Back to New York Unemployment

Lucas Notre-Dame

Can I get workers comp and unemployment at the same time in NY?

So I'm in a weird spot and trying to figure out if I'm shooting myself in the foot here. I got hurt at my warehouse job back in February - nothing catastrophic, but enough that my employer's doctor put me on light duty restrictions that my employer basically said they can't accommodate. So now I'm sitting at home, collecting workers comp wage replacement, and my employer hasn't officially laid me off but they told me verbally there's nothing for me right now. I filed for UI benefits last week because my neighbor told me I could collect both at the same time. But now I'm reading stuff online that's contradicting that completely, and I'm genuinely confused about where I stand. My NYSDOL claim is showing 'pending' and I honestly don't know if I even filled out the injury section correctly. Has anyone actually navigated this situation before? Can I get workers comp and unemployment at the same time, or was my neighbor completely wrong? I don't want to be hit with an overpayment notice six months down the road because I misunderstood the rules here.

Tried reaching NYSDOL about almost this exact question a few months back - spent two mornings getting disconnected before I found Claimyr (claimyr.com). The way it works is it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you, so you end up actually talking to a live agent instead of a busy signal. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see it first. I ended up getting my partial wage question cleared up in one phone call after days of going in circles online.

0 coins

How long did the hold itself actually take once you used it? I've been trying to reach NYSDOL for a week about my own comp situation.

0 coins

Honestly I wasn't watching the clock because I didn't have to sit there holding - that's the point. When I finally spoke to the agent it was pretty quick from there. Way less painful than my earlier attempts.

0 coins

Does it work for specific claim status questions or just general stuff? My situation involves partial disability and I really need someone who knows the system.

0 coins

Your comp status is actually the key detail here. Are you receiving full wage replacement or partial? Because NYSDOL treats those two situations pretty differently when it comes to whether UI benefits can even kick in.

0 coins

I'm getting about 66% wage replacement through workers comp. My employer isn't paying me anything on top of that - they said they have no modified duty positions available for my restrictions.

0 coins

That 66% figure matters a lot. Under NY rules, workers comp wage replacement reduces your UI benefit dollar for dollar - so if your weekly WC check is higher than your calculated UI benefit would be, you'd effectively get nothing from unemployment on top of it. If your UI benefit rate works out higher than what comp is paying, you'd theoretically only get the difference. But there's another layer: NYSDOL also looks at whether you're 'available for work' - which is tricky when you're on physical restrictions.

0 coins

Wait so they don't just add up? I always thought you got both separately and they didn't touch each other. I've been telling people that for like two years, sorry if I gave bad advice to anyone lol

0 coins

This is accurate. The offset provision is real and it trips a lot of people up. The WC board and NYSDOL actually do share information in New York so you really can't just not mention one while collecting the other.

0 coins

Your 'available for work' requirement - that's the part that's actually complicated for your specific situation. When I was dealing with a back injury and trying to file UI at the same time, the adjudication examiner specifically focused on whether my restrictions meant I literally couldn't accept any employment. NY unemployment requires you to be ready, willing and able to work - but that doesn't mean fully able-bodied, it means able to do SOME kind of work that exists in the labor market. I ended up having a long phone call with a NYSDOL agent thanks to Claimyr after my claim went into adjudication for weeks, and the agent explained that partial restrictions don't automatically disqualify you, it's about whether work within your restrictions actually exists.

0 coins

Did they actually approve your claim while you were still on comp? That's the part I can't find a straight answer to anywhere.

0 coins

Mine did eventually get approved but with a reduced benefit because of the offset. The key thing the agent told me was that I had to be actively applying for jobs within my physical restrictions and documenting it - the same 3 job contacts per week requirement applies, you just apply to jobs you can physically do given your restrictions.

0 coins

Three contacts a week even when you're on light duty restrictions? That seems like it could be really hard to prove depending on what your limitations are. How specific do they get about what 'within your restrictions' means in terms of job search?

0 coins

They want you to be realistic about it. If your restrictions say no lifting over 10 pounds, you're not applying to warehouse jobs - you're applying to desk work, receptionist roles, whatever fits. The agent told me the documentation is what protects you if it ever gets reviewed.

0 coins

My brother went through almost this exact scenario two years ago with a construction injury. The thing nobody explained to him upfront was that he had to actually REPORT the workers comp income when he filed his weekly certifications - there's a specific question about it. He didn't realize that at first and it caused a whole mess that took months to untangle.

0 coins

Yeah that's exactly what I'm worried about. I did see a question about other income when I was filing my weekly claim but I wasn't sure if workers comp wage replacement counts as 'wages' in that context.

0 coins

It definitely does, yes. It's not wages exactly but it's considered income that has to be reported. NYSDOL has a specific field for it - I believe it asks about 'other income received' rather than just wages from an employer. Your brother's issue was that he left it blank thinking only paycheck income counted.

0 coins

This is true - workers comp, pension payments, severance, vacation pay from a former employer - all of it gets reported in the weekly certification. The system will catch discrepancies because WC is a state program and those records are accessible.

0 coins

Honestly the available for work part is what gets people. I've seen people get approved for UI while on workers comp, but I've also seen people get denied because their doctor's note was so restrictive that there legitimately was no job in the economy they could perform. If your restrictions only limit certain tasks but leave you capable of sedentary or light work, you're in a much better position.

0 coins

My restrictions are no lifting over 15 pounds and no standing for more than 2 hours at a stretch. My regular job was physical warehouse work so my employer says they can't use me, but those restrictions still leave me able to do a lot of things.

0 coins

Honestly those restrictions sound like you'd be okay making the case that you're available for work. 15 pound lifting limit and limited standing doesn't lock you out of a huge chunk of the job market - customer service, light assembly, clerical roles. Document every application and keep notes about whether jobs you apply to fit within those restrictions.

0 coins

What if the jobs available near you don't pay close to what you were making? Do they still count toward the job search requirement even if you wouldn't realistically take a major pay cut to leave workers comp?

0 coins

Had a similar situation about a year ago and I want to flag something nobody mentioned yet - what did you put on your original claim application where it asks why you're no longer working? If you said 'laid off' but you're actually out due to a work injury, that could create an inconsistency that triggers adjudication. The claim application and what your employer reports to NYSDOL need to be consistent.

0 coins

I put that I was separated from employment due to lack of work because that's what my employer told me - that they had no work available for my restrictions. I didn't put 'injured' because technically the injury is covered by comp. Was that wrong?

0 coins

That's actually probably fine - the distinction matters though. If your employer confirms to NYSDOL that they had no modified duty work available for your restrictions, that lines up with 'lack of work' in a reasonable way. Where it gets messy is if your employer tells NYSDOL something different than what you reported, or if they say you're still employed and just on leave.

0 coins

Has anyone heard from their employer about what they actually reported to NYSDOL? I never know what my company told them and it's always a black box until an issue pops up.

0 coins

My experience with partial disability and UI went on for months. The adjudication process is what really drags it out - once NYSDOL sees workers comp in the picture they tend to put the claim on hold and investigate more carefully. I waited almost six weeks before getting any determination.

0 coins

Six weeks is a long time to wait without knowing if you're approved. Were you getting any comp payments during that time at least, or was everything frozen?

0 coins

Workers comp was still coming in during the adjudication wait - that never got frozen, it's a separate system. It was just the UI piece that was in limbo. Eventually got approved with the offset applied, so my actual UI payment was pretty small but it was something.

0 coins

That wait sounds brutal when you're already managing a recovery. I dealt with something similar and finally got answers by using Claimyr to reach an actual agent - the online portal just said 'pending' for weeks and there was nothing to do but wait or talk to someone who could actually look at the account.

0 coins

Does the adjudication examiner actually reach out to you during those six weeks or does everything just sit there silently until a decision drops?

0 coins

There's a misconception I want to push back on - workers comp is NOT automatic grounds for UI denial in New York. The two programs can overlap. The question is always about the offset calculation and whether you meet the availability test. I've seen people on this forum say 'you can't get both' and that's just not accurate - it's more nuanced than that.

0 coins

I think the confusion comes from the fact that in a lot of cases the offset wipes out any actual UI payment so practically speaking people end up with zero UI even if they're 'approved' - so they assume they were denied when really they were approved at $0 benefit.

0 coins

Exactly right. 'Approved with $0 benefit due to offset' and 'denied' are very different things for your record and for future claims. If your comp eventually ends and you're still unemployed, that prior approval status matters.

0 coins

This is a really important point that I wish someone had explained to me earlier. I spent months thinking I'd been denied when actually the offset had just reduced my benefit to zero temporarily.

0 coins

What happens when workers comp ends? Like say you settle your comp case or you reach maximum medical improvement and comp cuts off - does your UI claim just pick back up automatically or do you have to refile?

0 coins

You'd generally need to file a new claim or reopen an existing one depending on the timing. UI claims have a benefit year - they don't just sit open indefinitely waiting for your comp to end. If your benefit year has expired you'd refile.

0 coins

So timing matters a lot here. If your comp drags on past your UI benefit year you're basically starting from scratch with a new claim and new eligibility determination?

0 coins

That's right - and your base period wages for the new claim might look different too depending on what you earned in the year before the new filing date. It's worth at least keeping track of where your benefit year stands so you're not caught off guard.

0 coins

My claim had the same 'pending' status for a while and I was going crazy trying to understand what was happening. The online portal honestly doesn't give you much to work with - it doesn't tell you WHY it's pending or what's being reviewed.

0 coins

That's exactly where I'm at right now. The status just says pending and there's no note, no message in my inbox, nothing. I don't even know if someone is actively reviewing it or if it's just sitting in a queue.

0 coins

That frustration is real. I ended up getting answers by keeping my weekly certifications going even during the pending period - at least that way when it does resolve you don't have weeks of uncertified time that might complicate things.

0 coins

Keep filing those weekly certifications no matter what - even when the claim shows pending. If you stop certifying and then get approved you might not get back pay for weeks you didn't certify.

0 coins

Your employer's statement to NYSDOL is going to be a big piece of this. Have they been responsive to NYSDOL at all, do you know? Sometimes the delay is just waiting for the employer to respond to the initial inquiry.

0 coins

I have no idea what they've reported or whether NYSDOL has even contacted them yet. My employer and I aren't on bad terms or anything, the injury was clearly work-related and accepted by their insurance, but I still don't know what they're telling NYSDOL about my employment status.

0 coins

Worth sending your HR department a quick note asking what employment status they reported to NYSDOL and what they plan to report ongoing. You're not asking them to do anything, just to tell you what they said - most HR teams will respond to that kind of question. Knowing their version helps you catch any inconsistency before it becomes an adjudication problem.

0 coins

Is it weird to ask HR that directly? I always feel like asking about unemployment stuff at an old employer is awkward even when the separation was fine.

0 coins

I keep seeing people say to keep certifying weekly claims during all of this and I want to second that hard. Missing certifications is one of the most common ways people lose back pay they would otherwise have been entitled to. Even if you think the claim might be denied, certify every week.

0 coins

I've been doing that - I've certified for three weeks so far even though the claim is still pending. Hopefully that at least means I won't lose out on those weeks if it eventually approves.

0 coins

Exactly the right move. And when you certify, make sure you're accurately reporting the comp income each week. The dollar amount of workers comp you received that week goes into the income field. Don't underreport or skip it thinking it'll help your benefit amount - it won't and it creates a paper trail problem.

0 coins

This. The weekly certification income question is specifically asking about ALL income including workers comp, severance, pension - anything you got that week. It's not just about wage income from a job.

0 coins

Genuinely curious - if someone is on workers comp and their employer offers a light duty job that they refuse, does that affect UI eligibility or is that only a workers comp issue?

0 coins

Refusing suitable work is a disqualifying event for UI - and 'suitable' gets evaluated based on your skills, your prior wages, and in this case your physical limitations. If your employer offered you modified duty that actually fit within your medical restrictions and you turned it down without good cause, that's a problem for a UI claim.

0 coins

But what counts as 'good cause' for refusing? Like if the modified duty job was way below your pay grade or in a completely different role than what you were hired for?

0 coins

Pay is part of it - UI regulations look at whether the offered job pays substantially less than your previous wage. There's no hard percentage in the rules but examiners do weigh how big the gap is. A completely different role at significantly lower pay might constitute good cause to refuse, but it's not automatic - it depends on how long you've been out of work too.

0 coins

The 'good cause' question is super fact-specific and honestly this is where talking to an actual NYSDOL agent rather than reading general rules pays off, because they can apply it to your specific situation.

0 coins

How long has your claim been pending now? That sometimes tells you whether this is routine processing time or whether there's an actual issue being investigated.

0 coins

About two and a half weeks since the original filing. I haven't gotten any letters, no requests for additional information, nothing. Just the pending status sitting there.

0 coins

Two and a half weeks with workers comp involved isn't necessarily alarming yet - adjudication for cases with other income sources can take 4-6 weeks sometimes. That said if you haven't heard anything by week four I'd push harder to actually speak with someone. The portal alone won't help you at that stage.

0 coins

Week four without hearing anything is when I'd stop waiting around and do something about it. I used Claimyr when I hit that wall on my own claim - ended up talking to a live NYSDOL agent who could actually pull up my file and tell me what was holding things up. Online tools just can't do that.

0 coins

To put this simply since there's a lot of information flying around - yes you CAN collect both, but the amount you get from UI gets reduced by what workers comp is paying you. If your comp payment is higher than your calculated UI benefit, you'll end up with $0 from UI. If comp pays less than your UI would, you get the difference. And you have to meet the availability-for-work requirement showing your restrictions still let you do some job that exists out there.

0 coins

This actually summarizes it really clearly, thank you. So my next step should be making sure I understand what my UI weekly benefit rate would be and comparing it to my weekly comp payment?

0 coins

Exactly - your UI benefit rate is calculated from your highest earning quarter in the base period, and you can find the formula on the NYSDOL website. Once you know your weekly benefit rate, compare it to your weekly WC payment. The math tells you pretty quickly whether there's any UI money left after the offset.

0 coins

This is the clearest explanation in this whole thread honestly. The offset question is the first thing to figure out before worrying about anything else.

0 coins

Does any of this change if the work injury eventually leads to a workers comp settlement lump sum? Like if I accept a settlement and comp closes out, does that lump sum count as income that would affect UI benefits for some number of weeks?

0 coins

Lump sum comp settlements and ongoing weekly WC payments are treated differently. Weekly payments offset UI on a week-by-week basis. With a lump sum it gets more complicated - NYSDOL may prorate it across a period of weeks and treat that prorated amount as income, which could affect your UI benefits for that entire period. Settlement structure matters a lot here.

0 coins

Does NYSDOL get notified of a lump sum settlement automatically or do you have to report it yourself when certifying?

0 coins

Workers comp settlements in NY go through the Workers Comp Board which files records, and those records are accessible to NYSDOL. That said, you're also expected to report lump sum income when certifying. The two systems catching each other is exactly why accuracy matters - discrepancies between what you report and what their records show is what triggers overpayment investigations.

0 coins

My physical therapy was three days a week during my injury period and my therapist's office kept weird hours - I was genuinely struggling to find windows to even make calls to NYSDOL during their open hours. That part of dealing with an injury while also navigating the UI system is exhausting.

0 coins

This is so real. Recovery takes up so much time and mental energy on its own and then you're supposed to also navigate a complicated benefits system while doing it. I've been trying to call NYSDOL during the week but keep hitting the high volume message.

0 coins

I never found a great workaround for the call volume honestly. Some people swear by calling right when they open but even that's hit or miss. The online portal handles some things but anything nuanced like the comp/UI overlap question really needs a live person.

0 coins

The timing pressure is real when you're also dealing with medical appointments and trying to document job searches on top of everything. I hope the OP gets this sorted out quickly because the stress of not knowing your benefit status while injured is a lot.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure