Excessive earnings status reduced hours what to do differently when certifying for California EDD
So I got cut from full-time to about 22 hours a week at my warehouse job back in October. I filed a claim and started certifying, figured it would be straightforward since I'm still employed, just way fewer hours. But now UI Online is showing 'excessive earnings' on some of my weeks and either paying me nothing or just a tiny fraction of what I expected. I know I reported my wages each time but I feel like I'm doing something wrong. Like, am I supposed to report what I earned or what I got paid? Because sometimes the check comes a week late from my employer. And do they look at gross or net wages? I've been going back and forth trying to figure out what I messed up. Anyone who went through the reduced hours situation and got this sorted out, please help me understand what to do differently when certifying.
85 comments

Jayden Reed
Warehouse hours getting cut mid-claim actually happened to me in September, and I had the same excessive earnings confusion until I got actual answers from an EDD agent. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with someone after I'd spent days getting nowhere, and the video they have about reaching a live person at EDD showed me exactly what to expect before I tried: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent walked me through the whole thing on my specific weeks. What I'd been doing wrong was reporting my paycheck deposit date instead of which week I actually worked those hours. The agent confirmed EDD wants wages reported for the week they were earned, not when your employer cuts the check. Once I corrected how I was timing my wage reports, the excessive earnings flags stopped showing up on weeks where I'd earned under my threshold. Also confirmed it's gross wages, before taxes and deductions.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
The earned vs. paid timing is exactly where I went wrong too. My direct deposit always comes Thursday for hours worked the prior week and I was logging it in the wrong certification period for two months straight.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorOkay this makes sense now. So for the week of, say, November 3rd, I report whatever I earned at the warehouse that week regardless of when the paycheck actually hits my bank account?
0 coins
Jayden Reed
Exactly that. The week the shifts happened is the week the wages belong to, full stop.
0 coins
Eli Wang
Gross wages, not take-home, is the number EDD wants every single time. A lot of people make that mistake once and wonder why the math seems off. Your gross for the week gets run through the formula where the first $25 or 25 percent of what you earned, whichever is bigger, doesn't count against you, and then everything above that gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So if your WBA is $380 and you earned $240 gross in a reduced-hours week, 25 percent of $240 is $60, which beats the flat $25, so $60 is protected and the remaining $180 gets subtracted from $380, leaving you with $200 for that week. Excessive earnings shows up when your gross minus that protected amount wipes out your entire WBA or more.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorWait so if I work enough hours in a week that my gross earnings minus that protected chunk still exceeds my full WBA, I'd get zero that week but it still counts as a claimed week?
0 coins
Eli Wang
Right, zero benefit for that week, and EDD marks it as excessive earnings rather than ineligible. The week is counted, you just don't get paid for it.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
The formula above is accurate. Worth adding that full-time work in a week makes you ineligible entirely regardless of what the math would say, so the formula only applies to part-time or reduced-hours situations.
0 coins
Zane Hernandez
Report Wages in UI Online is a tool you can use before you certify to work out what a given week's wages will do to your payment. It doesn't fix already-submitted certifications but it'll show you how a week's gross plays out against your WBA before you lock it in. Find it inside UI Online under your claim options.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorDidn't even know that existed. I've just been guessing at the math in my head. Going to try that before my next certification.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
That tool saved me from a lot of confusion during a stretch where my hours were all over the place. Some weeks 15 hours, some weeks 32, and it helped me know what to expect before I hit submit.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
Does it account for the $25 vs 25 percent comparison automatically or do you have to do that part yourself?
0 coins
Zane Hernandez
It does the comparison for you and shows the resulting payment estimate. You just enter your gross for the week.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Something that tripped me up early on: the certification period is two weeks, but you're actually reporting wages for each individual week within that period separately. EDD asks week by week during the cert. So if week one at the warehouse was 22 hours and week two was only 10 hours because a shift got cancelled, those go in as two separate wage amounts. People sometimes add both weeks together and put the total in one field, which completely breaks the calculation.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorGenuinely think I may have done exactly that at least once. The form didn't make it super obvious to me that it was asking for each week individually.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
The way the certification screens are laid out does make it easy to miss. Each week's section is labeled but if you're rushing through it you can combine them without meaning to.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Had a coworker make that same bundling mistake. Got excessive earnings on both weeks when neither week alone would have triggered it. EDD couldn't just fix it on their end either, there's a process for correcting a past certification.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
Fixing a certification you already submitted the wrong way matters here. After my hours got cut last spring I had three weeks where I'd reported the wrong amounts, and UI Online's Report Wages tool wouldn't touch them because the certifications were already closed. Had to contact EDD directly. Used Claimyr to get a live agent and explained which weeks needed correcting and why. The agent noted the issue on my claim and told me EDD would review those weeks and mail any adjustment or a Notice of Determination if there was a determination involved. Took about two more weeks before the payment on one of the corrected weeks came through.
0 coins
Millie Long
Two weeks for the correction to process sounds about right from what I've seen others say. At least you knew it was moving and didn't just disappear into a void.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorKnowing there's actually a path to fix past certifications is a relief. I was worried I'd just permanently lost those weeks.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
You haven't lost them permanently but you do need to contact EDD proactively, they won't catch and fix it automatically.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
One thing worth double-checking: your weekly benefit amount on your Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award, the DE 429Z. With reduced hours rather than a full layoff, some people expect their WBA to be higher than it actually is because the base period wages they used to calculate it may have been from before the hours were cut. The WBA is set at claim filing from your highest earning quarter in the base period, so if the cut happened recently it might not be reflected the way you think.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorMine was cut in October and I filed almost immediately after so I think my base period predates the cut entirely. Does that mean my WBA was calculated on my old full-time wages?
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Most likely, yes. Your base period looks back at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters, so if your hours just got cut, those cut weeks probably aren't in it yet. Your WBA would reflect your fuller hours from earlier quarters.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
That's actually the better scenario because it means the WBA might be higher, which makes the partial payment calculation more favorable for you.
0 coins
Debra Bai
The excessive earnings label confused me too when I first saw it because it sounds like an accusation almost, like EDD is saying you made too much money on purpose. It really just means your earnings for that specific week, after the formula runs, reduced your benefit to zero or below. It's not a flag or a hold, it's just how the week calculates out.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorOkay that's actually reassuring because I was starting to think it was some kind of warning sign that my account was being reviewed or something.
0 coins
Debra Bai
Not a review trigger on its own. If every week shows excessive earnings though, that might be worth looking at to see if your hours are consistently too high to be collecting, but a few weeks here and there is just the math doing its thing.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Agree it's not an accusation, though I'd add that if excessive earnings shows up on a week where you barely worked, that's worth looking into more closely just to make sure the wages were reported to the right week.
0 coins
Laura Lopez
CalJOBS registration is easy to overlook when you're still employed with reduced hours. EDD can require it even for partial claim situations. Check whether you got a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work, the DE 8405, because if you did you have 21 days from that date to register and post a resume at caljobs.ca.gov or payments can stop.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorI did get something in the mail I think I skimmed past. Going to dig that out tonight and check the date on it.
0 coins
Laura Lopez
Check the date on it carefully because the 21-day clock runs from when EDD mailed it, not from when you read it.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Came here to say exactly this. EDD stopped my payments a few years back for missing the CalJOBS deadline and I had no idea until I checked UI Online and saw the pending status. Had to call in to get it sorted.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
Hours fluctuating week to week in the warehouse world is brutal for unemployment calculations. Some weeks I'd hit 30+ hours covering for someone and those weeks I'd get nothing, then the next week drop to 15 hours and expect a good payment. Last month a certification period had one of each and I needed to reach EDD to understand why the second week came out lower than I expected even at 15 hours. Claimyr got me through to an agent who pulled up my specific weeks and confirmed the 30-hour week earnings, even though excessive, were computed correctly and the 15-hour week payment was right too based on my gross. Turned out I'd mentally miscalculated which 25 percent applied.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorThe math really is confusing when the hours jump around like that. I've had weeks ranging from 10 hours to 28 within the same certification period.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
28 hours depending on your hourly rate might be close to excessive earnings territory. Worth running through the Report Wages tool before you certify that period.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
Does the tool show you a breakdown or just the final estimated payment amount?
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
From what I saw it showed the estimated payment for that week but not a full line-by-line breakdown of the formula. Enough to know whether you're going to get something or zero though.
0 coins
Millie Long
Work search requirements still apply even when you're partially employed on reduced hours in California. You still have to be able and available for full-time work and actively looking. Some people assume that because they still have a job they're exempt, but EDD's rules apply to the ability and availability piece every week you certify. If your employer offers the hours back and you turn them down, that becomes its own eligibility question.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorThat part makes sense to me. I've actually been keeping a list of jobs I've applied to each week just in case. Am I required to log those somewhere in UI Online?
0 coins
Millie Long
Keeping your own records is a good habit. EDD doesn't have a tracker inside UI Online where you log search activity, but they can ask you to show your records if they question a week.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Your employer also technically could call you back to full hours at any point and EDD expects you to accept that if it's your same position. Worth knowing.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
The DE 1101CZ notice goes to your employer when you file a partial claim after hours are cut. Your employer has 10 days from the date on that notice to respond with wage and separation information. Some employers miss the response window or submit something that doesn't match what you reported, which can kick off a phone interview to sort out the discrepancy. If you haven't heard anything about an interview, you're probably fine, but if EDD schedules one the notice, the DE 4800, will have the date and time on it and also shows on your UI Online homepage.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorMy employer knows I filed so I'm hoping they responded correctly. Is there any way for me to see what they submitted?
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
You won't see the employer's response directly in UI Online. If what they submitted doesn't match yours, EDD will reach out for the interview.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Had a situation where my employer's HR submitted the wrong hourly rate and it caused a pending status that lasted almost three weeks. The interview sorted it out but it was a stressful wait.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Pensions and retirement income would go on the report too if you have any, though at a warehouse job mid-career that's probably not the issue. Social Security benefits don't get reported and don't reduce your payment, so if anyone's collecting those alongside this, don't include them when certifying.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
Good note on Social Security since there's some confusion about that. EDD is clear that SS benefits don't factor into the calculation at all.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorNot collecting Social Security, so I'm good there. Good to know for the future though.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
When my hours got reduced I made the mistake of thinking I should wait until EDD approved the claim before certifying. Ended up missing my first certification window entirely and had to contact EDD to request those weeks back. Don't wait for some kind of approval letter or green light before you certify. The DE 429Z that shows your weekly benefit amount is not an approval of weekly benefits, it just shows what your claim could pay.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorAh I did receive that DE 429Z. I was treating it like a confirmation that everything was set. Good to know that's not what it means.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
Exactly, the DE 429Z is about the claim's potential, not the go-ahead for a specific week. Each week's eligibility is determined when you certify and EDD processes it.
0 coins
Zane Hernandez
Missing a certification window is recoverable in most cases if you contact EDD right away, but it's definitely a scramble you don't want to deal with.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
The first certification after filing usually covers the waiting week plus one paid week. The waiting week is your first eligible week and it's always unpaid, that's just how every California UI claim works, it doesn't come out of your total benefit amount. So the first time you certify you're submitting for two weeks but only getting paid for one, and that's correct, not an error.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorI did think something went wrong when the first payment was for one week instead of two. That explains it.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
Yep everyone goes through that confusion the first claim. Two weeks certified, one week paid, it's by design.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
And the waiting week itself still needs correct wage reporting even though it's unpaid. The wages you earned in that week count toward the formula.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
If EDD issues a Notice of Determination on any week, the DE 1080CZ, you have 30 days from the mailing date on it to appeal in writing if you disagree. The appeal form is the DE 1000M and it comes with the notice. For excessive earnings determinations that you think are wrong, that's the route. Keep certifying every two-week period even while an appeal is pending so EDD can pay any weeks you win back if the appeal goes your way.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorI haven't received a DE 1080CZ yet, the excessive earnings just shows in Claim History without a formal notice. Is that normal?
0 coins
Riya Sharma
If it's just the Claim History status showing excessive earnings and no formal notice, that may just be the payment result for that week rather than a determination that requires appeal. A notice comes when EDD makes a formal eligibility decision. Excessive earnings on a week that calculated to zero is different from a denial.
0 coins
Eli Wang
This is an important distinction. Zero payment due to the earnings formula is not the same as being denied eligibility for the week. You'd know you got a denial when the DE 1080CZ arrives.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Switched jobs last year to a different warehouse and the new hourly rate threw off everything I thought I knew about how my partial claim would calculate. When EDD shows pending on certain weeks it's not always excessive earnings, sometimes it's just verification of wages that's taking longer. Used Claimyr on a week that had been pending for 11 days and an agent told me the wages for that week hadn't been confirmed yet, probably because my new employer's EDD account was still being set up. No determination either way, just processing. Paid out four days after that call.
0 coins
Millie Long
The employer account setup lag is real, especially if you switched to a smaller employer who hasn't filed with EDD before.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorSwitching employers while on a partial claim, is that something I'd need to report to EDD separately or does the certification cover it?
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Certifying covers it because you're reporting the wages each week. If your hours or employer change, the wages you report reflect that. No separate form for it.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
Overpayment notices are what happen when the excessive earnings situation runs the other direction, meaning you got paid for weeks where you shouldn't have because wages were reported wrong. If you get a Notice of Overpayment, don't ignore it. Appeal within 30 days if you think the amounts are wrong, and if you think the error wasn't your fault, the waiver form DE 1446UI is an option EDD offers for non-fraud overpayments where repayment would be a genuine hardship.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorReally hoping I don't end up with an overpayment notice, but good to know there's a process if the correction process surfaces something.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
If you're proactively correcting past certifications by contacting EDD, that's actually better than waiting for them to catch it and issue a notice. Getting ahead of it matters.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Exactly. Reaching out first, explaining the error, is taken as a good-faith effort. The overpayment waiver process exists for situations where the error wasn't intentional.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Part-time or reduced hours situations can last the full benefit year, up to 52 weeks from the Sunday of the week you filed, as long as you stay under the full-time threshold each week and your WBA minus earnings still calculates to something above zero at least sometimes. The 26-week maximum on the total benefit amount is the financial cap, not a time limit on how long the claim stays open.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorSo theoretically my claim could be open for a year even with the warehouse job continuing at reduced hours, as long as the math still works out?
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Theoretically yes, as long as you have remaining benefit balance and you're still certifying and meeting the availability and work search requirements each period.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
The tricky part is tracking your remaining balance as you go so you're not surprised when it runs out before the year does.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Taxes on benefits are something to plan for. What EDD pays you counts as federal taxable income even if it's partial benefits from a reduced-hours situation. At certification you can opt into 10 percent federal withholding or skip it and handle the taxes yourself. EDD mails a 1099G every January and it's also available in UI Online under Payments.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorI didn't opt into withholding when I started. Can I change that mid-claim or is it locked in?
0 coins
Lola Perez
You can change it. The withholding election can be updated through myEDD, the same place you manage your claim.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
California doesn't tax unemployment benefits so the 10 percent federal option is the only one you'd need to think about.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Partial claim certifications require honest answers to the questions about full-time work too, specifically the question asking whether you worked full time in any week. At 22 hours a week at a warehouse you're clearly not full time, but if any week you pick up overtime and hit 40 hours, that week you're ineligible entirely and need to answer accordingly on the certification, even if the hourly math makes your earnings look low. The trigger is hours, not pay.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorOkay so even if a 40-hour week only pays me $320 gross and that's under my WBA, I'm still ineligible for that week just because of the full-time hours?
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Yes, full-time work in a week closes out eligibility for that week regardless of what you earned. The partial earnings formula is for part-time only.
0 coins
Eli Wang
This is the part that trips people up most. Full-time employment is an eligibility question separate from the earnings formula entirely.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Direct deposit is an option worth setting up if you haven't yet. Payments can post relatively quickly after a certification goes through. The default is the Money Network prepaid debit card but you can switch to direct deposit in myEDD. Payment status updates daily in UI Online and you can also check via phone at 1-866-333-4606, which runs 24 hours.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
AuthorStill on the debit card. I'll look into switching. Is there any lag in setting up direct deposit mid-claim?
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
There can be a processing period after you switch so the debit card might still get the next payment or two before direct deposit kicks in. Worth doing sooner rather than later.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
The 1-866-333-4606 line for payment info is genuinely useful because it's always available and you don't need to reach a live agent just to check a payment date.
0 coins