Back to California Unemployment

Yuki Sato

New claim when benefit year ends lower weekly benefit amount - is this normal for California EDD?

Filed a new claim two weeks ago after my benefit year wrapped up and the DE 429Z they mailed me is showing a weekly benefit amount that's about $90 less than what I was getting on my last claim. I did not expect that at all. My old claim was paying $380 a week and this new one is only showing $290. The thing is, I actually worked more during the period between claims - picked up some contract gigs and had a few months at a decent-paying job before they cut my position again. So why would more work history translate into less money? I checked on myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and everything looks like it processed fine, there's no pending flag or anything like that. Is this a known thing that happens, or did EDD mess something up with my base period calculations? Really confused and kind of stressed about budgeting around this lower number.

DE 429Z showing a lower amount than your last claim - the first thing I'd do in your spot is figure out which quarter EDD used as your highest-paid quarter, because that's what drives your weekly number. The way it works: EDD takes the four earliest of the last five complete calendar quarters before you filed, finds which of those four paid you the most, and runs your weekly amount off that one quarter. If your best-paying contract work landed in the most recent quarter - the one that gets left out of the standard calculation - it won't count toward your weekly amount even though it's sitting right there in your work history. That's how you can earn more overall and still end up with a lower weekly amount. It's not a bug, it's just the way the base period math falls.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Okay that actually makes a lot of sense. The contract work I mentioned was mostly in the last few months before I filed, so it probably landed in that excluded quarter. Frustrating but at least it's not a mistake.

0 coins

Same thing bit me last year. Worked a solid three months right before filing and none of it counted. The timing just didn't line up with the base period window.

0 coins

Does that mean the new wages are just completely wasted for unemployment purposes? Like they never count toward anything?

0 coins

Worth double-checking whether an alternate base period would help here. EDD normally uses the standard window the person above described, but if that standard window doesn't produce a valid claim at all, EDD automatically looks at the most recent four complete quarters instead. The catch is the alternate base period only kicks in when the standard one doesn't qualify you - it can't be used just to get a higher weekly amount on a claim that's already valid. If your $290 claim is already valid, the alternate base period won't come into play, unfortunately.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Mine definitely qualified under the standard period - I had earnings in several quarters, just not the right one being the highest. So sounds like the alternate base period isn't going to help my situation.

0 coins

Yeah I looked into this same thing when my new claim came in lower. Once EDD can pay you on the standard window they don't switch to the alternate just to bump the number up. Annoying but that's how it's set up.

0 coins

wait so there's literally no way to get the higher wages counted if you filed too early or too late? that seems like a huge flaw in the system

0 coins

Ended up in a similar spot - my benefit year ended in August and the new DE 429Z came back with a weekly amount that was noticeably lower than before even though I'd worked several months in between. Spent days trying to get through to EDD on the phone to ask whether my base period was calculated correctly and whether anything from my recent work could factor in. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me to an actual EDD agent after I'd been hitting busy signals for a week straight - there's a video showing how the whole reaching-a-live-person-at-EDD process goes at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my base period quarters, confirmed which one was my highest, and walked me through why the recent contract months I'd worked landed outside the calculation window. She also confirmed the alternate base period wouldn't apply since my standard claim was already valid. At least I knew for certain what I was dealing with after that call instead of just guessing.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Really glad you got through. The confirmed answer about the base period window is exactly what I needed to hear - at least it's not a random error on EDD's end.

0 coins

My new claim also came in lower and I've been going in circles trying to get through by phone. Might try that route to get the same kind of confirmation on my specific quarters.

0 coins

Useful to know there's a way to actually reach someone. I always assumed you just had to accept whatever the DE 429Z says with no explanation.

0 coins

The confusion a lot of people have is thinking the new claim pulls from all the wages they've ever earned or even from the whole past year. EDD looks at a pretty specific slice of time, and anything that falls outside that slice doesn't move your weekly amount one way or another. Your total base period earnings also set the ceiling on your maximum benefit amount - 26 weeks times your weekly amount, or half your total base period wages, whichever is smaller. So a lower weekly amount means your whole claim pays out less too, not just each week.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

That part about the maximum benefit amount is a gut punch - so it's not just the weekly number, the whole claim ceiling drops too. I hadn't thought through that part.

0 coins

ugh this is so demoralizing. filed a new claim last month and saw the same thing - lower weekly amount AND less total available. felt like being punished for going back to work in between

0 coins

Makes sense mathematically but it really does feel backwards. Work more, earn more, get less UI. The timing of when your earnings fall in the calendar is everything.

0 coins

To the person asking about whether unused wages are wasted - they're not wasted forever, they just affect your next claim's base period depending on when that one starts. The timing shifts each time you file.

0 coins

Something people get wrong sometimes: the weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z isn't the approval decision itself, it's EDD's calculation of what your claim can pay if you're found eligible. I've seen folks in this sub think the DE 429Z is EDD saying yes you're approved - it's not. It just tells you the weekly amount and the claim's potential total. The actual eligibility decision shows up through payments starting or a Notice of Determination arriving.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Had no idea about that distinction. So the lower amount on the DE 429Z isn't necessarily EDD's final say on eligibility, just the dollar figures if everything checks out.

0 coins

Good point. A lot of people including me when I first filed treat the DE 429Z like an approval letter and it's really not. It just sets the financial parameters.

0 coins

My new claim came in lower for a different reason - the job I had between claims was part time and paid less per quarter than the job I'd had before. So my highest quarter on the new base period was just genuinely lower. EDD didn't make an error, the earnings just weren't as strong. Worth reviewing your own pay stubs or W-2s from each quarter in your base period window to see if the math actually tracks before assuming EDD miscalculated.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Good reminder to actually verify the math myself. I've been assuming it must be an error but I haven't actually sat down and compared my quarterly earnings to what EDD used.

0 coins

Pay stubs by quarter are honestly the move. I did that comparison when my claim came in lower and realized the highest quarter EDD used was actually right - my biggest earnings just happened to fall outside the window.

0 coins

If after checking your quarterly earnings you genuinely think EDD got a number wrong, the DE 429Z has an appeal process. You have 30 days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing, using the DE 1000M form or just a letter sent to the address on the notice. That 30-day window runs from the mailing date, not from when you got it in the mail, so don't sit on it.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Thirty days from the mailing date, got it. I'll verify my own quarterly numbers first and if something's off I'll know I still have time to appeal.

0 coins

Does appealing the DE 429Z mean the whole claim gets paused? Or can you keep certifying while that gets sorted out?

0 coins

You can keep certifying through an appeal - in fact you should, because EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified. Don't stop certifying just because an appeal is open.

0 coins

Two quarters into my benefit year I got confused and thought my lower weekly amount was because I hadn't filed my claim at the right time - went back and forth on this for weeks. The quarterly window closes based on when the claim starts, not when you certified or when you got your first payment. Filed using Claimyr to reach EDD and ask about my specific filing date and what quarter window that opened - the agent confirmed the base period was set correctly for my claim start date and the lower amount reflected my actual highest quarter for that window, not a timing error on my end. Turns out I just earned less in the relevant quarters than I had the time before.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

The base period being locked to when the claim starts, not when you certify - that's a distinction I hadn't fully understood before. Makes sense though.

0 coins

Had the exact same confusion. Kept thinking if I'd filed a few weeks earlier or later it would have fixed the weekly amount, but the quarters are what they are based on the Sunday you file.

0 coins

edd is so confusing lol i thought when you filed a new claim it would just use all your wages from the past year. didn't know there were specific quarters that counted and that some could be excluded

0 coins

Really common misconception. The base period is specifically the first four of the last five complete calendar quarters before the claim week, not simply the past 12 months. It almost always excludes the most recent complete quarter and anything after it.

0 coins

yeah i learned this the hard way too. thought my recent work would automatically count and was shocked when it didn't

0 coins

Something I haven't seen mentioned yet - if you think there might be wages missing from your base period that EDD didn't capture, like from an employer who maybe reported late, it's worth reaching out to EDD directly to ask if all your wage records are showing up. Missing wages from a past employer that did report late have shown up and changed benefit amounts before. Not saying that's what happened here but it's another angle to check.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Had one employer who was notoriously slow with reporting. That's actually a real possibility for my situation. Good angle I hadn't thought of.

0 coins

Former employer who filed late W-2s caused my benefits to be understated one claim. EDD was able to pull the corrected wages once the employer finally reported them. Worth a call to check if all wages are on file.

0 coins

how would you even know if an employer reported your wages or not? is that something visible in UI Online?

0 coins

For whoever asked about seeing employer-reported wages - UI Online doesn't show you a wage breakdown by employer that I know of. You'd basically need to contact EDD directly and ask them to verify what wages they have on record for your base period quarters. Phone is probably the clearest way to get that specific info.

0 coins

Makes sense, figured it wasn't visible on the claimant side. Phone it is then, once I can actually get through.

0 coins

EDD's live chat through the Help button in UI Online is available weekdays 9 to 2 if you can't get through on the phone. For a wage verification question that might honestly be easier than trying to call.

0 coins

Benefit year ending and the new weekly amount dropping - that specific situation I dealt with after my retail job ended last spring. Spent a full week hitting 1-800-300-5616 and getting the busy signal every single time. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD and asked the agent to confirm what my highest base period quarter actually was and whether a part-time stint I'd had between claims was included. She looked it up, told me the specific quarter EDD used, confirmed the part-time months were in the excluded most recent quarter, and said my DE 429Z was calculated correctly. At that point I stopped guessing and just adjusted my budget to the $290.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

$290 as well - that's exactly my number. Sounds like adjusting the budget is probably where I land too once I confirm the calculation is correct.

0 coins

The part-time work between claims landing in the excluded quarter is exactly my situation. At least it sounds like there's a way to get a straight answer on which quarters EDD actually used.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question - when you file the new claim after the benefit year ends, does EDD automatically start from scratch, or do you have to do anything specific to open it? I've been worried about timing this correctly when my year ends next month.

0 coins

Not a dumb question at all. File as soon as your benefit year ends - the new claim starts on the Sunday of the week you apply. Waiting costs you potential payment weeks since there's no backdating. Apply through UI Online, it's the fastest option.

0 coins

Also keep in mind there's a waiting week on every new claim. That first certified week won't be paid, it's the unpaid waiting period. Budget for a gap at the start of the new claim even if everything processes quickly.

0 coins

Waiting week on every new claim, got it. I'd forgotten that applied to reopened claims too and was hoping to avoid a gap.

0 coins

the whole thing where working between claims can lower your weekly amount is so backwards to me. like you're being penalized for trying. i know it's not EDD's fault it's just how the formula works but still

0 coins

The formula is built around your highest earning quarter, not your most recent quarter, so it's really about when in the calendar your best paychecks landed. Work between claims that falls in the excluded quarter genuinely doesn't factor in - it's not a penalty exactly, just a timing thing. Cold comfort I know.

0 coins

yeah cold comfort is about right. still frustrating when the math doesn't go your way

0 coins

EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site at edd.ca.gov lets you estimate what your weekly amount should be based on your quarterly wages. If you plug in your four base period quarters and the number doesn't match your DE 429Z, that's your signal to contact EDD about a possible miscalculation. The calculator isn't perfect but it's close enough to know if something is way off.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Using the calculator to cross-check the DE 429Z is a solid practical step. Going to do that tonight with my pay stubs.

0 coins

Did this when my amount looked wrong and the calculator matched EDD's number exactly. Confirmed the lower amount was just my actual quarterly earnings, not a glitch.

0 coins

Good tool to know about. The calculator uses the same basic highest-quarter logic so if your number is off it'll show pretty clearly.

0 coins

Also worth noting - when you file the new claim, CalJOBS registration is required again if EDD sends you a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work. You have 21 days from the date on that notice to register and post a resume in CalJOBS. If you were registered before, check whether your profile is still current since accounts can go stale and EDD may treat an outdated profile the same as not being registered.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

I did get that notice and I think I already had a CalJOBS account from my last claim. Logging back in to make sure the resume is updated, hadn't thought about that.

0 coins

My old CalJOBS account was still there from my previous claim but my resume was two years out of date. Updated it and had no issues but definitely check - don't assume the old profile satisfies the new claim's requirement.

0 coins

Does the 21-day window start from when you get the notice in the mail or from the date printed on it?

0 coins

The date printed on the DE 8405 notice is what EDD goes by, not the postmark or when it arrives. Mail can take a few days so open that one as soon as it comes.

0 coins

Filing a new claim after the benefit year also means the waiting week applies fresh. Some people assume since they already served the waiting week on the last claim they don't need to serve it again - that's not how it works. Every new claim has its own one-week unpaid waiting period on the first eligible week you certify.

0 coins

wait really? even if you just had a claim that ended? i assumed the waiting week was a one time thing

0 coins

Every new claim has its own waiting week - it doesn't carry over from past claims. The first week you certify on a new claim is the waiting week and it won't be paid. Plan for it.

0 coins

ugh okay good to know before i file. would have been very confused when that first week showed up unpaid

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail for my new claim last week showing $265 when I'd been getting $340 on the previous one. Almost called to dispute it but reading through this thread I'm now thinking it's probably the base period timing issue everyone's describing. Worked a decent paying temp job for four months right before filing which almost certainly landed in that excluded quarter.

0 coins

Run the quarterly math yourself first using the edd.ca.gov calculator before calling. If the calculator confirms EDD's number, it's the base period timing. If there's a gap between the calculator and your DE 429Z, then it's worth getting EDD on the phone.

0 coins

Calculator is a good first step before spending time trying to get through on the phone. Going to do that before anything else.

0 coins

My situation when my benefit year ended was a little different - I'd had wages from two different states in my base period and had to file a combined wage claim instead of a straight California claim. Had to do that by phone, fax or mail, couldn't file it online. Weekly amount still came out lower than my previous California-only claim. Just flagging it since it's another scenario where the base period quarters can produce a lower number than expected.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

Hadn't even thought about the combined wage claim scenario. Mine is all California work so not my situation, but good to flag for others reading this.

0 coins

Combined wage claims being phone or mail only is a real thing - if someone worked in California and another state in the last 18 months they can't do the online application for that combined claim. Worth knowing before you try to file online and hit a wall.

0 coins

Following this thread closely because my benefit year ends in about six weeks and I'm bracing for the same lower amount situation. Already know my best-paying quarter from my new job is going to fall outside the standard window based on when I started. Kind of demoralizing to plan around.

0 coins

Apply as soon as your benefit year ends - the Sunday of that week is when the new claim starts. Don't wait around hoping the timing will shift in your favor, it's locked the moment you file.

0 coins

Also worth verifying all your CalJOBS info is current before the new claim starts. Easier to do that before you're already in the stress of a pending claim.

0 coins

Good reminders on both. Filing right away and getting CalJOBS updated are both on my list now.

0 coins

One thing that helped me feel less stuck about the lower amount: the weekly number on the DE 429Z sets your weekly benefit but your actual take-home each week depends on whether you have any part-time earnings to report. The partial payment formula means if you pick up any part-time hours during the claim, the first $25 or 25% of your gross earnings for the week, whichever is bigger, doesn't reduce your benefit. So a little part-time work doesn't necessarily cancel out the whole week's payment.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

Author

That partial earnings formula is a helpful reminder - if I pick up any contract work while on the new claim it won't automatically wipe out the week's payment. That's actually useful to know given my work situation.

0 coins

the first 25 or 25% rule is something i wish i'd known on my first claim. would have picked up more side work without worrying it would tank my weekly check

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure