Back to California Unemployment

Connor O'Neill

Notice of determination section 1279 holiday pay deducted from benefits - what does this mean?

Got my Notice of Determination in the mail yesterday and I'm completely lost. I was laid off from my hotel job in mid-October and filed for UI right away. Everything seemed fine until this notice showed up saying my benefits for one week were reduced because of holiday pay I received. The form references section 1279 and I genuinely have no idea what that means or whether this is even correct. Here's my situation: when I was laid off, HR gave me my final paycheck which included regular wages for my last days worked plus a separate line item for holiday pay (we had Columbus Day that week and apparently I was still on payroll through the holiday). I reported everything when I certified, like I was supposed to. But now EDD is saying that holiday pay counts against my benefits for that week and they've reduced what I'm getting. I thought holiday pay from a job you no longer work at would just be part of your final wages? The notice doesn't explain much beyond citing the code section. Has anyone dealt with a Notice of Determination that reduced benefits because of holiday pay? Do I have this right, or is there something about how EDD handles holiday pay that I'm missing entirely?

Holiday pay from a former job hitting your UI benefits is one of those things that caught me completely off guard too. My last week at a retail company, they paid out a floating holiday I hadn't used, and EDD flagged it and reduced that week's payment. The rule, as far as I understand it now, is that holiday pay, vacation pay, that kind of thing - EDD treats them as wages for the week they're tied to, not just extra money. So if the holiday fell during a week you were also certifying for UI, they subtract it from your weekly benefit amount using the earnings formula. It doesn't eliminate your benefits, but it does knock them down.

0 coins

That makes sense for a holiday that falls during a week you're on UI, but mine was my last week of employment, before I even filed. That's what confuses me about why they're reducing a UI week over it.

0 coins

Actually EDD's system looks at which week the pay is tied to, and sometimes pay from your last week of work can still affect a UI week depending on how payroll lined up. The notice should have a week date on it - which week did they reduce?

0 coins

The notice says it's the first week I certified, which overlaps with when I got that final paycheck. So that might be why.

0 coins

Section 1279 is California's UI code on how wages affect your weekly benefit. The way it works in plain terms: EDD takes your weekly benefit amount and subtracts everything you earned over a certain threshold that week. That threshold is whichever is bigger - 25 dollars or 25 percent of your weekly benefit amount. So if your holiday pay pushed your earnings above that threshold, they subtract the rest from your UI payment. It doesn't disqualify you from that week entirely unless your earnings hit full-time levels. You'd still get a partial payment.

0 coins

Okay so the holiday pay didn't wipe out my benefit for that week, just reduced it? Let me re-read the notice more carefully because I may have panicked before I understood what I was looking at.

0 coins

Yeah the notice language is really confusing. 'Reduced' and 'denied' look similar in those letters but mean very different things for your payment.

0 coins

Agree with what's said here. The 1279 calculation is basically: weekly benefit amount minus (holiday pay minus the 25% or $25 threshold, whichever's bigger). So you're not getting zeroed out unless you earned more than your whole weekly benefit that week.

0 coins

Thanksgiving week last year my final paycheck from a food service job included holiday pay for the holiday itself, and EDD flagged that week exactly the way you're describing. The UI Online claim history showed that week as partially paid with a reduced amount and I couldn't figure out why until the notice arrived. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent - there's a video on reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see how it works before trying it. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through exactly which dollar amount EDD used for the holiday pay, confirmed they'd applied the section 1279 earnings formula correctly, and told me my remaining weeks weren't going to be affected since the holiday pay was a one-time thing tied to that final paycheck. That was the clarification I actually needed to stop worrying about the rest of my claim.

0 coins

Really helpful to hear someone else had this exact situation. The 'one-time thing' part is reassuring - I was worried this was going to keep affecting my weekly payments going forward.

0 coins

Terminal paycheck with holiday pay mixed in is so common and EDD handles it differently from regular earned wages. Good to know you got a clear explanation from an agent.

0 coins

So once you confirmed it was just that one week reduced, the rest of your payments came through at the full weekly benefit amount?

0 coins

My Notice of Determination after my last job came with language about section 1256 and I spent two days thinking it was the same as a 1279 situation. They're completely different things - 1256 is about whether you qualify at all (like if you quit or got fired), while 1279 is just about how much you get paid in a specific week when you had earnings. If your notice says 1279, that's actually the better one to have. It means EDD isn't questioning whether you should be getting benefits, they're just doing the math on one week's payment.

0 coins

That is actually really clarifying. I was treating this like it meant my whole claim was being reconsidered. If it's just a calculation for one week, that's a much easier thing to deal with.

0 coins

My paperwork from earlier this year had a 1279 situation too - I'd gotten a small bonus in my last check and EDD reduced the first certified week accordingly. The partial payment still showed up within a couple days of certifying. The agent I eventually talked to confirmed the remaining balance on my claim was untouched.

0 coins

Exactly right on the distinction between those two code sections. If someone gets a 1256 notice and thinks it's just a payment math issue they're in trouble - that one you absolutely need to appeal if you disagree.

0 coins

Something I did wrong early on: I reported my final paycheck's holiday pay in the week I received the check instead of the week the holiday actually fell on. EDD's rules say you report wages for the week they were earned, not when you got paid. So if Columbus Day was the second week of October and your paycheck came the third week, you'd report that holiday pay against the second week. I reported wrong and had to contact EDD through UI Online to fix it, which delayed my payment on that week. Just flagging this in case the week in your notice doesn't match what you expected.

0 coins

I think I did it correctly - I reported it in the week Columbus Day fell, which is also the week I last worked. But this is a good thing to double check on my end.

0 coins

Reporting wages for the week earned vs. week paid trips up so many people. EDD's certifications ask which week you earned it but the question isn't always worded in an obvious way.

0 coins

UI Online has the Report Wages option that helps sort out which week to assign income to before you certify. If the week is already submitted you have to contact EDD directly to fix it, you can't just go back in and edit.

0 coins

The notice itself should tell you the exact dollar amount EDD counted as holiday pay and what they calculated as your reduced benefit for that week. If those numbers match what you got in your paycheck and what you reported when you certified, then EDD applied the section 1279 formula correctly and you don't necessarily need to do anything. If the numbers are off - like they used a different holiday pay amount than what you actually received - that's when you'd want to appeal within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice.

0 coins

The 30-day clock is good to know. The mailing date on mine is recent so I have time to actually verify the numbers before deciding whether to appeal.

0 coins

Don't let the 30 days slip by while you're trying to figure out if the numbers are right. If you're close to the deadline and still unsure, file the appeal and explain in your letter that you're still verifying. You can always withdraw it if everything checks out.

0 coins

Filing a protective appeal while I verify the math - that's smart. I hadn't thought about doing it that way.

0 coins

Holiday pay tripped me up when I was laid off from a manufacturing job. The company paid holiday pay even to workers on their last day if the holiday fell within the final pay period, and EDD counted it as wages for that week. My weekly benefit was $380 and the holiday pay was $190, so after the threshold calculation I still got about $240 for that week instead of $380. Not what I expected but also not nothing.

0 coins

That math example actually helps me visualize what happened to my payment. I need to sit down with my own numbers and do the same calculation.

0 coins

The 25 percent threshold on a $380 weekly amount is $95, so they subtracted $190 minus $95 from your benefit - yeah that's $95 subtracted, bringing you to $285. Actually wait, I might be doing this wrong.

0 coins

The formula is: earnings above the threshold get subtracted from the weekly benefit amount. So $190 holiday pay minus $95 threshold equals $95 subtracted from $380, leaving $285 - not $240. The numbers above might have been rounded or there were other factors, but the formula itself is weekly benefit amount minus (gross earnings minus whichever is greater, $25 or 25% of your WBA).

0 coins

My aunt is on UI right now and thought the same thing - that the determination letter meant her whole claim was being canceled. Had her completely panicked for two days. The notice language EDD uses is not written for regular people, it's written for lawyers and administrators. The actual impact is almost always narrower than it sounds when you first read it.

0 coins

Genuinely the same reaction I had. Saw 'determination' and 'section 1279' and my brain went straight to 'they're taking everything away.

0 coins

EDD really should include a plain-language summary at the top of those notices. Even one sentence like 'this reduces your payment for one week by X dollars' would prevent so much panic.

0 coins

My first week of certifying after a layoff from a staffing agency, I had holiday pay from Memorial Day that my former employer included in my final check - same situation as yours. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about whether the reduced payment for that week would affect my maximum benefit amount down the road. The agent checked the claim and told me the total maximum benefit amount on my claim stays the same regardless of the section 1279 reduction - only the payment for that specific week changes, and the unspent balance is still available in future weeks.

0 coins

Wait - so the reduced payment for that week doesn't permanently reduce how much I can collect total? That would be a big relief because I was worried this was eating into my overall claim.

0 coins

That's what the agent confirmed for my claim. The maximum benefit amount on the DE 429Z stays the same, and that one week's reduced payment is treated as spending less of your balance, not losing it.

0 coins

This is a really useful point. The section 1279 reduction changes what you get paid that week, but the total available on your claim shouldn't shrink because of it.

0 coins

THESE NOTICES DRIVE ME CRAZY. I got one for vacation pay after my last job and I swear EDD sends them written at the most confusing possible level on purpose. I had to read mine like four times before I understood that it wasn't denying my claim, just adjusting one payment. And then when I tried to call to ask about it I couldn't get through for a week. The hold times are absolutely brutal when you just need a quick answer.

0 coins

The not being able to get through part is real. I've been trying the phone line and hitting the same wall.

0 coins

If it's urgent, the live chat from the Help button in UI Online is available weekday mornings - I had better luck with that than the phone for quick questions.

0 coins

For what it's worth: I work in HR and whenever we lay people off I try to explain how their final paycheck's contents will interact with UI. Holiday pay, PTO payout, in-lieu-of-notice pay - EDD has specific rules for all of them and they're not the same. Holiday pay and vacation pay are both on EDD's list of things to report, and both run through the section 1279 formula. Severance, though, is different - EDD's rules say severance paid under a company plan isn't counted as wages against your benefits. So if someone gets both severance AND holiday pay in a final check, only the holiday portion would affect a UI week.

0 coins

My final check didn't include severance, just the holiday pay and regular wages for the days I worked. So it sounds like the section 1279 treatment was correct, just not something I'd ever been told to expect.

0 coins

The severance vs. holiday pay distinction is something a lot of people get wrong. HR folks knowing this stuff and communicating it at layoff would save a lot of confusion on the EDD end.

0 coins

This is an underrated point. I've seen people assume severance will kill their UI claim and not file at all, which is completely wrong. Severance under a company policy doesn't deny your UI.

0 coins

Before you do anything else, go into UI Online at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and pull up your Claim History. The week in question should show there with the payment amount and the reason for any adjustment. Cross-reference the holiday pay amount EDD used with what's on your final pay stub. If the amounts match, you know EDD at least had the right number to work with. If they don't match, that's your basis for an appeal.

0 coins

Just did this. The Claim History shows that week with a reduced payment and a note referencing 1279. The dollar amount they used matches my pay stub exactly. So it looks like the reduction was at least based on the right number.

0 coins

If the number is correct and the formula was applied right, then honestly the notice is just EDD explaining what already happened. Not great news for the week's payment, but no further action needed.

0 coins

Something that caught me off guard with my own determination notice was the appeal deadline. I kept thinking I had 30 days from when I received it in the mail, but it's 30 calendar days from the mailing date printed on the notice itself. Those two dates can be a week or more apart. So whatever you decide about appealing, use the date EDD printed on the notice, not the date it arrived in your mailbox.

0 coins

I'm glad you said this because I was counting from when I got it, not the mailing date. Let me recalculate - I may have fewer days than I thought.

0 coins

Yep, the mailing date is what controls. And if for some reason you miss the 30 days, you can still appeal but you'll need to explain why the deadline was missed, and EDD may or may not accept it.

0 coins

The mailing date vs. receipt date gap catches people constantly. EDD sends a lot of mail during holiday periods when postal delivery slows down, which only makes it worse.

0 coins

Totally went through this last spring after a hotel front desk job layoff - the hotel industry seems to love giving holiday pay on final checks and EDD definitely notices it. Mine came through Columbus Day too, same holiday as yours, and I ended up with a partial payment for that first certified week. After that, every other week paid out at my full weekly benefit amount with no deductions because the holiday pay was a one-time piece of that final check.

0 coins

Another hotel person! Did the reduced first week throw off your payment schedule at all, or did everything normalize from week two onward?

0 coins

Normalized completely from week two. EDD's system just moved on. The reduction was isolated to that week, and my second certification and every one after came through at the full amount.

0 coins

Hotel and hospitality employers almost always include holiday pay in final checks because of how their pay periods work. EDD agents probably see this exact scenario constantly.

0 coins

A retention bonus from my previous employer showed up in my last paycheck and I genuinely did not know if it would be treated the same as holiday pay or differently. Ended up talking to an agent - used Claimyr to get through since the phone line had been a dead end for me for days - and the agent confirmed the reduction EDD applied to that week used the section 1279 formula correctly. The specific week involved and the bonus amount were right there in my account when the agent looked it up. What mattered for my situation was that it was a one-time payment, not ongoing income, so the weeks after weren't going to be touched.

0 coins

The 'one-time payment' distinction seems to be the key thing - if it's not ongoing, the rest of the claim should be unaffected. Good to have that confirmed by an actual agent.

0 coins

Bonuses and holiday pay are treated similarly under section 1279 - they're wages for the week they were earned, so they run through the same reduction formula. Ongoing income like a part-time job would affect every week you work, but a final-paycheck lump sum only hits the one week.

0 coins

If your numbers check out and you decide not to appeal, you should still keep the notice somewhere safe. EDD can send overpayment notices later if they recalculate something, and having the original determination is useful if you need to show what EDD already decided about that week.

0 coins

Good call. I tend to toss mail once I think I've resolved it but UI paperwork probably deserves its own folder.

0 coins

Overpayment notices can come months later and they'll reference the original determination. Having that document on hand makes it a lot easier to track what changed and from when.

0 coins

Worth mentioning for anyone reading this later: in-lieu-of-notice pay works differently from holiday pay even though both show up in a final paycheck. Holiday pay runs through the section 1279 earnings formula. In-lieu-of-notice pay is also on EDD's list to report, but how it affects your specific weeks is EDD's call when they process it. Don't assume the two are treated identically just because they're both line items on a termination check.

0 coins

I didn't have in-lieu-of-notice pay in my check but good to know for future reference. My company gave me a few days notice so there wasn't a substitution payment like that.

0 coins

Exactly right. These distinctions matter a lot and they're not explained anywhere in the standard layoff paperwork employees receive. HR teams generally don't cover UI implications at separation.

0 coins

Vacation pay payout on a final check is another one people assume works like severance. It doesn't - it runs through the 1279 formula the same way holiday pay does.

0 coins

My section 1279 situation came from a PTO payout on my last check and I actually got more than I expected that week because I misread how the threshold works. I thought EDD would subtract the entire PTO amount from my benefit, but it's only the amount above the threshold. So on a week where my WBA was around $410 and I had $80 in PTO, the threshold was $102.50 (25%), which meant the PTO was entirely under the threshold and EDD didn't reduce that week at all. I got the full weekly amount.

0 coins

Oh that's interesting - so if the holiday pay I got was small enough relative to my weekly benefit, the threshold might mean my payment wasn't actually reduced much at all. I need to do the actual math on this.

0 coins

Exactly - if your holiday pay is under 25% of your weekly benefit amount (or under $25, whichever's bigger), section 1279 doesn't reduce your payment at all for that week. The notice would still be generated to document the calculation, but the payment might be unchanged.

0 coins

The notice coming even when there's no actual reduction is a quirk of EDD's documentation process. I've heard of people panicking over a 1279 notice only to find out their payment wasn't touched because the earnings were under threshold.

0 coins

Just want to add that the appeal process, if you go that route, isn't as scary as it sounds. You mail the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) or just a letter to the address on the notice, explaining that you disagree with the determination and why. An administrative law judge handles it, not EDD itself. If you appealed and you're right that the holiday pay was miscalculated, you'd get the difference. Keep certifying through the whole thing so you're not locked out of back weeks.

0 coins

The 'keep certifying through an appeal' note is really important - I would not have known to do that.

0 coins

A lot of people stop certifying when they get a denial or reduction notice thinking their claim is on hold. That's exactly the wrong move. Uncertified weeks can't be paid out even if you win.

0 coins

The 30-day clock for the appeal runs from the notice mailing date, the judge comes from the CUIAB not EDD, and yes - certifying throughout is essential. Those are the three things to keep straight.

0 coins

My final thought on this after going through two different determinations on the same claim: EDD's notices almost always look worse than the actual impact. The legal language and code citations are designed for formal compliance, not for someone trying to understand what happened to their payment. Nine times out of ten when I've seen people on here panicking about a 1279 notice, the actual dollar difference ended up being smaller than the anxiety made it feel. Run your numbers, verify against the pay stub, and go from there.

0 coins

After this whole thread I feel a lot better. The numbers in the notice actually match my pay stub, the formula seems to have been applied right, and the reduction was just for that one week. I think I'm okay.

0 coins

That's the best outcome - the notice was accurate, the reduction was minor and isolated, and your remaining claim is untouched. The confusion was just from the notice language, not from EDD doing something wrong.

0 coins

Coming out of a situation like this knowing how EDD handles holiday pay is actually useful for anyone who ever gets laid off again. Now you'd know to expect the 1279 calculation on any final check that includes holiday or vacation pay.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure