Call EDD
Back to California Unemployment

Lily Young

Is workers compensation the same as unemployment? California EDD explains the difference

Okay so I got hurt at work last month and my employer told me to 'file a claim' but didn't really specify which kind. I went ahead and filed with California EDD for unemployment benefits but now I'm second-guessing myself because someone at the doctor's office mentioned workers compensation. Are these the same thing or completely different programs? I've been getting conflicting info from coworkers too - one said workers comp and unemployment are basically the same payout, another said they're totally separate government programs. I'm currently out of work because of my injury and I genuinely don't know if I filed with the right agency or if I need to do something else entirely. My bills are piling up and I really just need to understand what I'm supposed to be doing here.

These are completely separate programs and it's actually a really common point of confusion. Workers compensation is run through your employer's insurance carrier and covers you specifically when you're injured ON THE JOB. It pays for your medical bills and a portion of your lost wages while you recover from a work-related injury. California EDD unemployment insurance, on the other hand, is for people who lost their job through no fault of their own - layoffs, company downsizing, that kind of situation. If you were injured at work and can't do your job because of that injury, workers comp is almost certainly what you need, not unemployment. You may want to contact your employer's HR department immediately to get the workers comp claim started if you haven't already.

0 coins

So I filed the wrong claim? Will California EDD just deny me or do I need to cancel it myself? I'm worried I messed something up officially.

0 coins

Don't panic - filing an unemployment claim when you're not eligible just means it'll likely be denied or put into adjudication. It won't get you in legal trouble. But yes, you should get your workers comp claim started right away because there are time limits on those. Contact your HR department today if possible.

0 coins

this happened to my cousin too, she filed with edd by mistake when she shoulda done workers comp. took forever to sort out

0 coins

To add some clarity here: there is actually ONE situation where California EDD disability insurance (SDI) comes into play with injuries - if your injury was NOT work-related. California EDD runs the State Disability Insurance program which covers non-work injuries and illnesses. So the breakdown is: work injury = workers comp through employer insurance, non-work injury or illness = California EDD SDI (State Disability Insurance), job loss with no injury = California EDD unemployment insurance (UI). Three different programs, two different agencies basically. Make sure you're applying to the right one for your situation.

0 coins

Wait so there's a THIRD option I didn't even know about? This is exactly the kind of info nobody tells you. My injury definitely happened at work so sounds like workers comp is my path.

0 coins

the SDI thing is so confusing. i filed SDI when i got laid off once and california edd was like 'uh no' lol

0 coins

Yeah the three-program thing trips a lot of people up. Workers comp, SDI, and UI all sound similar but serve completely different purposes. Glad you've identified workers comp as your path forward.

0 coins

One thing that's really important to understand: workers comp and unemployment benefits CANNOT be collected at the same time for the same period. If you're receiving workers comp wage replacement benefits and you also somehow got approved for unemployment, California EDD would consider that an overpayment and you'd have to pay it back. So it's not just about which program you apply to - it matters a lot that you don't accidentally double-dip. Make sure whichever claim you're actively pursuing, you're not simultaneously receiving payments from both.

0 coins

Good to know because honestly with how confused I was I might have ended up trying to get both. Definitely going to focus just on workers comp since my injury was work-related.

0 coins

this is correct, my brother in law tried to collect both and got a nasty letter from california edd about overpayment. don't do it

0 coins

Jumping in because I was in almost exactly this situation two years ago. Hurt my back at a warehouse job, had NO idea what workers comp even was, filed for California EDD unemployment out of confusion. Here's what I learned the hard way - when you're dealing with a work injury and trying to navigate either workers comp OR getting answers from California EDD about a mistaken claim, the phone situation is brutal. I spent days trying to reach a live California EDD agent to explain my situation. Eventually someone told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it's a service that basically gets you through to a real California EDD agent instead of the endless busy signals and hangups. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 that shows how it works. Once I actually got through to an agent they walked me through exactly what I needed to do to sort everything out. Saved me a ton of stress.

0 coins

I've been trying to call California EDD for two days now and keep getting the 'we cannot take your call' message. I'll check out that Claimyr link, at this point anything that gets me to an actual human would help.

0 coins

claimyr actually works? i always assumed those kinds of services were sketchy

0 coins

I was skeptical too honestly but I was desperate enough to try it. Got connected to a real California EDD rep who was actually helpful. For something like sorting out a wrong claim type it really helps to just talk to someone directly.

0 coins

gonna bookmark that link, edd phone lines are genuinely impossible

0 coins

ok so just to make sure i understand this right - if someone gets fired and ALSO has an old injury acting up, which one do they file? like can the injury still be workers comp if it happened before they got fired

0 coins

Good question - if the injury happened while employed and was work-related, workers comp can still cover it even if employment ends afterward, as long as the claim is filed within the statute of limitations. If the firing was also involved, unemployment insurance through California EDD might ALSO apply for the job loss portion. These would be separate claims for separate issues though.

0 coins

ok that makes more sense, i was wondering about my situation specifically lol

0 coins

Just to add - if you were fired AND have a work injury, you'd potentially be dealing with California EDD unemployment for the job loss AND a workers comp claim for the injury. They cover different losses so both could legitimately apply in that scenario.

0 coins

I'll be honest I still don't totally get the difference between SDI and workers comp because both seem to pay you when you can't work??

0 coins

The key difference is WHERE the injury or illness happened. Workers comp = injury/illness caused by your job or workplace. SDI through California EDD = injury or illness that has nothing to do with your job (like you broke your leg hiking on the weekend, or you got sick). Same outcome (you can't work) but different cause = different program.

0 coins

ohhhh okay that actually makes sense now. it's about where the injury happened not just whether you can work. got it

0 coins

yes exactly! source of the injury determines which program. wish someone explained it that simply to me years ago

0 coins

The workers comp system in California has its OWN bureaucracy that's totally separate from California EDD and honestly in some ways even more complicated. You deal with your employer's insurance carrier, potentially a claims adjuster, possibly a workers comp attorney. It's not like filing with California EDD where at least you're dealing with one state agency. If your employer's insurance carrier is being unresponsive about your workers comp claim, you can file with the California Division of Workers Compensation, not California EDD. Just want to make sure people know these are genuinely different systems.

0 coins

My employer gave me a form but the insurance company hasn't called me back in a week. I didn't know there was a state division I could escalate to. That's helpful.

0 coins

Yes - the Division of Workers Compensation (DWC) is the state body that oversees workers comp disputes. If you're getting the runaround from the insurance carrier, they're your resource. Completely separate from California EDD.

0 coins

the workers comp insurance companies are honestly as bad as trying to reach california edd sometimes lol, different kind of nightmare

0 coins

Wait OP mentioned their employer just said 'file a claim' without specifying... that's actually kind of sketchy? Shouldn't employers be required to tell you specifically that it's a workers comp claim when you're injured on the job?

0 coins

California employers ARE required to provide information about workers compensation when an employee is injured on the job. They're supposed to give you a claim form (DWC-1 form) within one working day of learning about a work injury. If your employer just vaguely said 'file a claim' without handing you the workers comp paperwork, that might be a problem on their end.

0 coins

They literally just said 'you should probably file' and pointed me toward HR. HR then sent me a general link to California EDD. I'm now realizing this wasn't handled correctly at all.

0 coins

Yeah that sounds like they dropped the ball. The DWC-1 form is specifically what you should have gotten. Might be worth talking to a workers comp attorney - many do free consultations.

0 coins

just reading through all this and wow i had no idea these programs were so different. i've always just thought 'if you cant work you file with edd' but clearly thats not always right

0 coins

It's a super common assumption! California EDD actually manages several different programs - unemployment insurance (UI), State Disability Insurance (SDI), and Paid Family Leave (PFL). Workers comp is the one that's completely outside California EDD's scope. Each has different eligibility, funding, and purposes.

0 coins

paid family leave is through edd too?? i did not know that. okay now I feel like I know nothing lol

0 coins

I want to add something about the TIMING of all this because it matters. Workers comp in California - you have 1 year from the date of injury to file a claim. California EDD unemployment - you should file as soon as possible after job separation, and your benefit year starts from when you file, not when you were let go. SDI - you can file after an 8-day waiting period of disability. All of these have different timing rules so don't just assume you can wait to figure it out. Especially workers comp, that 1-year clock is real.

0 coins

I'm within the time window for workers comp still but barely a month in. I need to get moving on this. Thank you for the urgency reminder.

0 coins

Glad I could help. The 1 year sounds like a lot but honestly between injury, recovery, confusion about which program, and back and forth with employers - it can sneak up on you. File the DWC-1 ASAP.

0 coins

didn't know about the 8 day waiting period for sdi, that's annoying

0 coins

Can someone tell me - what if your employer tries to say the injury WASN'T work-related to get out of workers comp? Like what happens then? Does it go to California EDD instead?

0 coins

If an employer or their insurance disputes that an injury was work-related, it doesn't automatically go to California EDD - it goes to the California Division of Workers Compensation for adjudication (note: different use of the word adjudication than California EDD uses). You'd need to file a Declaration of Readiness to Proceed with the DWC to have the dispute resolved. California EDD wouldn't cover a disputed work injury.

0 coins

So if workers comp gets denied you're just... stuck? What do you live on while the dispute is being resolved?

0 coins

Unfortunately this is where it gets hard. You might be able to file for California EDD SDI if you can show the disability itself (separate from the cause), but the workers comp dispute itself has to go through DWC. A workers comp attorney can really help here - many work on contingency.

0 coins

This is exactly why workers comp attorneys exist. The employer disputing the injury is one of the most common tactics and there are legal processes to fight it.

0 coins

Honestly just reading this whole thread I feel like every time I've been out of work I probably filed for the wrong thing lmao. California EDD unemployment when I should've done SDI, maybe should've done workers comp at least once... the system really doesn't make it easy to know what to apply for

0 coins

SAME. I filed unemployment once when I had a surgery and couldn't work for 6 weeks. Got denied obviously. Didn't know SDI through california edd was even a thing.

0 coins

This is genuinely such a common experience. The programs aren't well publicized and employers often don't explain them properly. For anyone reading this in the future: injury at work = workers comp, illness/injury not from work = California EDD SDI, job loss = California EDD UI. Screenshot it.

0 coins

that three-line breakdown should be on a poster in every workplace honestly

0 coins

slightly different angle here - has anyone dealt with transitioning FROM workers comp TO California EDD unemployment? like if your workers comp case closes and you're still not able to go back to work at your old job, can you then file for unemployment?

0 coins

Yes, this is actually a real scenario that happens. If your workers comp case closes (either settled or your benefits end) and you're now able to work but still unemployed, you can file for California EDD unemployment insurance. The key is that when you file UI you have to certify you're 'able and available to work' - so if your injury still prevents you from any work, UI probably won't work. But if you've recovered enough to work just not at your specific old job, you may qualify.

0 coins

That's really helpful to know. My physical therapist says I'll be cleared for 'light duty' work eventually but probably can't return to construction. Good to know there might be a California EDD UI option waiting at the end of this.

0 coins

Yes - that's actually a fairly common transition path. Workers comp may also owe you vocational rehabilitation assistance if your injury prevents return to your previous occupation. Worth asking your workers comp attorney or adjuster about that before your case closes.

0 coins

I spent THREE weeks trying to get through to California EDD on the phone earlier this year (I had a regular UI claim, different situation). The hold times were insane and half the time it just disconnected. Eventually I used Claimyr and got through to an actual agent same day. For anyone in this thread who needs to talk to California EDD about their claim status or sorting out a wrong claim type - claimyr.com is worth trying. There's a video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 showing the whole process. Made a miserable experience at least somewhat manageable.

0 coins

I tried calling California EDD again today about my mistakenly filed UI claim and got the automated rejection message three times in a row. Going to try Claimyr tonight.

0 coins

does claimyr work for any california edd issue or just specific types of claims?

0 coins

From what I experienced it just gets you to a live California EDD agent - from there you can discuss whatever your specific issue is, whether it's UI, SDI questions, or anything else EDD-related.

0 coins

My sister works in HR and she told me that a LOT of people confuse workers comp and unemployment and it creates problems for employers too because then they get flagged for potential UI claims when the person should really be on workers comp leave. Apparently it's one of the most common HR headaches they deal with.

0 coins

That's interesting perspective from the employer side. Makes sense that it creates confusion all around not just for employees.

0 coins

Yeah she said ideally employees come to HR first before filing anything and HR walks them through which program applies. But a lot of people (understandably) just go straight to filing online out of panic.

0 coins

That was literally me. Panicked, Googled 'file claim can't work', ended up on California EDD website, filed UI. Wish I had gone to HR first but they weren't super communicative after my injury either.

0 coins

is there any situation where you could receive workers comp AND unemployment at the same time and it NOT be fraud? asking for a friend (genuinely asking for a friend this is complicated

0 coins

The general rule is no - they cover different things and workers comp wage replacement + unemployment are considered duplicate benefits for the same loss. HOWEVER there is a nuanced scenario: if you're on workers comp but only receiving medical benefits (not wage replacement), AND you were also laid off through no fault of your own, technically the UI portion might apply because workers comp isn't replacing your wages in that scenario. This is genuinely complicated and your friend should talk to both an attorney AND call California EDD to explain the specific situation before collecting anything.

0 coins

okay yeah that's exactly the nuanced situation. genuinely asking because they're getting workers comp medical only, no wage replacement, and also just got laid off separately.

0 coins

In that specific case filing for California EDD UI is likely legitimate because the workers comp isn't paying wages. But seriously - have them call California EDD and explain the exact situation. Transparency with California EDD upfront is way better than an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

Not to pile on but OP you should also know that if you were injured at work and your employer fires you or creates a hostile environment to get you to quit (to avoid the workers comp claim), that's retaliation and illegal in California. Workers comp retaliation is taken seriously. Just something to be aware of if your employment situation gets weird after reporting the injury.

0 coins

My employer has been a little cold since I reported the injury. Good to know this is a thing that's recognized legally. I'm not at the point of thinking retaliation yet but noting this.

0 coins

Hopefully you won't need to worry about it! Just wanted to put it out there since sometimes these situations escalate. Document everything - emails, texts, any conversations about your injury and work status.

0 coins

100% document everything. Date, time, who said what. If it does become a retaliation situation that documentation is gold.

0 coins

This thread has been super educational. I always recommended California EDD to everyone who said they 'couldn't work' without thinking about whether their situation was actually UI-eligible. Never considered the workers comp angle or SDI. Bookmarking this.

0 coins

same honestly, sharing this with a few people in my life who've been confused about this stuff

0 coins

That's the thing - most people have only ever heard of 'filing for unemployment' so that's their default mental model for any situation where they can't work. The reality that there are three distinct programs for three different situations just isn't common knowledge.

0 coins

UPDATE for anyone following - I contacted my HR department today and they were actually apologetic about not giving me the right info initially. They're sending me the DWC-1 workers comp claim form and connecting me with their insurance carrier. I'm also going to call California EDD (probably using that Claimyr service since I still haven't been able to get through) to let them know about the mistakenly filed UI claim. Feeling way more clear on what to do now. Thank you everyone in this thread.

0 coins

Really glad to hear this! Getting the DWC-1 filed promptly is the right move. Good luck with your recovery and the claim process.

0 coins

Happy it worked out. And yes Claimyr was really helpful for me when I needed to sort out my own California EDD situation - should help you get that UI claim addressed quickly.

0 coins

good luck!! hope the workers comp process goes smoothly for you

0 coins

Thanks all - I'll update again once things are resolved. This forum genuinely helped more than anything else I found online.

0 coins

Related posts

EDD Phone Number Live Person: Fastest Way to Bypass Menu

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
43,680 users helped today