EDD claim approved with $0 balance - can reapply after additional work quarters?
My uncle lost his job last October (2023) and applied for unemployment. His claim was technically approved but showed a $0 balance because EDD determined he hadn't earned enough in his base period. He managed to find work for about 4 months after that, but now he's unemployed again. Would it make sense for him to file a new claim now? Wondering if EDD would count his recent earnings that weren't considered in his original claim? He earned about $9,800 during those 4 months of work. Anyone been through something similar or know how this works?
16 comments
Diego Vargas
Yes! Your uncle should absolutely file a new claim. EDD uses a base period that looks back at your earnings from 5-18 months before you file. Since it's been several months since his original claim, his new application will use a different base period that should include those 4 months of work (assuming he was paid legally with proper tax withholdings). The minimum qualifying earnings vary but his $9,800 might qualify him now, especially if he earned at least $1,300 in one quarter.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•That makes sense - thank you! He definitely was paid legally (W2 position). I'll tell him to go ahead and reapply. Do you know if he needs to do anything special since he had a $0 claim before? Or just file a regular new claim?
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
tell him to reapply asap. i had same thing happen except mine was $0 cuz i worked for cash under the table (dont do that lol). anyway when i got real job later i reapplied and got benefits. but make sure he applies right away cause theres like a 1 week waiting period anyway
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•Thanks! Yeah he's been putting it off because the first experience was so frustrating for him. I'll definitely tell him not to wait any longer.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Your uncle will need to file a completely new claim. The system will recognize that he previously filed, but this is considered a new benefit year with potentially different base period earnings. One thing to note: if he's been unemployed for more than a few weeks already, he might be leaving money on the table. EDD only pays benefits from the week you apply, not retroactively from when you lost your job. If he's been unemployed for a month already, that's potentially a month of benefits he won't get.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•Oh no, he's been unemployed for almost 3 weeks now! I had no idea it wasn't retroactive. I'll tell him to file TODAY. Really appreciate that info!
0 coins
Sean Doyle
The EDD system is TERRIBLE about explaining this zero dollar claim situation!! I went through EXACTLY the same thing in 2022 and had to figure it all out myself. They approve you but with $0 which is completely useless and feels like a cruel joke. Then you have to wait until enough time passes for your base period to include newer earnings. When your uncle reapplies, he should reference his previous claim number in the additional comments section just to help connect the dots for whoever reviews his case.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
•This is why I always tell people to try using Claimyr when dealing with confusing EDD situations like this. I was in a similar situation last year and spent weeks trying to get through on the phone. Finally used their service (claimyr.com) and got connected to an EDD rep in under 20 minutes who explained everything. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km Worth it when you're dealing with something time-sensitive or confusing that needs a human explanation.
0 coins
Luca Romano
There's actually a specific term for what your uncle is experiencing - it's called a "recomputation claim." If his previous claim was within the last 52 weeks but had $0 balance, and he's earned enough in qualifying wages since then, EDD should be able to recalculate his benefits based on those new earnings. The minimum earnings requirement is usually around $1,300 in your highest-earning quarter during the base period, and at least $900 total across the entire base period. With $9,800 across 4 months, he should definitely qualify now as long as those earnings are distributed across at least one complete calendar quarter in his new base period.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•Thank you - I had no idea there was a specific term for this! That's exactly his situation. I'm going to tell him to file right away.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
i disagree with some people here. my sister tried to reapply after getting a $0 claim and got denied AGAIN because not enough time had passed. something about needing a full quarter of work history? idk the details but dont get his hopes up maybe.
0 coins
Luca Romano
•That's because EDD requires complete calendar quarters for the base period calculation. If your sister worked for only a partial quarter and then immediately reapplied, those earnings might not have fully counted yet. But in this case, OP mentioned their uncle worked for 4 months, which means he likely has at least one complete quarter of earnings now in his base period (assuming he filed the original claim in October 2023 and we're now in May 2025).
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Thank you everyone for the helpful responses! I just spoke with my uncle and he's filing his new claim today. Fingers crossed that his recent work history will qualify him this time around. I'll update this thread once we find out what happens with his claim.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
•good luck! and tell him if he has problems getting through to edd just keep calling back. took me like 2 days of calling over and over to finally get someone lol
0 coins
Diego Vargas
One more thing to note: When your uncle files his new claim, he should make sure to have his employment information for all jobs worked since his last claim was filed. This includes employer names, addresses, phone numbers, supervisor names, dates worked, and earnings information. Being prepared with this info will help prevent delays in processing his new claim.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•Great tip - thank you! I'll pass this along to him so he has everything ready. It was such a hassle last time, so we're trying to make this process smoother.
0 coins