Back to California Unemployment

Steven Adams

Paid unemployment weeks I did not certify for after returning to work - what does California EDD want back?

So I went back to work in mid-September and figured my unemployment claim was just done. Didn't certify for the weeks after my start date, didn't reopen anything, just assumed it closed itself out. Fast forward to last week and I got a Notice of Overpayment in the mail saying EDD paid me for three weeks I supposedly certified for AFTER my return-to-work date. The dollar amount they're claiming is $1,140. Thing is, I genuinely don't remember certifying for those weeks, and I was working full-time the whole time. My employer's payroll records would show that. I'm panicking because the notice mentions possible fraud implications and I don't even understand how I could have been paid for weeks I didn't think I certified for. Has anyone dealt with something like this? Do I fight it, pay it, or what?

DE 1080CZ in hand with a fraud flag is genuinely alarming to get in the mail. The first thing to sort out is whether EDD is calling it fraud or non-fraud, because that changes everything about what comes next. Non-fraud overpayments have to be repaid but there's no penalty on top. Fraud ones carry a 30 percent penalty and can go further than that. The notice itself will say which category they put it in. If you're certain you didn't certify after going back, pull your Claim History in UI Online and look at which weeks show as paid. Then check your bank or Money Network card records for when deposits hit. If the deposits happened but you never touched the certification screen, that's something worth raising in an appeal.

0 coins

Claim History is showing three paid weeks starting September 15th. My first day back was September 17th so one of those weeks overlaps. The other two are fully after I was back full-time. Deposits did hit my Money Network card for all three. I'm so confused about how that happened without me doing anything.

0 coins

Payments hitting the card when you didn't certify is a red flag that someone else may have accessed your account, or EDD processed something incorrectly on their end. Either way, document the deposits and their dates before you do anything else.

0 coins

Exactly what the person above said. If those weeks certified without your login, that's a totally different situation than you forgetting you did it. Screenshot everything in UI Online now.

0 coins

Employer payroll records showing you clocked in full-time those weeks are probably your strongest evidence if you appeal. The appeal window is 30 calendar days from the mailing date printed on the DE 1080CZ, so count that date carefully. You send the Appeal Form DE 1000M or just a letter to the address on the notice. The California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board handles it after EDD reviews it first. Keep certifying for any other open weeks during the appeal, by the way, otherwise EDD can't pay back weeks even if you win.

0 coins

Appeal form is DE 1000M, got it. The mailing date on mine is November 3rd so I think I have until December 3rd. What do I actually write in the appeal? Just explain I was working full-time and didn't certify?

0 coins

Write exactly what happened in plain language: when you returned to work, that you did not certify for the weeks after that date, and that your employer records confirm full-time employment. Attach anything you have. The clearer and more specific the better.

0 coins

Definitely include your pay stubs or even a letter from HR if you can get one fast. Dates matter a lot in these hearings.

0 coins

November on my claim, UI Online showed a paid status on two weeks I had not touched since starting a warehouse job October 2nd. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent after the hold music kept cutting me off - there's a video on how to reach a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and told me EDD had received a certification under my login for those weeks, with dates I definitely wasn't home. She flagged my account for a security review and told me to change my myEDD password immediately, then said a Notice of Determination would come by mail after they finished looking at it. Filed a police report the same afternoon just to have documentation.

0 coins

Wait, so EDD showed a certification under YOUR login but you didn't do it? That's exactly what I'm worried happened with mine. Did they clear the overpayment once they finished the review?

0 coins

The determination letter came about three weeks after the agent flagged it. EDD cleared the two weeks because the IP address on those certifications didn't match any device I'd ever used on my account. Keep everything documented.

0 coins

Password on myEDD and changing the security questions right away is smart regardless. If someone got into your account even once, assume they still have the credentials.

0 coins

Fully working full-time ends your eligibility for that week, no matter what your earnings are. That part is pretty clear. But the question here isn't really about the earnings rules, it's about whether those certifications actually came from you. If you genuinely didn't certify, the burden of EDD's claim is shaky. An appeal puts that in front of an administrative law judge who can look at the actual certification records.

0 coins

Adjudication and appeal get mixed up all the time but they're different steps. Adjudication is EDD deciding before they issue a Notice of Determination. Once that notice is out, the next step is the formal appeal to CUIAB. The overpayment notice IS a Notice of Determination, so the OP is already at the appeal stage.

0 coins

Correct, and the judge can subpoena EDD's records including login metadata if the case gets that far. That kind of technical evidence has cleared overpayments before.

0 coins

Login metadata - I didn't even know that existed. So the appeal hearing could actually dig into whether the certifications came from my device?

0 coins

Missed a step myself early on and ended up with a mess to clean up. After going back to work part-time I kept certifying without reporting the wages properly, thinking I had to report them the week I got paid rather than the week I actually worked. That mistake cost me because EDD expects wages reported for the week they were earned. By the time I figured it out I had two weeks reported wrong and had to contact EDD through a UI Online message to fix them. Report Wages in UI Online only works before you certify a week, not after. If the OP somehow certified and forgot to report the full-time wages, that's a separate but related issue to sort out.

0 coins

Reporting wages for the week earned vs. the week paid is something I didn't know either. But my situation is different - I genuinely believe I never certified those weeks at all. I wasn't even logging into myEDD after I started the new job.

0 coins

Wages when earned, not when paid, tripped me up too. Vacation payout from my old job hit the week after I filed and I almost reported it in the wrong week.

0 coins

Vacation pay, holiday pay, severance - EDD has a whole list of things to report on the certification screen. Severance in particular still gets reported as the form asks even though EDD's rules say it generally doesn't disqualify you; EDD makes the final call on how it affects the payment.

0 coins

MY EMPLOYER submitted something that caused weeks to pay out without me certifying, happened to two people I know. EDD got confused between two accounts with similar info and paid the wrong one. These are NOT edge cases, the system just does this sometimes and then YOU get the overpayment notice even though you did nothing wrong. APPEAL EVERYTHING and don't let them intimidate you with the word fraud.

0 coins

EDD mixing up accounts is rare but it has happened. Definitely appeal and ask for the specific certification records they're relying on.

0 coins

They sent one of my coworkers a bill for $2,300 and when he appealed the judge found out EDD had pulled from the wrong Social Security number. Took four months but it got reversed.

0 coins

Before the appeal hearing itself, there's usually a step where EDD reviews it internally. Sometimes overpayments get cleared at that stage without ever going in front of a judge. When you file the DE 1000M, write clearly that you dispute the certifications were made by you and that you are requesting the certification records for those weeks. That puts EDD on notice that you want the documentation, and they have to bring it to the review.

0 coins

Can I literally write that on the appeal form? Just say I'm requesting the certification records?

0 coins

Absolutely. The appeal form has a space for your statement. Write in plain language that you deny certifying those weeks, state your return-to-work date, and request the records EDD used to issue those payments. Keep a copy of everything you mail.

0 coins

Sending it certified mail with return receipt is worth the extra couple dollars so you have proof of when it was delivered.

0 coins

Severance pay from my previous employer landed during my claim and my account ended up with a pending week I didn't understand. Eventually got a live EDD agent on the phone through Claimyr after trying the main line three days in a row - the agent explained that my severance had been flagged for review and walked me through which weeks were affected on my account, then told me to watch for a letter. For the person posting about unauthorized certifications: the agent I reached said EDD can see device and login information on certifications. That's the specific detail to push on in your appeal.

0 coins

Device and login info - that's exactly what I need them to pull. If someone else certified under my account from a different device that should be provable.

0 coins

Severance getting flagged for review is so common. Mine held up two weeks and all I needed to do was wait for EDD to finish reviewing it, but nobody tells you that upfront.

0 coins

The pending weeks resolved after the letter came. Waiting with no explanation is the worst part.

0 coins

Chiming in because I see a lot of people say to just pay it and move on to avoid trouble. That's the wrong move if you genuinely didn't certify. Paying an overpayment is treated by EDD as an admission that the amount was correctly owed. If you believe the certifications weren't done by you, fight it. The worst outcome of a losing appeal is you still owe the money - same as if you hadn't appealed.

0 coins

I did not know that paying could be seen as an admission. That actually makes me more confident I should appeal.

0 coins

Retail job ended and my hours got cut to zero the week before the layoff was official - ended up with an overpayment notice too, though mine was clearly a timing issue on my end. Spent two weeks trying to get through to EDD before finally reaching an agent through Claimyr; she told me EDD had coded the separation date wrong which is why the system kept issuing payments. The agent noted the correction on my account and said to expect a revised determination. My situation was different from possible unauthorized access but the point about appealing stands - paying doesn't make the dispute go away, it just closes your options.

0 coins

Exactly. And the waiver option - DE 1446UI - only applies if the overpayment wasn't your fault AND wasn't fraud. So if EDD is calling this fraud, a waiver isn't available yet. Getting the fraud designation removed first through the appeal is the priority.

0 coins

Nonfraud vs. fraud matters a ton for a waiver too. DE 1446UI is the Application for Overpayment Waiver and EDD weighs whether repaying would be an extraordinary hardship. But a waiver is totally separate from an appeal - the appeal challenges whether you owe the money at all, the waiver asks EDD to forgive collecting it even if you do owe it. Both are worth knowing about but start with the appeal.

0 coins

So I could potentially appeal AND apply for a waiver at the same time, or should I wait on one?

0 coins

Appeal first, since you're disputing that you certified at all. If the appeal doesn't go your way, then look at the waiver. Doing both simultaneously isn't necessarily wrong but the appeal resolves the core question faster.

0 coins

My sister told me to just pay mine and I really wish I'd appealed instead. Ended up repaying $870 for weeks where I genuinely had no wages to report. Lesson learned the hard way.

0 coins

Phone interview getting confused with the appeal hearing is really common in these threads and I want to clear that up. A phone interview is what EDD schedules when there's a question about your original eligibility - they send you a DE 4800 notice with the date and time, and the interviewer phones at that exact time. An appeal hearing is a formal proceeding before an administrative law judge at the CUIAB, which happens AFTER EDD issues a Notice of Determination. Those are two completely different things. For an overpayment, you're in appeal territory, not interview territory.

0 coins

DE 4800 for the phone interview, DE 1000M for the appeal form - keeping those straight helps a lot.

0 coins

Genuinely wish someone had explained this to me when I first got a determination. Called the number on the DE 4800 thinking it was for an appeal and completely confused the EDD rep.

0 coins

The DE 4800 also lists the questions likely to come up in the interview, which most people overlook. Reading it ahead of time makes the interview less stressful.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration has nothing to do with an overpayment situation, but just flagging for anyone reading this who is still on a current active claim - most claimants have to register and post a resume in CalJOBS within 21 days of the date on the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work. Missing that can stop your payments even if everything else is fine. It's a separate thing to stay on top of while you're dealing with any other EDD issues.

0 coins

CalJOBS almost got me because I didn't even know I had to do it. My first payment held because I hadn't registered yet.

0 coins

EDD does tell claimants if they don't need to register, so if you didn't get a notice about it, you might be exempt. But if you got the DE 8405, don't ignore it.

0 coins

Something worth knowing: keeping certifying during an appeal was already mentioned but let me add WHY. If EDD rules in your favor later, they can only release payment for weeks that were actually certified. Skip the certifications while your appeal is pending and you lose those weeks forever, even if you win. For the person posting - if your benefit year is still open and you stopped working again at some point, that matters.

0 coins

My benefit year should still technically be open since my claim started in July. But I'm fully employed now so there's nothing to certify for currently. This situation is just the overpayment notice from those September weeks.

0 coins

Got it, so the appeal is purely about disputing the September weeks. That actually simplifies things. You don't have an ongoing certification issue to manage at the same time.

0 coins

Tried calling EDD at 1-800-300-5616 eight times over three days about an adjudication hold on my account. Mornings, right at 8am, afternoons - couldn't get through. Eventually sent a message through my UI Online account using the message option and an agent responded within two days. For something like a potential account breach, the UI Online message might actually be faster than the phone since you can explain everything in writing and they have it documented on their end.

0 coins

UI Online message is an option I hadn't thought of. Would that be better than the phone for raising the unauthorized access issue?

0 coins

For something you want documented, written is usually better. It creates a paper trail. Phone calls happen but there's no record attached to your account the way a written message is.

0 coins

Sending a UI Online message AND mailing the appeal form covers both. Gives EDD notice through two channels.

0 coins

Separation date got coded wrong on my claim after a layoff - EDD kept showing one week as pending for a reason I couldn't figure out from the Claim History screen. The hold went on for three weeks. DE 429Z had arrived and everything looked fine on paper but that one week wouldn't move. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr on a Thursday morning and she found that the separation date in EDD's system was off by four days, which was making that week flag as potentially ineligible. She updated it and told me to watch for the payment to process. The separation date issue is different from unauthorized certifications but the broader point is that EDD's system can have errors that look like claimant mistakes when they're not.

0 coins

EDD's own data entry errors causing these notices is something I hadn't fully considered. So it's possible EDD's records just show wrong information about who certified, not that someone actually accessed my account?

0 coins

That's one possibility. EDD's systems have had processing glitches where payments issued without a standard certification step going through correctly. The appeal is the right move either way because it forces EDD to show their actual records.

0 coins

System error vs. unauthorized access vs. claimant-forgot: all three scenarios point to the same first move, which is appeal and request the certification records. The records will tell you which situation you're actually in.

0 coins

Administrative law judge hearings at CUIAB are less formal than people expect. Testimony is under oath but you can represent yourself. You can bring a union rep or an attorney if you want but it's not required. The judge gets the evidence from both sides and issues a written decision by mail. If you lose at that level there's a second-level appeal to the full CUIAB board. For a first-time claimant dealing with an overpayment, going in and explaining clearly what happened is completely doable without a lawyer.

0 coins

Knowing I can represent myself is actually a relief. I was worried this was going to cost me money to fight on top of the overpayment itself.

0 coins

The appeal is free to file. The only cost is your time preparing it. And the written decision comes by mail after the hearing, so you're not waiting around for an in-person verdict.

0 coins

The notice of hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before the hearing date, so you do have time to prepare once it's scheduled.

0 coins

Quick timeline question for anyone who's been through this - how long between mailing the DE 1000M and actually getting a hearing date? I'm dealing with a different overpayment issue (I reported wages in the wrong weeks, totally my fault, trying to see if a waiver is an option) and trying to plan around when this might actually get resolved.

0 coins

The hearing timeline varies and EDD's pages don't publish a standard number. What's public is that the Notice of Hearing arrives at least 10 days before the actual hearing. After mailing the appeal, the internal EDD review happens first before it goes to CUIAB.

0 coins

Waiver is DE 1446UI and I already found it, just hadn't submitted it yet. The agent at EDD when I finally got through told me EDD weighs both whether it was my fault and whether repaying is an extraordinary hardship. It's not guaranteed at all.

0 coins

Waiver and appeal are separate tracks. The waiver form is worth submitting even while an appeal is pending, since they evaluate it independently.

0 coins

Fraud finding on an overpayment notice adds 30 percent on top of the base amount owed and can mean a false statement disqualification anywhere from 2 weeks up to 23 weeks on a future claim. That's a serious consequence and worth fighting hard if you genuinely didn't certify. If EDD eventually determines it was non-fraud, the penalty disappears and you're just dealing with the repayment itself, possibly with a waiver if hardship qualifies.

0 coins

30 percent penalty on $1,140 is another $342. That's real money I definitely don't want to pay if I never actually certified those weeks.

0 coins

The false statement disqualification affecting future claims is honestly the scarier part. Even if you paid every dollar back, those penalty weeks follow you into your next claim.

0 coins

Both consequences clear if the fraud finding gets reversed on appeal. The goal of the appeal is getting EDD to reclassify this as either non-fraud or no overpayment at all.

0 coins

Came back here to give the update someone asked for earlier in this thread: got my determination letter three weeks after filing the appeal. EDD reversed the fraud finding and reclassified it as non-fraud, which wiped the 30 percent penalty. Still owe the base amount but I applied for the DE 1446UI waiver the same day. Waiting to hear on that now.

0 coins

This is genuinely good to hear. Fraud reversed to non-fraud means the waiver is at least possible. Good luck on the waiver decision.

0 coins

Hardship documentation they look for is financial: income, expenses, dependents. Have everything ready when you submit DE 1446UI because they'll ask for it.

0 coins

Fraud to non-fraud reversal is a real outcome and it's why appealing matters even if you think you might owe some of it.

0 coins

Last thing to flag: the DE 429Z that arrives after you apply shows what your claim could pay, but it's not an approval of eligibility. Some people treat it as a final answer and stop watching their account. The actual eligibility decision for each week only happens after certifying and EDD processing it. That distinction matters here because weeks that paid without a clear certification record are going to be scrutinized closely in an appeal.

0 coins

DE 429Z as an approval gets misread constantly. Mine said $380 weekly and I thought that meant I was approved, but EDD still had to process each certified week separately.

0 coins

Exactly. The DE 429Z is basically EDD saying here's what a valid claim would pay if each week is eligible. Each week still has to be certified and pass EDD's review.

0 coins

Mine showed $380 a week too. Knowing now that weeks still need to pass review makes the September payments even stranger - if I didn't certify, something in EDD's system issued them anyway.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure