Back to California Unemployment

Ava Martinez

UI overpayment options for paying it back how long does California EDD give you?

Got a Notice of Overpayment in the mail last week saying I owe $2,840 from claims I filed earlier this year. I reported my hours every time I certified, so I honestly have no idea how this happened, but here I am. The notice says it's non-fraud which I guess is good, but it doesn't really explain how long I have to pay it back or what my options even are. Can I do a payment plan? Is there a deadline where they start collecting from future benefits or tax refunds? And is there any point in asking for a waiver or is that basically impossible to get? I've been stressing about this all week trying to figure out what I'm actually supposed to do next.

Overpayment notice showed $3,180 on mine from last spring, also marked non-fraud, and I had the same panicked week you're having. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD — they handle the hold time for you so you end up talking to a live agent — and their video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see it first. The agent looked up my account and confirmed the balance, told me which weeks triggered it, and walked me through requesting a payment arrangement directly. I asked about the waiver too and the agent said EDD weighs whether repaying would be a real hardship and that I'd need to return the DE 1446UI form. So I sent that in along with a written payment arrangement request and I've been making monthly payments since. Nothing has been pulled from a tax refund yet.

0 coins

Which weeks triggered yours — was it because of wages you reported or something EDD recalculated on their end?

0 coins

EDD recalculated on their end based on my base period wages. The agent showed me which quarter they adjusted, but didn't explain why the original award was different. Sent in the DE 1446UI anyway.

0 coins

The DE 1446UI form for the waiver — did you get a decision back on it yet or is it still pending?

0 coins

Still pending as of last month. The agent said EDD would mail a decision and to keep making payments in the meantime so nothing goes to collections.

0 coins

Missed a wage on one of my certifications by accident last year and ended up with an overpayment notice for $1,190. What nobody told me at the time is that for a non-fraud overpayment there's no penalty on top of the balance — you just owe the amount on the notice. EDD can collect by taking from future unemployment, disability or Paid Family Leave payments, and also from state tax refunds, state lottery winnings, or other money the state owes you, and they can record a lien or get a court judgment. So it's not like it disappears, but they're not garnishing your paycheck. You can request a payment arrangement and also apply for a waiver on the DE 1446UI if repaying it would cause serious hardship and it genuinely wasn't your fault. The waiver isn't guaranteed, but it's worth submitting if your situation is tight.

0 coins

Does the payment arrangement stop them from pulling it from a tax refund while you're on the plan?

0 coins

EDD's pages don't spell that out, so I'd ask EDD directly when you request the arrangement. My refund didn't get touched while I was making payments, but I can't say that's a rule.

0 coins

Same question I had. When I set mine up the agent said to keep payments current and document everything, but didn't promise refunds were protected either.

0 coins

My overpayment was $2,100 and I went back and forth forever trying to figure out if I should appeal it or apply for the waiver or just pay it. The appeal route is for when you think EDD made a wrong call — you have 30 days from the mailing date on the Notice of Overpayment to file, using the DE 1000M or a written letter to the address on the notice. The waiver is different, that's for when you agree you were overpaid but it wasn't your fault and paying it back would be a real hardship. Those are two separate things and you can't really do both at the same time for the same reason. I didn't appeal because I knew I had been overpaid, so I went the waiver route with the DE 1446UI.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date — does that clock start from when they mailed it or when I actually received it?

0 coins

Mailing date on the notice itself, not when it showed up in your mailbox. So check the date printed on the letter, not the envelope postmark or when you opened it.

0 coins

Had no idea the appeal window runs from the mailing date. I almost waited too long on mine because I assumed it was from when I got it.

0 coins

Yeah that detail trips a lot of people up. If you're close to the 30 days, send something in writing right away even if it's just a brief letter explaining you disagree and need more time to gather documents.

0 coins

Payment arrangement process for me was pretty straightforward once I stopped assuming there was an online form for it. EDD doesn't have a self-service payment plan button in UI Online — you actually have to contact them and ask for a payment arrangement in writing or over the phone. I sent a message through my UI Online account explaining the amount I could realistically pay each month given my income, and they responded with the arrangement details. The key thing is to actually make those payments consistently because falling behind is what tends to trigger the more aggressive collection steps.

0 coins

Sent a message through UI Online? Did they respond back through the same account or did they mail something?

0 coins

They mailed a letter with the arrangement details. The UI Online message thread didn't have a direct reply, just a confirmation that my message was received.

0 coins

How long did it take them to respond to the UI Online message after you sent it?

0 coins

About three weeks before the letter came. If your 30-day appeal window is running short, don't wait on a message — phone them or appeal in writing to the address on the notice directly.

0 coins

My cousin told me fraud overpayments just get written off after a few years and my situation sounded similar so I didn't do anything for months. That was wrong and I want to flag it here. Non-fraud overpayments don't expire or get forgotten — EDD has multiple ways to collect: future benefits, state tax refunds, lottery winnings, liens, court judgments. I found out the hard way when my state tax refund got intercepted. The non-fraud label just means no extra penalty percentage on top of what you owe, that's the only difference it makes on the collection side.

0 coins

Wait, the refund just got taken without any warning? No notice first?

0 coins

There was a notice at some point but I honestly wasn't tracking my mail well during that period. EDD does send notices about collection actions. Lesson learned, open everything they send.

0 coins

The 30 percent penalty is only for fraud overpayments then? Because I've seen people on here say any overpayment has a penalty and that's not right.

0 coins

Correct — the 30 percent penalty and potential false statement disqualification only apply when EDD determined it was fraud. Non-fraud overpayments are just the base amount, no penalty added.

0 coins

Something that confused me for a while: reporting wages for a week you already certified wrong is different from the original overpayment. If you think you misreported a past week, you contact EDD — through a UI Online message or by phone — because Report Wages in UI Online only works out a week before you certify it, not to fix a week that's already submitted. I didn't know that and kept looking for a correction button in UI Online that doesn't exist.

0 coins

Does contacting EDD to correct a past week help at all with the overpayment amount, or does EDD still issue the full notice first and then adjust?

0 coins

EDD tends to calculate first and then you can dispute the amount in the appeal if the correction changes the math. Getting ahead of it by contacting them is still worth doing.

0 coins

The Report Wages screen in UI Online never did what I thought it did either. I kept thinking I could fix things there and I couldn't.

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail after my claim was filed and the weekly benefit amount on it looked right to me, but months later EDD recalculated and sent a $2,650 overpayment notice. I tried the EDD phone line for two weeks and kept hitting the same wall, so I went through Claimyr to get a live agent on the line. The agent pulled up my claim and explained that EDD had adjusted which quarter they used for my base period calculation, and the difference between what was paid and the corrected amount was what I owed. I asked about a payment plan and the agent noted my request. The DE 1446UI was my next step because the recalculation was not something I could have caught on my own.

0 coins

EDD recalculated your base period after already sending the DE 429Z? How does that happen — did they find wages they missed the first time?

0 coins

The agent said a discrepancy came up in my wage records, but didn't get into the specifics of which employer filed what. EDD sorted it and the new calculation was lower.

0 coins

Base period adjustments causing overpayments seem to be more common than people think. Mine was the same situation — EDD found wages in a quarter I didn't even know counted.

0 coins

STILL waiting on a waiver decision from eight months ago and every time I check UI Online there's nothing about it, the status isn't reflected anywhere I can find. This whole process is designed to make you give up. I keep making payments because I don't want a lien but it's exhausting paying something I genuinely should qualify for a waiver on. The hardship is real and documented and I returned the DE 1446UI with everything they asked for.

0 coins

Eight months with no waiver decision — have you tried following up through UI Online messages or only been waiting for mail?

0 coins

Both. Sent two UI Online messages and called twice. Nobody can tell me where in the process it is, just that it's under review.

0 coins

The waiver process seems to take forever for everyone. Friend of mine waited almost a year. Keep those payment records because if it gets approved they should credit what you've paid.

0 coins

Nobody talks about the fact that you need to keep certifying during an appeal if you're still eligible. Stopped certifying when I got my overpayment notice because I thought having an open dispute meant I should wait, and that was a mistake — EDD can only pay back weeks that were actually certified. The appeal and the certification process run parallel, they don't pause each other.

0 coins

Are you saying you were still eligible for new weeks of benefits when you got the overpayment notice? I stopped certifying too thinking the same thing.

0 coins

If your benefit year is still open and you're still eligible week to week, you certify. The overpayment notice doesn't close your claim or pause your ability to certify.

0 coins

Overpayment notice came while I was still in my benefit year and I had the same confusion. Ended up phoning EDD through Claimyr to ask whether my remaining weeks were still accessible. The agent confirmed my claim was still open and my balance was intact, and I started certifying again the same week. Definitely contact EDD if you're unsure rather than just stopping.

0 coins

Glad someone said this clearly. The overpayment doesn't automatically close the claim — EDD handles them as separate things.

0 coins

Waiver eligibility question that keeps coming up wrong in these threads: the waiver isn't just about hardship. EDD has to find that the overpayment was not your fault AND that repaying would be a real hardship. Both conditions together, not just one. Someone on a different thread was told they'd definitely get a waiver because they had no income, but that's only half the picture. If EDD thinks you caused the overpayment even a little, the waiver may not go through.

0 coins

The 'not your fault' piece — does EDD define that anywhere, or is it judgment call on their part?

0 coins

EDD decides case by case. The DE 1446UI asks you to explain the circumstances and EDD weighs it. No published threshold I've ever found.

0 coins

Honestly more people should read this before filing the waiver assuming it's automatic. The dual condition is news to me and I've been on this forum for two years.

0 coins

Payment options as I understand them from my own experience dealing with a $1,980 notice: you can pay the full amount at once, you can request a payment arrangement if you can't pay in full, or you can apply for the waiver on the DE 1446UI. Those aren't mutually exclusive on the arrangement and waiver side — sending in the waiver doesn't stop you from making payments, and making payments doesn't disqualify you from the waiver. The worst position to be in is ignoring it entirely, because that's when the tax refund intercepts and lien stuff starts.

0 coins

Can you request the payment arrangement through UI Online or does it have to be a phone call?

0 coins

UI Online message worked for me. Some people here had to follow up by phone when the message didn't get a fast enough response, so both options exist.

0 coins

Sent a message through UI Online for my arrangement request and also mailed a letter to the address on the notice just to have something on paper. Having both felt safer.

0 coins

Fraud classification question since someone earlier mentioned the 30 percent penalty: EDD marks an overpayment as fraud when they find you gave false information or intentionally withheld something. If EDD classified yours as fraud, the penalty is 30 percent on top of the amount owed and there can also be a false statement disqualification of anywhere from 2 to 23 weeks. That's a very different situation from a non-fraud notice, and the waiver option on DE 1446UI is for non-fraud only. Worth reading your notice carefully to confirm which category yours is.

0 coins

The false statement disqualification — is that on top of the repayment or instead of it?

0 coins

On top. The disqualification means future weeks of benefits are withheld, and you still owe the balance. They're separate consequences.

0 coins

This is why the fraud vs. non-fraud distinction on the notice matters so much. If yours says fraud and you think that's wrong, appeal within 30 days.

0 coins

Tried to find a payment portal on EDD's site for about an hour when my notice came. There isn't one. EDD collects through benefit offsets automatically, through tax refund intercepts, or through arrangements you have to request manually. The absence of a self-service payment option is incredibly frustrating but that's how it works right now. Phone or UI Online message is how you initiate an arrangement.

0 coins

Why is there no online payment portal for something this common? Like EDD has to know that overpayments are a constant thing.

0 coins

No idea, but it's been this way for years based on everything I've read. The whole EDD technology situation is a whole conversation.

0 coins

I read somewhere that EDD was building an overpayment payment system into UI Online but it still wasn't live as of when I checked edd.ca.gov. For now, manual request is still the path.

0 coins

Read the mailing date on that notice carefully because the 30-day appeal window is not long and it moves fast. My notice came during a stressful week and I nearly lost the window. If anything on the overpayment calculation looks wrong — wrong weeks, wrong amounts, wages they shouldn't have included or excluded — appeal in writing to the address on the notice using the DE 1000M or just a clear letter. The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and an administrative law judge handles the hearing. You can represent yourself, bring a union rep, or bring an attorney.

0 coins

If I appeal and lose, does the amount I owe stay the same or can it go higher after a hearing?

0 coins

The judge's decision is on the overpayment determination, not an opportunity for EDD to add to it. If you lose you still owe the original amount, nothing gets added for appealing.

0 coins

Also worth knowing: if you appeal, keep making payments or at least have a plan in place, because waiting for the hearing outcome doesn't pause the balance.

0 coins

Got hit with an overpayment because EDD reconsidered my eligibility for a week I had already been paid for. Didn't realize until the notice came that the original payment wasn't a final approval — EDD can revisit and issue an overpayment notice even after a week shows as paid in UI Online. The notice itself is what triggers everything: the 30-day appeal window, the waiver option, the payment arrangement process. Everything starts from that document.

0 coins

EDD reconsidered your eligibility — was that because of a phone interview that happened after the payment, or something else?

0 coins

There was a delayed employer response. EDD reopened the eligibility question after my former employer replied to the original claim notice, and after their review they issued the overpayment notice for that week.

0 coins

Former employers can respond late and trigger a whole new review? Didn't know that was possible this far down the road.

0 coins

EDD's pages say the employer has 10 days from the date on the claim notice to respond, but late responses still happen and EDD handles them. Had no idea until it showed up on my notice.

0 coins

DE 1446UI waiver form asks about your income, expenses and assets, and you have to show it would be a real hardship to pay back the amount. When I filled mine out I included everything — utility bills, rent, car payment, what I had in savings — and explained in the written section how the overpayment happened and why I had no way of knowing there was a problem when I certified. The more specific and documented the explanation, the stronger the submission. Generic statements about being broke don't carry the same weight as actual numbers.

0 coins

Did you attach bank statements and bills or just list the numbers on the form?

0 coins

Attached everything. Statements, a few months of bills, a written summary. Felt like overkill but I wanted EDD to see the actual picture.

0 coins

Specific documentation is the right call. EDD is weighing a real hardship determination, not just taking your word for it.

0 coins

Pension income and whether it affects the balance on an overpayment notice came up in a conversation with an EDD agent I reached through Claimyr — my situation involved retirement pay that started mid-claim, and I needed to know if it changed what I owed or how EDD would calculate a payment plan. The agent confirmed the balance on the notice was fixed based on the weeks already determined, and that pension income is something EDD considers when it looks at ongoing eligibility, not in recalculating a past overpayment balance. That cleared up a lot of confusion for me about whether the number could change.

0 coins

Does pension income get reported when you certify the same way wages do?

0 coins

The agent said to report it as the certification asks, and EDD decides how it affects each week. I reported mine and EDD adjusted accordingly in the weeks after.

0 coins

Pension reducing benefits during active certifications is a separate thing from an already-established overpayment balance — glad that distinction got clarified here.

0 coins

Something people skip over: the Notice of Overpayment has the address you need for any written response — appeal letter, waiver form, payment arrangement request. All of it goes to that address. I sent the DE 1446UI to the wrong EDD office initially because I looked up a general address online instead of using the one on the actual notice. It delayed everything by weeks.

0 coins

Every response goes to the exact address printed on the notice, not a general EDD mailing address — is that always true or only for appeals?

0 coins

For anything related to that specific overpayment notice — appeal, waiver, payment arrangement request — use the address on the notice. For general account questions, UI Online message or the main phone line works, but anything tied to that notice goes there.

0 coins

Wrote the wrong address on my first appeal letter too. If EDD sends it back as undeliverable you can refile but you lose time on the 30-day window.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure