Back to California Unemployment

Jibriel Kohn

Notice of overpayment how to check the overpayment amount before repaying California EDD

Got a Notice of Overpayment in the mail from EDD last week and I honestly don't know what to do. The letter says I owe money back but I want to make sure the amount they're claiming is actually right before I send a single dollar. Like, is there a way to see the breakdown of exactly which weeks they're counting, what I was paid, and how they calculated what I supposedly owe? I reported everything I was supposed to when I certified - my part-time hours, what I earned each week - so I'm not even sure how this overpayment happened. The number on the notice is $2,100 and it feels like it came out of nowhere. I've been trying to compare it to what I see in UI Online but I'm not sure I'm looking in the right place. Has anyone else gone through this and figured out how to verify the amount before deciding whether to pay or appeal?

Layoffs at my company hit in waves and my second round of UI had a week that showed pending for two months before EDD sent me their own overpayment notice for $1,870. Getting anyone on the phone felt impossible - hold music for an hour and then a disconnect. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live agent on the line. The video that shows how reaching a live person at EDD actually goes is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which two weeks the overpayment covered and that I had until the date on my notice to file a waiver or appeal if I disagreed. She also said the Claim History screen in UI Online would show the payment amounts for those weeks so I could check the math myself.

0 coins

Claim History in UI Online - that's where I should be looking? I've been clicking around Payments tab but maybe I need to be on a different screen. Going to check right now, thank you.

0 coins

How long did it take to actually get to an agent once you were through the hold part? I've been trying for three days on my own claim.

0 coins

The agent picked up and I got the information I needed about which weeks were flagged - that's the main thing. After that I pulled up Claim History myself to cross-reference.

0 coins

What week numbers are listed on the notice itself? The overpayment notice should actually spell out the period in question - mine had a table showing each week start date, what EDD paid out, and what it calculated I should have gotten instead. The difference column was the overpayment amount per week and they all added up to the total. If yours doesn't have that detail you can look at Claim History in UI Online and match the week dates on the notice to your payment history there.

0 coins

Mine just has a lump sum total and says the period but no week-by-week table. That's why I'm confused - I can't tell which specific week they think was overpaid.

0 coins

Did your notice come with an appeal form? They should include the DE 1000M. If the breakdown isn't in the letter, calling EDD to get the week-by-week detail before the 30-day window closes is probably the move.

0 coins

DE 1000M should definitely be attached. If the breakdown really isn't on yours, checking Claim History then calling to ask for the week detail is the right call. Don't let time run out before you understand what you're disputing.

0 coins

Can I ask what kind of income you had during those weeks? The reason I'm asking is my overpayment came from part-time earnings that I did report, but EDD applied them to the wrong week - I earned the money one week and got paid by my employer the following Friday, and I put it on the wrong certification. EDD counts wages in the week they're earned, not when you get the check. That tripped me up and caused my overpayment notice.

0 coins

That's actually exactly what might have happened with me. I had a few shifts where my paycheck came the week after I worked. I think I reported the money the week I got paid, not the week I worked the shifts.

0 coins

Wages go on the week you earned them, not when the paycheck arrives - yes that's correct and it catches a lot of people off guard. The good news is that's usually not fraud, it's a reporting mistake, which matters a lot for whether a waiver is possible.

0 coins

DE 1446UI is the waiver form if you want to go that route. It's for when the overpayment wasn't your fault and wasn't fraud. Hardship is part of what they weigh so the form asks about your finances.

0 coins

Why wouldn't you just pay it and be done though? Genuine question. Is there a reason to push back if EDD says you owe it?

0 coins

Verifying the amount first is just basic due diligence. EDD makes mistakes too and you have 30 days from the mailing date on the notice to appeal if the amount is wrong. After that window closes, disputing it is much harder.

0 coins

Fair point, didn't think about the deadline angle. So the clock is running from the mailing date even if you just got it.

0 coins

Mailing date is what matters for the 30-day window, not when you open it or when it arrives. So if the notice was mailed a week ago you're already a week into your window.

0 coins

EDD!!! sent me an overpayment notice for $2,400 and when I finally got someone on the phone they found out one of my employers had reported my wages twice - like double-entered them. The amount on my notice was completely wrong. So YES verify before you pay anything because sometimes it's their data that's off not yours.

0 coins

This is exactly why I wanted to check first. The thought that an employer could report wages incorrectly and that becomes my problem is infuriating.

0 coins

IT TOOK WEEKS to sort out but it did eventually get corrected. Keep copies of everything. Your pay stubs are your best proof.

0 coins

Employer reporting errors happen more than people realize. The notice EDD gets from the employer goes into the system automatically and if there's a discrepancy it comes back on the claimant first.

0 coins

Something that might help - Claim History in UI Online actually shows each individual week's payment amount and status. If you go through every week covered in the overpayment period you can build your own spreadsheet of what you got paid versus what you think you should have gotten. Then compare it line by line to whatever the notice says.

0 coins

Spreadsheet approach makes sense. I did my own math based on the earnings I reported and the offset formula EDD uses and it's not matching the number on my notice. That's exactly why I want to understand it before paying.

0 coins

What formula did you use? I'm in a similar situation and want to make sure I'm calculating correctly.

0 coins

From what I understand - your weekly benefit amount, subtract anything over the first $25 or 25% of gross earnings whichever is bigger. But I could be getting it wrong which is another reason to call EDD and get the agent to walk through it.

0 coins

The math in your third reply is essentially right for partial weeks. For a full week of work earnings don't get offset they just disqualify you for that week entirely regardless of the dollar amount.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the overpayment amount on the notice includes penalties? Mine showed up with a 30 percent penalty on top and I wasn't expecting that. I had no idea they could add that.

0 coins

Whether penalties apply depends on whether EDD classified it as fraud or non-fraud. When they say you intentionally gave false information or hid something on purpose they can add a 30 percent penalty on top of the overpayment amount. A non-fraud overpayment - like a reporting mistake - doesn't carry the penalty but you still owe the principal back.

0 coins

They marked mine as fraud which feels wrong. I didn't intentionally hide anything. Can that be appealed too?

0 coins

Appealing the determination is absolutely an option. The DE 1000M form or a written letter to the address on your notice, within 30 days. If you genuinely made an honest mistake and have documentation - pay stubs, your certification history - that's your evidence. The burden in a fraud finding is on EDD to show it was intentional.

0 coins

Okay that's helpful. I thought once they said fraud that was final. Going to send my appeal in this week.

0 coins

Adjudication on my claim got reopened when the overpayment notice came and I couldn't find out why from just the letter. Three weeks of back-and-forth messages through UI Online with no real answer. Eventually I used Claimyr to get through to someone at EDD and the agent told me my employer had contested two of my certified weeks after the fact and that those were the weeks on the notice. Knowing that I could actually pull my records for those specific weeks and decide whether to appeal or apply for a waiver.

0 coins

Employer contesting weeks after the claim is paid out - I didn't know that was even possible. If that's what happened with mine I really need to understand it before doing anything.

0 coins

Employers can respond to EDD's notice and contest eligibility even after initial payment has gone through. That's why overpayment notices can appear out of nowhere months after everything seemed fine.

0 coins

My specific weeks were ones where my employer said I wasn't available for work, which I disputed because I was. The agent just told me EDD had the employer's response on file and that the interview would sort it out - but at least I knew what I was dealing with.

0 coins

My situation is a little different - I got a notice and thought I had to file a whole new appeal in court. Someone here corrected me and explained it's just a written appeal sent to the address on the notice. The form DE 1000M makes it straightforward.

0 coins

Court gets involved only if you go all the way to a second-level appeal with the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. The first step is just mailing that form or a letter to EDD. An administrative law judge handles the hearing.

0 coins

Okay that makes me feel way less stressed about it. I thought I was going to need a lawyer just to dispute the amount.

0 coins

You can represent yourself at the hearing. Anyone can actually - you, a union rep, an attorney, it's your call. The notice of hearing comes at least 10 days before so you have time to prepare.

0 coins

Before you do anything else - read every line of that notice carefully. Mine had the mailing date buried in the header and I almost miscounted my 30 days starting from when I received it. Don't use the date you got it, use the date it was mailed, that's what starts your clock.

0 coins

Good catch - I've been counting from when I got it in my mailbox. Going to find the mailing date on the notice header right now.

0 coins

Mine had it in small print near the top right. After I found it I realized I had only 19 days left instead of the 26 I thought I had. Really glad I figured it out before it was too late.

0 coins

Pension income question on the side - when I was sorting out my own overpayment notice last year I also needed to check whether a pension I started receiving mid-claim had been counted. Getting the detail on that required actually talking to someone, so I used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent walked me through which weeks the pension offset had been applied to and by how much. That let me verify the notice amount matched what their system showed.

0 coins

Is filing for a waiver the same as appealing the overpayment? I keep seeing both mentioned and I'm not sure if you can do both or if picking one cancels the other.

0 coins

They're different and you can pursue both but for different reasons. Appealing says the overpayment amount or determination is wrong - you're contesting whether you actually owe it. A waiver says yes I owe it but I shouldn't have to repay it because it wasn't my fault and paying it back would cause real financial hardship. The form for the waiver is DE 1446UI. If you think the amount on your notice is incorrect, appeal first.

0 coins

So appeal if the number is wrong, waiver if the number is right but I genuinely can't pay it back. Got it.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you appeal and win, the waiver question becomes moot. If you appeal and lose, you can still try the waiver path depending on your circumstances.

0 coins

What happens to your ongoing claim while all this is being sorted out? I'm still certifying and I don't want EDD to just start taking money out of my current benefits without warning.

0 coins

EDD can and does collect overpayments from future UI benefits if you don't set up repayment or file an appeal. Keep certifying - stopping would just create more pending weeks and make things worse. But knowing that they might start withholding from your current payments is a reason to get this sorted quickly.

0 coins

That's a little terrifying honestly. So I could certify and then see a reduced payment because they're pulling the overpayment out?

0 coins

It's possible yes. They can also collect from state tax refunds and other state payments. The notice should say what their intended collection method is, or at minimum give a contact to arrange repayment before they start withholding.

0 coins

My overpayment notice came for a week I hadn't even certified - turns out EDD had automatically reopened a week that was already paid and recalculated it after my employer submitted corrected wage data. I had no idea the employer could submit corrected data after my claim was paid. Spent two weeks thinking I had made an error when it was entirely the employer's correction.

0 coins

Employer submitting corrected wages after the fact causing a ripple back to your claim - that's wild. And then EDD sends you the overpayment notice like you're the one who did something wrong.

0 coins

My pay stubs showed the original amounts. The employer had to submit a written correction to EDD to fix it. Took about six weeks total but the overpayment was eventually reversed.

0 coins

SAME thing happened to a coworker of mine. Keep all your pay stubs and your original offer letter. When the employer submits corrected data you need something to counter it with.

0 coins

Has anyone tried the live chat option in UI Online for overpayment questions? I haven't used it personally but I know there's a Help button that lets you chat with an agent Monday through Friday 9 to 2. Might be a faster way to get the week breakdown than waiting on hold.

0 coins

UI Online live chat is only available once you're logged in, right? I tried to find it from the main EDD page and couldn't. Had to go into my actual claim.

0 coins

You're right, it's inside UI Online through the Help button, not on the main EDD site. That's the only place it shows up.

0 coins

Going to try the chat approach tomorrow morning when it opens. If I can get the week-by-week breakdown from an agent that way it'll save a lot of back and forth.

0 coins

Just want to flag something for anyone reading this thread - there's a difference between verifying the amount and disputing it. You can call EDD, ask an agent to walk you through the calculation, and confirm the math without it being a formal appeal. Getting that understanding first helps you decide whether to pay, appeal, or apply for the waiver.

0 coins

That's actually how I've been thinking about it. I want to understand the number before I decide anything. If the math checks out and it matches my records I'll know what I'm dealing with. If it doesn't, then I appeal.

0 coins

Exactly. And whatever you decide, do it before that 30-day window is up. Paying first and then trying to appeal later is much harder and there's no guarantee EDD reverses anything.

0 coins

Retraining program I enrolled in mid-claim created a question about one of my certified weeks, and that ended up being part of my overpayment notice. EDD wanted to confirm whether I was available for work during the weeks I was in class. I ended up using Claimyr to get an agent and found out there's a California Training Benefits option that some people qualify for so they don't have to report as available for work during school - I had just never applied for it and so those weeks got flagged. The agent said I could look into the Training Extension before week 16 of my benefits.

0 coins

California Training Benefits is something I didn't know existed until I read this. So if you're approved for it you don't have to be actively looking for work while you're enrolled in training?

0 coins

That was what the agent explained about the program, yes - but it has to be EDD-approved training and you have to apply before week 16. For my specific weeks the question was whether I'd been enrolled before I applied, which I hadn't, so those weeks on my notice stayed.

0 coins

This thread keeps turning up things I didn't know about. I had no idea training could affect availability and therefore your eligibility for weeks you've already been paid for.

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the waiver option - EDD looks at two main things when you submit the DE 1446UI. First, was the overpayment your fault or not? Second, would repaying it cause real financial hardship? If both of those lean in your favor you have a reasonable case for a waiver. It doesn't guarantee anything but it's worth submitting especially if the overpayment came from something like the wage-reporting timing issue mentioned earlier in this thread.

0 coins

Does submitting the waiver form stop the collection process while they review it?

0 coins

Not automatically, no - but it may help to contact EDD and let them know you've submitted the waiver so they're aware it's in process. The form itself doesn't pause collection, the communication with EDD does.

0 coins

Got it. So submit the form and also send a message through UI Online saying you filed it. I'll do both.

0 coins

My Notice of Overpayment said I had to repay within 30 days but that felt impossible for my budget. I didn't know you could request a payment plan until I called in. Worth mentioning that there are options beyond just cutting one big check if the amount is verified and you decide not to appeal.

0 coins

Payment plan option - that's good to know. The $2,100 on my notice is not something I can just send all at once. Even if the amount turns out to be correct I'd need to know there are other ways to handle it.

0 coins

Calling EDD directly is how I set mine up. UI Online messages also worked but the phone conversation was faster because we could go back and forth about the schedule.

0 coins

Does the payment plan affect your ability to also file for a waiver or appeal at the same time?

0 coins

Arranging a payment plan doesn't waive your right to appeal - those are separate. You can be making payments toward the amount and still have an active appeal. If the appeal goes in your favor any amount you already paid back would need to come back to you.

0 coins

Reading through all of this - the main things you need: the mailing date on the notice for your 30-day window, the Claim History in UI Online to see your weekly payment amounts, your pay stubs for the weeks they're questioning, and either the DE 1000M if you want to appeal or DE 1446UI if you want to request a waiver. Those four things get you through most of what comes next.

0 coins

Okay I have the notice in front of me, I found the mailing date, I looked at Claim History - the week amounts there don't add up to the number EDD is claiming. Specifically there are two weeks showing payment amounts that combined are $340 less than what the notice says I owe. I'm going to try the live chat tomorrow to ask an agent to walk me through it.

0 coins

$340 discrepancy is significant enough to push back on. Screenshot everything in Claim History before you chat so you have a record of what it showed when.

0 coins

Already done. Screenshots saved with timestamps. If the chat can't resolve it I'll be filing the DE 1000M before the window closes.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure