year with no other income end up below the federal filing threshold or in the 10 or 12 percent bracket where the actual liability is quite small. The lack of withholding on those six weeks might end up being a non-issue. Still worth calculating but don't catastrophize before you have numbers.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorHad some wages from before the layoff so I'm not sure where I land overall, but you're right that I shouldn't be panicking before I actually run the numbers.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
Wages before the layoff plus UI for the rest of the year is a pretty common picture. Add those two things up and plug them into a free estimator - most years the number is less scary than the scenario in your head.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 is an option some people use for certifying who don't want to do it online - just mentioning it because if someone is on the phone doing Tele-Cert, the withholding question comes up there too. Same yes-or-no choice, same effect. So if for some reason UI Online isn't working, you can still certify by phone and handle the withholding question that way.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorDidn't even know Tele-Cert was a thing - good backup to have if the UI Online site is being slow. Does it cover everything certifying online does?
0 coins
Nolan Carter
Tele-Cert handles the main certification questions including withholding. It's a bit slower since you're following audio prompts but it covers what you need.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
EDD also has the payment info line at 1-866-333-4606 open 24 hours for checking payment status - same number does double duty depending on the option you pick.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Just want to say to anyone reading this mid-claim right now - change that withholding setting on your very next certification if you haven't already. The difference between owing a few hundred dollars in April versus zero is literally just answering yes to one question during each certification. It's one of those tiny decisions that feels invisible until you're doing your taxes.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
AuthorAlready have my next certification date noted and this is first on my list. Wish I'd read something like this before my first few weeks.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Most people learn from exactly the situation you're in. The good news is you caught it while you still have weeks left on the claim rather than realizing it in February.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
The same thing happened to my roommate and they ended up owing around $180 at filing from their first couple months of no withholding. Not a disaster but definitely avoidable.
0 coins