Back to California Unemployment

Zainab Ahmed

How to get through to a trusted referee for unemployment with California EDD

Two months into my claim and I keep hitting walls every time I try to reach someone at California EDD who can actually look at my case and tell me what's going on. The issue is my employer listed someone as a character reference on their response to EDD - basically a 'trusted referee' type witness for their side - and now there's this whole eligibility question hanging over my claim that I can't get clarity on. My UI Online Claim History just shows pending weeks going back almost six weeks now. I worked in property management for four years, never had a disciplinary issue, and then got let go in what my employer is calling a 'performance termination' but which I experienced as a setup. EDD said in a notice that they'd be scheduling a phone interview to get my side of things, which I totally understand - I want to give my side. But I haven't gotten the DE 4800 notice with the interview date and time yet, even though it's been almost three weeks since the initial notice. Meanwhile six weeks of certifications are sitting at Pending and I've got rent due. Has anyone dealt with the situation where an employer brought in some kind of outside reference or witness for their side during an EDD phone interview? And more practically - how do I actually reach someone at EDD who can tell me whether the DE 4800 was mailed or not?

DE 4800 not arriving is actually more common than people realize. Mine went to an old address because EDD still had my previous place on file even though I'd updated it in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ - worth checking that your mailing address in your profile is current. The interview date also shows on your UI Online homepage once it's been scheduled, so look there first before assuming the notice is lost.

0 coins

Address in myEDD shows the right place - been updated since I moved in January. So if the UI Online homepage isn't showing a scheduled interview date does that mean it hasn't been scheduled yet or that it's been delayed?

0 coins

No date on the homepage usually means EDD just hasn't gotten to scheduling it yet, not that something is wrong with your claim. The pending weeks pile up in the meantime though, which is the painful part.

0 coins

Exactly what the other person said - the scheduling backlog can run several weeks depending on caseload. Keep certifying every two weeks no matter what so those weeks stay in play.

0 coins

About the employer bringing in a witness or reference - the phone interview EDD does is between EDD and you, then separately between EDD and the employer. It's not like a courtroom where both sides are on the call at the same time and someone shows up with a witness. What your employer submitted in their response to EDD's notice (the DE 1101CZ employers get) is their written version of events. EDD's interviewer will have that when they talk to you. So whatever they wrote about a 'trusted referee' will be part of the file, but you won't be on a three-way call with them.

0 coins

That's actually a relief to hear structured that way. So I give my account to EDD, employer gave theirs in writing, and EDD's interviewer uses both to decide?

0 coins

More or less, yeah. EDD decides from what both sides tell it - that's how the fired/misconduct question works. Your job in the interview is just to give your honest account of what happened.

0 coins

Right, and document anything you have from your four years there - performance reviews, emails, anything that shows no disciplinary history. Have it ready when they call.

0 coins

Six pending weeks piling up with rent coming - that was exactly where I was two months ago when my termination eligibility question dragged on. Property sector too, actually. EDD's phone line was impossible to get a person on no matter how early I called. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handled the hold for me and I ended up speaking directly with an EDD agent. The video they have about reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my DE 4800 had actually been scheduled for the following week - it just hadn't mailed yet. She also confirmed my certifications for those pending weeks were all received and would be held until after the interview decision came through.

0 coins

The part about certifications being held until after the interview decision - does that mean if EDD decides in my favor they pay all the pending weeks at once?

0 coins

That's exactly what happened in my case - once the determination came through saying I qualified, every pending certified week paid within a couple days.

0 coins

Pending weeks held for an eligibility decision do pay out all at once after a favorable determination, yes. Keep certifying through the whole wait so none of those weeks fall off.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to talk about the employer's reference on the phone with you - what that person said or wrote is part of the employer's submission, and EDD's interviewer will form their own questions based on the full file. Focus your energy on being ready to explain clearly why you don't believe the termination was for misconduct. EDD's standard is basically that the employer has to show it was actual misconduct, not just performance they didn't like.

0 coins

Wait, is 'performance termination' the same as misconduct in EDD's eyes? My boss always said they could fire you for performance and you couldn't collect.

0 coins

That's a really common thing employers say and it's not how EDD sees it. EDD decides what counts as misconduct - the employer saying 'performance' doesn't automatically mean EDD agrees it was misconduct. The interview exists specifically so EDD can hear both sides.

0 coins

Misconduct and performance are genuinely different things under EDD's framework. 'Performance termination' doesn't equal disqualification. The interview is where your account matters.

0 coins

Calling EDD at 1-800-300-5616 between 8 and 10 in the morning tends to get shorter waits than the afternoon in my experience. Even so, the hold times lately have been brutal. If you get through, ask specifically whether the DE 4800 has been generated for your claim and what address it was sent to. That'll at least tell you whether the interview is in the pipeline.

0 coins

Eight to ten AM is what I've been trying - disconnected twice after 40-plus minutes. At this point I'd do anything to just confirm whether that notice was sent.

0 coins

EDD's live chat through the Help button in UI Online is another route - it runs Monday through Friday 9 to 2. Sometimes faster than the phone, sometimes not.

0 coins

Chat's hit or miss but worth trying if the phone keeps dropping. Have your claim number ready either way.

0 coins

Four years with no discipline and then a sudden 'performance termination' - EDD has seen this pattern before. Make sure when you do get the interview that you can speak to specific examples of work you did correctly and any positive feedback you received in writing. The interviewer is going to ask about the specific incident or pattern the employer cited, so know your version of those events clearly.

0 coins

I have two annual reviews from the last couple years that were both positive. Would those be something I can reference during the phone interview or is it just verbal?

0 coins

Reference them verbally during the interview - describe what they said, the dates, who signed them. EDD isn't going to have them in front of them, but your account of what they said becomes part of the record. If you later need to appeal, those documents become much more important.

0 coins

If it goes to an appeal hearing those reviews could be key evidence. At the hearing stage you'd actually submit documents and testify under oath, so keep everything.

0 coins

Paycheck from that job finally stopped and I realized how stuck I was when the pending status wouldn't budge and the phone line kept timing out. Had a DE 4800 scheduled but then saw a different eligibility flag pop up on my claim at the same time. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who looked at the account and said there were actually two separate issues flagged - the interview for the termination question and an identity step that hadn't cleared. Got the identity piece resolved through ID.me the same afternoon and the agent explained the interview would proceed once that cleared.

0 coins

Two separate flags at once sounds like a nightmare - glad you got both identified in one call. Did you know there was an identity issue before the agent told you, or did it only show as 'Pending' in Claim History?

0 coins

Just showed as Pending with no detail on my end. The agent was the one who saw the two separate holds. That's why getting someone on the phone who can actually read the account matters so much.

0 coins

Pending in Claim History with no explanation is basically EDD's default for anything they're reviewing - could be identity, eligibility, the interview, anything. Can't tell from the outside which one it is.

0 coins

My cousin told me that if the employer brings any kind of witness or outside person to the EDD interview, you can request that EDD gets a statement from someone on your side too. Is that true? Because if the employer is lining up references against you it seems like you should be able to respond somehow.

0 coins

The EDD phone interview isn't a hearing - there's no mechanism to bring witnesses on either side during that call. The employer submitted their version in writing when they responded to EDD's claim notice. If EDD issues a denial after the interview and you appeal, that's when an actual hearing happens before an administrative law judge and you can have representation and present your side fully.

0 coins

Oh so the interview is just you and EDD, not like a confrontation with the employer? That makes more sense.

0 coins

Correct - two separate conversations, never together. If you need to fight it further, the appeal hearing is the stage where it becomes more formal.

0 coins

EDD's live chat through the Help button in UI Online actually got me an answer about my DE 4800 faster than I expected last spring. The chat agent told me it had been mailed three days earlier and gave me the address it went to. Worth trying before spending hours on hold on the phone line.

0 coins

Tried the chat button twice and it shows as unavailable - I'm wondering if I'm hitting it outside the 9 to 2 window.

0 coins

Almost certainly that's it - 9 AM to 2 PM Pacific only, Monday through Friday. Outside those hours the button either disappears or shows unavailable.

0 coins

Also doesn't work if you're not logged into UI Online - has to be from inside your account, not from EDD's public homepage.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I was in adjudication for a termination question was writing out a full timeline of my last 60 days at the job before the interview. Dates of any meetings, what was said, emails I sent. Not because EDD asks for it in writing, but because having it in front of me meant I didn't blank on details when the interviewer asked questions. The interview moves fast and they're covering specific incidents.

0 coins

How long did your interview actually run? I want to make sure I'm somewhere quiet and have enough time blocked.

0 coins

Mine was about 20 minutes but I've heard they vary. Block an hour and have your timeline, any dates and names you need, right in front of you. And keep your phone charged - missing that call means you need to phone EDD the same day to try to reschedule.

0 coins

The DE 4800 notice itself will tell you the specific questions EDD plans to ask, so read it carefully when it arrives - you're not going in blind on what they'll cover.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something to check if you haven't already. The notice about registering in CalJOBS - the DE 8405 - gives you 21 days to get your resume posted there. Miss that and payments can stop regardless of how the interview goes. With six weeks already pending it might not feel urgent but it's one of those things that bites people quietly.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is done - I did that in the first week after applying. Resume is posted. At least that's one thing I can check off.

0 coins

Good - that one is easy to miss because the DE 8405 comes in a separate mailing from everything else and people assume they're done once they certify.

0 coins

Worth logging back into CalJOBS just to confirm the resume shows as active. Sometimes people set it up and it's visible to them but not fully published.

0 coins

Termination without prior discipline on record - my situation three months back was almost identical. The adjudication dragged and I finally used Claimyr to reach EDD directly. The agent confirmed my interview was already in the queue but had been assigned to a backlogged unit. She told me to keep certifying and to have documentation of my clean performance record ready. That's exactly what I did, and the determination came in my favor.

0 coins

How long between when you spoke to the agent and when the actual interview happened?

0 coins

About twelve days after that call. Having the agent confirm the interview was in queue at least meant I stopped worrying it had fallen through the cracks.

0 coins

Knowing it's queued versus not knowing makes a huge difference psychologically when you're waiting weeks with no information.

0 coins

EDD decides what counts as misconduct, not the employer - want to second that point someone made earlier. I had a manager tell me point blank that she was filing the response to EDD as 'terminated for cause' and that I wouldn't get benefits. Benefits paid within two weeks of my interview. What the employer writes in their response isn't the final word.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring to read. Did EDD ever tell you what the employer wrote or is that not something they share with the claimant?

0 coins

EDD doesn't walk you through the employer's response on the interview call. I found out what they'd written later when I requested my claim file, which you can do through Ask EDD. For the interview itself I just gave my own account.

0 coins

The interviewer might ask you to respond to a specific allegation - like 'your employer states X, what's your response?' - but they won't read you the whole submission.

0 coins

Appeals process kicks in if the determination goes against you - just want to flag that so it's not a shock if it happens. The Notice of Determination that EDD mails includes an Appeal Form, the DE 1000M. Appeal within 30 calendar days of the mailing date on the notice. After that your case goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, and an administrative law judge holds a hearing where you testify under oath. That's the stage where your performance reviews and any documentation really come into the foreground.

0 coins

Thirty days from the mailing date, not the date I receive it - is that right? That feels tight if mail takes a few days.

0 coins

Yes, 30 days from the mailing date printed on the notice, not from when you open it. So open any EDD mail the day it arrives and calendar the deadline immediately.

0 coins

If you miss the 30-day window you can still appeal but you need to explain why the deadline was missed. Much cleaner to just catch it within the 30 days.

0 coins

Pending weeks with no explanation drove me completely insane when I was in adjudication last year. What I eventually learned is that EDD's Claim History screen can show Pending for multiple different reasons and the screen itself won't tell you which one applies to your weeks. The only way to actually know what's holding your weeks is to reach someone at EDD who can read the account.

0 coins

That tracks with what I've been experiencing - Pending with zero context. So the screen is basically useless for diagnosis.

0 coins

For diagnosis, yes. It tells you something is unresolved, not what. EDD's payment info line at 1-866-333-4606 is 24 hours but it also can't explain what's causing the hold - just confirms what's paid and what's pending.

0 coins

1-866-333-4606 is good for confirming payment status but you're right that it won't explain a pending week. That still needs a person.

0 coins

Ask EDD - EDD's online contact form - is worth sending a message through your UI Online account asking specifically about the status of your DE 4800 scheduling. It's not as fast as a phone call but it creates a written record and sometimes someone responds within a few business days. Given how much trouble you're having reaching anyone by phone it might be worth doing in parallel.

0 coins

Can I ask through Ask EDD about more than one thing in the same message, or should I keep it to just the DE 4800 question?

0 coins

Keep it focused - one specific question gets a more useful answer than a list of questions in one message. Lead with the DE 4800 scheduling question since that's the most time-sensitive thing you're waiting on.

0 coins

Also be specific in what you write - give your claim number, say exactly what notice you're waiting for, and ask clearly whether it's been generated and what address it was mailed to.

0 coins

Misconduct under EDD's framework has to be something more than just not doing the job well enough in the employer's view. The way my interviewer explained it on my own call after a termination was: EDD is asking whether there was a deliberate or willful act against the employer's interests, not just whether performance fell short of expectations. Four years with no documented discipline history is exactly the kind of context that matters.

0 coins

Deliberate or' willful is the key piece -'that s a much higher bar 'than we decided your performance'wasn t good'enough . Worth knowing that going into theinterview.

0 coins

Right - which is why the employer's framing of 'performance termination' isn't the same as EDD agreeing there was misconduct. The employer's characterization is their starting point, not EDD's conclusion.

0 coins

And if the employer can't back it up with documented prior warnings or discipline, that makes their misconduct argument even harder to make.

0 coins

Waiting week is something to keep in mind if you're calculating what you're owed - every California UI claim has one unpaid waiting week, usually the first eligible week. So of your six pending weeks, one will come back as the waiting week with no payment. The other five should pay if EDD decides in your favor after the interview. DE 429Z that EDD mailed after you applied shows your weekly benefit amount and maximum benefit amount.

0 coins

I got the DE 429Z - weekly amount shows $388. So five paid weeks at $388 would be close to $1,900 if everything clears. That would genuinely cover the immediate crisis.

0 coins

$388 is within the standard range - sounds right for your wage history. And yes, that math tracks if five weeks pay out post-determination.

0 coins

Does EDD pay all the back weeks in one deposit or does it trickle out one week at a time?

0 coins

Usually processes as separate week amounts but they tend to hit the Money Network card in quick succession rather than spread over weeks. Some people see them all within 24 to 48 hours of the determination.

0 coins

DE 4800 also lists the specific questions EDD plans to cover in the interview - it's not just a scheduling notice. Read that section carefully when yours arrives because it tells you what angle EDD is approaching your case from, whether it's the reason for separation, your availability, something else entirely.

0 coins

Didn't realize the DE 4800 included the actual questions. So I won't be going in completely blind on what they'll ask - that's useful to know ahead of time.

0 coins

Exactly - gives you time to think through your answers before the call comes. The interviewer phones at the time printed on the notice so have everything ready and your phone available at that specific time.

0 coins

If something comes up and you can't be available at that time, contact EDD at least one day before - they can try to reschedule to an open slot. Missing the call without doing that creates problems.

0 coins

Missing the interview without warning and then having to deal with EDD was my situation last spring - I was stuck on a job site with no service when the interviewer called. Phoned EDD the same day I missed it and after a long hold, eventually got through. EDD rescheduled me but said the determination had already started processing from the employer's response alone. That's why getting Claimyr to hold the line for me on that follow-up call was what finally got me in front of an agent fast enough to flag that I needed a rescheduled interview before anything was finalized.

0 coins

Got rescheduled successfully after using it - did EDD put a note on the claim that the interview was missed due to a service issue, or did you have to explain that all over again at the actual interview?

0 coins

Had to explain briefly at the rescheduled interview why I'd missed the original time. Interviewer noted it, not a big issue since I'd phoned EDD the same day. The key was acting the same day, not waiting.

0 coins

Same day contact is important if you miss the interview - waiting even one day makes it harder to flag before EDD processes the determination from just the employer's information.

0 coins

Representation at an appeal hearing is something to look into early if you're part of a union, since union officials can represent you at the CUIAB hearing at no cost. If you're not, you can represent yourself or hire an attorney. Administrative law judge hearings are more formal than the phone interview but you're allowed to speak fully, present documents, and give sworn testimony about your four years of clean performance.

0 coins

Not in a union, but useful to know attorneys can appear at CUIAB hearings. Hoping the interview resolves it without needing to go that far.

0 coins

Most termination cases do resolve at the interview stage - the appeal hearing is for when the determination goes wrong. Having your documentation ready now means you're prepared either way.

0 coins

If the determination does go against you and you appeal, keep certifying every two weeks throughout the appeal process. EDD can only pay certified weeks - uncertified weeks during an appeal can't be recovered.

0 coins

Does having a 'trusted referee for unemployment' mean the same thing as having a character witness for an appeal hearing? Because I'm now confused about whether we're talking about the initial interview stage or the appeal hearing stage and what a referee even is in EDD terms.

0 coins

' Referee'isn t'EDD s term for the interview stage - that terminology sometimes comes from the'employer s internal language for whoever responded to'EDD s claim notice on the'employer s behalf. At the CUIAB appeal level, the person who runs the hearing is an administrative law judge. No one at the interview stage is called a referee in California'EDD s ownprocess.

0 coins

The OP's employer seems to have used 'trusted referee' as their own description of whoever vouched for their account in the written response to EDD. It's not a formal EDD term - which is part of why it was confusing.

0 coins

That clears it up - so it's the employer's own language, not an official role that EDD recognizes. Got it.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure