Back to California Unemployment

Victoria Jones

Unemployment eligibility after being fired for missed time that was excused - California EDD question

Lost my job two months ago and I'm still not sure where I stand with EDD. Here's the situation: I'd been dealing with a family medical thing and my manager approved the time off in writing, like actual emails saying "approved, no problem." But after I came back, HR reviewed my attendance record and apparently decided to fire me for excessive absences anyway, even though my direct supervisor had signed off on every single one. I filed for unemployment right away and had the phone interview last week. The EDD interviewer asked about every absence, the dates, whether I had documentation, and whether my employer had given me written warnings about attendance before the firing. I sent in the emails from my manager through my UI Online account as documentation. My Claim History has shown Pending on every certified week since I filed. The DE 429Z came and shows my weekly benefit amount based on wages from my old job, so I know the monetary side cleared. It's specifically this fired-for-absences question that's holding things up. Has anyone been through this where your absences were approved and you still got let go? Did California EDD find misconduct or did they rule in your favor? Really trying to understand what factors they look at.

Termination letters said "excessive absenteeism" on mine too, even though every single absence had prior approval from my team lead. Filed for California EDD unemployment the same week I got let go. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is how I got through to an EDD agent after the hold times on 1-800-300-5616 were killing me — the site holds the line for you so you end up actually speaking with someone. Their video on reaching a live person at EDD walked me through what to expect: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my phone interview was still open and that the pending weeks in Claim History meant they were waiting on the interview decision, not that anything was missing from my file. She also confirmed the DE 4800 date was what I needed to watch, not the online status. I kept certifying while I waited and the payments released about ten days after the interview. Hang tight and keep certifying no matter what.

0 coins

The DE 4800 date detail is really useful — I had no idea that was the thing to watch instead of the UI Online status. My absences were for a surgery and I have the FMLA paperwork but I'm nervous EDD won't weigh that the same way written approval emails might.

0 coins

Really glad you got through to someone. Did the agent give any sense of what specifically in the documentation pushed things toward a favorable decision, or was it just that you had the approvals at all?

0 coins

Payments releasing about ten days after the interview lines up with what happened on my claim, for a totally different reason but same timeline roughly.

0 coins

EDD's standard on a firing comes down to whether the employer can show misconduct — and in my own case, being fired for absences my doctor cleared in writing, the interview went pretty quickly because I had the documentation ready. The adjudicator asked me point blank: did you notify your employer before each absence and did they approve it. I said yes to both and had the emails to back it. EDD's position, as I understood it, is that if the company signed off on the time, they have a harder time arguing the absences were willful or in disregard of your duties. That's the core of what misconduct means to them — it has to be something you did intentionally or recklessly, not something the employer agreed to in writing beforehand. My decision came through as not disqualified and the pending weeks paid out the same week. Keep every email, text, or approval note you have and reference specific dates when you talk to EDD.

0 coins

The word "willful" is exactly what I kept seeing when I tried to look this up and couldn't find a plain explanation. So employer-approved absences essentially undercut the "intentional" argument they'd need to prove misconduct?

0 coins

My situation was a written warning first, then more absences, then termination — no prior approval on those later ones. The interview went differently for me. EDD asked specifically whether I had any written warnings about attendance before the final absences and I had to say yes. Still waiting on the determination.

0 coins

Had an almost identical setup, manager approved via text messages not email, and the adjudicator still accepted them. Format of the approval didn't seem to matter as much as whether it existed at all.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up early: I kept calling the phone interview an "appeal" when I was talking about it here and people kept confusing what stage I was at. The phone interview before the determination is EDD figuring out what happened — the appeal is what you file after you get a Notice of Determination if you disagree with the decision. They're completely separate steps. If the pending weeks are because of a conduct question, you haven't gotten to an appeal at all yet, which is actually the better place to be because there's still a chance EDD rules in your favor the first time without you needing to fight it.

0 coins

Went through the interview stage last spring and I made the same mistake — told my roommate I was "in the appeals process" when actually I was just waiting on the first determination. Confused both of us for weeks.

0 coins

Appreciate the clarification — I've been sloppy with that terminology too. I meant the phone interview when I said the EDD interviewer, not any kind of hearing.

0 coins

The distinction matters especially because if you do end up needing to appeal, you have to do it within 30 days of the mailing date on the Notice of Determination. Missing that window is a whole separate problem.

0 coins

Employer documentation is everything in these cases. I was let go from a warehouse job, attendance issue, every late arrival tied to a bus route change that HR had emailed me saying was fine as an accommodation. During my EDD phone interview the adjudicator specifically asked whether I had a copy of that email and I said yes and uploaded it through Report Wages — wait, no, that's not right, I uploaded it through my UI Online account messages. She went quiet for a second and then said she had what she needed. Determination came about two weeks later, not disqualified. The employer had 10 days to respond to EDD's claim notice and apparently did respond, but EDD still found in my favor because the email approval directly contradicted their misconduct argument.

0 coins

Uploading through the UI Online account message system worked for you? I've been mailing physical copies because I wasn't sure the online upload would actually get to the right person reviewing the claim.

0 coins

Mailed a backup set too just to be safe, but the agent I eventually spoke with confirmed they had the digital versions already on file when I checked in. Both routes seem to work, the online one just gets there faster.

0 coins

Employer responding but EDD still ruling for you is reassuring. I think a lot of people assume an employer response automatically tips the scales against the claimant.

0 coins

PENDING FOR SIX WEEKS NOW and the EDD phone line just rings and rings or tells me the queue is full. My situation is different — I was fired for three absences in a 90-day period that my supervisor verbally approved but I have nothing in writing, just my own notes with dates and times. The interview already happened, I told the adjudicator about the verbal approvals, and now it's just silence. I know verbal is way harder to prove than written but I genuinely have the texts where I told my supervisor I'd be out and they replied with thumbs up emojis. Does a text thumbs up count as approval or do I need something more explicit?

0 coins

Texts count as documentation — submitted screenshots in my own claim. The question EDD is weighing is whether a reasonable person would read that as approval, and a supervisor replying to your absence notification with a thumbs up is about as clear as it gets short of an email saying "approved.

0 coins

Six weeks is a long stretch. The phone line situation is brutal — I ended up sending a message through my UI Online account because I couldn't get through by phone, and an agent replied within a few days with a status update on my pending weeks.

0 coins

Absences on my claim dragged on even longer before I got a determination. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the line and found out there was a hold on my account from an identity step I thought I'd already finished — the agent walked me through clearing it and told me once it was done the pending weeks would process. Had no idea that was the holdup. If you're stuck past six weeks it might be worth checking whether there's something besides the interview decision holding things up.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading: a few comments up someone suggested that if the employer doesn't respond to EDD, the claimant automatically wins. That's not quite right. EDD mails the employer a notice and they have 10 days to respond — if they don't, they lose their right to appeal EDD's decision later, but EDD still decides the claim on the merits. It's not an automatic approval. I learned this the annoying way when I thought my former company had gone silent and I'd be fine, then had to go through the full interview and determination process anyway.

0 coins

That tracks with what I read on EDD's site — the employer not responding affects their appeal rights, not the initial decision itself. EDD still does the interview and weighs the evidence.

0 coins

Genuinely good correction. The idea that employer silence equals automatic payment is one of those things that gets repeated constantly and causes people to let their guard down before the determination even comes.

0 coins

Glad someone said this. I had been sort of banking on my old company not bothering to respond, but sounds like I still need to make my own case clearly in the interview regardless.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration caught me off guard while I was in the middle of a pending adjudication. I assumed I didn't need to do anything job-search related while everything was up in the air, but the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work showed up and said I had 21 days. Almost missed it because I was so focused on the conduct issue. If you got that notice, don't sit on it — register and post a resume on CalJOBS within that window or payments can stop separately from the adjudication question.

0 coins

The two-track thing — adjudication pending AND CalJOBS deadline — is genuinely confusing. Got that DE 8405 notice while still waiting on my own determination and had no idea which one was more urgent. Did both at the same time just to be safe. Also used Claimyr to get through to EDD when I wanted to confirm my CalJOBS registration had been received — the agent pulled up my account and confirmed the registration was showing on their end, which saved me from worrying about whether the system had actually processed it.

0 coins

I did get the DE 8405 and registered in CalJOBS about two weeks ago. Good to know that's a separate track from the conduct question.

0 coins

Not doing CalJOBS because I figured the pending status meant nothing was processing anyway — now I'm panicking about that 21-day window. Need to go check when the notice was dated.

0 coins

My employer told me during the termination meeting that they had reported the absences to EDD as unapproved, which isn't something they can really control the narrative on once EDD has documentation to the contrary. The thing I found out through the process is that EDD interviews both sides — the claimant and the employer — by phone before making a decision on conduct. So the employer's framing of the absences matters, but so does yours, and documentary evidence outweighs either side's verbal account. I had a written warning on mine which complicated things, but someone who has clear written approvals going in is in a much stronger starting position.

0 coins

Employer telling you they reported absences as unapproved is actually useful to know going into the interview — at least you know what EDD is likely hearing from their side and you can directly address it.

0 coins

Both sides getting interviewed is something I had to explain to my brother when he was going through a termination claim. He thought the employer just submitted paperwork and that was it, didn't realize they'd be talking to EDD directly.

0 coins

Certifying every two weeks regardless of the pending status is non-negotiable. If the determination eventually comes through in your favor, EDD can only pay you for weeks you actually certified. I skipped two weeks on a previous claim because I thought the pending status meant certifying was pointless, and those weeks were just gone — EDD couldn't go back and add them. Lost probably around $600 or so. Don't do what I did.

0 coins

Already certified through this week and I'll keep going. The DE 429Z showed my weekly benefit amount so I know the wage side is sorted, it's just the eligibility question that's holding the pending weeks.

0 coins

The "certifying is pointless while pending" mistake is so common and so costly. Even during an appeal you have to keep certifying or those weeks can't be paid back.

0 coins

Lost a week on a past claim for the same reason. The pending status doesn't suspend the certification schedule, it just means payment is on hold until the issue clears.

0 coins

Appeals process just in case things don't go your way: if EDD mails a Notice of Determination that says disqualified for misconduct, you have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing using the DE 1000M or a letter sent to the address on the notice. A late appeal needs a reason for missing the deadline. If it goes to a hearing, an administrative law judge handles it, not EDD — you testify under oath and you can bring documentation or even have someone represent you. The key thing is keep certifying through the whole appeal so there are weeks available to pay if the judge rules for you.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date, not from when you receive it — that one bites people who get mail slowly or are waiting to see what the notice says before deciding to appeal.

0 coins

Someone mentioned the ALJ doesn't work for EDD, which I didn't know. That actually makes the hearing feel slightly less stacked.

0 coins

Timing on appeal hearings is something I wanted to get clarity on when my own disqualification came through. Got stuck in the same phone wait loop everyone describes — tried Claimyr and an EDD agent picked up after I'd stopped expecting it. Asked specifically about when my hearing notice would arrive and the agent said to watch for the Notice of Hearing by mail, which comes at least 10 days before the scheduled date, and that mine was assigned to the Office of Appeals already. Meant I could stop checking UI Online for hearing info and just watch the mailbox.

0 coins

Misconduct in California EDD terms specifically means something the employee did that was intentional or deliberate disregard of the employer's interests, not just poor performance or making a mistake. I had a conversation with someone at an AJCC about this when I was job searching during a previous claim. The way she explained it: getting fired for absences that your employer approved in writing is tough for an employer to frame as intentional misconduct because they already gave the okay. That doesn't mean EDD rubber stamps it — they still run the full interview — but you're starting from a better position than someone who just didn't show up with no notice.

0 coins

The "deliberate disregard" framing is how I've always heard it explained too. Poor attendance without approval is different from poor attendance the company signed off on. The employer basically undermines their own misconduct claim with documentation of approval.

0 coins

This thread is probably the clearest breakdown I've found of how EDD actually thinks about the misconduct question. Feels less like a black box now.

0 coins

Wage side cleared fast on my claim too — the DE 429Z came within two weeks and showed a weekly benefit amount around $390. The adjudication question from a conduct issue is totally separate from whether your wages qualify you monetarily. Having the DE 429Z in hand just means you cleared the earnings threshold, not that the eligibility question is resolved. Some people on these threads conflate the two and think getting the DE 429Z means they're approved and then they're blindsided when the determination goes the other way.

0 coins

Went through this exact confusion myself — thought the DE 429Z was an approval letter and told my partner we were fine. Took another week to realize it was just the monetary side and the conduct question was still open.

0 coins

Nobody sends a letter saying you're approved when things go in your favor. If EDD decides you qualify, the pending weeks just start processing and you see payments. The DE 429Z showing a weekly benefit amount is not that message.

0 coins

Sending documentation through UI Online is one thing, but if you have emails that explicitly say "approved" with names and dates, it might be worth also referencing those exact emails verbally during the phone interview so the adjudicator can confirm they match what's on file. I uploaded documents on my claim and they were received but during the interview the adjudicator seemed to be working from the employer's written response primarily. When I described the emails in detail during the interview itself, that's when the conversation shifted.

0 coins

Good point — I referenced the emails in the interview and the adjudicator did confirm she could see them in the system. Hopefully that cross-reference helped.

0 coins

Describing the evidence verbally during the interview so the adjudicator can correlate it with what's on file is advice I wish I'd had going in. Uploaded documents sitting in a file and the adjudicator not knowing what they are doesn't help you as much.

0 coins

Direct deposit setup is something I'd handle now while everything is still pending — if the determination comes through in your favor, payments for all those certified pending weeks can drop at once and you want them going somewhere reliable. Changed mine through myEDD and it was pretty straightforward. Payment info updates daily in UI Online under Payments once things start processing.

0 coins

The pending weeks all posting at once after a decision is something people don't expect. Had several weeks release at the same time after my adjudication cleared and it looked like a mistake at first.

0 coins

Payment timing is in UI Online under Payments — checking 1-866-333-4606 also gives daily updates on payment status if the online system is showing anything confusing.

0 coins

Former HR coordinator here (different industry now). From the employer side of these situations: when a manager approves absences via email and HR later decides to terminate for those same absences, there's often an internal inconsistency in the company's own records. EDD's phone interview with the employer side is going to surface that inconsistency because EDD asks specific questions about whether the absences were approved. If the manager's approval emails contradict what HR tells EDD, that works in your favor. I saw this play out more than once when companies tried to fight unemployment claims for terminations that HR hadn't communicated clearly to managers beforehand.

0 coins

The HR-versus-manager inconsistency angle is something I never thought about from the employer's perspective. If the manager's email says approved and HR's answer to EDD says unapproved, those two accounts don't match and EDD has documentation of the discrepancy.

0 coins

That internal inconsistency probably explains why some employers don't even bother responding to EDD's notice when the documentation is clearly against them. They know the paper trail isn't in their favor.

0 coins

Even in cases with a written warning, if the warning was issued before the approved absences and the company fired based on absences that happened after the approval, the timeline itself creates problems for the misconduct argument.

0 coins

Waiting on a determination for my surgery absences claim right now and this thread has been genuinely helpful for understanding what factors matter. My situation has FMLA paperwork which I figured would be airtight but reading through here I realize the EDD interview is what it is regardless of what documentation you have — they still go through the whole process. Just submitted everything through UI Online last night and the interview is set for next week per the DE 4800.

0 coins

FMLA paperwork is strong documentation but the EDD process still runs its own course — keep certifying through the interview and after, and don't skip weeks assuming the FMLA automatically resolves the question before the determination comes.

0 coins

The DE 4800 date is key — make sure your phone is on and available at that specific time because if you miss the interviewer phoning at the scheduled time, you should contact EDD the same day to explain, otherwise they proceed with what they have.

0 coins

Hardship angle: if the pending weeks are stretching long and bills are becoming a real issue, CalFresh is worth looking into while you wait. Unemployment benefits count as income when you apply, but whether you'd be eligible depends on your household income and size — apply through BenefitsCal or call 1-877-847-3663. It doesn't affect your EDD claim at all.

0 coins

Didn't know CalFresh could overlap with an open unemployment claim. The "counted as income" piece means it might reduce what I'd get through CalFresh but it doesn't disqualify me from applying altogether?

0 coins

Whether unemployment income affects your CalFresh amount is the county's call — the application just asks for all income sources. You'd find out what your household qualifies for after they review it.

0 coins

One scenario worth preparing for: if EDD does issue a disqualification, the Notice of Determination will include the Appeal Form DE 1000M and the address to send it. The 30-day clock runs from the mailing date printed on the notice, not the day you receive it, so open it immediately when it arrives. If you disagree with the decision, write your appeal right away even if you don't have everything organized — you can always submit more documentation later but you can't get back a missed deadline.

0 coins

Opening the notice the day it arrives matters — I let a piece of EDD mail sit on my counter for almost a week once because I was dreading what it said, and I lost days off that 30-day window.

0 coins

Submitting the DE 1000M or even just a letter within the 30 days is the goal — it doesn't have to be a fully polished legal argument to start the appeal. Getting it in on time is the only thing that matters initially.

0 coins

Benefit year runs 52 weeks from the week you filed, not from when payments start. If the adjudication stretches long and payments are delayed by weeks or months, those weeks still count against the year. Something to factor in if you're thinking about how long your benefits might last once things clear up.

0 coins

The 52 weeks counting from the filing date, not from first payment, is a detail that catches people off guard especially when adjudication eats up weeks at the front of the claim.

0 coins

Filed about nine or ten weeks ago at this point. That timeline is ticking even while everything is pending, which I hadn't fully internalized until now.

0 coins

Maximum benefit amount is also capped at 26 times your weekly benefit amount or half your base period wages, whichever is less — so the weekly amount on the DE 429Z times 26 is roughly the most you'd see from the whole claim if everything clears.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure