Back to California Unemployment

Fatima Al-Qasimi

New claim have you filed last 12 months question on California EDD application - what does it mean?

Okay so I'm filling out the online application through myEDD and I hit a question that completely stopped me in my tracks. It asks something along the lines of whether I've filed a new claim in the last 12 months and I genuinely don't know how to answer. Here's my situation: I filed for unemployment back in spring of last year after getting laid off from a warehouse job, collected for a few months, then got hired somewhere else in the fall. That job just ended last week - company downsized and I was let go again. So technically yes, I had a claim within the past year, but that claim is definitely expired now and I collected benefits on it. Does answering yes to this question mean they'll try to reopen the old claim instead of starting fresh? I don't want to accidentally mess up my application by picking the wrong option. The old weekly benefit amount was pretty low because my wages were lower then, and my new job paid significantly better, so a fresh claim would obviously be much better for me. Someone please help me figure out what to actually pick here.

DE 429Z from your previous claim would show the benefit year end date, and that's the key detail here. If that benefit year is already over (sounds like it is, since you filed in spring of last year and a year has passed), then you're filing a completely new claim regardless of how you answer that question. EDD uses that yes/no answer to look up whether there's an active benefit year that could be reopened. When the old one is expired, there's nothing to reopen, so the system routes you to a fresh application either way. The wages from your more recent job will go into the base period for the new claim, which is good news for your weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

That's actually a relief to hear. So even if I say yes, it won't drag up the old claim as long as the benefit year ended?

0 coins

Correct - an expired benefit year stays expired. EDD can't extend it or reactivate it. You'd be starting from scratch with your new claim.

0 coins

Same question tripped me up when I filed last year. I picked yes because I had filed before and everything went through fine, got a whole new DE 429Z with my new weekly amount.

0 coins

Fourteen weeks ago my previous claim's benefit year finally ticked over and I had the same 'have you filed' question pop up when I reapplied after my retail manager job ended. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the phone because the UI Online help section wasn't clearing it up for me. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD walked me through what to expect before I called: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. Asked the agent specifically whether answering yes would pull my old exhausted claim back up and she pulled up my file and confirmed the old benefit year had ended, so I was being processed as a brand new claim. She also told me my base period would use wages from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before my new claim start date, which meant my better-paying retail job wages counted. Filed with that confidence and got my DE 429Z about two weeks later with a much higher weekly amount than before.

0 coins

Really helpful to know an agent could actually confirm which benefit year they're looking at. Did you have to wait a long time to get through?

0 coins

Claimyr handles the hold time, so by the time I picked up my phone an agent was already there. Took maybe a few minutes of actual conversation once I was on.

0 coins

The base period thing is what confuses most people on second claims. You just laid it out really clearly, so thank you for that.

0 coins

Your two layoffs being close together actually works in your favor for the base period calculation. The standard base period is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before the week you file. Since your second job paid more than your first, those wages should fall right inside that window and push your weekly benefit amount higher than what you were getting before. EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site can give you an estimate before your DE 429Z even arrives.

0 coins

Okay so the spring wages from my first job might not even factor in at all if that quarter is outside the base period window?

0 coins

Exactly - quarters that fall outside the standard base period don't count toward the new claim. That's not an error on EDD's part, that's just how the window works.

0 coins

Worth noting that even if the standard base period doesn't give you a valid claim, EDD automatically checks an alternate base period using your most recent four completed quarters. But sounds like your situation is straightforward enough that shouldn't be an issue.

0 coins

Good addition - the alternate base period is there as a backup, but EDD runs it automatically, you don't have to ask for it.

0 coins

WAIT. I went through this same thing and nobody told me the benefit year thing. I thought answering yes meant i was reopening my old claim and I panicked and answered no because I didn't want to get in trouble for lying?? Did I mess everything up by answering no when technically yes was correct??

0 coins

Answering no when your previous claim's benefit year had already expired doesn't create a fraud issue - there's no active claim to misrepresent. EDD would route a no answer straight to new claim processing anyway. If anything, answering no when there was an open benefit year would be the situation to worry about.

0 coins

Okay phew. My claim did end up processing fine and I got my new DE 429Z so I guess it worked out but I was stressed about it for weeks thinking I'd done something wrong.

0 coins

The EDD application doesn't penalize you for answering no on that question if there's genuinely no open claim, because there's nothing to reopen. You were fine.

0 coins

Something people don't realize is the question is essentially EDD checking whether a 'reopen existing claim' path exists for you. Reopening is meant for people whose benefit year is still active but stopped certifying because they found work - like if you get laid off again before the year ends. In your case with spring of last year, that year is gone. You answer yes, the system looks, finds an expired year, and processes you as new. Or you answer no and you skip straight to new. Either way you end up at the same place.

0 coins

That makes the question make so much more sense now. It's really just a routing question, not a 'did you cheat' question.

0 coins

Exactly - and when someone DOES have an open benefit year from a recent claim they should absolutely reopen it rather than start fresh, because starting fresh resets the whole benefit year clock and might not give a better weekly amount anyway.

0 coins

Right, reopening preserves whatever weekly amount and balance you already had. For the person posting though, that ship sailed when the old year expired.

0 coins

My coworker told me that if you filed within the last year you automatically get the lower weekly amount from the old claim instead of a new calculation - but that doesn't match what people are saying here and it doesn't match what happened to me either when I refiled. Mine went up significantly.

0 coins

That's not how it works - each new claim after a benefit year expires gets its own base period calculation based on current wages. The old weekly benefit amount doesn't carry over. Your coworker might be thinking of reopening a claim that's still active, where the amount is already set.

0 coins

That's what I figured. My new weekly amount was way higher because my wages had gone up in between. The coworker was definitely wrong on that one.

0 coins

The DE 429Z on the new claim will always reflect a fresh calculation. There's no mechanism to automatically inherit an old amount.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something to get ahead of too while you're waiting for your new claim to process. The notice about registering (DE 8405) gives you 21 days from when it's mailed and if you miss that window it can hold up payments. Setting up the CalJOBS profile and posting a resume took me maybe 30 minutes total - just don't forget to actually publish the resume on caljobs.ca.gov or it doesn't count as posted.

0 coins

Had no idea CalJOBS was part of this process. Is that separate from the myEDD account or connected somehow?

0 coins

Totally separate system - you make a CalJOBS account on their site and do everything over there. The only connection is that EDD checks whether you've done it when deciding your payments.

0 coins

The 21 days sounds like a lot but it goes fast especially when you're stressed about other stuff. Getting it done in the first few days after filing is way less risky than waiting.

0 coins

The waiting week piece catches people off guard on second claims too. Even though you've had an unemployment claim before, every new claim has that first unpaid week before anything gets paid. The first time you certify you're usually covering the waiting week plus one paid week, so your first actual payment is for one week even though you certified for two.

0 coins

Ugh, didn't realize that starts over with each new claim. So I shouldn't expect two weeks of payment on that first certification?

0 coins

Nope - one paid week on that first cert is normal and expected. Week two of benefits would then come with your second certification two weeks later.

0 coins

Got tripped up on this myself. Called EDD thinking something was wrong with my payment and the agent explained it's just the waiting week being served. It's annoying but it's the rule.

0 coins

Since you're about to get a new DE 429Z anyway, double check that all your employers from the past 18 months are on the application. When I refiled I forgot to include a short contract gig I did for about six weeks and EDD caught it and had to verify my wages before processing. Didn't block the claim but it added a couple weeks of pending status while they sorted it.

0 coins

Good call - I did have a brief temp assignment between the two main jobs. I should make sure that's on there.

0 coins

Even a few weeks of wages can affect your highest quarter calculation, so it matters. If you left someone off, contacting EDD through your UI Online message option to add them is better than waiting for them to find it.

0 coins

EDD's application asks for all employers from the last 18 months specifically, so they will cross-check wages with the Employment Development Department's records anyway. Better to include everything upfront.

0 coins

Last week of my previous claim showed pending in UI Online Claim History for over three weeks and I couldn't get a straight answer through Ask EDD messages. Ended up getting through to an EDD agent through Claimyr and the agent found that my final certification had flagged a small wages issue from a few days I worked before my layoff. The agent walked me through what I needed to report to clear it, and within days that pending week resolved and the payment posted. Mentioning it here because if your new claim shows pending weeks and you can't figure out why, talking to an actual agent makes a huge difference versus guessing.

0 coins

How long did your pending week situation drag on before you did that? Mine hasn't started yet but good to know the option is there.

0 coins

Nearly a month on that one week. The message responses from Ask EDD kept being generic. Once the agent looked at the actual account the reason was obvious and fixable.

0 coins

Pending in Claim History is so stressful because UI Online just shows that one word with no explanation attached. Getting a human to look at the account is usually the fastest way to understand what's actually holding it.

0 coins

The ID.me verification step tripped me up on my second claim even though I'd done it before for the first one. EDD wanted me to go through it again - had to take a new photo with the app and relink it. Something about their verification system not carrying forward between separate benefit years. Just flagging it because if you get a DE 1326C in the mail asking for identity verification don't ignore it, respond right away or payments stay pending.

0 coins

Oh that's a good heads up. I did ID.me for my first claim but had no idea I might have to redo it.

0 coins

Might not happen to everyone but it happened to me. The DE 1326C is pretty clear about what you need to do, just don't let it sit.

0 coins

Had the same thing - second claim after a fresh benefit year and ID.me wanted a new verification photo. Took about 20 minutes and then the pending weeks cleared.

0 coins

My benefit year expired in August and when I filed again in October the 'have you filed last 12 months' question showed up for me too. Answered yes because technically my previous filing was within 12 months even though the benefit year was done. Used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line because I wanted to confirm the new claim was processing fresh and not somehow attached to the old one. The agent pulled up both claim records and confirmed the August expiration, then told me the new claim was being built on a completely separate base period with my more recent wages. Ended up with a weekly benefit amount that was about $110 higher than my first claim.

0 coins

$110 higher is significant. And the agent was able to actually see both claims in the same system?

0 coins

Yeah she could see the old expired benefit year and the new application side by side. Confirmed they were separate records being handled independently.

0 coins

That's the kind of confirmation that's worth getting directly from EDD rather than just hoping the system does it right. Good to know an agent can see both records at once.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the myEDD application saves your progress if you need to stop and look something up before answering a question. You don't have to answer the 'have you filed' question on the spot and risk getting it wrong - you can pause, check your records, then come back and finish.

0 coins

Didn't realize that. I was powering through it nervously hoping I'd answer everything right the first pass.

0 coins

Totally understandable but definitely take your time on the application. Better to pause and confirm than rush and need to fix something later.

0 coins

Direct deposit setup is another thing to check early in the process. If your old claim had a Money Network card and you want direct deposit this time around, the change is made in myEDD under your payment method settings, not in UI Online. Learned that the hard way when my first few payments went to a card I thought I'd deactivated.

0 coins

Good to know - I'd prefer direct deposit so I'll make sure to set that up before my first certification.

0 coins

Do it before the first payment processes if you can. Once a payment goes to the card it doesn't reroute automatically even if you switch later.

0 coins

Payment method is per-account in myEDD, not per-claim, so it stays set how you last left it. Definitely worth confirming what yours is currently set to.

0 coins

Taxability of the new benefits is worth knowing upfront since it surprises people: unemployment is federal taxable income but California doesn't tax it at the state level. You can opt into 10 percent federal withholding each time you certify, which a lot of people skip and then end up with a tax surprise in January when the 1099G arrives.

0 coins

Had no idea about the withholding option. I'll set that up from the start to avoid a big bill come tax season.

0 coins

The 1099G is also available through UI Online under Payments every January 31 for up to five years back, so you don't have to track down paper copies if you need them.

0 coins

EDD mails the 1099G too unless you went paperless. But having it in UI Online as a backup is handy.

0 coins

Something that burned me on my second claim was not knowing I had to actively start certifying on the right schedule. EDD sends a prompt about two weeks after the application is processed, but I missed it and my weeks went uncertified for almost a month. EDD can only pay weeks that you actually certify - they don't back-pay weeks you just forgot to cert.

0 coins

Wait, so if I miss a certification window the week is just gone?

0 coins

Pretty much - EDD's position is you had to certify for that week to show you were eligible. Once the window passes without a cert, those weeks typically can't be recovered.

0 coins

UI Online does show the certification schedule once it kicks in. Setting a recurring reminder on your phone for every two weeks starting from your first cert date is the easiest way to not miss one.

0 coins

Appeals process is worth at least knowing exists before your claim starts. If EDD sends a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) saying you're not eligible for some reason, you have 30 calendar days from the mailing date to file a written appeal using the DE 1000M form that comes with it. Keep certifying during an appeal even if payments are on hold - EDD can only release those back weeks if they were certified.

0 coins

Really hope I don't need to appeal anything but it's good to know the form number and that certifying needs to continue even during an appeal.

0 coins

Most straightforward layoff claims don't hit that point - the interview and eligibility question steps are more common friction. But knowing the 30-day window exists matters a lot if something does come back denied.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date specifically, not from when you receive it. If the envelope sat somewhere for a few days, the clock started before you even opened it.

0 coins

My layoff was from a nonprofit and someone in HR told me I couldn't file for unemployment because nonprofits don't pay into it the same way. Ended up filing anyway based on something I read and got approved fine. For anyone reading who works or worked at a nonprofit - file, let EDD decide. The organization's tax setup doesn't change whether you can claim.

0 coins

That's a myth I might have believed if I worked there. Really important clarification.

0 coins

HR was completely wrong. Nonprofit workers file and are paid just like anyone else - the difference is on the employer's accounting side, not the worker's side.

0 coins

EDD decides eligibility, not the employer. That's true whether the employer is a nonprofit, a government agency, or a giant corporation. I've heard that nonprofit rumor at least three other times in this forum.

0 coins

The Unemployment Benefit Calculator on edd.ca.gov can at least give you a ballpark for what your weekly benefit amount might look like on the new claim. Plug in your wages from your more recent job and it'll estimate where you land in that $40 to $450 range. Just remember it's an estimate - the actual number is on the DE 429Z when it arrives.

0 coins

Going to use that now actually. Fingers crossed the number is decent given what I was earning at the second job.

0 coins

The highest-paid quarter of your base period is what drives the weekly amount. If your second job paid well and you worked most of a quarter at that rate, the estimate should be encouraging.

0 coins

Maximum is $450 a week regardless of how high wages were. Some people expect more based on their salary and are surprised when it caps out there.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure