EDD eligibility after being fired for missing work due to denied accommodations
I'm in a tough spot and really confused about my unemployment options. On May 2nd, I requested some medical accommodations from my supervisor at the warehouse where I've been working for almost 3 years. They flat out denied everything I asked for (modified lifting restrictions and occasional extra breaks for my back condition). I just couldn't physically continue without the accommodations, so I stopped showing up. They officially terminated me 20 days later for job abandonment. My question is - can I still file for unemployment benefits? Will EDD consider this a voluntary quit or termination? I'm worried they'll say I abandoned my job, but I literally couldn't physically do the work without accommodations. Has anyone dealt with a similar situation? What documentation should I have ready when I apply?
22 comments
Mei Chen
This is actually a pretty complex situation because it involves potential ADA rights. When you file for unemployment, EDD will ultimately determine if you had "good cause" for leaving your job. The fact that you requested accommodations first works in your favor, but documentation is critical here. Do you have: 1. Written proof of your accommodation request? 2. The denial from your employer? 3. Medical documentation of your condition? EDD will likely interview both you and your employer. Be prepared to explain why the lack of accommodations made it impossible for you to continue working. If you can demonstrate you had a legitimate medical need that your employer refused to accommodate, you have a better chance of qualifying.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•Thanks for responding! I have the email where I requested the accommodations and my doctor's note recommending the restrictions. The denial was verbal during a meeting with HR and my supervisor, so I don't have that in writing - that's probably going to hurt me, right? Should I apply right away or wait until I gather more documentation?
0 coins
Liam Sullivan
u shuld defiintely file ASAP, dont wait! u get backpaid from when u file not from wen u got fired. i had somethin similar happen at my last job and got approved but took forever
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•Oh wow, I didn't realize it only goes back to when you file! Thanks for the heads up. How long did your process take from filing to getting approved?
0 coins
Amara Okafor
I worked for EDD for several years. Here's what's likely to happen: When you file your claim, you'll need to explain why you stopped going to work. Be very clear that you requested accommodations for a medical condition, they were denied, and you were physically unable to perform the job without those accommodations. The key distinction here is whether EDD determines you had "good cause" to leave. After you file, you'll probably be scheduled for a phone eligibility interview. MAKE SURE you're available for this call - missing it can significantly delay your claim. During this interview, explain calmly and clearly what happened. Have your documentation ready. The interviewer will also contact your employer for their side. If your claim is initially denied, don't panic - many claims are. You can appeal, and many appeals are successful when proper documentation is provided. The judge will look closely at whether you took reasonable steps to preserve your employment (requesting accommodations counts) before leaving.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•Thank you so much for this detailed information! I'm definitely going to file right away and make sure I have all my documentation organized. Any tips on how to clearly explain this on the initial application? The forms don't seem to have a lot of space for explanation.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
I WAS IN THE SAME BOAT LAST YEAR!!!! My company refused my accommodations for my anxiety disorder and when I couldn't come in they fired me after 2 weeks. EDD DENIED my claim at first saying I voluntarily quit!!! I was sooooo mad. Had to appeal and wait 3 months with NO MONEY coming in. Eventually won but the process is TERRIBLE!!
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
•same happened to my cousin. edd system is broken
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Hey, I know this is stressful. One thing I learned in my situation that might help - call your former employer's HR and ask them to email you a confirmation of your termination date and reason. Having official documentation that they terminated you for job abandonment (rather than you quitting) can be helpful for your case. Also, were there any witnesses to your accommodation request meeting? Their statements could help too.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•That's a great idea about asking for the termination documentation! There was actually another supervisor in the meeting who was sympathetic to my situation - I could reach out to her for a statement. Thank you!
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Something to consider - have you looked into filing a complaint with DFEH (Department of Fair Employment and Housing)? If your condition qualifies under ADA or FEHA, your employer may have violated the law by denying reasonable accommodations. This might be separate from your unemployment claim, but could potentially strengthen your unemployment case if you have an active discrimination complaint. For your EDD claim, I'd recommend using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to connect with an EDD representative quickly. Given the complexity of your situation, speaking directly with a claims specialist is critical. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. I was stuck in pending for weeks until I used their service to actually speak with someone who could review my specific situation.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•I hadn't even thought about filing a DFEH complaint! That's definitely something to look into. And thanks for the Claimyr suggestion - I've been worried about getting stuck in the EDD phone system. I'll check out that video.
0 coins
Sofia Ramirez
Make sure when you certify that you mark yourself as "able and available for work" each week (assuming you are able to work with proper accommodations at a different job). I made the mistake of indicating I had medical restrictions and my payments got held up for months while they determined if I should be on disability instead. It was a nightmare getting it sorted out.
0 coins
Liam Sullivan
•omg this is so true!! happened to me 2 and i had to do phone interview to fix it
0 coins
Mei Chen
I wanted to follow up on something important. When you complete your initial application, you'll reach a section asking about your separation reason. There's usually options like "laid off/fired" or "quit." This is tricky in your situation. If you select "quit," you'll definitely get flagged for an eligibility interview, but selecting "fired" might not fully explain the situation either. My recommendation: Choose the option that most accurately represents what happened (likely "fired" since they formally terminated you), but be prepared to fully explain the circumstances during your eligibility interview. The key is consistency between what you report and what your employer reports.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•This is really helpful advice. I've been staring at the application trying to figure out which option to choose. I'll select "fired" since they did officially terminate me, and then explain the full situation in the interview. Thanks!
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
just wondering did u get anything in writing from ur doctor before u asked for accommodations? that might help ur case
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•Yes, I have a doctor's note specifying my condition and the recommended work restrictions. I submitted a copy with my accommodation request email, so at least I have that documentation!
0 coins
Amara Okafor
One last bit of advice - since your situation involves potential disability discrimination, you might qualify for expedited processing of your claim. When you're able to speak with an EDD representative (which can be challenging - see the Claimyr recommendation above), specifically ask if your case qualifies for expedited handling due to the potential hardship and possible disability discrimination elements. Also, keep certifying for benefits every two weeks even if your claim is pending or under review. If your claim is eventually approved, you'll only be paid for weeks you properly certified for.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
•Thank you! I hadn't heard about expedited processing - that would be incredibly helpful. And I'll definitely keep up with the certifications regardless of the status.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
UPDATE YOUR RESUME NOW AND START APPLYING FOR JOBS!!! EDD requires work search activities and they WILL ask for proof during interviews sometimes!! Don't get caught unprepared!!
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
•yep this is good advice. they're really strict about work search now
0 coins